Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to be offended by this T-shirt?

366 replies

parklife1 · 17/05/2022 12:29

I saw a post on social media today. It was about two gay men becoming fathers of twins via surrogate. There was a picture of the two men in "DAD" T-shirts. The pregnant surrogate stood in between them with a T-shirt saying "NOT THE MOMMA".

I'm not even against surrogacy perse, but I found this picture offensive.

I understood why she was wearing it - she wanted to display that she doesn't want to have a mothering role in the children's life.

I still think it's a slap in the face of women, we go through so much during pregnancy and labour. Giving birth can be life-threatening, I lost 2.1 litres of blood during my first birth and 1 litre of blood during my second birth.

Many women have postpartum depression after birth and the hormones are on a roller-coaster.

My body will be forever marked by giving birth (stretch marks, C-section scar, mum tum).

To me this picture is just offensive, because it sort of portrays women and our bodies as a commodity.

AIBU?

OP posts:
WildNights · 17/05/2022 22:35

AstroSurf · 17/05/2022 22:29

There is a bizarre notion, which you also see on SW discussions, that when employing a woman to do a service only woman can do, that is somehow 'renting her body'.

Newsflash: any service, that anyone does, is done with their body. We don't consider it 'buying access to a body' when we pay a man to clean windows, a woman to mine coal, a man to cook, a woman to render medical services and so on.

It's a service. Like all others. Some work is low risk and some higher, but it's all done with the person's body.

If the surrogate is acting freely, it's no different to any other service carried out.

Fucking he’ll. What have I just read?

WouldBeGood · 17/05/2022 22:30

Buying a baby is totally different to getting your windows cleaned

AstroSurf · 17/05/2022 22:29

Twizbe · 17/05/2022 13:42

@XelaM you've just said it yourself. They paid her lots of money so how is that not buying a baby? How is that not renting her womb?

There is a bizarre notion, which you also see on SW discussions, that when employing a woman to do a service only woman can do, that is somehow 'renting her body'.

Newsflash: any service, that anyone does, is done with their body. We don't consider it 'buying access to a body' when we pay a man to clean windows, a woman to mine coal, a man to cook, a woman to render medical services and so on.

It's a service. Like all others. Some work is low risk and some higher, but it's all done with the person's body.

If the surrogate is acting freely, it's no different to any other service carried out.

ArcheryAnnie · 17/05/2022 22:26

RainbowBallOfDoom · 17/05/2022 21:48

I have been a surrogate for a friend.

it’s my body, I chose to do it. My friends are happy their child is happy. I’m happy.

it’s not your business.

I think offering to be a surrogate for someone you know and love, as a gift between friends or family, is different to the surrogacy industry, where poor women are used as mobile incubators for the benefit of wealthy people they don't know.

Unfortunately the vast majority of surrogate births are of the latter kind, not the former.

buzzy06 · 17/05/2022 22:04

Anniefrenchfry · 17/05/2022 22:02

I’m also cringing, and feel a sense of shame, for some of the comments on this thread.

wanting a child and being unable to have one is horrendous, and it doesn’t matter if it’s ivf, egg donation, sperm donation, or surrogacy using someone else’s genetic material, to support people to have a child who would otherwise never be born is in many instances a huge positive. Not all, but many.

some posters on here should be ashamed and I’m sure that if they came out from behind their key boards and actually met someone in real life who used ivf, sperm/egg donation, surrogacy they’d not say a negative word, never mind shouting about “selling babies”. Behind their backs, maybe, but I don’t think anyone in real life would own that.

YABU

Anniefrenchfry · 17/05/2022 22:02

I’m also cringing, and feel a sense of shame, for some of the comments on this thread.

wanting a child and being unable to have one is horrendous, and it doesn’t matter if it’s ivf, egg donation, sperm donation, or surrogacy using someone else’s genetic material, to support people to have a child who would otherwise never be born is in many instances a huge positive. Not all, but many.

some posters on here should be ashamed and I’m sure that if they came out from behind their key boards and actually met someone in real life who used ivf, sperm/egg donation, surrogacy they’d not say a negative word, never mind shouting about “selling babies”. Behind their backs, maybe, but I don’t think anyone in real life would own that.

VestaTilley · 17/05/2022 21:48

YANBU.

I think surrogacy is human trafficking - it will explode in the next decade and women and children will pay an awful price. It writes women out of a process only we endure, and separates a baby from its mother (against all NHS guidance…)

It is inherently misogynistic and I could never remain friends with someone who colluded in it.

Women are not vessels. We are sleepwalking in to Gilead.

