Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

What’s the general MN verdict on donor eggs?

460 replies

Sortilege · 17/05/2022 14:22

The general critical re-examination of surrogacy is quite evident, and I have my own views on that, which I’ll keep quiet for the purposes of this thread.

Now I find myself chewing over other fertility treatment. I’ve had fertility treatment myself and so have family members. So I have a sense of how private clinics put you on a conveyor belt and normalise things.

What is the general view on donor eggs & embryos (implanted into the birth mother and gestated by her)?

Im trying really hard not to bias the result so have tossed a coin to assign YABU/YANBU to viewpoints. Don’t read into that.

YANBU = Donor gametes are ethically fine.
YABU = Donor gametes are problematic.

OP posts:
babyjellyfish · 17/05/2022 15:25

I am very opposed to surrogacy but I see egg donation as completely different.

Yes, the process can take a toll on the egg donor's mother, but not compared to actually carrying a baby intended for someone else. Nobody is forcing women to donate their eggs, and even if they receive some payment, it's not going to be a main source of income, the way commercial surrogacy is. In that sense I think there is much less risk of exploiting young and poor women for their reproductive labour. So I think that if you have given your informed consent to donating your eggs because you want to help someone have a child, and you understand the process, it should be your choice to do that. It's not the same as spending a year of your life growing a baby and then handing it over to someone else to raise.

As far as the baby is concerned, the woman who gives birth to it is its mother. Surrogacy involves deliberately conceiving a child with the intention of removing it from its birth mother as soon as it is born. Egg donation does not. As soon as the embryo is implanted into the intended mother, she is the one who does the rest of the work. She grows the baby, she gives birth to the baby, she raises the baby. She is the baby's mother.

Sortilege · 17/05/2022 15:24

Beamur · 17/05/2022 15:18

I can understand the desire for a child. But I don't think anyone has the right to be a parent.
I think saying it's unethical to deny same sex couples the chance is muddying two different areas entirely. Ideally they should have the same opportunities as extended to other infertile couples. But where to draw the line? Donated sperm, surrogacy?
But donated gametes must be considered in terms of the children created from them as well as how they were obtained.
I don't know what the 'right' answer is. But I was very struck recently by a poster on MN who was an adopted child and was really struggling with what that had meant for them. The sense of being wanted/grateful by their adopted parents was really at odds with the distress they were feeling at having been put up for adoption.
It's complicated. Too complicated for a simple yes/no.

Yes that’s fair. It is immensely complicated and so is infertility.

OP posts:
Sortilege · 17/05/2022 15:23

Coldilox · 17/05/2022 15:09

I gave birth to my son, he was conceived from my wife’s egg and donor sperm.

My opinion is that other people debating whether my child and thousands like him conceived from donor gametes should exist or not is pretty grotesque.

It’s not just a debate about whether the children should exist or not though, is it? There’s nuance that any decent debate should cover such as traceability, identity, registration, treatment tourism, etc.

We left it, but every month I’m still tempted to ring the clinic and squeeze in a menopause baby. My family ended with losses so it’s emotional. These decisions always are. I’m quite sure that if I’d had no DC, I would have gone with it, but I would still expect there to be rules, a framework and oversight.

I’m interested to know how the woman on the street sees it.

OP posts:
CottonBallsUp · 17/05/2022 15:20

To add however I do think genuinely altruistic donation should be allowed with appropriate protocols around access to donor information when the child becomes an adult.

Beamur · 17/05/2022 15:18

I can understand the desire for a child. But I don't think anyone has the right to be a parent.
I think saying it's unethical to deny same sex couples the chance is muddying two different areas entirely. Ideally they should have the same opportunities as extended to other infertile couples. But where to draw the line? Donated sperm, surrogacy?
But donated gametes must be considered in terms of the children created from them as well as how they were obtained.
I don't know what the 'right' answer is. But I was very struck recently by a poster on MN who was an adopted child and was really struggling with what that had meant for them. The sense of being wanted/grateful by their adopted parents was really at odds with the distress they were feeling at having been put up for adoption.
It's complicated. Too complicated for a simple yes/no.

CottonBallsUp · 17/05/2022 15:16

I think incentivising egg donations as part of IVF is as ethically problematic as paying women, if not more so. Women about to embark on IVF are often in an emotionally vulnerable state and the offers clinics give are very tempting. The idea of donating eggs as part of your cycle only for your cycle to fail but the donor recipient’s to be a success is awful. Imagine being contacted by your biological offspring 18 years later if you ultimately hadn’t been able to have your own child. I am not sure how thoroughly this is explored with women donating this way, although I know counselling is mandatory for donors.

Wheresmywoolyjumpers · 17/05/2022 15:15

The women participating are adults so I vote it is fine.

