Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

What’s the general MN verdict on donor eggs?

460 replies

Sortilege · 17/05/2022 14:22

The general critical re-examination of surrogacy is quite evident, and I have my own views on that, which I’ll keep quiet for the purposes of this thread.

Now I find myself chewing over other fertility treatment. I’ve had fertility treatment myself and so have family members. So I have a sense of how private clinics put you on a conveyor belt and normalise things.

What is the general view on donor eggs & embryos (implanted into the birth mother and gestated by her)?

Im trying really hard not to bias the result so have tossed a coin to assign YABU/YANBU to viewpoints. Don’t read into that.

YANBU = Donor gametes are ethically fine.
YABU = Donor gametes are problematic.

OP posts:
want2bemum · 17/05/2022 16:02

orwellwasright · 17/05/2022 14:46

As the mother of a child conceived using a donor egg, I'm just rocking up to let you know you've basically invited a load of women to say incredibly offensive things about something I very much doubt they have any personal experience of.

If you're pleased with that, then crack on. Well done, you.

Indeed.

I really think this is a topic that is incredibly hard to relate to or understand unless you have been through infertility yourself.

If you are not infertile, you really can't imagine how that feels and the impact of it.

I've seen this from both sides and personally I would have answered this question differently before experiencing infertility than after.

AlternativePerspective · 17/05/2022 16:01

Donor children are the same

Phineyj · 17/05/2022 16:00

We used a clinic in another European country to find an egg donor. The law there is that gamete donation must be anonymous. I can't speak for all parents who had their children this way, but I thought long and hard about the ethical issues - more so, I suspect, than friends and family members who did it "the natural way". Our daughter knows all about how she was conceived. I heard her explaining it to a classmate on a Teams chat once! (She's 9).

The barriers erected in the way of infertile people in the UK accessing treatment are largely to blame for "fertility tourism".

TiddleyWink · 17/05/2022 16:00

orwellwasright · 17/05/2022 14:46

As the mother of a child conceived using a donor egg, I'm just rocking up to let you know you've basically invited a load of women to say incredibly offensive things about something I very much doubt they have any personal experience of.

If you're pleased with that, then crack on. Well done, you.

Sorry but it’s utterly outrageous to say that people are only allowed an opinion on something that they have personally done. People who have done this will of course all agree it’s ok - what about the many people who have researched it and decided against it, are they not allowed an opinion because it disagrees with yours?

There are a few very defensive posters on this thread - understandable to a degree if you feel your child’s existence is being questioned. But to take that view is to say that only bringing babies into the world, at any cost, is what matters. That’s awful. The women donating eggs matter. The women who may have been coerced, like when vulnerable women undergoing fertility treatment are offered a discount if they donate eggs…that sort of thing is hideous and it’s disgusting it’s allowed. It’s an uncomfortable truth that people shouldn’t be allowed to go to any lengths to have a baby, that they’re not entitled to one at any cost.

There are significant ethical questions around this issue and it’s absolutely unfair to shriek at posters debating those points that they can’t have an opinion or that they wish your child didn’t exist (see another PP).

Infertility is awful, but the answer isn’t to engage in ethically questionable (at best) activities which take advantage of vulnerable women’s bodies.

I am personally not fully against egg donation in the same way as surrogacy as I don’t believe it’s as harmful to the babies born, but I do believe it should be far more regulated and the predators offering discounts to vulnerable women going through ivf if they hand over eggs, should absolutely be banned. Children should also, I think, have absolute transparency over their genetic origins and have full access to their genetic mother’s medical records.

AlternativePerspective · 17/05/2022 15:59

I don’t agree with the emotive “well you’ve obviously never experienced infertility” line which is often used to shut down discussion.

Where do we draw that line? Plenty of people have never experienced liver/kidney/heart failure, but that doesn’t mean it’s right for people who have to buy organs in less ethical countries? Just because someone hasn’t experienced it doesn’t mean they’re not entitled to an opinion on it.

In fact having experienced infertility for instance, it could be argued that the person is too close to the situation and their opinion is emotional rather than objective.

I’m in heart failure. Should my desire to live, which let’s face it is a primal thing, be a valid reason to travel to a country where a heart could be bought for the right price?

Or let’s make it simpler.