RainbowBallOfDoom · 17/05/2022 21:48

I have been a surrogate for a friend.

it’s my body, I chose to do it. My friends are happy their child is happy. I’m happy.

it’s not your business.

myceliumama · 17/05/2022 21:33

@VeryTrying22

www.psychologicalscience.org/publications/observer/obsonline/how-mother-child-separation-causes-neurobiological-vulnerability-into-adulthood.html

www.sciencedaily.com/releases/2011/11/111102124955.htm

www.babymed.com/news/separating-mother-baby-after-birth-causes-stress

Would you like me to link you to scholarly studies ? It's NEVER in a babies best interests to be removed from its mother unless the baby is at risk or for vital medical needs etc. but it IS in the best interest of the people purchasing the trafficked baby.

VeryTrying22 · 17/05/2022 21:14

Also @myceliumama it’s well documented babies attachment to their primary care giver isn’t formed until 2-4 months so maybe you can do some Googling yourself ffs.

VeryTrying22 · 17/05/2022 21:12

@myceliumama you're being very disingenuous with that comment and you know it. The stats on adult adoptees are skewed by the context of their adoptions. Currently for example foster to adopt is presenting better outcomes in children and teens, with it looking likely that a low ‘trauma’ at birth removal being optimal in terms of adoption.

surrogacy cannot be compared to adoption, especially when looking at adoptee stories as a collective, many in this space are from the US where adoption is a lot worse a process than here (also worse when compared to surrogacy too)

Adoption also doesn’t factor in a birth parent raising the child. Maybe do some more research on more accurate data sets before making such comments in future.

myceliumama · 17/05/2022 21:03

VeryTrying22 · 17/05/2022 20:53

YABU big time.

in the UK surrogates aren’t paid, so hardly rent a womb. Also so many on here harping on about starching a baby from its mother yet have no issue when mothers take babies from their fathers. They’re told to actively leave dads off the birth certificates to make it harder, if they’ve done anything wrong it seems.

They also conveniently forget that one of those dads is the biological father to that baby. They aren’t stealing a baby, surrogates are well ‘trained’ and most clinics required extensive counselling before conducting the treatment in this country.

that t shirt was no different to the many women who refer to their babies fathers as sperm donors because they don’t play an active role in their lives. This is no different, that woman will not play an active role in those babies lives, therefore she isn’t the mumma.

As a society wehave a huge amount of adult children that WERE removed from their mother at birth, and they tell us ALL THE TIME just how horrifically this has affected them, even when adopted by nice people. And you can't honestly suggest that a newborn baby's bond with its biological father is ANYTHING like that too it's mother?! You know the person that grew the baby for 9 months. The very first thing it heard was her heart beat. The very first thing out tasted was her amniotic fluid. It recognises her voice, her heartbeat, her taste, her movements and her smell. Even her language!! Babies can be born to a C loving mother and no dad and often go on to live perfectly happy lives. It's not always the same when there is no mother in the scene. People raised without a loving mother with whom they have a strong bond and a fully formed attachment are often very unhappy and struggle to form attachments themselves. All of this is provable. You can even Google it ffs.

VeryTrying22 · 17/05/2022 20:53

YABU big time.

in the UK surrogates aren’t paid, so hardly rent a womb. Also so many on here harping on about starching a baby from its mother yet have no issue when mothers take babies from their fathers. They’re told to actively leave dads off the birth certificates to make it harder, if they’ve done anything wrong it seems.

They also conveniently forget that one of those dads is the biological father to that baby. They aren’t stealing a baby, surrogates are well ‘trained’ and most clinics required extensive counselling before conducting the treatment in this country.

that t shirt was no different to the many women who refer to their babies fathers as sperm donors because they don’t play an active role in their lives. This is no different, that woman will not play an active role in those babies lives, therefore she isn’t the mumma.

MorganKitten · 17/05/2022 20:50

Because she won’t be the parent to the child, so ‘Not the Momma’

LoveFromD · 17/05/2022 20:45

ArcheryAnnie · 17/05/2022 20:01

I think all the posts that conflate adoption with surrogacy are unhelpful.

Adoptive families (or at least the decent ones) don't pretend the child arrived magically out of nowhere, or try to reduce the birth mother to nothing but a convenient rented uterus. I posted earlier about how on birthdays my mum would remember the other mothers that went before her. (There were other issues with my mum, but on this at least she was absolutely sound.)

Adoption is about trying to find the best outcome for the child. Surrogacy is about buying the best option for the would-be parent. They are quite different.

You are absolutely right. I think I very clumsily and insensitively tried to make a point.

As you can guess, I am not in favour of surrogacy but I do have the utmost respect for parents who adopt.

