Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

What’s the general MN verdict on donor eggs?

460 replies

Sortilege · 17/05/2022 14:22

The general critical re-examination of surrogacy is quite evident, and I have my own views on that, which I’ll keep quiet for the purposes of this thread.

Now I find myself chewing over other fertility treatment. I’ve had fertility treatment myself and so have family members. So I have a sense of how private clinics put you on a conveyor belt and normalise things.

What is the general view on donor eggs & embryos (implanted into the birth mother and gestated by her)?

Im trying really hard not to bias the result so have tossed a coin to assign YABU/YANBU to viewpoints. Don’t read into that.

YANBU = Donor gametes are ethically fine.
YABU = Donor gametes are problematic.

OP posts:
Organictangerine · 17/05/2022 19:11

AliceAbsolum · 17/05/2022 18:50

I was told after my failed NHS cycle that I would need donor eggs and I could go on a waiting list for 2 years to wait for someone to share their eggs with me, and it would cost £15,000. Oddly enough I did not take that option. I paid £5000 and was guaranteed 10 eggs. My donor was British, at university in Cyprus, and was paid around £1000 in expenses.
I've read interviews with egg donors and so many say that they wanted to help women, and wanted financial support, for uni for example. Why would you stop that? No one is being forced into it.

The thing that pisses me off is that no one has these discussions about donor sperm. I think its utterly sexist. Women who have eggs that don't make babies are massively stigmatised in society. Its absolutely fine to use mens tissue to make babies, but as soon as its the woman who has the problems, the moral police come out in force.

Where is the reproductive freedom if you cant have your own biological children?

Because donating sperm has nowhere near the taxing effect on the body that egg retrieval does. In fact it’s positively enjoyable.

and why is biology important when it comes to parents having a child, but not when it comes to a child knowing both of their biological parents? Where is your child freedom to know the woman who donated you her eggs?

GingerCake2018 · 17/05/2022 19:08

My DN was conceived via a donor egg. The egg came from a women who was offered cheap IVF in exchange for excess eggs. To me this is unethical, and it's effectively coercion of desperate women, as I doubt many wealthy women recieving IVF are generously giving their eggs (and genetics) away out of the kindness of their hearts.

I also have concerns about the complex questions that individuals produced via donor IVF will have about their generic mother's as they grow up.

I would have been happy to donate an egg, and then SILs brother would have had to donate sperm (for obvious reasons), as to me that would have made more sense as it could be easily explained to the child that at a grandparent level there was no difference in terms of genetics, than if they had been conceived normally.

FictionalCharacter · 17/05/2022 18:58

@AliceAbsolum Good point. Men have been donating sperm (one way or another) for thousands of years and generally people aren’t telling them what they should or should not do.

Lastqueenofscotland2 · 17/05/2022 18:55

In theory I don’t have an issue with it but I think you NEED to be very honest with your child and be prepared to support therapy/them wanting to know who their genetic parents are and that being a difficult thing for them

Sortilege · 17/05/2022 18:54

FictionalCharacter · 17/05/2022 18:50

Apparently ivf with egg donation started in the 80s and the HFEA was set up to include all aspects of fertility treatment, including sperm and egg donation. I didn’t realise you were still talking just about egg donation though, because you said “donor conception” rather than “egg donation”.

I’ll see if I can find figures, but I am totally convinced egg donation was still unusual in 1990. I can remember specific cases getting substantial coverage as late as the turn of the millennium precisely because of the novelty.

I did make clear in the OP that the vote was about eggs/embryos rather than sperm.

OP posts:
AliceAbsolum · 17/05/2022 18:50

I was told after my failed NHS cycle that I would need donor eggs and I could go on a waiting list for 2 years to wait for someone to share their eggs with me, and it would cost £15,000. Oddly enough I did not take that option. I paid £5000 and was guaranteed 10 eggs. My donor was British, at university in Cyprus, and was paid around £1000 in expenses.
I've read interviews with egg donors and so many say that they wanted to help women, and wanted financial support, for uni for example. Why would you stop that? No one is being forced into it.

The thing that pisses me off is that no one has these discussions about donor sperm. I think its utterly sexist. Women who have eggs that don't make babies are massively stigmatised in society. Its absolutely fine to use mens tissue to make babies, but as soon as its the woman who has the problems, the moral police come out in force.

Where is the reproductive freedom if you cant have your own biological children?

WalkerWalking · 17/05/2022 18:50

Organictangerine · 17/05/2022 18:41

Because I wanted my own genetic child. But I’m not then depriving her of knowing her biological dad by saying ‘well genetics matter when it’s me wanting a child, but not you wanting to know your father’

This is my belief as well. But I was never actually tested on this myself- I have a feeling I wouldn't have been so selfless 💐

FictionalCharacter · 17/05/2022 18:50

Sortilege · 17/05/2022 18:14

Donor eggs weren’t a mainstream treatment in 1990. Were they even available. The availability of IVF, which has only been clinically/commercially available for a decade then, was the main impetus for the formation of the HFEA, surely?

Apparently ivf with egg donation started in the 80s and the HFEA was set up to include all aspects of fertility treatment, including sperm and egg donation. I didn’t realise you were still talking just about egg donation though, because you said “donor conception” rather than “egg donation”.

Thereisnolight · 17/05/2022 18:49

Organictangerine · 17/05/2022 18:41

Because I wanted my own genetic child. But I’m not then depriving her of knowing her biological dad by saying ‘well genetics matter when it’s me wanting a child, but not you wanting to know your father’

Agree.
I’m so glad the anonymity clause was scrapped. How can people presume to deny another person their right to know their own genetic history. It’s bizarre.