Sortilege · 17/05/2022 15:14

Interesting that the vote is almost evenly split.

OP posts:
Sortilege · 17/05/2022 15:14

toastofthetown · 17/05/2022 15:05

Donor gametes is a very interesting subject ethically, and just because it upsets some people to hear, I don’t think that means it shouldn’t be talked about. There are two things with donor eggs, which is worth thinking about.

Firstly, many IVF clinics will incentivise egg sharing with either free or discounted IVF. This is brilliant for some families, but it poses the same moral issues to me as paying for gametes. Some women who might not want to share their eggs might feel pressured into it if treatment is otherwise out of price range. Seems like it’s commodifying it a little.

Second, and this is also applicable to donor sperm, is how will children born from donor gametes feel about it? From the answers we have so far, some children are fine with it, they see their family as those who raised them and it’s all good. For some though, being raised without access to half of their biological background is a significant problem. Donors now have to be accessible to children when they turn 18 which I think is a very important step, even if that reduces the amount of donors. When discussing how donor conception should work, the only consideration should be wide ranging studies on the best outcomes for the children conceived. At the moment it seems like the balance is good with emphasis on being honest with children from the earliest moment about their background, and giving children access to their biological background. But if it turns out that actually that isn’t right, changes should be made on behalf of the children, even if that is more difficult for their parents.

This is the thing. It’s my observation that the easier access to the gametes is, the less of an ethical debate there even is, which of course is tempting when you’re facing infertility. Secondary infertility, in my case.

Which is why, I think, the donor sperm genie is well out of the box and not being discussed much at all. (Which is why I didn’t include it in the vote.)

Similarly, but running 50+ years behind, donor eggs and embryos have become much more available over the past two decades without much public debate. Practice has just overtaken policy, and of course it is so tempting to just go with it when you’re there at the clinic and the medics are telling you that donor gametes are the obvious next step.

In terms of identity for the donor conceived person, obviously the issues are exactly the same, be it sperm or eggs, and double in the case of donor embryos. OTOH, for the donors, it is fair to say egg donation is much more arduous as a procedure.

OP posts:
WhatNoReally · 17/05/2022 15:12

It's absolutely fine

fugly1 · 17/05/2022 15:11

orwellwasright · 17/05/2022 14:46

As the mother of a child conceived using a donor egg, I'm just rocking up to let you know you've basically invited a load of women to say incredibly offensive things about something I very much doubt they have any personal experience of.

If you're pleased with that, then crack on. Well done, you.

I second this!!

Movingonup22 · 17/05/2022 15:11

I’ve got a shed load of eggs if the freezer because I personally thought I’d struggle with the idea and time was ticking.

but I was very surprised by how many women I met at the clinic seemed genuinely happy with the concept of egg sharing for reduced cost.

I think there is scope for exploitation which needs to be guarded against - but I think it is much easier to do than with surrogacy and ultimately it has less of an impact than surrogacy (not that if you think it’s harmful the fact it is less harmful is necessarily relevant).

my personal view is that there are lots of potential issues with it but these likely can be managed if properly regulated and overseen and - if these risks are managed - can be a good thing.

Coldilox · 17/05/2022 15:09

I gave birth to my son, he was conceived from my wife’s egg and donor sperm.

My opinion is that other people debating whether my child and thousands like him conceived from donor gametes should exist or not is pretty grotesque.

LaurieFairyCake · 17/05/2022 15:07

Poor people selling bits of their body to people who have more money

Lacedwithgrace · 17/05/2022 15:06

Donor eggs and surrogacy is ethical, any unethical surrogacy or 'donations' are as a result of abuse/coercion/exploitation etc. MN users seem to think pregnant people involved in surrogacy are always abused and don't competently consent to it.

Sortilege · 17/05/2022 15:06

BetsHilton · 17/05/2022 14:47

I am ok with donor eggs being used and implanted into the woman who will raise the baby but I think there should be no anonymous egg donation and anyone who uses them should assist their child in contacting egg donor when at an appropriate age. I also think children should be told from babies about the egg donation so they are fully aware growing up of their genetic heritage.

I’m still wrestling with it but I tend to agree. I made the rule for myself that I’d (personally) only consider traceable donors if it came to that.

The irony is that the lack of donors drove people overseas, where donors often weren’t traceable (as I say I’m not up to date with domestic waiting lists currently so don’t know how much that’s still the case).

The other irony was that it was EXH’s male factor infertility that first led us to a clinic and nobody even seems to consider ethical issues around sperm donation much at all. Perhaps because retrieval is, ahem, much easier, everyone is quite blasé about it?

OP posts:
toastofthetown · 17/05/2022 15:05

Donor gametes is a very interesting subject ethically, and just because it upsets some people to hear, I don’t think that means it shouldn’t be talked about. There are two things with donor eggs, which is worth thinking about.

