Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

What’s the general MN verdict on donor eggs?

460 replies

Sortilege · 17/05/2022 14:22

The general critical re-examination of surrogacy is quite evident, and I have my own views on that, which I’ll keep quiet for the purposes of this thread.

Now I find myself chewing over other fertility treatment. I’ve had fertility treatment myself and so have family members. So I have a sense of how private clinics put you on a conveyor belt and normalise things.

What is the general view on donor eggs & embryos (implanted into the birth mother and gestated by her)?

Im trying really hard not to bias the result so have tossed a coin to assign YABU/YANBU to viewpoints. Don’t read into that.

YANBU = Donor gametes are ethically fine.
YABU = Donor gametes are problematic.

OP posts:
Rrrunrunrunrunrun · 17/05/2022 17:06

We nearly used donor sperm to have a baby. Dd1 was unexpectedly born with a serious (fatal) genetic condition so rare that we don’t know if she inherited it from us. Without children I felt my life would have no purpose and I was nervous about taking a risk and having to hold another child as they died in my arms. As luck would have it, we’d had 3 failed rounds of fertility treatment when I fell pregnant naturally (by accident) and we have 2 healthy DC.

As others have said, unless you’ve been in this position I think its shameful to judge.

Elsiebear90 · 17/05/2022 17:05

I think creating any child is selfish though, it’s all about what you want, if it was about giving a child a good home you would adopt. It’s about fulfilling your own desires ultimately. Very few family situations are perfect, I think if you can provide a child (whether your own biologically or through donor conception) with a loving, stable good home then that’s better than what a lot of kids get growing up.

Sortilege · 17/05/2022 17:03

SleeplessInEngland · 17/05/2022 17:00

Fair enough. Just bear in mind that, going by mumsnet, trans rights are the most important political topic of the day - yet polling shows that for the electorate at large it’s not even a top 20 concern.

The only time I’ve ever heard something like IVF spoken of negatively is when people say the NHS shouldn’t fund it. But that’s as far as it’s ever gone. I don’t it’ll boil over anytime soon, but we’ll see.

OOH, you’re probably quite right.

OTOH, the internet is quite useful for hearing things people are too polite to say IRL.

I suspect there are a lot of people who only think about it in depth when they need to.

OP posts:
BatBay · 17/05/2022 17:02

drpet49 · 17/05/2022 16:53

Personally no, I think donor sperm/eggs/surrogacy should all be illegal.

The problem with all of these procedures is that they are all about someone becoming a parent with very little thought given to the children who are the product of these arrangements.

^I agree

Except that's not remotely true. There is a huge amount of thought that most parents who use donor gametes put into it. That has been my experience of talking to other parents.

My child is 16 and donor conceived. She has always been fully aware of it. She is considering getting in touch with her biological father and/or siblings when she turns 18 and we will of course support her in whatever she chooses to do.

We used to go to donor conception network meetings, primarily so she could meet other donor conceive children but she has no interest any more so we stopped going. She says that being donor conceived is the least interesting thing about her.

She is the spitting image of me.

want2bemum · 17/05/2022 17:01

toastofthetown · 17/05/2022 16:17

I suppose this comes down to whose rights matter more? For me, the rights of the children born are the most important. If the research in the next ten years tells us that overall, being born from donor gametes is a net negative to the children then the process should be stopped. If it turns out that egg donation is more exploitative than it is altruistic on behalf of those donating then that should be stopped as well. In a case of competing rights, these come above the right to have a baby through donor conception, despite how painful and desperate that might be for the couple experiencing infertility.

Its a very different situation than blood donation, as the direct result of blood donation isn’t a child being born, half of whose genetic background is unknown to them in childhood, and may have come from a woman who only donated her eggs in a desperate attempt to find her own IVF, rather than altruism.

Considering the numbers of infertile people who experience mental health issues, depression and suicidal thoughts, I don't think the argument is as clear cut as you make out.

I stand by my point that people who haven't experienced it can't truly know.

Obviously everyone can (and should) contribute to the debate. But if you have not walked in these shoes, you really cannot know how it feels.

It is something that needs extremely careful regulation and rules, but it is not inherently wrong to donate eggs and sperm or to use them to conceive a child.

Sortilege · 17/05/2022 17:01

Organictangerine · 17/05/2022 16:28

It’s very complicated.

Ultimately I wouldn’t just hand a stranger a baby, so I wouldn’t donate my eggs. Yes they would probably be used by a loving and responsible person(s), but it isn’t guaranteed and I would always be wondering if the baby I helped to create was safe and loved.

I also do not agree with paid surrogacy or egg donation in any form.

