Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

What’s the general MN verdict on donor eggs?

460 replies

Sortilege · 17/05/2022 14:22

The general critical re-examination of surrogacy is quite evident, and I have my own views on that, which I’ll keep quiet for the purposes of this thread.

Now I find myself chewing over other fertility treatment. I’ve had fertility treatment myself and so have family members. So I have a sense of how private clinics put you on a conveyor belt and normalise things.

What is the general view on donor eggs & embryos (implanted into the birth mother and gestated by her)?

Im trying really hard not to bias the result so have tossed a coin to assign YABU/YANBU to viewpoints. Don’t read into that.

YANBU = Donor gametes are ethically fine.
YABU = Donor gametes are problematic.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Rubyupbeat · 02/06/2022 09:34

I have no thoughts on it, as I have never been in the situation of desperately wanting a child.
But, I would never have donated my eggs to anyone. The thought of someone giving birth and bringing up 'my' child is really not good .

DonorConceivedMe · 02/06/2022 09:20

Gamete donation is in the Guardian today. Sperm donor with genetic condition

DonorConceivedMe · 02/06/2022 00:19

@House12
Inviting an ill-informed mob to chip in with comments on the “ethics” of altruistic donation for a bit of light entertainment is grim af. It’s like posting “who thinks immigration is ok” and then sitting back to enjoy the self-righteous responses.
Huh? “ill-informed mob”?! Who says who’s ill-informed? Seems to me that you define “ill-informed” as anyone who doesn’t agree with you, despite paying lip service to listening to donor conceived adults.

Some of those on this thread who’ve had children via assisted reproduction seem to think that they deserve a medal. Or handling with kid gloves. Or both. It’s strange.

Sushi7 · 01/06/2022 17:31

HeadNorth · 19/05/2022 20:04

I am very conflicted on this as my young daughter chose to donate her eggs as a first year student. It was all done correctly through the NHS and I found that pretty appalling. She was only 18, just left home for University, what did she know about the implications of her actions? But the NHS was happy to harvest her healthy young eggs, probably for a much older woman, which I cannot feel is right and feels a bit Handmaids Tale.

So I may well have a biological grandchild out there. And my lovely altruistic daughter will have to live with this as she grows up and matures and may well get a door knock in 18 years time. So I think far more caution and circumspection is needed than currently exists in the process.

This is why I think egg “donors” should be unpaid. You’re not donating something if you’re being paid. It makes me so uncomfortable that older women who can’t conceive due to their old eggs take advantage of very young women who are desperate for money.

It also makes me uncomfortable that IVF is discounted if you donate your eggs. What if you don’t conceive but another woman does because she’s used your eggs? Again, taking advantage of desperate women.

I’m a young woman (mid 20s) waiting to see a fertility specialist/gynaecologist. I think my issue is due to random ovulation and irregular periods. I will draw the line at using donor eggs. I want my dc to be biologically mine.

TheKeatingFive · 01/06/2022 16:44

“Reduced ivf” is an egg sharing program

Yes, I misread, apologies. However those in egg sharing programmes/being paid for their eggs will make up a significant proportion of those donating, so we can't exactly airbrush them out of the conversation and get on with our day. What percentage of U.K. donations are entirely altruistic btw? And even there we need to understand the role of emotional pressure.

I’m not shutting anything down, but your post has somewhat proved my point.

That you don't want it discussed 😂 quite.

There are very important issues here for the children conceived of donor eggs and the donors themselves. It's crucial to debate the implications even if that makes you uncomfortable.

House12 · 01/06/2022 16:38

TheKeatingFive · 01/06/2022 14:59

Anyone donating here outside of egg-sharing programs is doing so with no financial recompense and altruistically.

aren't some people doing it for reduced IVF? That's financial recompense. And even if your point was correct, it doesn't mean it's morally or ethically unproblematic.

Inviting an ill-informed mob to chip in with comments on the “ethics” of altruistic donation for a bit of light entertainment is grim af

These are important ethical issues to debate, you don't get to shut this conversation down because you don't like it.

“Reduced ivf” is an egg sharing program. I’m not shutting anything down, but your post has somewhat proved my point.

TheKeatingFive · 01/06/2022 14:59

Anyone donating here outside of egg-sharing programs is doing so with no financial recompense and altruistically.

aren't some people doing it for reduced IVF? That's financial recompense. And even if your point was correct, it doesn't mean it's morally or ethically unproblematic.

Inviting an ill-informed mob to chip in with comments on the “ethics” of altruistic donation for a bit of light entertainment is grim af

These are important ethical issues to debate, you don't get to shut this conversation down because you don't like it.

