Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to be offended by this T-shirt?

366 replies

parklife1 · 17/05/2022 12:29

I saw a post on social media today. It was about two gay men becoming fathers of twins via surrogate. There was a picture of the two men in "DAD" T-shirts. The pregnant surrogate stood in between them with a T-shirt saying "NOT THE MOMMA".

I'm not even against surrogacy perse, but I found this picture offensive.

I understood why she was wearing it - she wanted to display that she doesn't want to have a mothering role in the children's life.

I still think it's a slap in the face of women, we go through so much during pregnancy and labour. Giving birth can be life-threatening, I lost 2.1 litres of blood during my first birth and 1 litre of blood during my second birth.

Many women have postpartum depression after birth and the hormones are on a roller-coaster.

My body will be forever marked by giving birth (stretch marks, C-section scar, mum tum).

To me this picture is just offensive, because it sort of portrays women and our bodies as a commodity.

AIBU?

OP posts:
LoveFromD · 17/05/2022 19:21

The adoption is trauma thread is very eye opening.

www.mumsnet.com/talk/_chat/4546976-adoption-trauma

I love mumsnet, it never ceases to amaze me how little I know until a thread like the above comes up.

calmlakes · 17/05/2022 19:18

@Bovrilly I think one issue is that surrogacy and egg donation is a massive industry ( certainly here in the USA) so there isn't much funding going towards looking for medical difficulties with it.

I think one of the articles was from a service providing egg donation so they don't have much incentive to emphasize the medical issues. But even they have to acknowledge increased risks.

Fundamentally it isn't surprising that using a donor egg is higher risk as it isn't a genetic part of the woman's body and the human body often struggles with donor parts.

Lynnthesearesexnotgenderpeople · 17/05/2022 19:18

RancidRuby · 17/05/2022 18:19

Question for those who don't have an ethical issue with surrogacy.

What's the difference between:

A. a woman in financial need, purposely trying and succeeding to get pregnant, then selling the resulting child to a loving couple who cannot have their own children for whatever reason, for £10k.

B. a woman in financial need, offering herself as a surrogate using her own eggs, then giving the resulting child to a loving couple who cannot have their own children for whatever reason, for £10k.

I am also interested in answers to this question. How come it (presumably) isn't OK for a woman to get pregnant herself and sell her baby, but it is OK for her to be commissioned to get pregnant and sell her baby?

Lynnthesearesexnotgenderpeople · 17/05/2022 19:15

I disagree with surrogacy full stop, for both gay and straight couples, for lots of reasons. For the child (as others pointed out, we don't take baby animals from their mothers at birth, but doing it to humans is fine?) and because of exploitation of women. Do you ever see a wealthy woman being a surrogate? When all these celebrity couples (Kim K, Oli Locke, Tom Daly etc) use surrogates, how come none of their celebrity mates or siblings ever step up and volunteer?

On the gay couple thing, there is definitely misogyny at play, although obviously not in all cases. I always remember the reality TV show with the gay couple whose surrogate mother gave birth on the show (without her consent apparently!) and one of them hilariously quipped - 'if I knew i was going to be giving birth on TV, I would have at least got a wax'. It made me feel sick. Funnily enough that particularly story did not have a happy ending.

But I disagree with it in all forms, apart from perhaps if it is a very close friend or family member doing it.

browneyes77 · 17/05/2022 19:13

LoveSpringDaffs · 17/05/2022 13:44

A lot of smug & offensive posts on this thread.

Not everyone can have a baby 'naturally' calling surrogacy 'revolting & disgusting' is plain nasty. Saying only babies that grew in your own womb & were created with your own egg are the only ones that are yours is also plain nasty.

I have no skin in the game, but my heart is hurting for people who are reading this absolute crap who are babies or parents if adoption, IVF or surrogacy.

many of you should be ashamed of yourselves.

disingenuous & goady thread, it's not the t shirt that's offensive.

I quite agree!

SolasAnla · 17/05/2022 18:57

Getoff · 17/05/2022 18:19

To repeat my answer in pie-chart terms, I would award 95 points to the woman who brought up the child, 4 points to the egg donor, and 1 to the woman who gave birth.

Thats nice dear

Cornettoninja · 17/05/2022 18:44

@Tamzo85 everything you’ve posted is based on supposition. There’s no evidence that gay men are particularly singled out for criticism around surrogacy.

On the other hand it’s blindingly obvious that there are ethical issues around third parties using a woman’s uterus for their own benefit using the inequality of wealth. It’s largely why the UK has the restrictions around surrogacy it does.