When it comes to altruistic donation… hmm. It just seems far too complex emotionally for the child, if not for the parents as well. Particularly if they know the donor. The issue is most egg donor children are not adults yet, so there’s no way of measuring the impact on them.

these stories always attract the ‘I tell my toddler a kind lady gave me an egg’ stories but you can’t tell anything from that because they’re a toddler so obviously will accept whatever they’re told

ultimately I don’t agree with it I suppose

I did have a very strong reaction to the fertility nurse saying “We like to say it’s like being given a missing ingredient to bake a cake”. That probably worried me more than anything, as, for me, that was a completely inadequate narrative to give a child, and downplayed the genetic aspect too much.

Who knows, maybe if I’d found a more convincing (for me) narrative in the timeframe, it would have topped me the other way?

Anyway, I agree that being able to explain it adequately is a fundamental issue.

OP posts:
SleeplessInEngland · 17/05/2022 17:00

Sortilege · 17/05/2022 16:48

Well I just didn’t know. I have heard the odd negative comment IRL, from people who don’t know our history, but nothing major.

So I was posting to find out what the dominant view was.

As it turns out, the vote is 50/50.

Fair enough. Just bear in mind that, going by mumsnet, trans rights are the most important political topic of the day - yet polling shows that for the electorate at large it’s not even a top 20 concern.

The only time I’ve ever heard something like IVF spoken of negatively is when people say the NHS shouldn’t fund it. But that’s as far as it’s ever gone. I don’t it’ll boil over anytime soon, but we’ll see.

toastofthetown · 17/05/2022 17:00

Sortilege · 17/05/2022 16:52

I'd be interested to know what children born of donor eggs feel about it all.

Yes, me too. I’ll dig a bit more later. I found a couple of sites, but online views tend to cluster to one side or the other.

This is from a website linked upthread which I found interesting. Overwhelmingly the view of this survey is that conception should not be anonymous, and most of those who we conceived from an anonymous donation found it harmful. Most feel the identity of the donor should be available from birth, whereas now it’s from 18. The question I found most interesting is that around two thirds of respondents said that their parents weren’t aware of their true feelings regarding being donor conceived.

Hallyup89 · 17/05/2022 16:58

I think it's fine. How many women on here are actively encouraged to keep their kids away from their fathers? I think that's far worse than having two loving parents who you just so happen not to be biologically related to.

I've never had to go through fertility treatment, fortunately, but I wouldn't judge anyone who does. I'd do the same in that position.

felulageller · 17/05/2022 16:53

For me my DC was my DC because they grew from my egg. I didn't feel any significance from gestation, labour, lactation.

drpet49 · 17/05/2022 16:53

Personally no, I think donor sperm/eggs/surrogacy should all be illegal.

The problem with all of these procedures is that they are all about someone becoming a parent with very little thought given to the children who are the product of these arrangements.

^I agree

Sortilege · 17/05/2022 16:52

I'd be interested to know what children born of donor eggs feel about it all.

Yes, me too. I’ll dig a bit more later. I found a couple of sites, but online views tend to cluster to one side or the other.

OP posts:
LondonJax · 17/05/2022 16:51

We had IVF to have our child. Using my eggs and his sperm. But the first attempt failed. I didn't produce any viable eggs. We had a long conversation, before we met with the consultant a month later, about whether donor eggs would be the way forward. We didn't have to make that decision as I became pregnant on the next attempt. I still don't know what my (or my husband's) answer would have been - we went back and forth so many times.

But, what I do know, is that a work colleague who was having IVF with a donor egg at the same time is now proud mum to a wonderful teenager, who is the spitting image of her. The matching on height, size, hair and eye colour, ethnic background etc was incredible. He actually looks more like his mum than his dad, the fit was so close.

Both our DSs know they were conceived through IVF (and a donor egg in my work colleague's case).

EveryFlightBeginsWithAFall · 17/05/2022 16:50

Elsiebear90 · 17/05/2022 16:45

Yeah I’m not convinced outside of mumsnet large amounts of people think it’s an issue, I’ve actually never heard anyone voice a negative opinion about egg or sperm donation outside of this website, and I used to work at a fertility hospital that provided both.

Same

I do have a friend who was conceived using donor sperm. She's never had any interest in who the sperm came from

I suppose its the same as adoption, some people just aren't interested

Sortilege · 17/05/2022 16:48

SleeplessInEngland · 17/05/2022 16:41

"That is part of the reason my rational head says we should have had this debate and ironed out the policy wrinkles before donor conception went mainstream. The problem was, I suspect, that nobody anticipated that it would go mainstream"

You say that like large swarthes of people think sperm/egg donation is a massive problem that needs resolving. Surrogacy from poor countries has its dissenters, but that's different.

