Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to be offended by this T-shirt?

366 replies

parklife1 · 17/05/2022 12:29

I saw a post on social media today. It was about two gay men becoming fathers of twins via surrogate. There was a picture of the two men in "DAD" T-shirts. The pregnant surrogate stood in between them with a T-shirt saying "NOT THE MOMMA".

I'm not even against surrogacy perse, but I found this picture offensive.

I understood why she was wearing it - she wanted to display that she doesn't want to have a mothering role in the children's life.

I still think it's a slap in the face of women, we go through so much during pregnancy and labour. Giving birth can be life-threatening, I lost 2.1 litres of blood during my first birth and 1 litre of blood during my second birth.

Many women have postpartum depression after birth and the hormones are on a roller-coaster.

My body will be forever marked by giving birth (stretch marks, C-section scar, mum tum).

To me this picture is just offensive, because it sort of portrays women and our bodies as a commodity.

AIBU?

OP posts:
ThisSeemsSilly · 18/05/2022 00:32

ThumbWitchesAbroad · 18/05/2022 00:25

I have mixed views on surrogacy. I think commercial surrogacy is wrong, and CAN go wrong in various ways, leaving the surrogate to care for the baby/ies - such as when there is something "wrong" with the baby/ies, or if the parents change their minds, or can't get there for whatever reason. I know there are contracts, but that doesn't stop people breaking them.

I think familial or good-friend surrogacy, done voluntarily, is a different matter. Also the mum will usually still be in the baby's life, as an auntie (familial or not).

I have no issue at all with gay male couples wanting to be parents - but if they have to "buy" a baby to do it, then I feel they should maybe consider adoption or fostering an older child instead - lord knows there are plenty of children in care who are in need of loving parents!SadSad

I think all surrogacy is abhorrent but altruistic surrogacy is particularly abhorrent. Family expectations and pressure make it not a free choice at all. After all, what sort of woman would refuse to carry a baby for her poor, loved infertile sister? If you said no, imagine every family gathering forever more with the resentment and anger. Imagine trying to enjoy your own children in front of your childless sister when you are the big nasty meanie who denied her the same.

ThisSeemsSilly · 18/05/2022 00:29

TeaKlaxon · 17/05/2022 14:18

Funny how despite claims that surrogacy should be opposed regardless of who does it, it only ever seems to be gay couples doing it that provoke howls of outrage.

Bur sure, it’s all about surrogacy in general rather than surrogacy by gay couples.

You obviously missed the threads about the appalling behaviour of the Irish heterosexual couple getting their made to order baby from the Ukraine. To hell with the mother left in war zone.

calmlakes · 18/05/2022 00:27

The world is changing, best get use to it. We are in the 21st century

There are quite a few similar statements that could have been made in centuries past. Progress isn't strictly linear.
Sometimes we realize that we haven't actually got everything right and change course, reverse even.

SammyScrounge · 18/05/2022 00:25

MajorCarolDanvers · 17/05/2022 23:43

If she is consenting and no money involved then I have no issue with it.

The baby might though. And he or she is the important one.

ThumbWitchesAbroad · 18/05/2022 00:25

I have mixed views on surrogacy. I think commercial surrogacy is wrong, and CAN go wrong in various ways, leaving the surrogate to care for the baby/ies - such as when there is something "wrong" with the baby/ies, or if the parents change their minds, or can't get there for whatever reason. I know there are contracts, but that doesn't stop people breaking them.

I think familial or good-friend surrogacy, done voluntarily, is a different matter. Also the mum will usually still be in the baby's life, as an auntie (familial or not).

I have no issue at all with gay male couples wanting to be parents - but if they have to "buy" a baby to do it, then I feel they should maybe consider adoption or fostering an older child instead - lord knows there are plenty of children in care who are in need of loving parents!SadSad

WildNights · 18/05/2022 00:19

LiSue · 18/05/2022 00:05

The world is changing, best get use to it. We are in the 21st century. I don't think surrogacy is a bad thing, and just be honest and open with the child. It won't even be a topic of conversation in 20 or less years time.
People spend too much damn time fretting and moaning about stuff when they should just be enjoying and getting on with their lives. Ridiculous!

‘Fretting’ about women being exploited and children being bought and sold.....worth ‘fretting about I’d say.

21st century, yes, awful that women and babies are used in this way today. Not surprising though, we live in a world where the richer take advantage of poorer, men take advantage of women, many believe if they want something they should go to any lengths to get it and many people refuse to accept that they can’t have something.

LiSue · 18/05/2022 00:05

The world is changing, best get use to it. We are in the 21st century. I don't think surrogacy is a bad thing, and just be honest and open with the child. It won't even be a topic of conversation in 20 or less years time.
People spend too much damn time fretting and moaning about stuff when they should just be enjoying and getting on with their lives. Ridiculous!

JeffThePilot · 18/05/2022 00:00

Collaborate · 17/05/2022 13:53

This thread is hompophpobic because it seeks to deny gay males the oportunity to have a family. It is getting offencded at the thought that gay men may want to have a child with a surrogate, and that surrogate will be perfectly happy to help. Children can have two fathers and they can have two mothers.

I'll paraphrase this OP - Children can only have one mother and one father.

What about the concept of adoption?

Sometimes this site is a real cess pit.

As a PP said, adoption is about the child and surrogacy is about the parents.

