Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To get irritable with my boyfriend of 2 years constantly commenting on how attractive the women on screen are?

58 replies

EmpyreanIsles · 17/05/2022 10:16

I think I’m normally a very reasonable person. I am inclined to be a little insecure admittedly, but I think I handle it and I’m not in the habit of making this other people’s problem. Nevertheless perhaps someone wiser/more mature/emotionally grounded etc could guide me on how not to get wound up by this. It doesn’t spoil EVERY programme or film we watch but it does frequently piss me right off and spoil my enjoyment and any feelings of quiet intimacy of watching something together. I find I’m managing those feelings instead of enjoying the show. I am just so fed up of hearing how beautiful, graceful, elegant, Hepburn-esque, sexy the women on our tv screen are. Their teeth, their eyes, their legs, their hair. It’s so bloody annoying.

I have finally said something about it and essentially he’s gone all quiet and said he wouldn’t intentionally offend me and to call him when I’m ready and gone back to his own house. To me that isn’t the same as being interested in why your partner is upset or being genuinely sorry. So he has left this morning and avoided asking anything or acknowledging how I feel in any meaningful way. I am possibly being hard work and I know you guys won’t hold back in letting me know.

Does anyone else get this on a regular basis and are you bothered by it or not? And if not, how do you rise above it. I have thought about doing the same to see if he notices but a) I think that would be childish and unhelpful and b) there are way fewer genuinely attractive men on screen than women so it’s harder to comment! And it just doesn’t feel like me to do that.

I realise that this could be a bit thought-policey or controlling and that’s why I have never mentioned it before because I don’t want to make him uncomfortable or feel like he can’t express himself freely but I can’t go on listening to it either because it’s getting right on my wick.

Our relationship is otherwise pretty good and he is a caring, loving partner but this drives me up the wall. It’s possibly not helped by the fact that he isn’t that forthcoming with compliments on my appearance and all of his commentary illustrates just how far I am from what it is that he seems to find attractive. Maybe I am being excessively needy or narcissistic.

Anyone else feel like this or am I being unreasonable and a bit of a twat to have asked him if he could stop doing this because I find it really annoying. I feel worse now than I did before because he has neither apologised nor asked why I feel like that and he hasnt demonstrated that he cares how I feel. Perhaps I’m not entitled to expect that and it would be understandable if he felt defensive in the first instance but I suspect he is going to be feeling all hard done by and unless I force the issue (which doesn’t feel right for me to do), he will never broach it again of his own accord.

Thank you for reading this. It really is a storm in a teacup in many ways but any views and insights welcome!

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
SeedyBloomer · 17/05/2022 22:31

I find men that frequently point out to their partners how hot other women are, when it’s out of the blue and not even part of a conversation, are trying to keep their partners on their toes. My husband of 15 years has never once told me he finds anyone else attractive. Obviously he must do, but the point is he doesn’t feel the need to let me know. Interestingly, your angle here is mainly worrying about if you are unreasonable / jealous / controlling etc etc. What you probably need to be saying to him is that his behaviour is pretty immature and unattractive - he’s not a teenager and he really doesn’t need to say phwoar out loud time he spots an attractive women - and while you frequently spot attractive men, you don’t feel the need to note it out loud. This is an issue with him, not you.

FirewomanSam · 17/05/2022 21:55

Oh OP it seems like you’re trying so hard here to defend your boyfriend and justify your relationship to a bunch of strangers over the internet. You’ve told us that he’s a good guy, really, over and over again. You don’t need to convince any of us, just be careful that you’re not trying to convince yourself, deep down.

Your posts about how he tells you his colleagues are attractive and you think he has a crush on one of them made me so sad. Then you said it’s ok because he compliments your personality. You deserve to feel loved and special and beautiful, not just settling for the scraps your partner deigns to give you.

Please look after yourself OP and set yourself a higher standard for what you deserve.

MyneighbourisTotoro · 17/05/2022 15:31

My ex did it, a long with staring at/commenting on women on the street all the time, its one of the reasons he is an ex!
My husband wouldn’t dream of doing any of that!

Anonymous48 · 17/05/2022 15:02

I would hate that, OP. Completely unnecessary and disrespectful of you.

My husband knows some that there are a few famous men that I find attractive. I don't go on about it though, or discuss exactly what about them I find appealing.

I have no idea what famous women he finds attractive, although as a healthy heterosexual man I have no doubt there are some. He would never think to discuss with me how physically attractive a woman is. He would think it completely irrelevant. He has told me in the past that the one thing I have in common with the women he has previously been involved with, and the most important quality for him, is intelligence.

MissChanandlerBong80 · 17/05/2022 14:59

This would upset me and I’ve known a few men who do it but funnily enough it’s because they’re insecure! Finding someone attractive is fine but commenting constantly is unnecessary.

