Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

What’s the general MN verdict on donor eggs?

460 replies

Sortilege · 17/05/2022 14:22

The general critical re-examination of surrogacy is quite evident, and I have my own views on that, which I’ll keep quiet for the purposes of this thread.

Now I find myself chewing over other fertility treatment. I’ve had fertility treatment myself and so have family members. So I have a sense of how private clinics put you on a conveyor belt and normalise things.

What is the general view on donor eggs & embryos (implanted into the birth mother and gestated by her)?

Im trying really hard not to bias the result so have tossed a coin to assign YABU/YANBU to viewpoints. Don’t read into that.

YANBU = Donor gametes are ethically fine.
YABU = Donor gametes are problematic.

OP posts:
shewasa99 · 17/05/2022 18:09

TheKeatingFive · 17/05/2022 17:41

What one woman chooses to take out of her body and another put into her body is their business and not yours

Not if there's an unequal power dynamic open to exploitation

would you make that comment about organs?

I wasn't trying to approve of exploitation. I suppose that is why I used the word 'chooses' rather than 'forced'.

I was trying to make the point that this is about body autonomy and people should stop trying to control women's bodies and their reproductive functions (not sure function is the right word - sorry).

An egg is not an organ. Organs are usually needed to continue life, eggs are needed to create a new one.

Sushi7 · 17/05/2022 18:08

The egg retrieval process (from what I’ve read) is pretty nasty, as is the recovery. My issue is that it’s mainly poor young women who are preyed upon to believe this is a quick and easy way to make money. It‘s. eerily reminiscent of The Handmaid’s Tale. It must be even worse if you donate your eggs to someone you know. It might be really freaky and heartbreaking to see someone raising your doppelgänger. Also, you’ll be birthing a dc that isn’t genetically yours. Kind of like adoption but with the childbirth experience. I’m struggling with my fertility issues (despite being in my 20s) and I wouldn’t choose egg donation for all the above reasons.

Organictangerine · 17/05/2022 18:07

Clymene · 17/05/2022 17:59

Homophobic! It's extraordinarily homophobic.

Good god when is mn going to sort out this quoting issue

I don’t think so. I think a parent should know both of their biological parents. Ideally people in same sex relationships would find a donor who also wanted to be a parent and make it work.

I know one person conceived by sperm donor to a mum who is a lesbian. She had him quite late in life - 42/43 I think - so she’s his entire family. She’s also… not the most caring mum shall we say, I think she has had a very problematic life. I really worry for him. I remember her refusing to seek medical attention for him when he clearly needed it as a toddler, i won’t say why as outing but not all people who use donors are lovely caring parents.

FfeminyddCymraeg · 17/05/2022 18:05

FourTeaFallOut · 17/05/2022 14:46

I think that there are ethical considerations around it that don't really get much of an airing. There was a tread once about a woman who used her sister's eggs to conceive a child/children and was upset because her sister was upset that she had considered using another egg which was already frozen to have another. What followed has a conversation that couched in terms that sounded a lot more like property law than the usual terms we hear - like gift and selflessness.

I don't think there are any easy answers but I think the questions and assumptions, like about who actually is the mother and what rights do each party have, including that of the conceived child, that are important but missing in a broader societal conversation about the impact of new narratives about parents, women and children which emerge with donor and surrogacy technologies.

I remember that thread - I wonder what the outcome was? I really felt for the sister who had done a wonderful thing but only expected one child to come the process.

FictionalCharacter · 17/05/2022 18:03

Sortilege · 17/05/2022 16:38

Yes, it must be difficult. Even at the point when you’re considering treatment, you’ve already lost impartiality to some extent. I know that from experience.

That is part of the reason my rational head says we should have had this debate and ironed out the policy wrinkles before donor conception went mainstream. The problem was, I suspect, that nobody anticipated that it would go mainstream.

The policy was very much considered though, certainly in the uk. The HFEA was founded in 1990 - surely that was recognition that it was mainstream.

InChocolateWeTrust · 17/05/2022 18:01

I had some fertility problems but the one thing i always knew was that i didn't want donor eggs unless they came from my sister. I needed a connection. I didn't want a baby, I wanted mine. I concluded that I would rather be a brilliant, involved auntie to my siblings kids than go down the donor route.

Maybe I would have felt differently if I didnt already have a niece and nephew I loved, maybe I wouldnt have felt the same 10 years later and still childless (as it happened, I did conceive).

I completely respect everyone else's feelings choices though, as long as they are choices and not poor people exploited for money.

Clymene · 17/05/2022 18:01

Oops. There's an update. Apologies Blush

Ifitistobesaid · 17/05/2022 18:00

I have long term infertility and have done a lot of research into the views of donor conceived adults in case it’s a route we go down in the future.

