Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

What’s the general MN verdict on donor eggs?

460 replies

Sortilege · 17/05/2022 14:22

The general critical re-examination of surrogacy is quite evident, and I have my own views on that, which I’ll keep quiet for the purposes of this thread.

Now I find myself chewing over other fertility treatment. I’ve had fertility treatment myself and so have family members. So I have a sense of how private clinics put you on a conveyor belt and normalise things.

What is the general view on donor eggs & embryos (implanted into the birth mother and gestated by her)?

Im trying really hard not to bias the result so have tossed a coin to assign YABU/YANBU to viewpoints. Don’t read into that.

YANBU = Donor gametes are ethically fine.
YABU = Donor gametes are problematic.

OP posts:
Organictangerine · 17/05/2022 16:40

PurrBox · 17/05/2022 15:50

I think egg donation is a wonderful thing that science has made possible.

I was almost a donor for a close friend, but I ended up not being able to donate. I am so glad she had an anonymous donor in the end because her children are wonderful but I would not like the complications of seeing my genetic material in a close friend's family.

In that case I like to think you would’ve felt able to say no?

SleeplessInEngland · 17/05/2022 16:38

"And yet here we are."

Mumsnet's gain really is the Oxford Union Debating Society's loss.

Sortilege · 17/05/2022 16:38

Elsiebear90 · 17/05/2022 16:13

I think this thread was always going to upset people as there are many mothers on the site who have used donor eggs or sperm and there are posts essentially saying they were morally wrong to do so.

I’m sure if people were judging how your baby was created and said you were morally wrong to have them then you would be upset too. It’s like posting a thread asking for opinions on teenage mothers then being shocked that people think it’s goady and insensitive. It’s hardly surprising some people are upset.

Yes, it must be difficult. Even at the point when you’re considering treatment, you’ve already lost impartiality to some extent. I know that from experience.

That is part of the reason my rational head says we should have had this debate and ironed out the policy wrinkles before donor conception went mainstream. The problem was, I suspect, that nobody anticipated that it would go mainstream.

OP posts:
Organictangerine · 17/05/2022 16:37

veronicagoldberg · 17/05/2022 16:29

And yet here we are.

I think you know we’re not debating whether EXISTING children should be exterminated or not! But hey, way to shut down conversation with a bit of emotional blackmail.

Organictangerine · 17/05/2022 16:35

zingally · 17/05/2022 16:24

My best friend used donor eggs and donor sperm to get pregnant with both her children.
Ethically... It's not that great perhaps? When there's so many children in the world that need a home. But then... you'd perhaps argue the same thing about anyone having biological children of their own... when they could just as easily foster or adopt. When you think about the other side of the argument like that, it becomes a lot less problematic - to me at least.

BUT, these 2 children were the most wanted children ever, and it's irrelevant that they're not biologically related to either parent (but are full siblings to each other). Maybe it will become an issue in the future, but at the moment, it's not in the slightest.

It's perhaps not something I'd have chosen for myself, but who am I to judge someone elses decision? A mile in someone else's shoes, and all that.

How old are the children now?

GETTINGLIKEMYMOTHER · 17/05/2022 16:31

I do know someone who (after masses of failed IVF) had a baby (herself) using a donor egg and her husband’s sperm. Everybody was very happy for them all and the baby is much loved.

AlienatedChildGrown · 17/05/2022 16:30

I would suggest you read through some of the writings of the now adult donor conceived children.

There are some here
www.wearedonorconceived.com

But there are other places on the internet if that site does not appeal.

Personally I found far too many overlaps between my own experience of living in the shadow of “parental wants before children’s needs” and theirs to ever consider gamete donation and surrogacy an ethical enterprise. Regardless of it being completely altruistic and coercion-free, or not so much. Human beings, even teeny tiny ones, are not commodities, nor a gift for one adult to bestow onto another.

veronicagoldberg · 17/05/2022 16:29

Coldilox · 17/05/2022 15:09

I gave birth to my son, he was conceived from my wife’s egg and donor sperm.