Of course gay people should be able to adopt if they are suitable, in the same way heterosexual people can. But I’m against surrogacy in any form. In part because it reduces women to a womb for rent, and you never see a wealthy surrogate, leaving people ripe for exploitation . I’ve seen first hand how even in the UK where “commercial surrogacy” is supposedly outlawed how expenses can be claimed.

But also about the impact on the child who will even before birth know only their mother, her sound, her body, her smell. There are real concerns about the long term impact of separating a newborn from their birth mother. Why would you do such a thing unless it was a necessity (infertility isn’t a necessity - nobody is entitled to a child).

There’s a reason surrogacy is banned in a great many countries.

BTW I write as a childless, infertile woman whose friend offered to carry a child for me and I said thank you, I love you, but absolutely not.

LiSue · 17/05/2022 23:51

Wow! You're not really cut out for the future are you.

LiSue · 17/05/2022 23:48

Don't bother yourself about what other people think. They don't know you, you don't know them....which is just as well as you wouldn't get on. It is what it is.

LiSue · 17/05/2022 23:44

Tbh , I don't notice these things and if I did, I'm too busy with my own life to think about it.

MajorCarolDanvers · 17/05/2022 23:43

If she is consenting and no money involved then I have no issue with it.

WildNights · 17/05/2022 23:42

cherrybonbons · 17/05/2022 23:38

I did read it. Full of vitriol. Standard

Then why are you asking about if it would make a difference if the couple was a man and a woman? It’s been addressed. Surrogacy is wrong regardless of the sex of the couple or their sexuality in my and others opinion.

cherrybonbons · 17/05/2022 23:38

I did read it. Full of vitriol. Standard

WildNights · 17/05/2022 23:35

cherrybonbons · 17/05/2022 23:31

So Mumsnet hates surrogacy?
What if it were a man and a women with a surrogate? Would that change things.
Crass thing to write on a t shirt but can't be bothered to get worked up about it.
You can't legally pay for surrogacy in the UK. Do what you will.
My friend has a chance of being a mother (with her own egg) by using a surrogate. She couldn't be without one.

Try reading the thread. 😏

cherrybonbons · 17/05/2022 23:33

SugarNspices · 17/05/2022 23:21

I find it very unnatural and cruel on the poor baby. It's just selfish.

Unnatural.... ffs 🙈

cherrybonbons · 17/05/2022 23:31

So Mumsnet hates surrogacy?
What if it were a man and a women with a surrogate? Would that change things.
Crass thing to write on a t shirt but can't be bothered to get worked up about it.
You can't legally pay for surrogacy in the UK. Do what you will.
My friend has a chance of being a mother (with her own egg) by using a surrogate. She couldn't be without one.

SugarNspices · 17/05/2022 23:21

I find it very unnatural and cruel on the poor baby. It's just selfish.

WildNights · 17/05/2022 23:20

jcyclops · 17/05/2022 23:15

Many people seem to be against surrogacy because there is money involved. Are they also against it when money doesn't change hands - such as cases like this where due to a woman's medical inability to carry a baby to term, her mother became a surrogate and gave birth to her daughter and son-in-law's baby:
nypost.com/2020/11/15/grandmother-acts-as-daughters-surrogate-and-births-granddaughter/

Yep. It’s always wrong.

mycatisannoying · 17/05/2022 23:20

Fucking hell, that is truly awful.

jcyclops · 17/05/2022 23:15

Many people seem to be against surrogacy because there is money involved. Are they also against it when money doesn't change hands - such as cases like this where due to a woman's medical inability to carry a baby to term, her mother became a surrogate and gave birth to her daughter and son-in-law's baby:
nypost.com/2020/11/15/grandmother-acts-as-daughters-surrogate-and-births-granddaughter/

Blossomtoes · 17/05/2022 22:59

myceliumama · 17/05/2022 21:33

@VeryTrying22

www.psychologicalscience.org/publications/observer/obsonline/how-mother-child-separation-causes-neurobiological-vulnerability-into-adulthood.html

www.sciencedaily.com/releases/2011/11/111102124955.htm

www.babymed.com/news/separating-mother-baby-after-birth-causes-stress

Would you like me to link you to scholarly studies ? It's NEVER in a babies best interests to be removed from its mother unless the baby is at risk or for vital medical needs etc. but it IS in the best interest of the people purchasing the trafficked baby.

It’s not a trafficked baby. It’s a baby being raised by one of its parents. Are babies whose mothers die trafficked?

WouldBeGood · 17/05/2022 22:49

Absolutely @WildNights

i had fertility issues but never considered buying a baby

WildNights · 17/05/2022 22:45

Anniefrenchfry · 17/05/2022 22:02

I’m also cringing, and feel a sense of shame, for some of the comments on this thread.

wanting a child and being unable to have one is horrendous, and it doesn’t matter if it’s ivf, egg donation, sperm donation, or surrogacy using someone else’s genetic material, to support people to have a child who would otherwise never be born is in many instances a huge positive. Not all, but many.

some posters on here should be ashamed and I’m sure that if they came out from behind their key boards and actually met someone in real life who used ivf, sperm/egg donation, surrogacy they’d not say a negative word, never mind shouting about “selling babies”. Behind their backs, maybe, but I don’t think anyone in real life would own that.

I say it in real life too.

No issue with IVF where the parents who will bring up the child use their own eggs and sperm.

We have family members that were/are considering surrogacy. When they talked to me about it, I said I couldn’t support their decision and told them my reasons why. I’m not going to pretend I agree with something to validate someone else’s choices. It’s the people that buy babies and exploit women that should be ashamed, not me.

WildNights · 17/05/2022 22:36

hell