I’ve wrestled with whether it’s fair on the children but having done the research I feel pretty comfortable now that donor conception is not harmful in itself, though certain aspects of it are. Namely secrecy and finding out late, and having a totally anonymous donor. Those who have known their whole life and have info or a relationship with the donor seem well adjusted about it. I’ve even come across donor conceived adults who used a donor themselves to conceive their children.

What is also is harmful is the stigma around it, and to be honest I think threads like this just perpetuate that. You are inviting people to be judgemental about a very sensitive topic. It’s not a binary ‘AIBU’ or not.

Clymene · 17/05/2022 17:59

Homophobic! It's extraordinarily homophobic.

Good god when is mn going to sort out this quoting issue

Clymene · 17/05/2022 17:58

AlternativePerspective · 17/05/2022 17:53

so, as I asked upthread, if it’s ok to essentially buy a child through surrogacy/donation and only those who have been through infertility are allowed an opinion, then why is it wrong to buy an organ such as a kidney? After all it all comes down to their body their choice when it comes to the donation doesn’t it?

So basically all women who want children need to be in a loving heterosexual relationship to have children?

That's extraordinary homophobic.

Franca123 · 17/05/2022 17:57

@Sortilege Stacy Dooley has a DNA programme on IPlayer which sometimes touches on these issues. On NowTV there was a documentary about Doctor in the 60s in the US who impregnated tonnes of women with his own sperm.

AlternativePerspective · 17/05/2022 17:53

so, as I asked upthread, if it’s ok to essentially buy a child through surrogacy/donation and only those who have been through infertility are allowed an opinion, then why is it wrong to buy an organ such as a kidney? After all it all comes down to their body their choice when it comes to the donation doesn’t it?

Elsiebear90 · 17/05/2022 17:52

Organictangerine · 17/05/2022 17:42

Imagine if hers hadn’t been successful…

I also find it unethical when people deliberately choose a foreign clinic with anonymity laws so their child cannot find their biological parent when they get older

basically depriving them of that in order to fulfil a ‘fantasy’

I don’t think many people do that for the anonymity laws, they do it because the laws in this country have led to a huge shortage of donor eggs and sperm because the vast majority of people donating don’t want kids turning up on their doorstep 18 years later. For a lot of people it’s down to cost as well, I know a couple who went to Greece for their donated embryo as it was half the price.

Lynnthesearesexnotgenderpeople · 17/05/2022 17:51

I know from experience that a child who is the product of a donor gamete can have the most loving, wonderful parents, never want for anything and basically have 'the perfect upbringing' and still have major issues stemming from the fact that they know that one of their parents isn't their biological parent.

Humans are kind of wired to want to know this stuff.

I also disagree with egg donation having seen how some women are exploited. It's also quite hard on the body with the drugs needed to stimulate and harvest the eggs, and can even cause strokes and other medical issues. Very different to spaffing into a little plastic cup.

InChocolateWeTrust · 17/05/2022 17:44

I think things freely given, out of love, between family/close friends is ok. Whether surrogacy by a sibling/mum/cousin, donor eggs from a sibling etc.

Where money changes hands there's just so much potential for exploitation, I would just always worry that the donor didn't truly want to give those eggs.

Blistory · 17/05/2022 17:43

There hasn't been long enough time for us to know how children conceived from donor eggs/sperm feel as they age.

I am very much loved and have an amazing, confused and blended family. Growing up I would have told anyone that none of it mattered - my mum and dad were my parents and they cherished me.

Over 50 years later, I feel differently. I feel connected to my mother but with my father, I felt like I was a second class child as I wasn't his. I don't need to know who my sperm donor is. Knowing that my father loved me as much as his biological children doesn't help because deep down, the older I get, the less I feel this is true. The more I age, the more I feel lost and missing something. I still feel obliged to protect my mother's feelings by telling her that none of it makes a difference to me - I suspect a lot of donor children and adopted children say this and mean it when they are younger but find their perspective changes as they age. I don't judge my parents for the choices they made but it's me that lives with the consequence of it and it weighs heavy times. It's not something I think of frequently but it's there. Would I feel that way if raised by two biological parents ? I don't know.

Organictangerine · 17/05/2022 17:42

lonelygirl15 · 17/05/2022 17:36

Someone I know donated eggs whilst undergoing IVF, basically the clinic did some sort of ‘deal’ where you would get a free round of IVF if you donated eggs at the same time! Not sure whether this is still legal practice? It felt a bit off as I think they were more motivated by their own desperation for a child and the fact that would help significantly with the costs. The donor eggs lead to a successful pregnancy and she finds it a bit uncomfortable that she has an unknown ‘biological’ child somewhere the same age as her other child.

