Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to be offended by this T-shirt?

366 replies

parklife1 · 17/05/2022 12:29

I saw a post on social media today. It was about two gay men becoming fathers of twins via surrogate. There was a picture of the two men in "DAD" T-shirts. The pregnant surrogate stood in between them with a T-shirt saying "NOT THE MOMMA".

I'm not even against surrogacy perse, but I found this picture offensive.

I understood why she was wearing it - she wanted to display that she doesn't want to have a mothering role in the children's life.

I still think it's a slap in the face of women, we go through so much during pregnancy and labour. Giving birth can be life-threatening, I lost 2.1 litres of blood during my first birth and 1 litre of blood during my second birth.

Many women have postpartum depression after birth and the hormones are on a roller-coaster.

My body will be forever marked by giving birth (stretch marks, C-section scar, mum tum).

To me this picture is just offensive, because it sort of portrays women and our bodies as a commodity.

AIBU?

OP posts:
TeaKlaxon · 17/05/2022 16:07

SoftSheen · 17/05/2022 15:27

There is no problem with a child having two Dads. They may be brilliant parents. The problem with surrogacy is that it is arranged to intentionally deprive a baby of its mother.* *Gay men who want to become parents can consider adoption or perhaps a co-parenting arrangement with a woman. Nobody (whatever their sex and orientation) should be paying someone else to make them a baby, because babies should not be commodities.

  1. Surrogacy isn't solely about payment. Not all surrogacy is commercial surrogacy.
  2. It's an odd way of looking at it to think that a specific child would be better off not existing than to exist but with a less usual relationship with their biological mother. Essentially that is what calls to ban surrogacy amount to (notwithstanding the fact that a ban is entirely unenforceable).
  3. Everyone seems to be labouring under the assumption that the fathers and surrogate in this situation (or indeed other situations) haven't thought long and hard about what role the surrogate will play in the child's life and how their life story will be handled. Many parents having a child through surrogacy consider this extensively, with detailed plans as to how the surrogate will be referred to, any contact she might have with the child etc.
Ohmybod · 17/05/2022 16:07

Franca123 · 17/05/2022 12:37

Yeah. It made me feel a bit ill too. Yes, you're selling your baby and got a fun t shirt to shout about it. I hope the baby finds that photo cute / funny in years to come.

She maybe didn’t sell her own baby though, did she? She might have rented her womb and carried someone else’s baby…it’s her choice. Maybe she does not want to be the ‘momma’ and is happy with that. I know a few women who have done this and all for altruistic reasons. And the male couple I know who had a baby this way are fantastic parents to happy kids. My own heterosexual parents were batshit and had many children (who they fucked up) by ‘traditional’ means.

OP I think you are projecting here and YABU to be offended.

TeaKlaxon · 17/05/2022 16:02

Twizbe · 17/05/2022 15:56

@TeaKlaxon did you not seem the multiple threads about Priyanka Chopra and Joe Jonas? Or the many Kim Kardashian and Kanya West threads.

Not to mention the Baldwins? Hilaria was pregnant when they commissioned their surrogate.

Also all the general threads on this topic not in response to a particular couple?

I have. They do not constitute two thirds of the discussion on this subject though.

Twizbe · 17/05/2022 15:56

@TeaKlaxon did you not seem the multiple threads about Priyanka Chopra and Joe Jonas? Or the many Kim Kardashian and Kanya West threads.

Not to mention the Baldwins? Hilaria was pregnant when they commissioned their surrogate.

Also all the general threads on this topic not in response to a particular couple?

Hallyup89 · 17/05/2022 15:55

Any woman wearing that t-shirt is more than likely to have had a choice in becoming a surrogate. She's unlikely to have been exploited. I find maternity shirts with baby-related slogans on quite crass, regardless, but I don't think it implies what you say it does.

Pllink · 17/05/2022 15:55

Lol it's not about you

TeaKlaxon · 17/05/2022 15:51

SunThroughTheCloudsAt6am · 17/05/2022 15:10

Because that would be nonsense. About 90% of negative commentary about surrogacy is focused on examples of gay couples, even though they only make up about one third of cases of surrogacy.