Tamzo85 · 17/05/2022 18:36

@Steamoutmyears

Dont worry about this thread. Your DD is yours. These people are head deep in their ideology and don’t represent most.

Tamzo85 · 17/05/2022 18:32

ArcheryAnnie · 17/05/2022 16:47

and yet it is the case that whenever an example is given of a specific case of surrogacy that people want to oppose it is almost always gay men, despite them making up only about a third of surrogacy cases.

You still haven't offered any evidence that most discussion is about gay men.

why is that?

Let's pretend (and we do have to pretend, because you haven't offered any evidence) that your assertion that most discussion revolves around gay male couple is true. If (if) that's the case, then I would suggest that the most likely answer is misogyny. Women are shamed for having babies and shamed for not having babies in this misogynistic society. Straight couples may well not blast pics of their surrogate all over their social media pages because the woman in the couple has an internalised sense of shame and failure about not carrying the baby herself. Whereas most of the gay male couples I see are very wealthy white men, who will receive praise for their posts, and not be shamed because they weren't carrying the baby themselves.

@ArcheryAnnie

So “misogny” is responsible for people being harder on gay men who use a surrogate than straight women? Actually no, it’s quite a different bias at play.

The mental gymnastics some on here will go through to blame everything on “misogny” and cast women as the victims of the bias of it - even when (as in her example) someone else (gay men) are the ones experiencing negative bias is amazing. Somehow it all circles back to misogny and their own cause.

Lynnthesearesexnotgenderpeople · 17/05/2022 18:30

Blokes using women's bodies for their own ends.

Plus ca change......

Witchcraftandhokum · 17/05/2022 18:29

I think you're getting offended by a woman making a statement about a choice she made about her body and I think that's wrong.

I chose not to be a parent. If I wore a T-shirt that said 'Not a Momma' would you be offended by that too?

Tamzo85 · 17/05/2022 18:26

@Emotionalsupportviper

New mothers can’t identify their babies accurately sadly. There used to be quite a few baby mix ups which went totally unnoticed until the child was older and didn’t resemble the parents at all.

NeverDropYourMooncup · 17/05/2022 18:21

Bunnyfuller · 17/05/2022 13:59

The mother is the person who is there when you’re sick, for your first period, for your first kiss, your first break up..

LOVE for the baby makes the parents. With respect, do NOT tell me who my mum is. I know.

There is something horrifically offensive on this thread, and it’s not the t-shirt.

That means I never had a mother or a father, then.

But how was I born? With whom did I live?

A fair description would be with my female owner. It's certainly how she saw it - and me - as a piece of property.

The only difference is that the sole owner and the male provided some genetic material before being kicked into touch.

I still wished for a connection with them. Still would have been so happy if she had given a shiny shit about me. Or him. But legally, biologically, and emotionally as far as I was concerned (and was constantly let down about) they were my father and mother.

Love is not a prerequisite of any parent, biological or adoptive.

The difference is that this couple have bought and already decided that their property is not anything to do with the woman who carries it, enables it to grow and then finally births it, rather than mine where they made it, she decided she wanted it all to herself, he didn't or couldn't stop her and then she decided that she didn't really like the latest property that much after all, as it wasn't performing to specification.

Getoff · 17/05/2022 18:20

(That is for their claim on the word mother, not their overall contribution, which would be a different question.)

Cornettoninja · 17/05/2022 18:20

ArmWrestlingWithChasNDave · 17/05/2022 15:04

By all means disprove it.

You made the claim, you back it up.

To do so you’d need to show that 66% of negative coverage about specific cases of surrogacy related to straight couples. That is demonstrably not the case though so good luck trying.

Ah, if it's "demonstrably" the case, then demonstrate it. We'll wait.

P.S. Not only do you not understand the burden of proof, but also maths and statistics. Not sure where you've pulled 66% from, but presumably the same place as your wild claims.

I agree and would have posted similar if I’d come back earlier Grin

for the 66% of coverage to stand as a serious figure it needs to be evidenced and @TeaKlaxon also needs to show that the remaining 34% of coverage was received overwhelmingly positively and responded to slower since the claim is that coverage of same sex surrogacy prompts quicker criticism and is overwhelmingly negative thus proving homophobia.

Getoff · 17/05/2022 18:19

To repeat my answer in pie-chart terms, I would award 95 points to the woman who brought up the child, 4 points to the egg donor, and 1 to the woman who gave birth.

RancidRuby · 17/05/2022 18:19

Question for those who don't have an ethical issue with surrogacy.

What's the difference between:

A. a woman in financial need, purposely trying and succeeding to get pregnant, then selling the resulting child to a loving couple who cannot have their own children for whatever reason, for £10k.