Yep, I agree with this. I’ve known a few men who do it including an ex. The constant never-ending stream of comments on women’s appearances. I actually once got sat next to a man at a wedding who did it - I didn’t even know him but he kept on commenting on women’s appearances - other guests at the wedding, celebrities who came in conversation, women who he knew who weren’t even present. It was so, so creepy.

In the case of my ex and the wedding guest I think they were both insecure and also absolute raving misogynists.

Mondaymanic · 17/05/2022 14:46

I think that's a big ignorant of him tbh. I totally get everyone will find other people attractive but the running commentary would be annoying. I'd be saying you won't be arsed staying together if they keep it up x

KettrickenSmiled · 17/05/2022 14:43

Your boyfriend leaving the house when you’ve made the very reasonable requeat that he not admire other women in front of you is HIM policing your speech.

Yes.
Please be very aware of this OP.
You come over as such a kind & thoughtful person. Please don't allow your good nature to be taken advantage of or manipulated.

Neverreturntoathread · 17/05/2022 14:29

What he’s doing is disrespectful.

People in tv are generally better looking than us. They spend a lot of time and effort getting that way. But to constantly go on about how attractive other women are is rude. DH has never, ever, commented on how a woman looks in front of me, and if I started going in about how hot I think Aquaman looks or whatever, DH would go very silent.

Your boyfriend leaving the house when you’ve made the very reasonable requeat that he not admire other women in front of you is HIM policing your speech.

MasterBeth · 17/05/2022 13:25

I think it's mostly rude and unnecessary. I don't need to know what my partner thinks about how attractive or not other people are and I'll generally keep my own thoughts to myself.

I will make a small exception for stating the obvious about conventionally attractive film/TV stars. We don't mind hearing that Chris Evans (not that one) is extremely hunky or Jenna Coleman is extremely pretty. I don't need to hear that about someone in the street or my best friend, though.

DrinkFeckArseBrick · 17/05/2022 13:05

I think there are three types of relationships.

The type where these types of comments are ok, and they both point out attractive people, both have lists of people they're 'allowed' to shag and it doesn't bother them as it's all hypothetical

The type where they both think its disrespectful to openly lust after someone else in front of the person you're supposed to be loyal to

Both these are fine

And then it goes a bit wrong when you get one person from each relationship type. The person commenting should definitely be the one to stop though, it's not an essential thing to comment on other people that it would be at all detrimental to stop and if it bothers the other person then there is no reason for them not to just change their approach slightly and not say anything.

I'm with you OP but I'm quite literal in general. If someone I was with pointed out how attractive someone else was in front of me, when they're not telling me I'm attractive, my response would be along the lines of 'fuck off and be with someone who you think is that attractive then'

Rinatinabina · 17/05/2022 13:02

If DH started doing that I would think he’s broken his brain. He can fancy who he wants but if talked through everything to comment on looks I’d be like “shut up you are distracting from the story”.

personally I think its a grind you down and make you insecure project. Only reason it’s happened to me in the past is because i was dating a negger or someone who was low level abusive.

I think other men are attractive sometimes but I don’t feel the need to share with DH because a)it’s in passing - I’ll think, he’s pretty or nice shoulders” but not something I’ll spend a lot of brain time on b) I don’t actually know what the purpose of articulating it would be. I also think things like “oh she’s got nice shoes” “fabulous hair” it doesn’t all come spilling out of my gob.

bloodyunicorns · 17/05/2022 12:57

Commenting occasionally on a woman's appearance - ok. Constant comments - not ok.

He should be sorry he's upset you and thinking about his own actions, not sulky and defensive.

Josette77 · 17/05/2022 12:41

He tells you how attractive his colleagues are??? And he has previously had an affair. Red flags everywhere. Saying Angelina Jolie is gorgeous is not the same as commenting on Sarah from accounting.

Beautifulmonster87 · 17/05/2022 12:33

This would upset me and I’ve known a few men who do it but funnily enough it’s because they’re insecure! Finding someone attractive is fine but commenting constantly is unnecessary. Of course it’s going to make you feel a bit insecure and if he can’t see that then you shouldn’t be together.

My parents don’t have sky tv because my mum worried my dad would see too many attractive women and he always commented and it upset her! So I was brought up thinking all women even on tv must be a threat. I’ve done well to accept my husband loves me and can find people attractive but he wouldn’t comment! I am more likely to comment and say ‘wow she’s Beautiful’ about a women but like you find it hard to spot many nice looking men!

RoseGoldEagle · 17/05/2022 12:27

It’s just thoughtless and rude. I completely accept DH will find other women attractive, but if he went on about that to me I’d think he was incredibly disrespectful. I’m not remotely insecure about how I look either (not because I’m a stunner, far from it! I’m ok looking and think I’m a nice person and have lovely friends and am just fine with how I look!), so my irritation wouldn’t be down to being insecure or too sensitive, it would simply be that I felt that behaviour unnecessary and quite rude.