SleeplessInEngland · 01/06/2022 14:59

House12 · 01/06/2022 14:56

Egg donation in the UK is not paid bar expenses. Anyone donating here outside of egg-sharing programs is doing so with no financial recompense and altruistically. Inviting an ill-informed mob to chip in with comments on the “ethics” of altruistic donation for a bit of light entertainment is grim af. It’s like posting “who thinks immigration is ok” and then sitting back to enjoy the self-righteous responses. If you genuinely want to know more about it go to the DCN website, or perhaps ask for the opinions of couples who have taken this route, or donor conceived adults.

Agreed. Apart from a few people saying IVF shouldn't be funded at all by the NHS (it does 1-3 tries depending on your postcode) this is the first time I've ever seen people morally opposed to altruistic egg donation full stop.

I guess you find all kinds of opinions on Mumsnet when the bait is wiggled.

House12 · 01/06/2022 14:56

Egg donation in the UK is not paid bar expenses. Anyone donating here outside of egg-sharing programs is doing so with no financial recompense and altruistically. Inviting an ill-informed mob to chip in with comments on the “ethics” of altruistic donation for a bit of light entertainment is grim af. It’s like posting “who thinks immigration is ok” and then sitting back to enjoy the self-righteous responses. If you genuinely want to know more about it go to the DCN website, or perhaps ask for the opinions of couples who have taken this route, or donor conceived adults.

TheKeatingFive · 22/05/2022 08:06

You can't adopt a cell.

Hmm, this is exactly the kind of double speak I was talking about upthread.

Its 'only a cell' when we're minimising what the donor gives up. If it actually was 'only a cell', why is it so valuable to those who want it?

The truth is, it's a cell with the potential to be a person and as such would contribute half of that persons DNA. So everyone involved in this process needs to be fully aware of the implications of that and their rights and feelings protected in the event that it does result in a person (which is of course the aim of the process).

There are similarities with adoption when it comes to transparency about the child's genetic legacy, yes.

Tandora · 22/05/2022 06:35

MangyInseam · 22/05/2022 02:52

I don't think donating gameets is ethical. Functionally, it's selling or giving away children, which is not ok.

what do you mean by “functionally”? So you think gametes are children?
reminds me of this song:

MangyInseam · 22/05/2022 02:52

I don't think donating gameets is ethical. Functionally, it's selling or giving away children, which is not ok.

Sortilege · 21/05/2022 23:38

Society IS still adjusting to it, I mean.

OP posts:
Sortilege · 21/05/2022 23:37

orwellwasright · 21/05/2022 23:22

I see it as a form of early adoption and I think viewing it this way would start to change the narrative around it for the benefit ultimately of all

No. A thousand times no. It really really wouldn't. That's some kind of fucked up handmaid's tale, pro life bullshit.

Foetuses don't even have rights FFS, let alone a cell. You can't adopt a cell.

Seriously. The shit spouted on here is frightening.

You can see why that description might be seen as helpful though? For recognising the genetic heritage? Not as an approach to legal parentage.

The fact is egg donation isn’t adoption but it isn’t as straightforward as IVF with your own gametes. So society isn’t still adjusting to it.

The only comparators we have for “children not genetically related to one or both parents” are “adopted children” and “step children”. It’s not offensive (or sci-fi) to say, “these are the pools of experience we have to draw on”,

OP posts:
Robinni · 21/05/2022 23:35

@orwellwasright

Respectfully, this is a discussion forum. No one’s opinion is irrelevant. And you can not force your ideology into other people, anymore than they could on you.

I empathised with @mucky123 and could see where they were coming from, because for me to have a donor egg would be “adopting” potentially a complete strangers genetic lineage into my family. And I’m not sure I would want to. That is not what it would feel like for all people just as not everyone has the same viewpoint on abortion.

Swearing, ranting, raving and saying different opinions aren’t permissible isn’t liable to convince people of your point of view.

Marvellousmadness · 21/05/2022 23:30

An egg. Yes.
An embryo?? That's basically adoption ....

orwellwasright · 21/05/2022 23:22

I see it as a form of early adoption and I think viewing it this way would start to change the narrative around it for the benefit ultimately of all

No. A thousand times no. It really really wouldn't. That's some kind of fucked up handmaid's tale, pro life bullshit.

Foetuses don't even have rights FFS, let alone a cell. You can't adopt a cell.

Seriously. The shit spouted on here is frightening.

orwellwasright · 21/05/2022 23:10

Anyone who thinks that genes trump everything else is setting an insane precedent. Surrogacy will always exist (whether people agree or not) and prioritising the genetic mother means that surrogates will become nothing more than wombs for hire.