Someone’ has to die to get a heart, so let’s say someone in kidney failure could travel abroad to buy a kidney from someone who has sold one. Is that ok?

Because donor children are the sae, in fact I’d say it’s worse, because there is another human. Being in this mix who hasn’t consented to growing up in what is essentially a step family.

toastofthetown · 17/05/2022 15:57

I understand why a thread like this is hard for the parents of donor conceived children, but I don’t think that means people shouldn’t be able to discuss it. However hard this is for parents of donor conceived children, the rights of the children conceived matter more. There should be constant research done to improve wherever possible the situation and outcomes for children born from donor gametes and/or surrogacy.

Pretending there aren’t ethical considerations because it’s painful to the parents does a huge disservice to the children. Acknowledging this has led to changes in ensuring that the donors are available for children to contact should they wish, shared learning in the best way to discuss children’s conception with them and will lead to more discoveries in the future, which will make each generation of donor conceived children have a better experience than the last.

HopingForMyRainbowBaby · 17/05/2022 15:56

Onionpatch · 17/05/2022 15:26

The reason I feel differently about sperm is there are no risks associated with retrieval. Menierally leave the stuff all over the place.

I also think babies have a link with the person that carries them and gives birth to them and that if they are removed from that person they experience loss. I could be wrong about that but that is part of my reasoning for feeling different about different scenarios.

Depends really. I was adopted as a newborn Baby. Believe me I do not feel a loss from being separated from my biological mother. Neither does my Sister and she was just under a year when we adopted her. For a child who was taken off their parents at a much older age, fostered and then adopted then they might feel some sort of loss I suppose

Georgeskitchen · 17/05/2022 15:56

Who are we to judge others? If a woman is happy and willing to give another woman the chance of motherhood then I'm all for it. As long as they are not coerced into doing it

Happyplace88 · 17/05/2022 15:55

I am totally for altruistic egg donation.

I recently donated eggs to a friend who suffers from premature ovarian failure. It was not an easy ride and I absolutely wouldn’t do it for a stranger. the physical strain it put on my body was tough, and logistically it was very difficult fitting appointments etc in around work.
I don’t feel comfortable with incentivising egg donation; I feel it treats womens bodies as a commodity and it makes me uncomfortable.
But for a friend who was going through the agony of infertility, I’d do it again in a heartbeat.

OnlyFoolsnMothers · 17/05/2022 15:51

DangerouslyBored · 17/05/2022 15:44

What a disgusting thread. As if the heartache of infertility or having a genetic disease isn’t painful enough. Now this, a thread on a site used by many, many mothers of donor egg babies, to be criticised and judged by other, frankly, callous, ill informed, utterly clueless women.

You should hang your head in shame for creating a space for the toxic judgments of the ignorant poster, who just loves a thread like this, somewhere to release their pent up vitriol concerning a subject they know nothing of.

Well done 👏🏼

any opinion different to yours is uneducated, sure.

Mommabear20 · 17/05/2022 15:50

I personally don't agree with fertility treatments that require any 3rd party, be it egg donor, sperm donor or surrogacy, and would not choose to use them myself. HOWEVER those are my own personal feelings and I don't think that I'm important enough to have any say as to other peoples choices when it comes to using those methods. My view is very much the same as abortion, I don't like it, I'd never choose it, but everyone has their right to their opinion. No answer is ever 100% right or 100% wrong.

PurrBox · 17/05/2022 15:50

I think egg donation is a wonderful thing that science has made possible.

I was almost a donor for a close friend, but I ended up not being able to donate. I am so glad she had an anonymous donor in the end because her children are wonderful but I would not like the complications of seeing my genetic material in a close friend's family.

Eelicks · 17/05/2022 15:49

You get a discount on IVF if you donate eggs which always seems abit iffy

Elsiebear90 · 17/05/2022 15:49

I have no problem with it at all, and I think people like to forget that there are many many children conceived naturally have no relationship with their dads or don’t even know who they are as well.

Franca123 · 17/05/2022 15:48

I've come lately and reluctantly to think that all gamete and embryo donation is wrong. I have a load of embryos frozen myself (from my partner and my gametes) which we thought we'd donate. Now we know for sure we will not. I don't feel very strongly about it though.

