Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

What’s the general MN verdict on donor eggs?

460 replies

Sortilege · 17/05/2022 14:22

The general critical re-examination of surrogacy is quite evident, and I have my own views on that, which I’ll keep quiet for the purposes of this thread.

Now I find myself chewing over other fertility treatment. I’ve had fertility treatment myself and so have family members. So I have a sense of how private clinics put you on a conveyor belt and normalise things.

What is the general view on donor eggs & embryos (implanted into the birth mother and gestated by her)?

Im trying really hard not to bias the result so have tossed a coin to assign YABU/YANBU to viewpoints. Don’t read into that.

YANBU = Donor gametes are ethically fine.
YABU = Donor gametes are problematic.

OP posts:
Soontobe60 · 17/05/2022 17:34

orwellwasright · 17/05/2022 14:46

As the mother of a child conceived using a donor egg, I'm just rocking up to let you know you've basically invited a load of women to say incredibly offensive things about something I very much doubt they have any personal experience of.

If you're pleased with that, then crack on. Well done, you.

Whilst I can understand your feelings, the fact is that many many women experience difficulties in conceiving or carrying a pregnancy to term.

Sortilege · 17/05/2022 17:33

Rrrunrunrunrunrun · 17/05/2022 17:06

We nearly used donor sperm to have a baby. Dd1 was unexpectedly born with a serious (fatal) genetic condition so rare that we don’t know if she inherited it from us. Without children I felt my life would have no purpose and I was nervous about taking a risk and having to hold another child as they died in my arms. As luck would have it, we’d had 3 failed rounds of fertility treatment when I fell pregnant naturally (by accident) and we have 2 healthy DC.

As others have said, unless you’ve been in this position I think its shameful to judge.

Sorry to hear that and I’m glad it worked out for you. FWIW, I think there is zero chance donor conception for medical reasons would ever be unavailable.

I don’t really subscribe to the idea that only those directly involved can debate an ethical issue, though. You came about as close to donor conception as I did, and, if anything, I think it makes it harder for us to be objective about all of the issues.

It’s certainly not “shameful” for individuals to have a view, or for society to get involved in ethical debates. What would be shameful is to leave things to laissez faire policy development.

OP posts:
Franca123 · 17/05/2022 17:32

@Sortilege I started to change my mind after watching a few documentaries concerning children born of donor sperm. Many of them were clearly struggling with their identity. This prompted me to think a lot deeper about the matter. I also worry about the exploitative nature of egg donation having been through ivf myself. It was gruelling. This should never be allowed to be done for money or for equivalent compensation.

PurrBox · 17/05/2022 17:32

Organictangerine · 17/05/2022 16:40

In that case I like to think you would’ve felt able to say no?

Of course I would have felt able to say no!

At the time I wanted desperately to say yes but was unable to, and now that the children are grown up, I am glad they were anonymously conceived.

It is possible to have feelings which gradually change over a 20 year period, and after lots of thought and experience.

There are reasons for anonymous donation, and detailed medical histories are part of the anonymous donation process, at least they were for my friend.

Keha · 17/05/2022 17:31

I think good research needs to be done to look at the outcomes for donor conceived children. If it's banned, then in future they wouldn't exist. How do they feel about that? I think there are a lot of opinions on this thread, but not from the people actually living with this experience.

I think we need to remember that what people see as a "normal" family, parent, who they are related to, who they are linked to etc is quite culturally varied. So I would keep an open mind about it.

There are ethical issues so should be regulation.

I think all parents are ultimately making a decision about what they want, not what their child wants. My child didn't ask to be born either. And many people bring children into less than perfect scenarios for their own (selfish) reasons. I imagine a lot of those children on balance are happy to exist, but you'd have to ask them.

Soontobe60 · 17/05/2022 17:31

FieryPitOfMordor · 17/05/2022 14:38

I don’t really agree with anything that treats children as a commodity. So no issue about assisted conception using own eggs & sperm, or altruistic donation / surrogacy (by friends / family etc). But anything you pay a stranger to use… no, I don’t think that’s right.

And I say this as someone who can’t have biological children, and has taken the decision not to use donor eggs and therefore has had to accept this means not being a parent (wouldn’t be approved to adopt).

Altruistic surrogacy absolutely treats children as commodities. Just because it might be free, doesn’t mean it’s OK.

ConcussedPigeon · 17/05/2022 17:28

orwellwasright · 17/05/2022 14:46

As the mother of a child conceived using a donor egg, I'm just rocking up to let you know you've basically invited a load of women to say incredibly offensive things about something I very much doubt they have any personal experience of.

If you're pleased with that, then crack on. Well done, you.

Ditto.

Sortilege · 17/05/2022 17:25

Elsiebear90 · 17/05/2022 17:12

If that was a survey of their own website users then it’s likely to be heavily biased, as I imagine most people who have no issue with being donor conceived don’t use websites created to support people who are struggling with it?

Yes I think that’s true of most sources, but at least for an organised survey, the link will have been widely shared, including on social media, which means anyone with a strong view could have participated.

OP posts:
TheKeatingFive · 17/05/2022 17:24

It already has and that’s why we have the laws and regulations we do

Globally I'd say the laws and regulations leave a LOT to be desired

Organictangerine · 17/05/2022 17:23

want2bemum · 17/05/2022 17:16

Well in that case you would be wrong.

As someone who may have to use donor sperm to conceive a child, I have thought a lot, and deeply, about the ethics, including the donor and the potential child.

This is why it is problematic when people who are not in the situation themselves judge those who are. You do not truly know what the journey entails or what people go through.

