Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to be offended by this T-shirt?

366 replies

parklife1 · 17/05/2022 12:29

I saw a post on social media today. It was about two gay men becoming fathers of twins via surrogate. There was a picture of the two men in "DAD" T-shirts. The pregnant surrogate stood in between them with a T-shirt saying "NOT THE MOMMA".

I'm not even against surrogacy perse, but I found this picture offensive.

I understood why she was wearing it - she wanted to display that she doesn't want to have a mothering role in the children's life.

I still think it's a slap in the face of women, we go through so much during pregnancy and labour. Giving birth can be life-threatening, I lost 2.1 litres of blood during my first birth and 1 litre of blood during my second birth.

Many women have postpartum depression after birth and the hormones are on a roller-coaster.

My body will be forever marked by giving birth (stretch marks, C-section scar, mum tum).

To me this picture is just offensive, because it sort of portrays women and our bodies as a commodity.

AIBU?

OP posts:
OneTC · 18/05/2022 09:16

Surrogacy, is to me similar to abortion in that it isn't something I say I support but I do support the right of women to choose to do it. In supporting women to make a choice you understand that's there's going to be reasoning behind some of those choices that you don't agree with.

It's important though that it comes from choice and not from coercion. Money as a reason, eh it's unpalatable to me but I'm pretty comfortable so don't feel ideally positioned to have an opinion on that.

Many of the people who are arguing against surrogacy are using both the worst case scenario to support their arguments whilst presenting an idealised outcome to natural birth, which we know frequently isn't the case. The reality is that many people have babies, naturally, for selfish reasons, the needs and wants of the baby came second.

Also if we're going into needs and wants of babies and pretending that it's actually at the forefront of the breeding instinct then there's actual spare babies and small children out there who's needs and wants aren't met and making a fresh one rather than adopting one of them is also kinda morally dubious. This applies to natural birth and to surrogate birth.

So yeah quite alot of stuff happens around birth and child raising that I think I'm not a vocal supporter of BUT I understand that someone else has made that choice.

I think there probably needs to be stricter laws regarding going overseas into areas with a more lax approach to it though

FannyCann · 18/05/2022 08:41

Sorry, I would add a screen shot of figures from the Law Commission re expenses but the Mumsnet website isn't being helpful.

FannyCann · 18/05/2022 08:35

Yes it's funny that in the UK surrogate mothers can't be paid except expenses and yet there is an apparent "going rate" of about £15,000.
When I see surrogate mothers discussing their expenses on YouTube etc they always talk about the maternity clothes, the sanitary towels and the vitamins!

My pregnancies probably cost me about £300 - I had a lot of pass down maternity clothes but treated myself to a few items and things like bras. I doubt vitamins and sanitary items exceeded £50
A few costs like hospital parking and I suppose the petrol.

🤷‍♀️

Anniefrenchfry · 18/05/2022 08:34

You’re right, not everyone feels like me, it’s all about what they want. Want, want, want. They’re selfish and entitled and think they have a right to a child. Surrogacy doesn’t centre the child, it’s about the adults...entitled ones

wow, this is just too much. I can’t believe what I’m reading on this thread.

JeffThePilot · 18/05/2022 07:51

When someone offers to be a surrogate - most of the time they're not receiving payment for this. They are paid for time they'll miss from work for appointments etc but don't receive an actual payment for doing it.

this is naive

Emotionalsupportviper · 18/05/2022 07:51

VestaTilley · 17/05/2022 21:48

YANBU.

I think surrogacy is human trafficking - it will explode in the next decade and women and children will pay an awful price. It writes women out of a process only we endure, and separates a baby from its mother (against all NHS guidance…)

It is inherently misogynistic and I could never remain friends with someone who colluded in it.

Women are not vessels. We are sleepwalking in to Gilead.

@VestaTilley is right.

For some, it may be a selfless act, voluntarily undertaken - they are few and far between. For most women this is desperation or coercion. In many countries - Eastern Europe among them, women are effectively "battery-farmed" to produce babies. In some countries husbands make their wives/partners act as surrogates because it is comparatively easy money. This includes 1st world countries.

This horrible, brutal war in Ukraine saw dozens of surrogate babies left without parents because no-one was able to collect them. Every day they are in the clinical situation makes them less acceptable to the parents - not just because they wanted their tiny baby now, but because the terror of war and institutionalisation will have affected them badly.What will happen to them?