My opinion is that other people debating whether my child and thousands like him conceived from donor gametes should exist or not is pretty grotesque.

And yet here we are.

SpaceyCake · 17/05/2022 16:28

I think altruistic donation is fine. I don't think you should get paid for it because then it might make women do it out of necessity, and no-one should be forced to do it just because they're struggling financially.

I don't really see the issue with donating eggs if you want to. My friend regularly donates eggs because she loves kids and wants to help others have kids (she has four children already and doesn't have the resources to have more), and I always found this quite sweet. She doesn't get paid for it either.

Organictangerine · 17/05/2022 16:28

It’s very complicated.

Ultimately I wouldn’t just hand a stranger a baby, so I wouldn’t donate my eggs. Yes they would probably be used by a loving and responsible person(s), but it isn’t guaranteed and I would always be wondering if the baby I helped to create was safe and loved.

I also do not agree with paid surrogacy or egg donation in any form.

When it comes to altruistic donation… hmm. It just seems far too complex emotionally for the child, if not for the parents as well. Particularly if they know the donor. The issue is most egg donor children are not adults yet, so there’s no way of measuring the impact on them.

these stories always attract the ‘I tell my toddler a kind lady gave me an egg’ stories but you can’t tell anything from that because they’re a toddler so obviously will accept whatever they’re told

ultimately I don’t agree with it I suppose

veronicagoldberg · 17/05/2022 16:28

orwellwasright · 17/05/2022 14:46

As the mother of a child conceived using a donor egg, I'm just rocking up to let you know you've basically invited a load of women to say incredibly offensive things about something I very much doubt they have any personal experience of.

If you're pleased with that, then crack on. Well done, you.

The world doesn't revolve around you.

Sortilege · 17/05/2022 16:27

Franca123 · 17/05/2022 15:48

I've come lately and reluctantly to think that all gamete and embryo donation is wrong. I have a load of embryos frozen myself (from my partner and my gametes) which we thought we'd donate. Now we know for sure we will not. I don't feel very strongly about it though.

What changed your mind @Franca123 ?

OP posts:
zingally · 17/05/2022 16:24

My best friend used donor eggs and donor sperm to get pregnant with both her children.
Ethically... It's not that great perhaps? When there's so many children in the world that need a home. But then... you'd perhaps argue the same thing about anyone having biological children of their own... when they could just as easily foster or adopt. When you think about the other side of the argument like that, it becomes a lot less problematic - to me at least.

BUT, these 2 children were the most wanted children ever, and it's irrelevant that they're not biologically related to either parent (but are full siblings to each other). Maybe it will become an issue in the future, but at the moment, it's not in the slightest.

It's perhaps not something I'd have chosen for myself, but who am I to judge someone elses decision? A mile in someone else's shoes, and all that.

felulageller · 17/05/2022 16:22

I think a child should have the right to know they were conceived this way.

They should know who their genetic mother is.

toastofthetown · 17/05/2022 16:17

want2bemum · 17/05/2022 16:07

@TiddleyWink I suppose the point is, if you haven't had personal experience, it is very hard for you to relate to just how desperate infertility can feel for those who ultimately go on to use an egg donor. You can't truly understand their motivations if you haven't been in their shoes. My views would probably have been similar to yours before I experienced infertility myself. I'm not in a position where I need an egg donor, but I can understand. In and of itself, it is no more wrong than blood donation or anything else, it just needs careful regulation.

I suppose this comes down to whose rights matter more? For me, the rights of the children born are the most important. If the research in the next ten years tells us that overall, being born from donor gametes is a net negative to the children then the process should be stopped. If it turns out that egg donation is more exploitative than it is altruistic on behalf of those donating then that should be stopped as well. In a case of competing rights, these come above the right to have a baby through donor conception, despite how painful and desperate that might be for the couple experiencing infertility.