WalkerWalking · 17/05/2022 18:46

There's a lot of support for adoptive parents and adopted children in this country (because adoption is seen as finding a family for a child, rather than finding a child for a family- the child is absolutely front and centre, in the UK at least).

I'm concerned that there is none of this same support for donor conceived children, or children born through surrogacy.

Overthewine · 17/05/2022 18:46

This reply has been withdrawn

This has been withdrawn by MNHQ at the poster's request.

Organictangerine · 17/05/2022 18:41

Clymene · 17/05/2022 18:39

Why didn't you adopt @Organictangerine?

Because I wanted my own genetic child. But I’m not then depriving her of knowing her biological dad by saying ‘well genetics matter when it’s me wanting a child, but not you wanting to know your father’

Organictangerine · 17/05/2022 18:39

Clymene · 17/05/2022 18:38

@Organictangerine - there are millions of shit parents. Most of them are straight and in heterosexual relationships with children conceived through PIV sex . Not sure what your point is?

Just countering the notion that people conceiving using donor gametes are somehow inherently better parents that put more thought into it…

Clymene · 17/05/2022 18:39

Why didn't you adopt @Organictangerine?

Clymene · 17/05/2022 18:38

@Organictangerine - there are millions of shit parents. Most of them are straight and in heterosexual relationships with children conceived through PIV sex . Not sure what your point is?

Organictangerine · 17/05/2022 18:38

WalkerWalking · 17/05/2022 18:35

I guess the crux of the issue is that people with donor conceived children don't believe that genetics are a particularly important part of family/identity. And they could fairly reasonably assume that if their children hear that mantra from birth, then they will also grow up believing the same, and all will be good.

I suspect that for some people, however, genetics will always form a huge part of their identity, however they have been raised. It's a huge assumption that this just won't affect your child, no matter how fantastic a parent you are.

But, of course, we all know that children born to totally conventional families can have shitty parents and shitry childhoods.

If they’re not important why do they desire to conceive and carry and give birth to a child? Why do you need that biological ‘connection’, why not adopt?

And in the case of using a sperm donor, the same thing goes - obviously they have preferred to create a child using their own egg and a donor’s sperm rather than adopt because they want that genetic connection.

but when queried about whether donor gametes are ethical they suddenly say biology and genetics don’t matter?

breatheintheamazing · 17/05/2022 18:35

I think it's the most outrageously selfish act anyone can do to be honest.

I don't care if it's a same sex couple doing it or a single woman or man. So no homophobia there. It should be banned. It's a mental health crisis waiting to happen

WalkerWalking · 17/05/2022 18:35

I guess the crux of the issue is that people with donor conceived children don't believe that genetics are a particularly important part of family/identity. And they could fairly reasonably assume that if their children hear that mantra from birth, then they will also grow up believing the same, and all will be good.

I suspect that for some people, however, genetics will always form a huge part of their identity, however they have been raised. It's a huge assumption that this just won't affect your child, no matter how fantastic a parent you are.

But, of course, we all know that children born to totally conventional families can have shitty parents and shitry childhoods.

FourTeaFallOut · 17/05/2022 18:30

Orwellwasright - that's an odd name choice for someone telling people not to talk about things.

Teder · 17/05/2022 18:25

Given the law on anonymity was only changed in 2005 and was fully in force from April 2006, there just isn’t enough evidence to ascertain the implication for donor conceived children and adults. This is something that will emerge in time.

I have a dear friend going through donor conception in the U.K.. Being able to give information on background and identity is a huge factor in helping donor conceived individuals. Going abroad is problematic for the potential child. I know some people use these clinics due to cost and availability. I have some concerns over the ethics of a minority of parents who are actively consciously choosing to deny their child this information. Knowing your biological background is a fundamental right IMO.

Roastonsun8 · 17/05/2022 18:25

orwellwasright · 17/05/2022 14:46

As the mother of a child conceived using a donor egg, I'm just rocking up to let you know you've basically invited a load of women to say incredibly offensive things about something I very much doubt they have any personal experience of.

If you're pleased with that, then crack on. Well done, you.

If it makes you feel uncomfortable perhaps it's because it holds some truth? Why open the thread if you feel that way?

Anyway what I wonder is about the poor child and adult later on in life. What about that child's identity... where do they come from as in background? A whole side of the family missing? Looking from this angle I think it's wrong. I would be interested why the men would want to give their sperm away to multiple people..not even one! I mean you have created a child and then just gone about your day to day life and bases upon that POV it's sickening that a man can do that.

QueenofDestruction · 17/05/2022 18:22

The idea it isn't discussed is worse, it should be openly debated taking into consideration of children born of these donations.

TheDuchessOfMN · 17/05/2022 18:17

The donors are often young women in university in Eastern European countries. I wonder how many of them feel now, ten years later and having their own babies, knowing that that baby has a sibling

It’s exploitation of young women. None of those women would go through it if it weren’t for financial reasons

TheKeatingFive · 17/05/2022 18:16

I wasn't trying to approve of exploitation. I suppose that is why I used the word 'chooses' rather than 'forced'.

'choices' aren't always freely made though. Which we need to be on the alert for. And there can be emotional manipulation also.

Organs are usually needed to continue life, eggs are needed to create a new one.

Its not nothing to retrieve an egg. There can be considerable stresses on the body and very occasionally outcomes like stroke. We do need to acknowledge that.

Sortilege · 17/05/2022 18:14

FictionalCharacter · 17/05/2022 18:03

The policy was very much considered though, certainly in the uk. The HFEA was founded in 1990 - surely that was recognition that it was mainstream.

Donor eggs weren’t a mainstream treatment in 1990. Were they even available. The availability of IVF, which has only been clinically/commercially available for a decade then, was the main impetus for the formation of the HFEA, surely?

OP posts:
Swipe left for the next trending thread