Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to be offended by this T-shirt?

366 replies

parklife1 · 17/05/2022 12:29

I saw a post on social media today. It was about two gay men becoming fathers of twins via surrogate. There was a picture of the two men in "DAD" T-shirts. The pregnant surrogate stood in between them with a T-shirt saying "NOT THE MOMMA".

I'm not even against surrogacy perse, but I found this picture offensive.

I understood why she was wearing it - she wanted to display that she doesn't want to have a mothering role in the children's life.

I still think it's a slap in the face of women, we go through so much during pregnancy and labour. Giving birth can be life-threatening, I lost 2.1 litres of blood during my first birth and 1 litre of blood during my second birth.

Many women have postpartum depression after birth and the hormones are on a roller-coaster.

My body will be forever marked by giving birth (stretch marks, C-section scar, mum tum).

To me this picture is just offensive, because it sort of portrays women and our bodies as a commodity.

AIBU?

OP posts:
saleorbouy · 17/05/2022 14:03

I don't see why you need to be offended, this lady is only expressing herself in her own surrogacy situation and is not using it in the context of your birth experience.
As far as making women commodities I think it's comparative to females accepting sperm from donors.
Both in my opinion are very giving gestures that allow those unable to conceive to have the joy of parenthood.

Cornettoninja · 17/05/2022 14:02

Leaving the surrogacy issue to one side, I think this is awful for the resulting child. No one can predict how this child will feel about how it came into existence, maybe it won’t be particularly affected, maybe it will but it’s up to that person how they wish their biological mother(/s if egg donation is involved) to be defined.

I know someone who has no issue with their adoption but I also know people who’ve grown up not knowing who their father was (for instance) and feel a keen loss of a part of their identity. I don’t think it’s right at all to try to define that relationship for someone else, particularly when I think it’s safe to presume none of the adults involved have any experience of it themselves.

it’s a pretty strong statement that leads me to suspect they will tell their child how to feel rather than listen to what they’re being told and that makes me quite sad.

Adoption has made great strides with recognising the importance to some about understanding their genetic backgrounds and feeling a connection to it, participants of surrogacy would do well to take note to support the children it creates.

hearmywomanlyroar · 17/05/2022 14:02

(That was in response to hear hear vs here here)

ThereWillBeSnacks · 17/05/2022 14:01

What about the concept of adoption?

Adoption is entirely different to surrogacy.

Adoption is a complex process with the child's needs firmly at the centre. Adoption is not about what the parents or prospective parents want, it's about the child and what is best for them.

Surrogacy is entirely about the wants of the commissioning parents. It ignores the needs of the child who is created with the express intention of removing it, usually at birth, from its mother.

Adoption is necessary, important and difficult. Surrogacy is an abhorrent practice, currently being normalised by social media and celebrity, and should be banned.

hearmywomanlyroar · 17/05/2022 14:01

@SleeplessInEngland oops! Confused I did wonder if I'd got that right but no edit button!

SleeplessInEngland · 17/05/2022 14:01

"We are against the exploitation of women."

Going by the OP the woman was happily posing with them. Not quite the same as financially desperate eastern europeans, no matter how much mental gynmanstics people on here try.

DaleTrimont · 17/05/2022 14:00

ArcheryAnnie · 17/05/2022 12:36

The two men should've been wearing t-shirts that say "I bought a human being".

I am all for gay men being parents, but there are options available that don't commodity children and erase women.

This.

GirlCrushxxx · 17/05/2022 13:59

Bunnyfuller · 17/05/2022 13:59

The mother is the person who is there when you’re sick, for your first period, for your first kiss, your first break up..

LOVE for the baby makes the parents. With respect, do NOT tell me who my mum is. I know.

There is something horrifically offensive on this thread, and it’s not the t-shirt.

What a load of shite!!!

Gasp0deTheW0nderD0g · 17/05/2022 13:59

GirlCrushxxx · 17/05/2022 13:53

What happened to a surrogates 'my body my choice'?

And trying to cheapen the process by saying surrogate babies are 'bought' really has no effect

Nobody has a totally unfettered right to do what they like with their body, if it's against public policy. In the UK it's illegal to sell your organs for transplant into another person's body, for example. Many other countries have banned surrogacy. It's a great shame we haven't done the same.

SleeplessInEngland · 17/05/2022 13:59

"Here here"

*Hear hear

(Sorry, seen this three times today and something snapped in my brain.)

Bunnyfuller · 17/05/2022 13:59

The mother is the person who is there when you’re sick, for your first period, for your first kiss, your first break up..

LOVE for the baby makes the parents. With respect, do NOT tell me who my mum is. I know.

There is something horrifically offensive on this thread, and it’s not the t-shirt.

hearmywomanlyroar · 17/05/2022 13:58

Collaborate · 17/05/2022 13:53

This thread is hompophpobic because it seeks to deny gay males the oportunity to have a family. It is getting offencded at the thought that gay men may want to have a child with a surrogate, and that surrogate will be perfectly happy to help. Children can have two fathers and they can have two mothers.

I'll paraphrase this OP - Children can only have one mother and one father.

What about the concept of adoption?

Sometimes this site is a real cess pit.

No one is against gay men being fathers - I imagine if you did a survey of everyone on this thread they would all be in favour of gay men becoming fathers via adoption. We are against the exploitation of women.