Its a very different situation than blood donation, as the direct result of blood donation isn’t a child being born, half of whose genetic background is unknown to them in childhood, and may have come from a woman who only donated her eggs in a desperate attempt to find her own IVF, rather than altruism.

TheDuchessOfMN · 17/05/2022 16:16

OnlyFoolsnMothers · 17/05/2022 15:38

Personally I think if you cant have children naturally you have no right to buy body parts/ substances from other people.

I would love to hear from children conceived as such once adults, and their opinions and feelings- rather than parents who insist everything is fine because they got what they wanted.

I agree with this

Elsiebear90 · 17/05/2022 16:13

I think this thread was always going to upset people as there are many mothers on the site who have used donor eggs or sperm and there are posts essentially saying they were morally wrong to do so.

I’m sure if people were judging how your baby was created and said you were morally wrong to have them then you would be upset too. It’s like posting a thread asking for opinions on teenage mothers then being shocked that people think it’s goady and insensitive. It’s hardly surprising some people are upset.

SleeplessInEngland · 17/05/2022 16:09

I know women who have donated eggs for free once they decided they wouldn't have more children (or any). 'Commodity' seems to be the buzzfword on these threads now but I don't think it's applicable in that situation.

BetsHilton · 17/05/2022 16:08

I can understand the desire for a child. But I don't think anyone has the right to be a parent

i agree @Beamur I think we should be sterilising any women or men who are drug addicts or any parents who have a child taken into care to stop them having further children to abuse.

Clymene · 17/05/2022 16:08

Oh sorry I think we're agreeing @AlternativePerspective!

want2bemum · 17/05/2022 16:07

@TiddleyWink I suppose the point is, if you haven't had personal experience, it is very hard for you to relate to just how desperate infertility can feel for those who ultimately go on to use an egg donor. You can't truly understand their motivations if you haven't been in their shoes. My views would probably have been similar to yours before I experienced infertility myself. I'm not in a position where I need an egg donor, but I can understand. In and of itself, it is no more wrong than blood donation or anything else, it just needs careful regulation.

Clymene · 17/05/2022 16:07

AlternativePerspective · 17/05/2022 16:05

But people seem to only be thinking of the baby stage.

What about the child, the teenager, the adult who has questions around where they come from, who they’re related to, whether the girl down the road could be biologically related to them.

The laws surrounding anonymity of donation were changed for very valid, reasons, because these children want to know where they’ve come from.

Even if they’ve grown up in a loving family that’s not enough for many of them, and they want to know where they’ve really come from.

Which is why the law changed in the U.K. in 2005. It seems to me to be a good compromise - to ensure that children born via donated gametes know where they are from and who their parents are. I think that is a fundamental human right.

AlternativePerspective · 17/05/2022 16:05

But people seem to only be thinking of the baby stage.

What about the child, the teenager, the adult who has questions around where they come from, who they’re related to, whether the girl down the road could be biologically related to them.

The laws surrounding anonymity of donation were changed for very valid, reasons, because these children want to know where they’ve come from.

Even if they’ve grown up in a loving family that’s not enough for many of them, and they want to know where they’ve really come from.

Phineyj · 17/05/2022 16:05

Yes, no, don't know. Anonymous!

TiddleyWink · 17/05/2022 16:03

Phineyj · 17/05/2022 16:00

We used a clinic in another European country to find an egg donor. The law there is that gamete donation must be anonymous. I can't speak for all parents who had their children this way, but I thought long and hard about the ethical issues - more so, I suspect, than friends and family members who did it "the natural way". Our daughter knows all about how she was conceived. I heard her explaining it to a classmate on a Teams chat once! (She's 9).

The barriers erected in the way of infertile people in the UK accessing treatment are largely to blame for "fertility tourism".

Did you consider the impact on the donor woman though, and not just the baby? Did you have 100% cast iron certainty that she wasn’t in any way vulnerable and was donating for altruistic reasons with no financial benefit? Did she come from a poorer background/country?