Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

What’s the general MN verdict on donor eggs?

460 replies

Sortilege · 17/05/2022 14:22

The general critical re-examination of surrogacy is quite evident, and I have my own views on that, which I’ll keep quiet for the purposes of this thread.

Now I find myself chewing over other fertility treatment. I’ve had fertility treatment myself and so have family members. So I have a sense of how private clinics put you on a conveyor belt and normalise things.

What is the general view on donor eggs & embryos (implanted into the birth mother and gestated by her)?

Im trying really hard not to bias the result so have tossed a coin to assign YABU/YANBU to viewpoints. Don’t read into that.

YANBU = Donor gametes are ethically fine.
YABU = Donor gametes are problematic.

OP posts:
imperialminty · 17/05/2022 21:04

This reply has been deleted

This has been withdrawn by MNHQ on OP's request.

But having a child isn’t necessary in any medical way??

And also the NHS already does that - it makes decisions on when to offer and withdraw treatment all the time.

Sortilege · 17/05/2022 21:04

VeryTrying22 · 17/05/2022 20:57

But there is no need for discussion on this topic. If I posted a thread titled ‘what’s your views on teen mothers, I think they’re so wrong and babies shouldn’t be born to teenage girls because they’re shit parents’ it would be considered goading and most likely taken down.

I think that’s an utterly bizarre and totalitarian viewpoint, but if you honestly think that “there’s no need for discussion on this topic”, please do report the thread to MNHQ.

OP posts:
FourTeaFallOut · 17/05/2022 21:03

VeryTrying22 · 17/05/2022 21:01

More like ‘those with no common sense or empathy be quiet’

the same would apply to men making such sweeping, inaccurate and nasty comments on such an emotive subject

I don't exclude differing voices from discussion.

FourTeaFallOut · 17/05/2022 21:02

They are boards that are managed to build community, the chat forum and aibu are for discussion. You could bring up any one of those topics on this board and expect robust debate with many voices.

Sortilege · 17/05/2022 21:02

VeryTrying22 · 17/05/2022 20:57

But there is no need for discussion on this topic. If I posted a thread titled ‘what’s your views on teen mothers, I think they’re so wrong and babies shouldn’t be born to teenage girls because they’re shit parents’ it would be considered goading and most likely taken down.

Probably, but that’s not analogous. I very carefully didn’t express an opinion or a bias. I was asking an open question to find out what people really thought, because despite thinking about it quite hard for years, I’m still a bit on the fence myself.

Which is light years from “what’s your views on X, I think they’re so wrong and babies shouldn’t be born to Y because Z is shit.”

OP posts:
VeryTrying22 · 17/05/2022 21:01

FourTeaFallOut · 17/05/2022 20:46

Yeah, more "Women. Be quiet" shit. Fuck that for a game of soldiers. Perhaps a discussion forum is not for you?

More like ‘those with no common sense or empathy be quiet’

the same would apply to men making such sweeping, inaccurate and nasty comments on such an emotive subject

VeryTrying22 · 17/05/2022 20:59

FourTeaFallOut · 17/05/2022 20:35

Can you think of any other topic where it would be a good idea to confine a topic of conversation to those that have the most to gain from it?

Many actually

adoption - there is a reason posts on that sub are blocked from showing up in active for this very reason tbh
infertility
IVF
ways to grieve

just to name a few topics where those who haven’t experienced the topic shouldn’t really chime in.

Mossstitch · 17/05/2022 20:58

To me it's just like eggs on the supermarket shelf, they are never going to become chicks. It's the combining with a sperm (which nobody has a problem with the donation of) and every cell is nourished/grown by the woman who eventually gives birth and becomes the loving mother. End of the story, she is the parent! I don't, however, feel that money should change hands for any of this, it should only be for altruistic reasons that anybody donates, just like blood products.

Sortilege · 17/05/2022 20:58

TheKeatingFive · 17/05/2022 20:54

Well someone did say 'ew'

Yes ISWSMs now.

I don’t see what good it does to know that some random mumsnet user thinks it’s ‘eww’. is a bit hyperbolic, though, isn’t it? We’re not all here discussing that post. Most of us did not even notice that post.

OP posts:
VeryTrying22 · 17/05/2022 20:57

TheKeatingFive · 17/05/2022 20:49

I don’t see what good it does to know that some random mumsnet user thinks it’s ‘eww’.

Absolutely no one is saying that however.

There is discussion about the ethics of it from everyone's point of view. And yes people are entitled to an opinion about that and to express it.

