Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to be offended by this T-shirt?

366 replies

parklife1 · 17/05/2022 12:29

I saw a post on social media today. It was about two gay men becoming fathers of twins via surrogate. There was a picture of the two men in "DAD" T-shirts. The pregnant surrogate stood in between them with a T-shirt saying "NOT THE MOMMA".

I'm not even against surrogacy perse, but I found this picture offensive.

I understood why she was wearing it - she wanted to display that she doesn't want to have a mothering role in the children's life.

I still think it's a slap in the face of women, we go through so much during pregnancy and labour. Giving birth can be life-threatening, I lost 2.1 litres of blood during my first birth and 1 litre of blood during my second birth.

Many women have postpartum depression after birth and the hormones are on a roller-coaster.

My body will be forever marked by giving birth (stretch marks, C-section scar, mum tum).

To me this picture is just offensive, because it sort of portrays women and our bodies as a commodity.

AIBU?

OP posts:
LoveSpringDaffs · 17/05/2022 17:35

@Steamoutmyears

im glad you have your DD. I hope this vile thread hasn't upset you too much. Hide the thread, give her lots of cuddles & remember, these comments are not representative of real, normal, people!!

Your bond with YOUR DD is real xx

Bovrilly · 17/05/2022 17:23

It's very high risk for the woman who goes through the pregnancy, especially if she has no genetic connection to the baby, and it's not in a baby's best interests to be removed from the mother immediately after birth

I don't know anything about surrogacy - why is it very high risk for the surrogate and are there any studies which measure the long term harm caused to babies who are removed from their mothers immediately after birth (whether due to surrogacy or other adoption / taken into care / NICU)?

How important is the mum-baby connection compared to a baby's connection with another loving adult - is a baby with a loving carer who is not the mum better or worse off than one with a mum who is not very loving?

What they shouldn't be able to do, what no one should be able to do, is rent a woman's body.

This also prompted another question for me - I understand that in some circumstances the surrogate is not treated well or is coerced. But are there any circumstances in which you think it's ok for a woman to decide herself what she does with her uterus? Is it ok to donate eggs or breast milk or bone marrow or a kidney?

calmlakes · 17/05/2022 17:10

you'd swear the child has been ripped away from it's mother.

It wasn't ripped away it was bought and sold, with paperwork and social media photos.

The actual newborn baby itself won't understand that difference of course. They are primed to seek out their birth mother who they recognize before birth. Who they have permanently exchanged dna with during the pregnancy.

They will obviously survive given appropriate care. But it is considered to be such a damaging thing to do to newborns that to remove a child at birth for child protection reasons requires a judge to believe that their is a risk of significant harm. It requires many reports, multiagency meetings and agreement from a range of professionals. It is action only taken in the most high risk cases.

I can't understand why buying a child makes this trauma go away?
As someone else has pointed out you aren't allowed to treat puppies like this.

LoveSpringDaffs · 17/05/2022 17:09

GirlCrushxxx · 17/05/2022 13:59

What a load of shite!!!

Who do YOU think you are to tell someone who was adopted that their feelings are shite?

that's a very nasty thing to do!

LoveSpringDaffs · 17/05/2022 17:06

SleeplessInEngland · 17/05/2022 13:59

"Here here"

*Hear hear

(Sorry, seen this three times today and something snapped in my brain.)

You might want to look at your own posts before pulling others up on theirs!

The baby's ecsatic. It can't believe it's luck

Femalewoman · 17/05/2022 17:05

I'm not in support of surrogacy for money, rent a womb etc. Some agencies and women make money selling babies so I am totally against it. Perhaps the type of person to sell a womb/egg/whatever might wear that t-shirt because they don't care as long as they get paid?

LoveFromD · 17/05/2022 17:00

It's dehumanising for the pregnant woman, excuse me, pregnant person. Handmaids Tale comes to mind.

WouldBeGood · 17/05/2022 16:56

I don’t agree with surrogacy for anyone, lest I appear homophobic.

beastlyslumber · 17/05/2022 16:55

Surrogacy is the practice of renting a woman's body, and taking - often buying - her baby. It's human trafficking and it's wrong.

The trauma of a baby taken from its mother at birth is significant. After nine months of incredible closeness, to be taken away from her, is just heartbreaking.

It's all just wrong. No one is entitled to have a baby. If you can't have a baby naturally then there are some reasonable and ethical options to try. But surrogacy is not one of them.

WouldBeGood · 17/05/2022 16:55

ArcheryAnnie · 17/05/2022 12:36

The two men should've been wearing t-shirts that say "I bought a human being".

I am all for gay men being parents, but there are options available that don't commodity children and erase women.

Yes to this

ArcheryAnnie · 17/05/2022 16:47

and yet it is the case that whenever an example is given of a specific case of surrogacy that people want to oppose it is almost always gay men, despite them making up only about a third of surrogacy cases.

You still haven't offered any evidence that most discussion is about gay men.

why is that?

Let's pretend (and we do have to pretend, because you haven't offered any evidence) that your assertion that most discussion revolves around gay male couple is true. If (if) that's the case, then I would suggest that the most likely answer is misogyny. Women are shamed for having babies and shamed for not having babies in this misogynistic society. Straight couples may well not blast pics of their surrogate all over their social media pages because the woman in the couple has an internalised sense of shame and failure about not carrying the baby herself. Whereas most of the gay male couples I see are very wealthy white men, who will receive praise for their posts, and not be shamed because they weren't carrying the baby themselves.

hamdden12 · 17/05/2022 16:47

Doesn't bother me. The reactions on this thread are hilarious, you'd swear the child has been ripped away from it's mother. For the woman to stand there and have a photo wearing this T shirt says to me she made her choice to help them have a baby and wasn't pushed into the decision.