To be honest I don’t think what the prospective parents have been through, changes the ethics of donor gametes as a stand-alone thing. The suffering of the parent isn’t inversely proportional to how ethical having a donor gamete child is - they’re sort of two separate issues if you see what I mean.

Elsiebear90 · 17/05/2022 17:21

TheKeatingFive · 17/05/2022 17:18

Well in that case you would be wrong.

In all fairness, you're not in a position to judge that. This needs to be looked at dispassionately with everyone's rights and requirements carefully considered.

It already has and that’s why we have the laws and regulations we do…

TheKeatingFive · 17/05/2022 17:18

Well in that case you would be wrong.

In all fairness, you're not in a position to judge that. This needs to be looked at dispassionately with everyone's rights and requirements carefully considered.

TheKeatingFive · 17/05/2022 17:17

Anyone having a baby is making a selfish choice, let’s not pretend that’s a trait exclusive to people who suffer from infertility.

I don't think anyone is pretending that, but there's a difference when you're involving others in your decisions.

GodspeedJune · 17/05/2022 17:17

Cross posted with Elsie and Cookie

want2bemum · 17/05/2022 17:16

TheKeatingFive · 17/05/2022 17:11

Parents of donor conceived children have been through so much more on their journey to become parents, and will have thought through the ethics and implications of this more than you can possibly imagine.

From their own POV perhaps. I wouldn't be sanguine they've thought too much about the donor's.

Well in that case you would be wrong.

As someone who may have to use donor sperm to conceive a child, I have thought a lot, and deeply, about the ethics, including the donor and the potential child.

This is why it is problematic when people who are not in the situation themselves judge those who are. You do not truly know what the journey entails or what people go through.

GodspeedJune · 17/05/2022 17:16

Anyone having a baby is making a selfish choice, let’s not pretend that’s a trait exclusive to people who suffer from infertility.

There are a billion ways that children, conceived naturally or not, can be affected by their parents choices. Research shows that children conceived by IVF have good outcomes.

I have frozen embryos, with my eggs and my partners sperm. If we have any left over, we would seriously consider donating them. To destroy them would seem like an utter waste of potential life.

cookiemonster2468 · 17/05/2022 17:14

Elsiebear90 · 17/05/2022 17:05

I think creating any child is selfish though, it’s all about what you want, if it was about giving a child a good home you would adopt. It’s about fulfilling your own desires ultimately. Very few family situations are perfect, I think if you can provide a child (whether your own biologically or through donor conception) with a loving, stable good home then that’s better than what a lot of kids get growing up.

Indeed.

Nobody is bringing children into the world for altruistic reasons.

Especially not now, with climate change, the rising cost of living, and all the various crises that humans are likely to live through in the next 100 years.

You are not choosing to have a child for the child's sake. You are having the child for yourself, however they are conceived.

Elsiebear90 · 17/05/2022 17:12

Sortilege · 17/05/2022 17:07

Oh thanks! That’s a goldmine. I’ll read that now.

If that was a survey of their own website users then it’s likely to be heavily biased, as I imagine most people who have no issue with being donor conceived don’t use websites created to support people who are struggling with it?

TheKeatingFive · 17/05/2022 17:11

Parents of donor conceived children have been through so much more on their journey to become parents, and will have thought through the ethics and implications of this more than you can possibly imagine.

From their own POV perhaps. I wouldn't be sanguine they've thought too much about the donor's.

Quietlyhere · 17/05/2022 17:10

Of course there are many opinions on this complex topic. I agree people have the right to discuss it despite the sensitivity.

I just wanted to add my voice as someone who has been through multiple failed NHS IVF rounds. We were told in the end that it would only be worth trying again with donor eggs. Despite being in a distressing situation, it didn't feel right to me. It was a step too far for me personally. So we don't have children. I don't see it as a right and we can't control everything in our lives.

want2bemum · 17/05/2022 17:10

drpet49 · 17/05/2022 16:53

Personally no, I think donor sperm/eggs/surrogacy should all be illegal.

The problem with all of these procedures is that they are all about someone becoming a parent with very little thought given to the children who are the product of these arrangements.

^I agree

What a load of absolute nonsense.

Parents of donor conceived children have been through so much more on their journey to become parents, and will have thought through the ethics and implications of this more than you can possibly imagine.

When using a donor to conceive, counselling for the parent(s) is obligitory to ensure you have explored your own feelings and those of the child conceived.

By the time a child is conceived, they have thought an awful lot more more about parenting and providing for the potential child's needs than the vast majority of people who conceive naturally.

ChocChipPancake · 17/05/2022 17:09

This reply has been withdrawn

This has been withdrawn by MNHQ on OP's request.

TheKeatingFive · 17/05/2022 17:09

As others have said, unless you’ve been in this position I think its shameful to judge.

No, I think we need to be careful with this line of argument. It's not just prospective parents we need to be thinking of. It's the donor mothers and the children themselves. People's desire for a child doesn't trump what's right for those individuals.

Sortilege · 17/05/2022 17:07

toastofthetown · 17/05/2022 17:00

This is from a website linked upthread which I found interesting. Overwhelmingly the view of this survey is that conception should not be anonymous, and most of those who we conceived from an anonymous donation found it harmful. Most feel the identity of the donor should be available from birth, whereas now it’s from 18. The question I found most interesting is that around two thirds of respondents said that their parents weren’t aware of their true feelings regarding being donor conceived.

Oh thanks! That’s a goldmine. I’ll read that now.

OP posts:
TheKeatingFive · 17/05/2022 17:06

Actually I think this topic should be given far more consideration and discussion than it is. It's ethically very complex.