But there is no need for discussion on this topic. If I posted a thread titled ‘what’s your views on teen mothers, I think they’re so wrong and babies shouldn’t be born to teenage girls because they’re shit parents’ it would be considered goading and most likely taken down.

Sortilege · 17/05/2022 20:56

Ifitistobesaid · 17/05/2022 20:47

There’s a difference between confining conversation and giving people an opportunity to be judgemental about a sensitive topic they know nothing about.

By all means we should listen to donor conceived adults, donors, child psychologists and parents through donation. And if reform is needed it should come through their lived experience.

I don’t see what good it does to know that some random mumsnet user thinks it’s ‘eww’.

Oh I see you mean the person who just plop-posted “eww” and ran (!?)

You know the purpose of the discussion isn’t to discuss their “view” right? Everybody except you quietly ignored that post.

OP posts:
VeryTrying22 · 17/05/2022 20:55

Clymene · 17/05/2022 20:46

People should be allowed to talk about anything. If it offends or upsets people then they can just hide the thread

Nah, this forum shuts down posts that offend a certain set of posters all the time.

clearly people on here aren’t able to talk about anything and expect people to hide threads.

TheKeatingFive · 17/05/2022 20:54

Well someone did say 'ew'

Sortilege · 17/05/2022 20:54

Ifitistobesaid · 17/05/2022 20:47

There’s a difference between confining conversation and giving people an opportunity to be judgemental about a sensitive topic they know nothing about.

By all means we should listen to donor conceived adults, donors, child psychologists and parents through donation. And if reform is needed it should come through their lived experience.

I don’t see what good it does to know that some random mumsnet user thinks it’s ‘eww’.

Nobody said “eww”. 🤨

This might work better if you read the thread.

OP posts:
TheKeatingFive · 17/05/2022 20:54

literally the very first post said that.

ok I stand corrected. Given it was only two letters it didn't register. However to sum up the thread as a whole like that is a total misrepresentation.

Ifitistobesaid · 17/05/2022 20:52

@TheKeatingFive literally the very first post said that.

Sortilege · 17/05/2022 20:50

VeryTrying22 · 17/05/2022 20:40

well not on this forum no, the amount of absolute batshit views around surrogacy, drag queens and various other emotive subjects shows it’s not the most balanced place.

And of course you wouldn’t want to be a part of such a discussion forum? 🙄

OP posts:
FourTeaFallOut · 17/05/2022 20:50

It's now eww, it's reasonable arguments and observations that can be made without a view to achieving a consensus that benefits those demanding the loudest voice. It's not for you to say who can and cannot speak.

TheKeatingFive · 17/05/2022 20:49

I don’t see what good it does to know that some random mumsnet user thinks it’s ‘eww’.

Absolutely no one is saying that however.

There is discussion about the ethics of it from everyone's point of view. And yes people are entitled to an opinion about that and to express it.

ChocChipPancake · 17/05/2022 20:48

This reply has been withdrawn

This has been withdrawn by MNHQ on OP's request.

Ifitistobesaid · 17/05/2022 20:47

There’s a difference between confining conversation and giving people an opportunity to be judgemental about a sensitive topic they know nothing about.

By all means we should listen to donor conceived adults, donors, child psychologists and parents through donation. And if reform is needed it should come through their lived experience.

I don’t see what good it does to know that some random mumsnet user thinks it’s ‘eww’.

movintothecountry · 17/05/2022 20:47

Just wanted to add to something an earlier poster said about many people being too polite to air their views on egg donation in real life. I agree.
This is something I wouldn't discuss with people IRL because I don't want to hurt people's feelings. As we have seen on here, some can get very distressed and I'm not trying to be a dick to people who have obviously had a hard time creating a family.

However I do think it's deeply unethical and exploitative. You should have to pass a financial test to donate eggs and only do it if you have savings over a certain limit, and can fund your own fertility treatment several times over if needed. Then we would really see how much of a 'free choice' it is Hmm

I expect if that happened we would see next to no egg doners, because barring a few altruistic exceptions, most women are unlikely to fancy giving away what basically amounts to one of their own biological children to strangers out of the goodness of their heart.

FourTeaFallOut · 17/05/2022 20:46

Yeah, more "Women. Be quiet" shit. Fuck that for a game of soldiers. Perhaps a discussion forum is not for you?

Clymene · 17/05/2022 20:46

People should be allowed to talk about anything. If it offends or upsets people then they can just hide the thread

ChocChipPancake · 17/05/2022 20:45

This reply has been withdrawn

This has been withdrawn by MNHQ on OP's request.