Imagine if hers hadn’t been successful…

I also find it unethical when people deliberately choose a foreign clinic with anonymity laws so their child cannot find their biological parent when they get older

basically depriving them of that in order to fulfil a ‘fantasy’

TheKeatingFive · 17/05/2022 17:41

What one woman chooses to take out of her body and another put into her body is their business and not yours

Not if there's an unequal power dynamic open to exploitation

would you make that comment about organs?

Sortilege · 17/05/2022 17:39

lonelygirl15 · 17/05/2022 17:36

Someone I know donated eggs whilst undergoing IVF, basically the clinic did some sort of ‘deal’ where you would get a free round of IVF if you donated eggs at the same time! Not sure whether this is still legal practice? It felt a bit off as I think they were more motivated by their own desperation for a child and the fact that would help significantly with the costs. The donor eggs lead to a successful pregnancy and she finds it a bit uncomfortable that she has an unknown ‘biological’ child somewhere the same age as her other child.

Yes, that feels like unfair pressure at a vulnerable time, doesn’t it?

OP posts:
Soontobe60 · 17/05/2022 17:38

want2bemum · 17/05/2022 17:10

What a load of absolute nonsense.

Parents of donor conceived children have been through so much more on their journey to become parents, and will have thought through the ethics and implications of this more than you can possibly imagine.

When using a donor to conceive, counselling for the parent(s) is obligitory to ensure you have explored your own feelings and those of the child conceived.

By the time a child is conceived, they have thought an awful lot more more about parenting and providing for the potential child's needs than the vast majority of people who conceive naturally.

Your last comment is pretty offensive tbh. Some of us have thought long and hard about having a child, being a good parent, providing for them financially and emotionally.

Eastlyne · 17/05/2022 17:38

*As the mother of a child conceived using a donor egg, I'm just rocking up to let you know you've basically invited a load of women to say incredibly offensive things about something I very much doubt they have any personal experience of.

If you're pleased with that, then crack on. Well done, you*

= my emotions on this are really strong and I don't want other people talking about it in case they disagree with me.

Sorry, not how it works.

As others have said, unless you’ve been in this position I think its shameful to judge

The experience of people directly affected by an issue is important but other people are still allowed to have an opinion on the ethics of a situation.

Sortilege · 17/05/2022 17:37

Franca123 · 17/05/2022 17:32

@Sortilege I started to change my mind after watching a few documentaries concerning children born of donor sperm. Many of them were clearly struggling with their identity. This prompted me to think a lot deeper about the matter. I also worry about the exploitative nature of egg donation having been through ivf myself. It was gruelling. This should never be allowed to be done for money or for equivalent compensation.

Thanks for answering.

I might have a look on YouTube for documentaries.

OP posts:
shewasa99 · 17/05/2022 17:36

Her body, her choice.

What one woman chooses to take out of her body and another put into her body is their business and not yours.

If you make surrogacy/ donation illegal it will only go underground and endanger women.

Foetuses don't have rights and eggs, sperm and uteruses certainly don't.

If you would ban surrogacy/donation because the subsequent child might not know her mother or father then you had better ban one night stands where the man doesn't leave his forwarding details, make it a serious offence for women not to put the name of a deadbeat, violent but known father on the birth certificate and end adoptions and removals into care where the birth parents are written out of the child's life.

The most important thing for a child is to be loved and surrogate/donated children are. They are born and they are blessed.

lonelygirl15 · 17/05/2022 17:36

Someone I know donated eggs whilst undergoing IVF, basically the clinic did some sort of ‘deal’ where you would get a free round of IVF if you donated eggs at the same time! Not sure whether this is still legal practice? It felt a bit off as I think they were more motivated by their own desperation for a child and the fact that would help significantly with the costs. The donor eggs lead to a successful pregnancy and she finds it a bit uncomfortable that she has an unknown ‘biological’ child somewhere the same age as her other child.

Elsiebear90 · 17/05/2022 17:36

TheKeatingFive · 17/05/2022 17:24

It already has and that’s why we have the laws and regulations we do

Globally I'd say the laws and regulations leave a LOT to be desired

I agree in regards to surrogacy and I think there are issues with commercial egg donation in particular as it targets young poor women or women desperate for fertility treatment themselves.

However, the rights of donor conceived children have been discussed objectively in this country already which is why they have the legal rights they do. I respect that you may not agree with the outcomes, but it definitely has been discussed objectively, probably many many times as it’s not a new concept, by experts across many fields and the consensus was that people should be allowed to use donor eggs and sperm.

So I don’t see why anyone wouldn’t go for that option if they needed to and could afford to unless they had a moral objection to it. There’s not really (AFAIK) any strong evidence to say donor conceived children overall, suffer from how they were conceived.