Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Paying money from business account - war and peace required - feel like a child

35 replies

Morenamesandpasswords · 17/05/2022 08:59

I had to transfer £30K from my company account to a car dealership for a vehicle purchase.

Set up the payment - had to click three time on "Continue" on the page where it warned about fraud before it would continue.

Then, there was a series of 20 questions to ask along the lines of:

  1. What am I buying
  2. have I received the goods
  3. Have I done the deal face to face
  4. Am I sure
  5. what are the goods
  6. Am I really really really really sure
etc etc

In between each question was a splash page telling me that fraudsters are criminals and they are telling me how to answer the questions.......

I could only do 15K per day so I went through the whole rigmarole yesterday

After bracing myself for a repeat performance this morning, I tried to transfer the second tranche only to find it is making me wait 72 hours for my own protection before I can transfer the rest.

Supposed to be collecting the vehicle Friday so its going to be cutting it fine.

It really winds me up. Its my money. If I want to withdraw it and cut it up into confetti its my choice not theirs.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
KateAlyson1995 · 30/08/2022 09:32

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Alwayshoovering · 17/05/2022 15:37

It's MY money, I'm not a child, don't treat me like an idiot blah blah blah.
That's what all the victims or fraudsters said and then they got scammed.

The government have now made it the banks problem to deal with when their idiotic customers hand over their money to fraudsters so now they have to show they have taken steps to prevent fraud and alert custoners to the types of scsms to avoid having to cover the cost of losses and these warnings etc are there to protect you as well as the bank.

Get over it, it's a minor inconvenience once in a while when you make large payments.

FreddyVoorhees · 17/05/2022 14:38

ALoadOfCodswallop · 17/05/2022 14:18

I used to work in a call centre for a bank in the fraud department. I can 100% guarantee that the people who are saying this is all ridiculous, and I'm an adult, I don't need constant reminders would be the ones phoning up and blaming the bank when they send their savings to a fraudster.

Also, fraud on business accounts is a massive thing and is easier than on personal accounts with spoofed invoices and less oversight on accounts.

Spot on. It's not ridiculous at all.

What is ridiculous is just how much the banks have ended up on the hook for the actions of their customers.

3monkeybars · 17/05/2022 14:36

Just call the bank - we had this when transferring 000sk for a house purchase, they lifted the limit temporarily on our account.
And YABU, those checks and limits are there to protect mistakes and the the vulnerable

grapewines · 17/05/2022 14:31

If you'd sent your money to someone else by mistake you'd be on here moaning that there weren't enough checks. Your OP sounds like it was a very strenuous task indeed! If you don't want to wait then go to a branch and pay them to do it.

lovingtheheat · 17/05/2022 14:19

You'd be surprised how many directors misappropriate company funds for personal use so yabu. You maybe the sole shareholder but unless and until dividends are paid the money actually belongs to the company.

ALoadOfCodswallop · 17/05/2022 14:18

I used to work in a call centre for a bank in the fraud department. I can 100% guarantee that the people who are saying this is all ridiculous, and I'm an adult, I don't need constant reminders would be the ones phoning up and blaming the bank when they send their savings to a fraudster.

Also, fraud on business accounts is a massive thing and is easier than on personal accounts with spoofed invoices and less oversight on accounts.

YellowDome · 17/05/2022 11:38

Call the bank! Have you done this yet? Everytime I've had to make a big purchase I call the bank beforehand to make them aware so they can preauthorise it and stop it from being automatically blocked. Give them a call.

decentchap · 17/05/2022 10:09

Find a simpler way for the next time - banking can still be done by Bankers Draft.
I do agree though that assuming every transaction might be driven by fraud etc is good but bloody annoying when its your money - spare a thought for those who have lost life savings is my way to talk sensibly to the bank.

Peeeas · 17/05/2022 09:52

You can usually pay £30 to make a same day CHAPS payment for any amount. For my bank you just send them a private message with all the details when logged in online and they do the magic (did this recently for house purchase deposit)

MozerellaSalad · 17/05/2022 09:51

You could have gone into the bank and done it in 1 transaction.

Ducksinthebath · 17/05/2022 09:48

I think business accounts need just as much scrutiny as personal ones, if not more. The sums involved could easily be more significant, the consequences can be very far-reaching with jobs at stake as well as the funds in question. Fraudsters are growing increasingly savvy and take advantage of the time and commercial pressures businesses are under.

