Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to be offended by this T-shirt?

366 replies

parklife1 · 17/05/2022 12:29

I saw a post on social media today. It was about two gay men becoming fathers of twins via surrogate. There was a picture of the two men in "DAD" T-shirts. The pregnant surrogate stood in between them with a T-shirt saying "NOT THE MOMMA".

I'm not even against surrogacy perse, but I found this picture offensive.

I understood why she was wearing it - she wanted to display that she doesn't want to have a mothering role in the children's life.

I still think it's a slap in the face of women, we go through so much during pregnancy and labour. Giving birth can be life-threatening, I lost 2.1 litres of blood during my first birth and 1 litre of blood during my second birth.

Many women have postpartum depression after birth and the hormones are on a roller-coaster.

My body will be forever marked by giving birth (stretch marks, C-section scar, mum tum).

To me this picture is just offensive, because it sort of portrays women and our bodies as a commodity.

AIBU?

OP posts:
Cornettoninja · 18/05/2022 12:04

XelaM · 18/05/2022 11:06

@MintIceCream1 Yeah because it's so easy to adopt 🙄you clearly know absolutely nothing of the adoption process. I had a colleague go through it and she got rejected for ridiculous reasons even though they already had a child and were amazing parents but both worked full time.

Anyway, the surrogate children in my post are very happy adored children with two brilliant parents.

People on this thread are disgusting.

People on this thread are disgusting? For raising legitimate concerns and issues? I’m slightly gobsmacked that you can reduce real world examples of suffering because of your own limited, second hand experience. By your logic I can dismiss all accounts of starvation because I’ve never starved and know no one who has. It’s preposterous.

I’m very glad that the example of surrogacy you’re aware of had a good outcome (although I note you have nothing to say about the surrogate and her mental/physical health or whether it was a sound financial decision for her) but your anecdote is tunnel visioned and fails to acknowledge there is more than one case of surrogacy in the world and they’re not all rainbows and lollipops, many on closer inspection have clear points where harm could have been prevented.

I’m sorry that your colleague was rejected for adoption but I can’t trust your assessment of what ‘ridiculous reasons’ might constitute. Adoption should be difficult and standards exceptionally high. Adoption involves many people tasked with ensuring the best possible placement for children; as it should do because we have enough evidence from history telling us what happens if we don’t have high standards. Even with high standards adoptions fail or cause the children/adoptive parents involved life long distress. Children awaiting adoption have their care handed over to the state and deserve the best the state can do for them.

MintIceCream1 · 18/05/2022 11:52

TeaKlaxon · 17/05/2022 14:38

No. I’m claiming that opponents of surrogacy are almost always faster to start a thread about it when it comes to a gay couple rather than a straight couple doing it.

That's rubbish. Most threads on surrogacy are about heterosexual couples.

But lets say that your lie is correct, that it's mainly gay couples. Perhaps it's because the way they flaunt their determination to push the woman, the mother, out of the baby's life. It's because of their femphobia, their absolute hatred of women and their disregarding of the importance of the mother. That doesn't happen with heterosexual couples, you don't see them flaunting and boasting about it like you do with this couple. This couple is literally wearing their advertising of how little they respect women and our bodies.

AskingforaBaskin · 18/05/2022 11:50

Regardless of what lies they want to tell. She is the mother. To that baby she is it's mummy. And it will be traumatised when ripped away

RingRingRed · 18/05/2022 11:43

I find it a bit off tbh.

It's like renting out your womb.

Giving birth is pretty horrific on the body. You do it because you have something amazing at the end. Or in these instances, money.

scegliere · 18/05/2022 11:42

I listened to this interesting discussion on the ethics of surrogacy yesterday %3F

(Yes, it is a Christian source, although they only discuss the theology surrounding surrogacy and adoption in the last 10 mins or so)

MintIceCream1 · 18/05/2022 11:41

TeaKlaxon · 17/05/2022 14:18

Funny how despite claims that surrogacy should be opposed regardless of who does it, it only ever seems to be gay couples doing it that provoke howls of outrage.

Bur sure, it’s all about surrogacy in general rather than surrogacy by gay couples.

@TeaKlaxon Feminists have been against surrogacy since the Baby M case in 1986. That is from whence the anti-surrogacy laws in many countries come from. Read up on the Whitehead and Sterns. They were both HETEROSEXUAL married couples; one couple was a biochemist husband and a paediatrician wife, and the other a garbage man and a stay at home mum.

People turned against surrogacy due to that case. A case involving two heterosexual couples. So stow your homophobia bs. At least read about the Baby M case, that is responsible for the anti-surrogacy laws in many, many countries, before weaponising homophobia.