What about the families of the women who die in childbirth, or whose health is destroyed? Not every country has an HNS. What happens to their families

What about the children who are born "not perfect"? Many of those are abandoned by the commissioning parents. Whose responsibility are they?

What about the children who are commissioned bay/ sold on by paedophiles? The whole system is hideously open to abuse, and it is children and women who are suffering.

Surrogate is a modern-day slavery, and a human-trafficking nightmare which is ignore because of the stories of 'We got the child we longed for" plastered all over the papers.

This isn't Disney - it's much more Stephen King.

ImAvingOops · 18/05/2022 07:48

The reactions on this thread are hilarious, you'd swear the child has been ripped away from it's mother

So far as the newborn is concerned, they have been tipped away from their mother. That's not 'hilarious'.

GetOff, you might not view a woman who gives birth as the mother but the newborn does.

Children are entitled to have people about whom they can say 'this is my mother and father', even when those people aren't raising them. It's a human right imo. That doesn't happen when eggs come from one woman, another grows and births the baby - it means that for the child, neither woman can be claimed as the mother, which I consider to be an injustice to the child.

Its not comparable to leaving a feckless father off the birth certificate so that he cannot use the baby to control the mother. Even where he is left off the paperwork, I still consider that the child has a human right to know who he is.

Lynnthesearesexnotgenderpeople · 18/05/2022 07:11

Clymene · 18/05/2022 05:54

You can't give people as gifts.

This!

Clymene · 18/05/2022 05:54

You can't give people as gifts.

WildNights · 18/05/2022 05:40

DropYourSword · 18/05/2022 05:15

I was considering being a surrogate for some very close friends who have had a horrendous history of miscarriages.
If I had gone through with it, right from the very start I would never have considered myself the child's mother.
It's not deluded at all.
You don't have to understand it. You just have to accept not everyone feels the same way you do.

Whether you would have considered yourself that or not, you would have been the child’s birth mum. You would have given birth to the child and that matters.

You’re right, not everyone feels like me, it’s all about what they want. Want, want, want. They’re selfish and entitled and think they have a right to a child. Surrogacy doesn’t centre the child, it’s about the adults...entitled ones.

Tamzo85 · 18/05/2022 05:33

DropYourSword · 18/05/2022 05:15

I was considering being a surrogate for some very close friends who have had a horrendous history of miscarriages.
If I had gone through with it, right from the very start I would never have considered myself the child's mother.
It's not deluded at all.
You don't have to understand it. You just have to accept not everyone feels the same way you do.

@DropYourSword

This! I can’t understand how people can view this as anything but a wonderful gift. Yes I get being offended that some rich celeb just uses a surrogate because she can’t be arses giving birth or doesn’t want to lose her figure or career - but those are by far the minority of surrogacy cases.

DropYourSword · 18/05/2022 05:15

WildNights · 18/05/2022 05:03

She is the child’s birth mum, no matter how much she pretends or what t shirt she wears. She’s deluded.

I was considering being a surrogate for some very close friends who have had a horrendous history of miscarriages.
If I had gone through with it, right from the very start I would never have considered myself the child's mother.
It's not deluded at all.
You don't have to understand it. You just have to accept not everyone feels the same way you do.

Joessaysthankyou · 18/05/2022 05:15

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

Tamzo85 · 18/05/2022 05:12

Interesting how there’s this thread about how very wrong surrogacy for two willing parents is (which I think the wrongness of which is exacerbated to people because they’re both men), yet on another thread about how much parents see their children when working there are answers like “20 mins in the morning and an hour at night”.

Why is it wrong for this woman to be a surrogate for two loving parents, but fine to have your own children and (when their is the choice), barely see them to make the choice to progress your career because you “like it”?

Joessaysthankyou · 18/05/2022 05:08

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

WildNights · 18/05/2022 05:03

DropYourSword · 18/05/2022 04:58

I don't understand how anyone else finds this offensive. That's how she perceives HER role in HER situation. She's not saying that's how any or all other mothers should feel. It's quite ridiculous to call it a "slap in the face"!

She is the child’s birth mum, no matter how much she pretends or what t shirt she wears. She’s deluded.

WildNights · 18/05/2022 05:02

cognitivedissonance1 · 18/05/2022 04:48

I can't help but respond to the comments on this thread ...

When someone offers to be a surrogate - most of the time they're not receiving payment for this. They are paid for time they'll miss from work for appointments etc but don't receive an actual payment for doing it. Especially when going through a clinic, all legal documents are drawn up etc, and you need to have Counselling to clarify your reasons for doing it, potential pitfalls etc, what it means for all involved .. basically all adults consenting.