Emotionalsupportviper · 17/05/2022 20:37

Tamzo85 · 17/05/2022 18:26

@Emotionalsupportviper

New mothers can’t identify their babies accurately sadly. There used to be quite a few baby mix ups which went totally unnoticed until the child was older and didn’t resemble the parents at all.

Sorry Tamzo - that wasn't what I meant. I meant that a woman forms a strong emotional bond with her baby in utero, and if that baby is taken from her (or she must give up her child) then she will feel it - not that a mother is as able to tell her own baby as a baby is its mother. (Though I would be interested to know if there has been research in this area)

Sorry to be unclear.

Many people on here think that to the surrogate mother the baby is purely a commodity that she can't wait to hand over, and doesn't give the child second thought. For some, maybe, but many women find it a dreadful wrench.

Footloose78 · 17/05/2022 20:08

ChaToilLeam · 17/05/2022 16:39

Surrogacy is a vile practice. No matter what the t-shirt says, the baby has a mother and will be willfully deprived of her while still tiny.

This x 1000

Bovrilly · 17/05/2022 20:08

Thanks @calmlakes

Yes, I agree there needs to much more and better research. It would be interesting to know the cause of raised blood pressure in these pregnancies, I see what you're saying about foreign tissue but would have expected miscarriage to be the more usual response. (But maybe miscarriage rates are also higher with donor eggs.) Anyway, an interesting and worthwhile area of research, good luck with it.

ArcheryAnnie · 17/05/2022 20:01

I think all the posts that conflate adoption with surrogacy are unhelpful.

Adoptive families (or at least the decent ones) don't pretend the child arrived magically out of nowhere, or try to reduce the birth mother to nothing but a convenient rented uterus. I posted earlier about how on birthdays my mum would remember the other mothers that went before her. (There were other issues with my mum, but on this at least she was absolutely sound.)

Adoption is about trying to find the best outcome for the child. Surrogacy is about buying the best option for the would-be parent. They are quite different.

DappledShade · 17/05/2022 19:59

@GenderCriticalTrumpets That is not the case for all of us adoptees.

GenderCriticalTrumpets · 17/05/2022 19:49

There are some really heavy handed comments on here that are upsetting to myself and other adoptees. It is TRAUMA and the baby is RIPPED AWAY from it's mother. We know this, we feel it, we live it. We don't need insensitive arseholes that don't have any lived experience of this situation telling us that our opinions are shite.

Fuck. Off.

ArcheryAnnie · 17/05/2022 19:48

So “misogny” is responsible for people being harder on gay men who use a surrogate than straight women? Actually no, it’s quite a different bias at play.

Er, no, @Tamzo85 , that's not what I am saying at all. I am suggesting that it's possible heterosexual couples don't post as much about acquiring a child via a surrogate, because women are frequently shamed and told their are "failures" for not being able to produce children.

Gay men, on the other hand - and particularly the very wealthy, white gay men that are frequently featured in these stories - aren't shamed for not being able to produce children, so there isn't that factor pressuring them into keeping the surrogacy private.

I'm just as "hard" on straight couples as I am on gay couples when they exploit poor women. It's just possible that I am slightly less likely to hear about a lot of the straight couples that use surrogates, because yhe pressure and shame dumped on women who cannot produce their own babies means they are less likely to post on social media with pics of them and their surrogate.

Abhannmor · 17/05/2022 19:29

ArcheryAnnie · 17/05/2022 12:36

The two men should've been wearing t-shirts that say "I bought a human being".

I am all for gay men being parents, but there are options available that don't commodity children and erase women.

Yes. Adopt don't shop.

calmlakes · 17/05/2022 19:28

I am not saying that people with children who have donor egg or surrogate backgrounds are not their children.

This isn't about individual families. The biological drivers to reproduce in some form and raise dc is very strong. We shouldn't leave this decision making to individuals desperate for families and those willing to financially exploit this desire.

I am saying as a society we should really think about whether we want to continue buying and selling babies based on adult wants rather than babies needs.

I also can see no difference between selling babies directly from the full biological birth mother and mix and matching womb and egg and selling that combination.

hearmywomanlyroar · 17/05/2022 19:26

RancidRuby · 17/05/2022 18:19

Question for those who don't have an ethical issue with surrogacy.

What's the difference between:

A. a woman in financial need, purposely trying and succeeding to get pregnant, then selling the resulting child to a loving couple who cannot have their own children for whatever reason, for £10k.

B. a woman in financial need, offering herself as a surrogate using her own eggs, then giving the resulting child to a loving couple who cannot have their own children for whatever reason, for £10k.

From the very little I know about private adoption in the States, I don't think (A) is a million miles off. The birth mother may not get pregnant deliberately but she chooses the adoptive parents who then cover her medical bills and expenses (whatever that may entail) and the baby is handed over just after birth.