It is about baby-selling. As Whitehead's lawyer said in summation: it will always be the wife of the garbage man, who will bear the children for the rich doctor.

Gasp0deTheW0nderD0g · 18/05/2022 11:26

It absolutely shouldn't be made any easier to adopt. Current adoption procedures in the UK are designed to put the needs and interests of the child first, well above those of the potential adoptive parents. Given the trauma these children have already experienced, this is as it should be. A great many adoptions break down, which is awful for all concerned. There needs to be a lot more support for everyone in the process.

What isn't needed is a return to the days when almost anyone could adopt with minimal scrutiny first.

Squillerman · 18/05/2022 11:20

Guessing they used a donor egg so she technically isn’t the Mother. It’s crass and not my taste but not offensive.

MintIceCream1 · 18/05/2022 11:19

XelaM · 18/05/2022 11:06

@MintIceCream1 Yeah because it's so easy to adopt 🙄you clearly know absolutely nothing of the adoption process. I had a colleague go through it and she got rejected for ridiculous reasons even though they already had a child and were amazing parents but both worked full time.

Anyway, the surrogate children in my post are very happy adored children with two brilliant parents.

People on this thread are disgusting.

Then advocate for it to be made easier to adopt.

Supporting human trafficking that is surrogacy is disgusting, and people like yourself should be ashamed to support such an abhorrent practice. You clearly aren't a feminist either.

MintIceCream1 · 18/05/2022 11:17

Collaborate · 17/05/2022 13:53

This thread is hompophpobic because it seeks to deny gay males the oportunity to have a family. It is getting offencded at the thought that gay men may want to have a child with a surrogate, and that surrogate will be perfectly happy to help. Children can have two fathers and they can have two mothers.

I'll paraphrase this OP - Children can only have one mother and one father.

What about the concept of adoption?

Sometimes this site is a real cess pit.

@Collaborate No, it does NOT seek to deny gay males the opportunity to have a family. Hello, ADOPTION???

Gasp0deTheW0nderD0g · 18/05/2022 11:16

There have been awful stories of babies born with a disability being abandoned by the so called 'commissioning' parents because what they wanted was a 'perfect' baby.

buzzy06 · 18/05/2022 11:15

It's so entitled. I'm rich so I don't have to be bound by the laws of biology. I can just pay someone else if I'm too old. I don't think songs' ridiculously wealthy' to the anecdote serves them well.

ArmWrestlingWithChasNDave · 18/05/2022 11:12

Buying babies is disgusting.

buzzy06 · 18/05/2022 11:11

I see nothing wrong with surrogacy. My former boss had two kids via surrogacy, as she was too old to have kids. Her and her partner were ridiculously wealthy and the two kids will have amazing lives and want for nothing. What's wrong with that?

@XelaM
So she wasn't that bothered about it when she was younger, and just uses her wealth to rent someone else's body to grow a baby for her? Not even fertility issues, you just didn't want to. Reminds me of that British couple who wrote to the news about their surrogate baby in Ukraine- anyone remember?

There are so many things that can go wrong in this kind of arrangement like child abandonment if it's not how they want it, I doubt they'd care if the mum had any health issues. Why would anyone think this is ok (beyond altruistic surrogacy)?

XelaM · 18/05/2022 11:06

@MintIceCream1 Yeah because it's so easy to adopt 🙄you clearly know absolutely nothing of the adoption process. I had a colleague go through it and she got rejected for ridiculous reasons even though they already had a child and were amazing parents but both worked full time.

Anyway, the surrogate children in my post are very happy adored children with two brilliant parents.

People on this thread are disgusting.

MintIceCream1 · 18/05/2022 10:52

Collaborate · 17/05/2022 13:17

I find this whole thread quite homphobic actually.

@Collaborate One could argue that surrogacy is femphobic.

MintIceCream1 · 18/05/2022 10:47

XelaM · 17/05/2022 13:03

I see nothing wrong with surrogacy. My former boss had two kids via surrogacy, as she was too old to have kids. Her and her partner were ridiculously wealthy and the two kids will have amazing lives and want for nothing. What's wrong with that?

@XelaM If she was too old to have babies then she could have ADOPTED two of the many kids in need, rather than creating designer babies. The shallowness of your argument that because her and her partner are 'ridiculously wealthy' is unbelievable. Many children in wealthy families are unhappy and just want love, not gifts and material items. Them being ridiculously wealthy does not mean they will be HAPPY.

Cornettoninja · 18/05/2022 10:00

You don't have to understand it. You just have to accept not everyone feels the same way you do

@DropYourSword do you accept that the ‘everyone’ you refer to includes the resulting person? If you had gone ahead with being a surrogate how would you approach a situation where the resulting person did feel or desire a connection with you at some point in their life? There’s no guarantee either way whether they would or wouldn’t have their own emotional investment.