Zilla1 · 17/05/2022 12:27

HNRTT but bothered? No but you are and if he is constantly commenting then how he seems to have responded in terms of going away and telling you to call him might appear to be giving you space but might not bode well for the future of your relationship. How do you think he will respond if you plan on sharing a home let alone having children or if unemployment, bereavements or other difficulties arise?

EmpyreanIsles · 17/05/2022 12:26

Thank you, Antarctic, you have summed it up very well and that is exactly what I’m going to do.

BigCheese, your wry comments really made me laugh.

Thank you all !

OP posts:
AntarcticTern · 17/05/2022 12:23

Yes I agree. Call him, don't make a big deal of it, don't apologise yourself or demand an apology from him.

Then observe his actions. If he stops doing it, all well and good. If not, bring it up again and give him one (just one!) more chance to stop.

Fingers crossed OP!

EmpyreanIsles · 17/05/2022 12:17

I have been asking myself if I call him or not. This morning I was thinking “no way” and he can call me when he has worked out that he needs to either apologise properly or try to understand/acknowledge why it might be annoying.

Now I am inclined to think that I don’t want this to mushroom. I talk to him like a mature sensible adult and he either responds in kind and we move on better than before or he acts like a twit, which to be fair to him, I don’t think he will and then I would have to ask myself where we are going and how much more I want to invest in this.

I think this is a bit of a cock up but that overall he is a really good person and we have a good relationship so I don’t want to over-react.

I can’t thank you guys enough. Wise, funny women-folk of Mumsnet 🤗

OP posts:
AntarcticTern · 17/05/2022 12:13

I don't think you should necessarily expect an apology from him, as you've never mentioned this before so he may honestly not have realised it was bothering you.

What you should expect is for him to emerge from his sulk and STOP doing it (or at least cut it right back to very occasional) now that he does know.

If he doesn't do that, you'll know that he is not a kind person.

The sulking thing would also bother me. It sounds like the two of you could improve your communication more generally.

Sausageandeggs · 17/05/2022 12:10

First of all, I agree with those who say you’re not being too sensitive. I think he’s being insensitive.

Secondly, this isn’t a one-size-fits-all type of universal answer. People are very different. This is a bit like monogamy: some people are monogamists and some are not. We all have different levels of interest in other people. And there is no right or wrong in that regard. However, there is a necessity for being with someone who is willing to understand your level of interest, and be willing to meet you on it. There are couples for whom they spent a lot of time noticing and commenting on others. If it works for them, awesome. There are also couples who feel that it erodes the intimacy of their relationship to be this way. In other words, the grass grows where you water it. I’m personally one of those types. I’ve been with men of the former type and it simply does not work. His attention is elsewhere. It’s not on me. I’m now in a relationship with a guy who thinks I shit gold dust, and the difference is night and day. He isn’t naturally interested in giving his attention elsewhere. And he would hate it if I did too. we have discussed this extensively. Communication is vital in any relationship, and where your values match is a key to success.

Just some things to consider. There is absolutely nothing wrong with you.

EmpyreanIsles · 17/05/2022 12:08

That is such a useful template, Kettricken. Thank you.

OP posts:
EmpyreanIsles · 17/05/2022 12:03

Hi Cigarettes and Kettricken,

sorry I hadn’t seen your response when I replied. It’s really useful to know that I am not being unreasonable. And I do have work to do on what is reasonable to expect. That’s a work in progress and you have all helped me here with figuring out where the boundary is for me personally.

He has been a bit careless with my feelings but I don’t think it’s deliberate. I have asked him before why he talks about colleagues in terms of their attractiveness. I think there might be something of that lurking behind this for me because he seems a little put out by one of his protégés not taking him up on an opportunity for progression and I think there is something small there that is troubling me ( like a crush perhaps) and it has come out obliquely here.

He is a very caring person and he does show his love in many meaningful ways but I think he also avoids issues and pushes things to one side a lot. I think it was interesting that he didn’t really apologise and so I think he is sorry I’m hurt but doesn’t think he has done anything wrong. I suspect he will think the problem is my self-esteem and not his commentary. I think it’s probably a bit of both.

Having said all of that he is a genuinely very good, caring and loving person. To be fair to him, I should clarify that he does give me compliments on who I am as a human being. He says Im kind and compassionate etc, lots of nice things but actually I would like him to sound as animated about how attractive I am to him as he sounds about women on screen or maybe just flirt with me a bit more.

Anyway, you have all really helped me to find some clarity on this. Thank you so much for taking the time and for all of your thoughtful insights.

OP posts:
MsTSwift · 17/05/2022 12:01

Just downright rude and horrible. Dh has never done this. I keep my views of Cillian Murphy in peaky blinders to myself too.

Aussiegirl123456 · 17/05/2022 12:00

Negging.
He is slowly trying to chip away at your confidence likely. If it makes you uncomfortable then that’s how you feel, definitely don’t apologise for it or feel there’s something wrong with you or that you’re being over sensitive. You’re not.

Swipe left for the next trending thread