Why do you think that is?

I would hazard a guess that we only talk about ones that are published in the media for some reason - famous people, or those who post distasteful photos on social media. People who quietly buy a human and get on with their lives, we have no way of knowing about.

I see. So you just think gay people are more likely to post ‘distasteful photos’.

TeaKlaxon · 17/05/2022 15:49

ArmWrestlingWithChasNDave · 17/05/2022 15:04

By all means disprove it.

You made the claim, you back it up.

To do so you’d need to show that 66% of negative coverage about specific cases of surrogacy related to straight couples. That is demonstrably not the case though so good luck trying.

Ah, if it's "demonstrably" the case, then demonstrate it. We'll wait.

P.S. Not only do you not understand the burden of proof, but also maths and statistics. Not sure where you've pulled 66% from, but presumably the same place as your wild claims.

I explained where the 66% comes from.

straight couples make up two third of people in the UK using surrogacy.

so if opposition to surrogacy is genuinely blind to sexuality then we should see two thirds of negative views of surrogacy arise in respect of straight couples.

and yet it is the case that whenever an example is given of a specific case of surrogacy that people want to oppose it is almost always gay men, despite them making up only about a third of surrogacy cases.

why is that?

Hoppinggreen · 17/05/2022 15:43

I find everything about surrogacy offensive so a tshirt is the least of it

52andblue · 17/05/2022 15:41

I think what should be paramount is the CHILD.
The wishes & feelings of that child as they get older.
The fundamental right to know your parents (ALL of them, if birth & adopted)
so you know (all of) who you are which is very important developmentally.

The 'rights' and wishes of the adults are usually talked about but rarely the child.

After much thought, I had Icsi IVF as my husband turned out to be sub-fertile.
He was clear he didn't want to adopt as both his cousins were &, despite their adoptive parents being lovely people, they'd both found it hard at times.
I was clear that I would only 'do IVF' if we were using our own genetic material only. That is because I never knew my Father (& it was handled v badly) so I didn't want that for any child I helped to create. We all bring our experiences to the table but I do think the rights of the child (who will grow up) are overlooked.

And 'baby ownership' T-shirts are surely crass whichever way you look at it.

SliceOfCakeCupOfTea · 17/05/2022 15:37

I meant, it's a quote from a TV show so I can't get worked up by it.

buzzy06 · 17/05/2022 15:31

Collaborate · 17/05/2022 13:17

I find this whole thread quite homphobic actually.

That's great, except it's not, because people here are anti surrogacy for all, not anti-gay dads. Had they adopted or had a previous child, nobody would care. It's surrogacy they object to.

buzzy06 · 17/05/2022 15:29

Thebestwaytoscareatory · 17/05/2022 12:45

The two men should've been wearing t-shirts that say "I bought a human being"

You could say the same about anyone who's went through IVF or used a sperms donor.

I didn't know sperm donors gestate babies (and give them away).

SoftSheen · 17/05/2022 15:27

Collaborate · 17/05/2022 13:53

This thread is hompophpobic because it seeks to deny gay males the oportunity to have a family. It is getting offencded at the thought that gay men may want to have a child with a surrogate, and that surrogate will be perfectly happy to help. Children can have two fathers and they can have two mothers.

I'll paraphrase this OP - Children can only have one mother and one father.

What about the concept of adoption?

Sometimes this site is a real cess pit.

There is no problem with a child having two Dads. They may be brilliant parents. The problem with surrogacy is that it is arranged to intentionally deprive a baby of its mother.* *Gay men who want to become parents can consider adoption or perhaps a co-parenting arrangement with a woman. Nobody (whatever their sex and orientation) should be paying someone else to make them a baby, because babies should not be commodities.

calmlakes · 17/05/2022 15:23

I think that gay men are maybe more open about surrogacy because there is no expectation that they can birth children.

There are expectations on women about the ability to conceive and carry babies. There can be a strong sense of shame if they are unable to do this or even don't want to.