@ImAvingOops and @Emotionalsupportviper both sum up my feelings regarding both the surrogate themselves and the resulting person.

I don’t understand why anyone supporting surrogacy, and there are valid reasons for that support that I can understand, wouldn’t address the concerns raised rather than switch into attack-defence mode. These issues exist, how are being addressed by those involved in surrogacy?

WildNights · 18/05/2022 09:59

Hoppinggreen · 18/05/2022 09:42

While I still have some concerns around this arrangement it’s very different from people commissioning a poorer woman who they don’t know to do this.

Less exploitation of the birth mum, but still puts the wants of the adults above the child. It should be banned.

Hoppinggreen · 18/05/2022 09:42

RainbowBallOfDoom · 17/05/2022 21:48

I have been a surrogate for a friend.

it’s my body, I chose to do it. My friends are happy their child is happy. I’m happy.

it’s not your business.

While I still have some concerns around this arrangement it’s very different from people commissioning a poorer woman who they don’t know to do this.

Hoppinggreen · 18/05/2022 09:33

Clymene · 18/05/2022 05:54

You can't give people as gifts.

Yep
and the sex of the people who are given/sold the baby is totally irrelevant

JeffThePilot · 18/05/2022 09:30

cognitivedissonance1 · 18/05/2022 09:17

How is this naive?

Have you ever had fertility treatment?
I have. Over several years.

Fertility treatment as well as surrogacy costs money.
The appointments cost money.
The consultations cost money.
The Counselling and therapy appointments required costs money.
The travel, fuel, hotel fees if the fertility clinic is long distance costs money.
Maternity clothes costs money.

The time off work for appointments costs money. (The time the surrogate has off work after the pregnancy also costs money).
The supplements and medications cost money.

The cost racks up a bit doesn't it...??

Because the figures run into tens of thousands. Vitamins, massages, special food, clothing, relaxation music, furnishings, you name it. If it can be shoehorned in, it will be. It’s not just necessities by any means. It’s actually quite easy to bulk up payments.

ArcheryAnnie · 18/05/2022 09:24

What if it were a man and a women with a surrogate? Would that change things

@cherrybonbons many posters have said rrpeatrdly that they object to straight people using surrogates, too. It's not an issue that the couple who bought a child are gay men - it's the fact they bought a child that's wrong.

cognitivedissonance1 · 18/05/2022 09:22

FannyCann · 18/05/2022 08:35

Yes it's funny that in the UK surrogate mothers can't be paid except expenses and yet there is an apparent "going rate" of about £15,000.
When I see surrogate mothers discussing their expenses on YouTube etc they always talk about the maternity clothes, the sanitary towels and the vitamins!

My pregnancies probably cost me about £300 - I had a lot of pass down maternity clothes but treated myself to a few items and things like bras. I doubt vitamins and sanitary items exceeded £50
A few costs like hospital parking and I suppose the petrol.

🤷‍♀️

You are EXTREMELY LUCKY that's all your pregnancies cost you. 👏🏻
For others it isn't like that. I have already replied to one person with this but thought I'd copy and paste my reply to you as well.
Your pregnancies cost you very little because you didn't NEED to consider all of the other costs when it comes to fertility treatments.

Fertility treatment as well as surrogacy costs money.
The appointments cost money.
The consultations cost money.
The Counselling and therapy appointments required as part of the fertility/surrogacy costs money.
The travel, fuel, hotel fees if the fertility clinic is long distance costs money.
Maternity clothes costs money.

The time off work for appointments costs money. (The time the surrogate has off work after the pregnancy also costs money).
The supplements and medications cost money.

I have had fertility treatment which obviously cost thousands and thousands of pounds. However, separate to that, I have lost A LOT of money through having to attend appointments therefore missing work etc and the other things mentioned above.

It's a lot more than £300.

cognitivedissonance1 · 18/05/2022 09:17

JeffThePilot · 18/05/2022 07:51

When someone offers to be a surrogate - most of the time they're not receiving payment for this. They are paid for time they'll miss from work for appointments etc but don't receive an actual payment for doing it.

this is naive

How is this naive?

Have you ever had fertility treatment?
I have. Over several years.

Fertility treatment as well as surrogacy costs money.
The appointments cost money.
The consultations cost money.
The Counselling and therapy appointments required costs money.
The travel, fuel, hotel fees if the fertility clinic is long distance costs money.
Maternity clothes costs money.

The time off work for appointments costs money. (The time the surrogate has off work after the pregnancy also costs money).
The supplements and medications cost money.

The cost racks up a bit doesn't it...??