It's interesting because this woman CHOSE to be a surrogate. She consented. She made the decision to help two men become parents.

The amount of people on this thread saying 'it's disgusting', 'they bought a baby', 'how could they take the baby away from their mother', 'what about what the poor mother went through being pregnant, and then giving birth', 'they're selfish, just thinking about their needs and not the poor baby!'

Do you drink dairy milk?
Because cows are put through utter hell, forced into being pregnant so that they produce milk, but have their babies taken from them immediately after birth so they baby doesn't drink their mother, so the milk can be sold to humans instead.. then she's impregnated again and so it continues....

Do you eat lamb? Pigs?
These are also babies taken from their mothers and sold to humans to EAT (not to parent, and look after, and love - but to EAT).. and the mothers are again in horrendous conditions throughout their whole miserable lives.

In this situation - it involved consenting adults. No one was exploited. But I can guarantee there are many of you who will continue to be part of the exploitative process of eating animal flesh and fluids, babies or otherwise because it suits you, tastes nice etc and won't give a single thought to the mothers in that situation!

Can’t speak for everyone, but I’m vegan.

However, just because farm animals are treated badly isn’t justification for surrogacy. Surrogacy does exploit women, it puts adults wants before babies. I’d love to see an end to animal exploitation and campaign for it, but I also want surrogacy banned.

DropYourSword · 18/05/2022 04:58

I don't understand how anyone else finds this offensive. That's how she perceives HER role in HER situation. She's not saying that's how any or all other mothers should feel. It's quite ridiculous to call it a "slap in the face"!

cognitivedissonance1 · 18/05/2022 04:48

I can't help but respond to the comments on this thread ...

When someone offers to be a surrogate - most of the time they're not receiving payment for this. They are paid for time they'll miss from work for appointments etc but don't receive an actual payment for doing it. Especially when going through a clinic, all legal documents are drawn up etc, and you need to have Counselling to clarify your reasons for doing it, potential pitfalls etc, what it means for all involved .. basically all adults consenting.

It's interesting because this woman CHOSE to be a surrogate. She consented. She made the decision to help two men become parents.

The amount of people on this thread saying 'it's disgusting', 'they bought a baby', 'how could they take the baby away from their mother', 'what about what the poor mother went through being pregnant, and then giving birth', 'they're selfish, just thinking about their needs and not the poor baby!'

Do you drink dairy milk?
Because cows are put through utter hell, forced into being pregnant so that they produce milk, but have their babies taken from them immediately after birth so they baby doesn't drink their mother, so the milk can be sold to humans instead.. then she's impregnated again and so it continues....

Do you eat lamb? Pigs?
These are also babies taken from their mothers and sold to humans to EAT (not to parent, and look after, and love - but to EAT).. and the mothers are again in horrendous conditions throughout their whole miserable lives.

In this situation - it involved consenting adults. No one was exploited. But I can guarantee there are many of you who will continue to be part of the exploitative process of eating animal flesh and fluids, babies or otherwise because it suits you, tastes nice etc and won't give a single thought to the mothers in that situation!

EmmaGrundyForPM · 18/05/2022 04:22

Collaborate · 17/05/2022 13:17

I find this whole thread quite homphobic actually.

In what way?

Viewing surrogacy as a vile practice isn't homophobic.

habibihabibi · 18/05/2022 03:33

Should have said - Gay and rich so I hired a bitch
Black out the surrogates face - she is just a commodity

AstroSurf · 18/05/2022 03:12

WouldBeGood · 17/05/2022 22:30

Buying a baby is totally different to getting your windows cleaned

Whoosh... Way to miss the point.

LouiseBelchersPinkBunnyEars · 18/05/2022 01:16

RitaFaircloughsWig · 17/05/2022 16:29

This is exactly what I was going to post. If they are American they possibly thought it was funny - the irony is that the baby dinosaur always wanted the momma and not the daddy !

The baby in the dinosaurs called his dad 'not the mumma' in the same way Bart calls homer homer instead of dad.
It was a running joke as Earl was always trying to get baby to call him dad but he wouldn't.

ThumbWitchesAbroad · 18/05/2022 00:54

"voluntarily" means "done by volunteer" - which is what I said - so not pressganged into it. I don't agree with people being put under pressure to do it either.

Mrssheppard18 · 18/05/2022 00:33

If she’s fine with it that’s up to her, her body her decision but you’ve made that completely about you when you don’t even know the woman. Get a grip.