Therefore gay men are likely to attract more publicity and therefore criticism regarding surrogacy.

But this is again focusing on adult wants rather than what is best for babies.

SunThroughTheCloudsAt6am · 17/05/2022 15:10

Because that would be nonsense. About 90% of negative commentary about surrogacy is focused on examples of gay couples, even though they only make up about one third of cases of surrogacy.

Why do you think that is?

I would hazard a guess that we only talk about ones that are published in the media for some reason - famous people, or those who post distasteful photos on social media. People who quietly buy a human and get on with their lives, we have no way of knowing about.

ArmWrestlingWithChasNDave · 17/05/2022 15:04

By all means disprove it.

You made the claim, you back it up.

To do so you’d need to show that 66% of negative coverage about specific cases of surrogacy related to straight couples. That is demonstrably not the case though so good luck trying.

Ah, if it's "demonstrably" the case, then demonstrate it. We'll wait.

P.S. Not only do you not understand the burden of proof, but also maths and statistics. Not sure where you've pulled 66% from, but presumably the same place as your wild claims.

lightfalling · 17/05/2022 15:04

Yeah, its a public and political statement to erase that women.

The gross commodification of women in surrogacy could not be made clearer in that statement.

And if the surrogate in this case was actually biologically related to that child it is even more disgusting. Because then she actually is the mother.

VeryLongBeeeeep · 17/05/2022 15:03

ThereWillBeSnacks · 17/05/2022 14:01

What about the concept of adoption?

Adoption is entirely different to surrogacy.

Adoption is a complex process with the child's needs firmly at the centre. Adoption is not about what the parents or prospective parents want, it's about the child and what is best for them.

Surrogacy is entirely about the wants of the commissioning parents. It ignores the needs of the child who is created with the express intention of removing it, usually at birth, from its mother.

Adoption is necessary, important and difficult. Surrogacy is an abhorrent practice, currently being normalised by social media and celebrity, and should be banned.

Very well said!

If surrogacy is so altruistic, why is it never rich women offering to carry babies for poorer ones?

MagpiePi · 17/05/2022 15:02

So the two men have a slogan saying what they consider themselves to be in a psoitve and affirming way ie Dads. The woman has a slogan saying what she is not.

So what could she have on her t-shirt to say what she is as an actual person in this scenario? Or is she not really a person? Just a means of production?

Incubator?
Womb-haver?
Baby producer?
Signatory to a sale contract?

Sodthatforagameofsoldiers · 17/05/2022 15:02

The two men should've been wearing t-shirts that say "I bought a human being"

You could say the same about anyone who's went through IVF or used a sperms donor

Uh, no. You really can't. Confused

SoftSheen · 17/05/2022 14:59

Gasp0deTheW0nderD0g · 17/05/2022 14:48

This, in spades.

I agree, 100%

SoftSheen · 17/05/2022 14:57

I'm not comfortable with the idea of surrogacy in general (irrespective of the orientation of the parents) because it turns pregnancy and childbirth into a transaction. Also I don't think that a child should be intentionally deprived of their biological mother (unless they're abusive or neglectful, obviously). This couple should have considered adoption.

calmlakes · 17/05/2022 14:53

Focusing on whether there is more negative coverage for same sex or opposite sex couples completely ignores what is happening for the baby in surrogacy.

We are going to buy and sell babies it would be better to be more honest about we are doing.
Then do some research about what is in their best interests with regards to removing them from their birth mother.

Personally I would just ban the practice but allowing it and pretending it isn't an issue is the worst of all worlds.

GatoradeMeBitch · 17/05/2022 14:51

I just came from a reddit thread by a surrogate who has been called rude and unreasonable by the two fathers for wanting her DH in the delivery room to support her. She can only have three people in the room and they want one of their mothers there instead. She was actually questioning whether she was in the wrong.

I strongly dislike surrogacy. The surrogates without a financial motive I suspect were little girls who got a lot of praise for being kind and selfless, probably only got praise for that, and don't have much of a sense of identity outside of it. I've read so many examples of surrogates having their most basic human rights trampled, it makes me furious.