Well I just didn’t know. I have heard the odd negative comment IRL, from people who don’t know our history, but nothing major.

So I was posting to find out what the dominant view was.

As it turns out, the vote is 50/50.

OP posts:
Vikinga · 17/05/2022 16:48

Surrogacy, donor eggs and sperm is fine imo. But in all cases, children should have access and contact details to their biological source (though they wouldn't be held financially liable nor have any legal rights over them).

Beamur · 17/05/2022 16:47

I would imagine many of the people commenting on this thread do have personal experience of infertility, miscarriage and having children. Thus having insight into this in some way or another.
But equally, something so emotive cannot only be discussed or decided by people who are close to it - it does require a level of detachment and perspective when making law and policy.
I know personally children born through surrogacy. Several of my friends are adopted or have adopted children. I know it's far from simple. There's great joy but also a lot of pain.
My views on fertility/infertility/adoption etc have changed over time and with experience. When I was younger, I was quite blithe about adopting/donating. Now I know I could not donate an egg as the thought of a child that is half of me being out there, but unknown to me - however well loved and cared for, I just couldn't do it. But I wouldn't judge another woman for making a difference choice.

TheKeatingFive · 17/05/2022 16:47

Difficult one.

As a general thought, there are serious issues with any aspects of reproduction being bought / sold, which applies to surrogate eggs.

Equally there is a sliding scale of impact on the donor which is significantly different if we're talking about carrying a pregnancy and giving birth, to donating eggs, to donating sperm - in that order.

Most of those who donate eggs tend to be young and poor, so again its less about free choice and more of an exploitative practice. However I do see a distinctive moral difference between those who do it to pay for college or whatever and those who want to share spare eggs from their own IVF rounds.

I'd be interested to know what children born of donor eggs feel about it all.

In conclusion, I'd be against donor eggs as something that you pay for, but in other circumstances I'm probably okay with it. Lots to work through in terms of the child/donor mother's rights however.

Clymene · 17/05/2022 16:46

This reply has been deleted

This has been withdrawn by MNHQ at the poster's request.

I'm not sure it will. There is a massive push to move towards implementing a commercial surrogacy model in the U.K. for the convenience of the people who are angry about the current altruistic model.

Elsiebear90 · 17/05/2022 16:45

Yeah I’m not convinced outside of mumsnet large amounts of people think it’s an issue, I’ve actually never heard anyone voice a negative opinion about egg or sperm donation outside of this website, and I used to work at a fertility hospital that provided both.

Sortilege · 17/05/2022 16:45

SleeplessInEngland · 17/05/2022 16:38

"And yet here we are."

Mumsnet's gain really is the Oxford Union Debating Society's loss.

😏

I have a friend with an Oxford Union membership. I sometimes think I should tag along there more often, to scratch the discursive itch.

OP posts:
Sortilege · 17/05/2022 16:43

zingally · 17/05/2022 16:24

My best friend used donor eggs and donor sperm to get pregnant with both her children.
Ethically... It's not that great perhaps? When there's so many children in the world that need a home. But then... you'd perhaps argue the same thing about anyone having biological children of their own... when they could just as easily foster or adopt. When you think about the other side of the argument like that, it becomes a lot less problematic - to me at least.

BUT, these 2 children were the most wanted children ever, and it's irrelevant that they're not biologically related to either parent (but are full siblings to each other). Maybe it will become an issue in the future, but at the moment, it's not in the slightest.

It's perhaps not something I'd have chosen for myself, but who am I to judge someone elses decision? A mile in someone else's shoes, and all that.

I suppose there aren’t many of us who would choose not to exist. I do always wonder, though, if I had gone through with donor gametes treatment, (or if I still made a last minute dash for it), how would that child feel about it, and how would society view that child?

Future policy can be refined, regardless. The greater the numbers being born this way, the more important it is to get it right.

OP posts:
Loopytiles · 17/05/2022 16:43

Any kind of economic exchange is unethical IMO, including egg ‘donation’ in return for reduced cost or free fertility treatment.

SleeplessInEngland · 17/05/2022 16:41

"That is part of the reason my rational head says we should have had this debate and ironed out the policy wrinkles before donor conception went mainstream. The problem was, I suspect, that nobody anticipated that it would go mainstream"

You say that like large swarthes of people think sperm/egg donation is a massive problem that needs resolving. Surrogacy from poor countries has its dissenters, but that's different.

Overthewine · 17/05/2022 16:40

This reply has been withdrawn

This has been withdrawn by MNHQ at the poster's request.