Firstly, many IVF clinics will incentivise egg sharing with either free or discounted IVF. This is brilliant for some families, but it poses the same moral issues to me as paying for gametes. Some women who might not want to share their eggs might feel pressured into it if treatment is otherwise out of price range. Seems like it’s commodifying it a little.

Second, and this is also applicable to donor sperm, is how will children born from donor gametes feel about it? From the answers we have so far, some children are fine with it, they see their family as those who raised them and it’s all good. For some though, being raised without access to half of their biological background is a significant problem. Donors now have to be accessible to children when they turn 18 which I think is a very important step, even if that reduces the amount of donors. When discussing how donor conception should work, the only consideration should be wide ranging studies on the best outcomes for the children conceived. At the moment it seems like the balance is good with emphasis on being honest with children from the earliest moment about their background, and giving children access to their biological background. But if it turns out that actually that isn’t right, changes should be made on behalf of the children, even if that is more difficult for their parents.

MissChanandlerBong80 · 17/05/2022 15:04

Is there a reason the thread title and the text of the post refers to donor eggs and not donor sperm? Although I’m aware you’ve used ‘gametes’ at the end?

Anyway, I see no ethical problem with donor gametes whatsoever. Obviously lesbian couples often use donor gametes in order to start their families. I do see a massive ethical problem with denying parenthood to same sex couples.

Onionpatch · 17/05/2022 15:03

I doubt there is a general view.

I feel there is a difference between someone donating spare eggs as part of their own ivf journey and someone selling eggs to help fund college - in terms of potentially 'exploiting' another person. I also think the long term risks to egg donars hasnt been followed up for the second type of donar.

In terms of the baby, there are less issues around being removed from the heartbeat and sounds of the mother you grew inside, and first smelled etc.

But possibly issues about your genetics and siblings.

AlternativePerspective · 17/05/2022 14:59

Personally no, I think donor sperm/eggs/surrogacy should all be illegal.

The problem with all of these procedures is that they are all about someone becoming a parent with very little thought given to the children who are the product of these arrangements.

The reason why the law was changed in order for the children of donated eggs/sperm to be able to trace their biological parent is because so many of them grow up with a sense of not belonging, or that half of them is missing.

It’s all very well saying that anything which means a child is born into a loving family is fantastic, but that’s not enough. That child is going to grow up into an adult in their own right, and that missing heritage is theirs to deal with.

It’s not possible to know how a child of donated eggs/sperm is going to feel about their heritage, or lack thereof, and the potential implications if they trace their donor only to be rejected.

And as a donor it’s also not possible to know that the product of your donation will be born into a loving family. There seems to be this perception that anyone who has fertility treatment is automatically going to be a loving parent. But there are no guarantees.

EveryFlightBeginsWithAFall · 17/05/2022 14:50

I think it's fine. Don't have any problem with it at all

Sortilege · 17/05/2022 14:49

ColdColdColdColdCold · 17/05/2022 14:47

I suspect OP knows what they're doing. There are better spaces to discuss the ethics of using donor eggs if they were truly interested. They know what MN can be like regarding surrogacy, yet they've chosen MN to ask this question? Interesting.

Where are these “better places” then? I’ll reserve judgment until you say.

OP posts:
NotMaryWhitehouse · 17/05/2022 14:48

orwellwasright · 17/05/2022 14:46

As the mother of a child conceived using a donor egg, I'm just rocking up to let you know you've basically invited a load of women to say incredibly offensive things about something I very much doubt they have any personal experience of.

If you're pleased with that, then crack on. Well done, you.

Congratulations on your family! A loved, wanted and cherished child is such a blessing Flowers

Sortilege · 17/05/2022 14:48

orwellwasright · 17/05/2022 14:46

As the mother of a child conceived using a donor egg, I'm just rocking up to let you know you've basically invited a load of women to say incredibly offensive things about something I very much doubt they have any personal experience of.

If you're pleased with that, then crack on. Well done, you.

Its better that it’s openly debated than discussed in corners though, isn’t it? Do you worry that stigma from the surrogacy debate will have an effect?

OP posts:
ColdColdColdColdCold · 17/05/2022 14:47

orwellwasright · 17/05/2022 14:46

As the mother of a child conceived using a donor egg, I'm just rocking up to let you know you've basically invited a load of women to say incredibly offensive things about something I very much doubt they have any personal experience of.

If you're pleased with that, then crack on. Well done, you.

I suspect OP knows what they're doing. There are better spaces to discuss the ethics of using donor eggs if they were truly interested. They know what MN can be like regarding surrogacy, yet they've chosen MN to ask this question? Interesting.