The law deems the mother to be the woman who gave birth and that should always be the case.

orwellwasright · 21/05/2022 22:59

I see it as a form of early adoption

How lovely for you. That's not how the law sees it though so your opinion is pretty irrelevant.

Heart78 · 21/05/2022 22:39

I shared my eggs when I was doing IVF in return for a free round. Luckily for me, it worked first time and as far as I recall, my recipient had a successful pregnancy too. I have zero regrets and certainly didn’t feel forced in to the situation. I had the means to pay for IVF but decided to help another family going through infertility and I was having the invasive procedure in any case. I am fully aware that I may be contacted by a biological child of mine around the same time my son turns 18 and quite possibly at a later date too from siblings, should there have been subsequent successful pregnancies from the eggs that I shared.

DonorConceivedMe · 21/05/2022 13:26

The other thing to think about when contemplating donor conception is the unequal status of the two parents -- depending on exactly what gametes they use, who is the gestational parent etc. And as a PP said, having a DC child is saying both "genetics really matter" and "genetics really don't matter" at the same time.

There are families where a child was born via donor conception, then the parents had a child which was genetically "theirs" -- both of them. The difference in treatment between the donor conceived child and the "natural" child is striking. You're basically creating a child with the "step-parent" role built in. And we all know how difficult step-family relationships can be.

Lots of stories available on Anonymous Us . It's not all people who agree with me btw ;-)

Tandora · 20/05/2022 20:08

mucky123 · 20/05/2022 19:00

www.theguardian.com/society/2022/may/20/uk-fertility-watchdog-could-recommend-scrapping-donor-anonymity-law?fbclid=IwAR2iDMchCZYR-rBbZzzEqc4HIIZ9q6R_v5JH3PcFNxbx9Tz9EIE_0OF6vS8

Topical.

I guess the comparison to adoption is poor in the sense you say @Equalbutdifferent Gametes are just gametes until they become an actual child and I don't think anything around the decision-making of a woman in relation to her body should change.

However, for lots of DC people we use the literature and studies done in relation to adoption (of which they are currently lots more than in relation to DC) to help frame the narrative of the "genetic bewilderment"/separation from bio family that some of us feel. Obviously there are other parts of adoption that do not apply to the DC narrative (separation from birth mother, in utero trauma, post-natal trauma etc).

The other thing that is helpful in relation to adoption is the birth certificate. There is an initial birth certificate showing the birth/bio parents which is changed following the adoption to reflect that legal process. I would argue that there should be a similar process with DC people (perhaps reflecting the 3 parties that are part of the child's make-up but only showing two with parental responsibility).

Really informative. Thank you

mucky123 · 20/05/2022 19:00

www.theguardian.com/society/2022/may/20/uk-fertility-watchdog-could-recommend-scrapping-donor-anonymity-law?fbclid=IwAR2iDMchCZYR-rBbZzzEqc4HIIZ9q6R_v5JH3PcFNxbx9Tz9EIE_0OF6vS8

Topical.

I guess the comparison to adoption is poor in the sense you say @Equalbutdifferent Gametes are just gametes until they become an actual child and I don't think anything around the decision-making of a woman in relation to her body should change.

However, for lots of DC people we use the literature and studies done in relation to adoption (of which they are currently lots more than in relation to DC) to help frame the narrative of the "genetic bewilderment"/separation from bio family that some of us feel. Obviously there are other parts of adoption that do not apply to the DC narrative (separation from birth mother, in utero trauma, post-natal trauma etc).

The other thing that is helpful in relation to adoption is the birth certificate. There is an initial birth certificate showing the birth/bio parents which is changed following the adoption to reflect that legal process. I would argue that there should be a similar process with DC people (perhaps reflecting the 3 parties that are part of the child's make-up but only showing two with parental responsibility).

Tandora · 20/05/2022 18:52

Equalbutdifferent · 20/05/2022 17:50

We're in a lot of trouble in terms of women's reproductive rights if we confuse gametes with the potential to result in children, with children themselves. They are different things.

This is not to diminish the genetic legacy that is passed from donor to child. But it is to say that adoption is a poor comparison.

100% this.
not to in any way dismiss the absolute relevance and importance to all people to understand their biological heritage, and the pain of being kept in the dark about that, but gamete donation is not comparable to early adoption. A sperm is not a baby, nor is an egg.

whumpthereitis · 20/05/2022 18:42

Genetics may be meaningless to some, but they’re extremely important to others. Ultimately no one knows what genetics will mean to the child created from a donor, even if said child is told by the parents that they’re irrelevant.

It’s also potentially difficult for the donors, because while some may be interested in having a relationship with their biological offspring, you’ll have others that won’t have the slightest interest and will reject contact outright.

There’s a multitude of issues.