B. a woman in financial need, offering herself as a surrogate using her own eggs, then giving the resulting child to a loving couple who cannot have their own children for whatever reason, for £10k.

Bovrilly · 17/05/2022 18:17

Thank you @calmlakes

The first of those studies does say that they can't be sure they have eliminated age as a confounding variable and the second says that while high blood pressure seems to be more likely with donor eggs, it is routinely screened for and very treatable, so I'm not sure if that warrants the "very high risk" label that the PP used? Unless there are other factors, as I said I don't know much about the ins and outs of surrogacy.

@Emotionalsupportviper

What makes you think the biological mother doesn't care about her baby?

Not that they don't care but in the past mums were encouraged not to "spoil" their baby by cuddling them too much. Newborns were looked after in the hospital nursery and brought back to mum for feeds. Even now for various reasons not every biological mum finds it easy to bond with their baby.

Getoff · 17/05/2022 18:16

The mother is always the woman that grows and delivers the baby.

Consider a baby with three "mothers"
A. provided the egg
B. had the pregnancy and gave birth to the baby
C. brought up the child from birth to adulthood

If we have to choose, I would say C has the biggest claim on the word mother, followed by A, with B last. I guess by biggest claim, I meant the word "mother" can be used to describe them in the largest possible number of contexts that might crop up.

ArcheryAnnie · 17/05/2022 18:05

Is it ok to donate eggs or breast milk or bone marrow or a kidney?

Yes. But I would suggest if you find that such "donations" are primarily low-income women "donating" their breast milk and kidneys and bone marrow to wealthy couples, and that very few (if any) wealthy people "donate" breast milk and kidneys and bone marrow to poor women, then you'd be right to find the whole industry pretty shady.

Emotionalsupportviper · 17/05/2022 17:59

DappledShade · 17/05/2022 16:40

@Emotionalsupportviper But many adoptees establish bonds that are just as strong with their adopted mothers. It is offensive to suggest that I, and many other adoptees, cannot have a significant bond just because we weren't grown in the womb of the person we call mum. There is so much more to a strong bond between mother and child than this.

I wouldn't suggest any such thing - what I am saying is that it is unnecessarily cruel to deprive a newborn of her/his mother unnecessarily. You were fortunate - you're obviously adopted by a wonderful and loving family - but although you won'r remember it, you will have experienced distress as an infant.

I would also argue that people who regard a baby's mother as just a convenient "womb-to-rent" , and who want to whitewash her out of their and the baby's lives, are unlikely to put a baby's needs above their own.

How important is the mum-baby connection compared to a baby's connection with another loving adult - is a baby with a loving carer who is not the mum better or worse off than one with a mum who is not very loving?

What makes you think the biological mother doesn't care about her baby? Even if she hasn't provided the ovum, she has still carried that child to term,, felt it grow and quicken inside her, and experienced giving birth and the rush of bonding hormones that comes with that experience.

Surrogacy is an appalling thing. I will believe it is a good career choice when wealthy people start suggesting it to their daughters. It is poor, desperate women who do this. Or women who are effectively "pimped" out as surrogates - usually by men.

And the opportunities for peadophiles to obtain children like via surrogacy are enormous- and it is happening.

Bovrilly · 17/05/2022 17:52

@LoveFromD

Did you read the gut wrenching thread on adoption a few weeks ago?

No.

calmlakes · 17/05/2022 17:49

I'm in the USA and doing a search about risks of donor eggs in surrogates is very difficult because the first few pages are just paid adverts.

There are a lot of people making a lot of money out of this.

But here are a couple of articles which highlight some basic health risks of donor eggs. Which cover the increased risk to the pregnant women.

evidence.nihr.ac.uk/alert/donor-eggs-may-be-linked-to-higher-risk-of-pregnancy-complications-following-ivf/

www.inviafertility.com/egg-donation/vicki-meagher/egg-donor-pregnancy-preeclampsia-risk-higher/?hs_amp=true

clumperoo · 17/05/2022 17:46

Thebestwaytoscareatory · 17/05/2022 12:45

The two men should've been wearing t-shirts that say "I bought a human being"

You could say the same about anyone who's went through IVF or used a sperms donor.

What? Not the same for ivf at all

LoveFromD · 17/05/2022 17:42

@Bovrilly

How important is the mum-baby connection compared to a baby's connection with another loving adult - is a baby with a loving carer who is not the mum better or worse off than one with a mum who is not very loving?

Did you read the gut wrenching thread on adoption a few weeks ago?