Surrogacy is the only option for some people and it's easy to say how wrong it is when you are gifted with the ability to carry a child naturally.

LoveSpringDaffs · 17/05/2022 16:45

Franca123 · 17/05/2022 13:57

@LoveSpringDaffs I had ivf. Criticising surrogacy doesn't offend me. Please don't worry about me!

Surprisingly enough, you're not the only person to have IVF. If you're not bothered, great, doesn't mean no one else is!

DappledShade · 17/05/2022 16:40

@Emotionalsupportviper But many adoptees establish bonds that are just as strong with their adopted mothers. It is offensive to suggest that I, and many other adoptees, cannot have a significant bond just because we weren't grown in the womb of the person we call mum. There is so much more to a strong bond between mother and child than this.

ChaToilLeam · 17/05/2022 16:39

Surrogacy is a vile practice. No matter what the t-shirt says, the baby has a mother and will be willfully deprived of her while still tiny.

Emotionalsupportviper · 17/05/2022 16:34

Tamzo85 · 17/05/2022 16:15

@SoftSheen So does that also apply to lesbian couples (or single women) who use sperm donors? If this is depriving the baby if the mother then likewise they are depriving the children of a father.

A baby doesn't grow i side the father, recognising the father's voice, being aware of the father's smell. New babies can identify their mothers.

It's not all about milk and cuddles - there is deep physical and psychological bond which develops in utero, and it works both ways.

Emotionalsupportviper · 17/05/2022 16:31

myceliumama · 17/05/2022 12:52

Surrogacy is a horrific practice. It's all about the parents and nothing about the child. To intentionally create a baby with the express intent of removing it from its mother (regardless of genetic heritage) is barbaric .... so much so its illegal in other mammals. THEY can't be sold until weaned at 8 weeks. All that baby knows is the mothers voice, taste , movements and smell. It doesn't want anybody else and to sever that bond intentionally is monstrous.

Hear, hear!

RitaFaircloughsWig · 17/05/2022 16:29

NotExactlyHappyToHelp · 17/05/2022 12:34

Isn’t it a famous quote from that funny dinosaur program that was on in the late 80s? The little baby dinosaur said it all the time.

This is exactly what I was going to post. If they are American they possibly thought it was funny - the irony is that the baby dinosaur always wanted the momma and not the daddy !

Gooseberrypies · 17/05/2022 16:24

Who actually cares about a t-shirt? Don’t you have anything that requires mental effort in your own life?

ArmWrestlingWithChasNDave · 17/05/2022 16:15

why is that?

It isn't. You just made it up.

TeaKlaxon · 17/05/2022 16:15

Choopi · 17/05/2022 16:13

so if opposition to surrogacy is genuinely blind to sexuality then we should see two thirds of negative views of surrogacy arise in respect of straight couples.

Did you not see all of the discussion around this at the start of the war in Ukraine? Tbh I'm not sure if all of those couples that were concerned that the war would interfere with their 'commissioning' a baby as you so nicely put it were straight but all of the couples I saw looking for sympathy and trying to dictate how their surrogates react to a war that is tearing their country apart were straight. How anyone can look at that situation and say surrogacy is all fine and dandy is beyond me.

If you're going to lie about what I said (I never used the term 'commissioning') then you're not worthy of a substantive reply. Jog on.

Tamzo85 · 17/05/2022 16:15

SoftSheen · 17/05/2022 15:27

There is no problem with a child having two Dads. They may be brilliant parents. The problem with surrogacy is that it is arranged to intentionally deprive a baby of its mother.* *Gay men who want to become parents can consider adoption or perhaps a co-parenting arrangement with a woman. Nobody (whatever their sex and orientation) should be paying someone else to make them a baby, because babies should not be commodities.

@SoftSheen So does that also apply to lesbian couples (or single women) who use sperm donors? If this is depriving the baby if the mother then likewise they are depriving the children of a father.

TeaKlaxon · 17/05/2022 16:14

Incidentally, everyone doing the 'they could just have adopted' routine really need to learn a bit more about adoption.

Maybe they could have adopted. But maybe they would not be particularly well equipped to meet the needs of an adopted child. Most children adopted in the UK will have some sort of trauma and very many of them will have additional needs. That trauma may be in utero exposure to drugs and alcohol or domestic violence, birth trauma, or neglect, abuse and violence post birth.

Anyone claiming to care about the wellbeing of the child they are about to have, while also doing an off the cuff 'they can just adopt' is someone who perhaps doesn't care very much about adopted kids if they think just anyone should adopt. Perfectly good parents to non-adopted kids could be absolutely dreadful parents to adopted kids.

If these guys decided it's not right for them to adopt, then that is absolutely the right decision. Going down a parenting route that they are not well positioned to undertake just to satisfy some mumsnetters would actually be damaging for a child.

Choopi · 17/05/2022 16:13

so if opposition to surrogacy is genuinely blind to sexuality then we should see two thirds of negative views of surrogacy arise in respect of straight couples.

Did you not see all of the discussion around this at the start of the war in Ukraine? Tbh I'm not sure if all of those couples that were concerned that the war would interfere with their 'commissioning' a baby as you so nicely put it were straight but all of the couples I saw looking for sympathy and trying to dictate how their surrogates react to a war that is tearing their country apart were straight. How anyone can look at that situation and say surrogacy is all fine and dandy is beyond me.

Tamzo85 · 17/05/2022 16:12

NotExactlyHappyToHelp · 17/05/2022 12:34

Isn’t it a famous quote from that funny dinosaur program that was on in the late 80s? The little baby dinosaur said it all the time.

@NotExactlyHappyToHelp

Is that what that thing was saying? All those years I thought it was saying “knockamama” for some reason. And I’ve seen quite a bit of that show (kids right age at right time).