DangerouslyBored · 17/05/2022 15:44

What a disgusting thread. As if the heartache of infertility or having a genetic disease isn’t painful enough. Now this, a thread on a site used by many, many mothers of donor egg babies, to be criticised and judged by other, frankly, callous, ill informed, utterly clueless women.

You should hang your head in shame for creating a space for the toxic judgments of the ignorant poster, who just loves a thread like this, somewhere to release their pent up vitriol concerning a subject they know nothing of.

Well done 👏🏼

AllyCatTown · 17/05/2022 15:42

What worries me is that arguments about the commodification of women’s bodies, which is my concern, is dismissed as homophobic or less important than the desire to have a child.

I do however think donor eggs are much less concerning than commercial surrogacy but there are ethical issues.

TaraRhu · 17/05/2022 15:41

@AlternativePerspective I agree with you. But playing devils advocate- how many people have children the conventional way without any thought about their quality of life ? How many born into terrible lives? At least with fertilisation you have some idea the child is wanted and loved.

Having kids the normal way is often commodified too.

I think there is a problem with traceability. It's impossible to know where people get their eggs and sperm from. Unregulated donors and donors from abroad are impossible to spot and nothing can be done to offer these kids the choice of finding their biological heritage (should they desire).

Clymene · 17/05/2022 15:41

BetsHilton · 17/05/2022 14:47

I am ok with donor eggs being used and implanted into the woman who will raise the baby but I think there should be no anonymous egg donation and anyone who uses them should assist their child in contacting egg donor when at an appropriate age. I also think children should be told from babies about the egg donation so they are fully aware growing up of their genetic heritage.

This is also my position. Which in the U.K. only means U.K. donors who are typically women donating their eggs to fund their own fertility treatment

OnlyFoolsnMothers · 17/05/2022 15:38

Personally I think if you cant have children naturally you have no right to buy body parts/ substances from other people.

I would love to hear from children conceived as such once adults, and their opinions and feelings- rather than parents who insist everything is fine because they got what they wanted.

myceliumama · 17/05/2022 15:37

I don't see a big problem about donor eggs and donated embryos . The child would be gestated by its birth mother and remain with her. The mother baby bond would absolutely exist and remain intact. Genetics really don't matter in that respect, the baby only knows it's mother. Her sound, taste, movements and smell. It wouldn't recognise it's genetic parents ( if it was a donated embryo).

Surrogacy is human trafficking. It's no different to purchasing an organ in my eyes and it prioritises the buyers over the baby.

CupidStunt22 · 17/05/2022 15:33

There's an ethical difference between donated eggs and bought eggs.

And there's a massive difference between eggs and sperm. Men can and always have left their sperm all over the place, having no idea what happens to it afterwards. Men have children without ever being aware of it. Women don't. Women don't casually lay eggs that someone else may or may not turn into a human.

Sortilege · 17/05/2022 15:30

Onionpatch · 17/05/2022 15:26

The reason I feel differently about sperm is there are no risks associated with retrieval. Menierally leave the stuff all over the place.

I also think babies have a link with the person that carries them and gives birth to them and that if they are removed from that person they experience loss. I could be wrong about that but that is part of my reasoning for feeling different about different scenarios.

Yes, the whole “in utero bonding” issue seems highly significant to me, too, but I’m never sure if I’m over-emphasising that at the expense of the genetic issue because of my own bias.

OP posts:
Onionpatch · 17/05/2022 15:26

The reason I feel differently about sperm is there are no risks associated with retrieval. Menierally leave the stuff all over the place.

I also think babies have a link with the person that carries them and gives birth to them and that if they are removed from that person they experience loss. I could be wrong about that but that is part of my reasoning for feeling different about different scenarios.

HopingForMyRainbowBaby · 17/05/2022 15:25

Well it must be absolutely lovely being able to conceive and carry a Baby to term with no worries about fertility issues and stuff. Pity we can't all manage to do that!! So no I have no problems at all with it. I have no problems with surrogacy either when done legally and used for the right reasons to help a childless couple unable to conceive or carry a Pregnancy to term. However I also think, that like adoption surrogacy should also be approved by social services of the couple wanting a Baby and also the mental and emotional health of the surrogate be taken into consideration to stop couples exploiting vulnerable women from foreign countries or them feeling like they need to do it in order to get money. There should also be a cut off to how many times you can be a surrogate to someone.