Twizbe · 17/05/2022 13:58

Collaborate · 17/05/2022 13:53

This thread is hompophpobic because it seeks to deny gay males the oportunity to have a family. It is getting offencded at the thought that gay men may want to have a child with a surrogate, and that surrogate will be perfectly happy to help. Children can have two fathers and they can have two mothers.

I'll paraphrase this OP - Children can only have one mother and one father.

What about the concept of adoption?

Sometimes this site is a real cess pit.

No. Gay men can have a family. Like I say I know several who have adopted. They are great parents. I know one who had children with a woman before coming out.

What they shouldn't be able to do, what no one should be able to do, is rent a woman's body.

Franca123 · 17/05/2022 13:57

@LoveSpringDaffs I had ivf. Criticising surrogacy doesn't offend me. Please don't worry about me!

GirlCrushxxx · 17/05/2022 13:57

Some of the lily livered little snowflakes on this site might be shocked to know MUMSnet is not only for mums.....'for parents'

Doesn't matter how you become a parent. Or if you are male.

Too many bored mumsnetters trying to paint a 'mother' as some kind of superior being! Worried about being erased, not needed....Grin

Gasp0deTheW0nderD0g · 17/05/2022 13:57

Collaborate · 17/05/2022 13:53

This thread is hompophpobic because it seeks to deny gay males the oportunity to have a family. It is getting offencded at the thought that gay men may want to have a child with a surrogate, and that surrogate will be perfectly happy to help. Children can have two fathers and they can have two mothers.

I'll paraphrase this OP - Children can only have one mother and one father.

What about the concept of adoption?

Sometimes this site is a real cess pit.

Nonsense. I feel the same about heterosexual people, and single people of any sexuality, as I do about two gay men 'using' a surrogate to obtain a baby.

Vikinga · 17/05/2022 13:57

I don't find it offensive but I do think that most people want to know where they come from and who they come from. You can't and shouldn't erase part of a human's backgound because it doesn't suit you.

My eldest's father has played very little part in his life (little more than a sperm donor) but he's still an important part of his life. I did not let the fact that he didn't see him or pay anything or ask about him or show any concern about his welfare for most of his childhood get in the way of him wanting to get to know him and that side of the family.

I have 2 friends who are adopted and who despite having very loving parents, wanted to know their biological mother.

CaptSkippy · 17/05/2022 13:56

Surrogacy is abhorrent. Women are not wombs for hire. It's often poor women in countries with lacks surrogacy laws that end up having to carry babies for wealthy couples.

There was even one instance with a Urkanian surrogate where a couple forced the woman to be induced early, and without the doctor signing off on it they toke the baby and raced for the border before the Russians invaded.

Caminante · 17/05/2022 13:55

Velvian · 17/05/2022 13:15

To the baby, the woman that carried them is the mother surely? They have been hearing the mother's voice, heartbeat, home and family for the pregnancy.

That would be my understanding of it. Eggs and sperm aside, surely the woman who carries the baby is the mother?

Twizbe · 17/05/2022 13:54

Donor sperm is not the same as surrogacy at all.

For a start all a man has to do to donate sperm is wank into a cup. Hardly an invasive medical procedure that carries some significant risks for him.

Collaborate · 17/05/2022 13:53

This thread is hompophpobic because it seeks to deny gay males the oportunity to have a family. It is getting offencded at the thought that gay men may want to have a child with a surrogate, and that surrogate will be perfectly happy to help. Children can have two fathers and they can have two mothers.

I'll paraphrase this OP - Children can only have one mother and one father.

What about the concept of adoption?

Sometimes this site is a real cess pit.

hearmywomanlyroar · 17/05/2022 13:53

ThereWillBeSnacks · 17/05/2022 13:49

It has nothing to do with homophobia. Surrogacy is morally abhorrent regardless of whether the baby is bought by same-sex or mixed-sex couples.

Here here

Gasp0deTheW0nderD0g · 17/05/2022 13:53

XelaM · 17/05/2022 13:03

I see nothing wrong with surrogacy. My former boss had two kids via surrogacy, as she was too old to have kids. Her and her partner were ridiculously wealthy and the two kids will have amazing lives and want for nothing. What's wrong with that?

Having a lot of money doesn't necessarily mean the children will be happy. I'm against surrogacy in all circumstances. It's very high risk for the woman who goes through the pregnancy, especially if she has no genetic connection to the baby, and it's not in a baby's best interests to be removed from the mother immediately after birth - and before anybody starts up with the idea that she's not the baby's mother, yes, she is, in the sense that the baby has had virtually all of its gestation in her womb and she gave birth to the baby. The baby has known the sound of her voice for weeks and weeks before birth.

Nobody has the right to a baby. It's very sad that not everybody can have a child who wants one, for a variety of reasons, but unfortunately that's how it is. Enabling wealthy people to buy a baby, which is effectively what's happening here, is abhorrent.

GirlCrushxxx · 17/05/2022 13:53

What happened to a surrogates 'my body my choice'?

And trying to cheapen the process by saying surrogate babies are 'bought' really has no effect

hearmywomanlyroar · 17/05/2022 13:53

I agree with you @myceliumama. I just don't understand the mental gymnastics people have to go through to claim that the surrogate is somehow not the mother. Of course she is!