Just this week my firm had an extremely convincing fake invoice sent to Accounts purporting to come from the Head Buyer requesting expedited payment. Had the transaction been completed it would have meant in excess of £100k disappearing into the ether and a very unhappy few days for a junior staff member. So I'm very glad the process was such that the staff member was prompted more than once to question what they were being asked to do.

Hoppinggreen · 17/05/2022 09:45

Banks can’t win, there is “hysteria” about them supposedly allowing fraud which is all too often down to user error/stupidity or they are criticised for putting in safeguards
They actually aren’t too bothered if you do send your money to the wrong place but they have to be able to show that they tried to stop you to cover their corporate arses.

PipeScatter · 17/05/2022 09:41

Unfortunately the quickest way to make large payments like this nowadays is to actually go in to one of the rapidly reducing numbers of branches. They'll still do the checks and it will cost you a fee, but at least it will be done in one go.

For some perspective, one of our clients lost £5k before they allowed you to check the account name and sort code as my colleague's email had unknowingly been hacked and they sent a copy invoice to a client saying "Sorry - forgot we changed our bank details - here's the new reference".

Client didn't realise their mistake until we chased them for their fees and said that in retrospect they should have realised as the email was very poor quality and the updated invoice was a very dodgy pdf editor job. The £5k was long gone though by then.

The new changes to check the account name are good, but not perfect. Metro bank, for example, aren't on the list, so it doesn't check automatically, so you're still taking a risk with them, but there are other ways to mitigate the risks.

The banks have to be so careful to ensure that if a mistake is made, that it's YOUR mistake and not theirs. Basically, they're trying to be able to lay all the blame on the customer so they don't have to reimburse any money.

Brefugee · 17/05/2022 09:41

thanks @rainyskylight i missed the 72 hours. But for those who say this impedes business - it doesn't impede mine. We regularly make huge transfers - easily into the high 6 figures (we don't go into 7 figures, because we break them down if we need to go that high), and whenever we have a new supplier, we have to get them to complete a billion forms under KYC rules/regs. After that they're registered at our bank as a known supplier and every other transfer goes through as soon as we click send.

For a one-off it's a pain in the neck, but how often do you buy a car from a business account. Make a note of it so next time you're ready

Blarting · 17/05/2022 09:38

rainyskylight · 17/05/2022 09:26

@Brefugee the OP clearly says that she needs to wait 72 hours to transfer the rest. So, 3 days. 3 days to pay a b2b bill. She’s not talking about transferring her life savings.

£30k would be a lot of peoples life savings or more!

Sally872 · 17/05/2022 09:37

Seriously, you're buying a new car and instead if looking forward to it you are moaning about ticking a few boxes?

Yes, it's annoying. It is also important to try and stop people being ripped off. In my mind minor inconvenience would be an eye roll at my phone and move on. I would not waste any time thinking about it any further.

Blarting · 17/05/2022 09:37

*continue not continents

Blarting · 17/05/2022 09:36

Crikey six continents clicks, must've been awful for you. Hope you've recovered ok.

MrsPelligrinoPetrichor · 17/05/2022 09:28

They'd ask the same if you rang up and did it over the phone. The bank always ask me the same set of questions even for a £5 transfer.

rainyskylight · 17/05/2022 09:26

@Brefugee the OP clearly says that she needs to wait 72 hours to transfer the rest. So, 3 days. 3 days to pay a b2b bill. She’s not talking about transferring her life savings.

IanOsenfrote · 17/05/2022 09:25

You are mistaken. It stops being your money as soon as you hand it over to another entity. You merely administer it now, whereas the entity (bank in your case) actually controls it. You have to jump through whatever hoops they decide to get 'your' money.

The actual banknotes in your pocket or under your mattress are yours to both administer and control.

People seem to struggle to understand the difference.

Brefugee · 17/05/2022 09:19

FFS stop using the word hysteria.

If you had transferred your 30k to the wrong account with one click, would you be in hysterics on the phone to the bank to get it back? What a fuss over a few clicks. How long did it take? 20 minutes? an hour? 2 days?

rainyskylight · 17/05/2022 09:18

I agree this is absurd for a business account. If you had to go through this level of checks to run a business then you’d never be able to pay anyone. I think you need to reconsider who your commercial account is with.

AffIt · 17/05/2022 09:16

I'd also argue that business accounts should not be subject to the same hysteria as personal ones.

The banks couldn't give a shiny shit about what you do with your money as a business: however, the law on financial regulation is a LOT more concerned.

Are you a fan of unchecked money laundering?