Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Is it even worth trying to lost weight?

110 replies

toolatetoloseweight · 16/05/2022 20:06

I am currently in the obese range and about 4 stone over my healthy weight. I basically put on loads of weight in my first pregnancy (6 years ago) and I've never managed to shift it.
I was previously a healthy weight but was a fat child and have always struggled a bit with putting on weight very easily.

I keep reading stats saying how unlikely it is for an obese woman to ever lose the weight and keep it off without bariatric surgery - and it is making me wonder if it is even worth trying at this stage...

For context, I am relatively active - walk the dog twice a day, swim twice a week, run around after kids, occasionally go for a run (3-5km so not massive distances but just to put in context that I'm not so big as to be struggling to get around). I dont have a terrible diet (though obviously could be better!). i know from experience that small changes don't make a difference to me- I need to eat under 1200 calories to lose. I am terribly unhappy with the way I look and dread going out and being see by people. However not sure if it is all just a losing battle at this stage...

OP posts:
KellynchHall · 17/05/2022 01:54

Another who would recommend low carb. It sounds impossible at the start but it soon just becomes normal. I usually skip breakfast then have salad for lunch which will be lots of leaves with chicken or cheese and usually coleslaw. Dinner is meat or cheese with veg or salad. So halloumi with roast veg for example. Carbs still comes out at less than 50g.

I know it gets a lot of hate because you are excluding a food group but we didn't evolve to eat carbs like we do. Carbs trigger insulin and if you are secreting insulin you are storing fat. Get blood sugar low enough for long enough and you switch to burning fat. But it is forever in so far as if I stop and start eating pasta, rice, bread etc all the time the weight will go back on. I feel better on the diet as I don't suffer cravings like I usually do. I actually eat more varieties of veg and greater quantity on this diet than I ever would on my usual carb heavy diet.

CalicoAnnie · 17/05/2022 00:25

I am about 3 stone overweight and have been for a few years. I am also post menopausal. I have been a vegetarian for most of my life and had a carb heavy diet. Since having kids (not vegetarian) I have made sure I am cooking them a healthy meal and then have been existing and am totally addicted to carbs.
I am pre diabetic and never seem satisfied with what I eat and am hungry soon after.

So, I have recently done lots of research and have started a keto diet. So far my hunger is so much less, I have lost a couple of kg and actually feel better in myself. I am enjoying the food, feel like this is sustainable in the long run and realise that it is a change for life and not a diet. I am doing lazy keto eating low carb substitute foods but plan to eat cleaner as I become fat adapted.

TheFrustratedRedhead · 17/05/2022 00:17

@misskatamari i second rebelfit, just the Facebook posts alone have transformed the way I think. I’m focussing on lowering my set point now, not my weight.

Sofasogood1 · 17/05/2022 00:14

Hi op. I really empathise, I've been you and felt the same but much much heavier. I did eventually have surgery.

Also on calories, I've eaten 1283 calories today and walked the dog, did work, did chores and 45 mins of cardio and haven't passed out.

Read Why We Eat Too Much by Andrew Jenkinson. He basically says processed food is the problem. He says if you do what he suggests in the book you will lose weight and it will last forever but it will be slow - but worth it.

SouperNoodle · 17/05/2022 00:07

misskatamari · 16/05/2022 20:55

I honestly believe now that diets don't work. They're not sustainable.

I'm reading Anti-diet by Christy Harrison at the moment and it's eye opening. I also really recommend the "out of the cave" podcast by Lisa Schlosberg, which is all about the mind/body connection and our relationship with food.

I have spent my life feeling shit about myself because I'm not thin enough, and I'm sick of it. Dieting and restriction just leads to bingeing in my experience. Which leads to shame and self hatred. I'm done.

I'm focusing on healing my relationship with my body and my relationship with food. Exercising to get strong, eating to nourish my body. Being kind to myself instead of punishing myself. If I get thinner then great, if not, I'm really working on not feeling like my worth is defined by my weight and size.

I needed to see this comment today. I'm going to take your advice and work on my relationship with my body and food instead of punishing myself.

PickAChew · 17/05/2022 00:06

I've been 4 stone heavier than I am. Don't diet. Change how you eat.

gwenneh · 17/05/2022 00:06

My understanding is the diets only work while you are on them, and the minute you come off them, the weight comes back on.

The same is true for bariatric surgery, which requires a strict diet.
Figure out how to get around the restrictions, and your weight comes straight back. The stomach is a fairly elastic organ & if you overeat it will still stretch, even after surgery.

Long-term follow up studies show this usually happens within two years of the surgery; after surgery, it takes very little to overeat.

The weight will come off if you find a sustainable way to consume fewer calories than you expend.

Menora · 17/05/2022 00:01

also in all honesty, I’m on a weight loss journey and the first thing I had to admit to myself was that I wasn’t honestly tracking correctly to begin. I was over estimating food and forgetting to add things. 100g of pasta is way smaller than you think it is, so people end up eating 200g accidentally and not logging it. I don’t love logging calories but I think it’s a useful tool to open your mind to what you are actually eating

and resetting your metabolism has been proven to not be a thing
fasting is an awful idea for someone who struggles to diet. It is setting yourself up to fail within about 2 weeks. I wish people would stop giving such awful advice. Like drinking water with lemon in it helps you lose weight (it doesn’t)

Menora · 16/05/2022 23:56

There is thread after thread on here from people who did very low cal diets or cut out carbs and put all the weight back on. Like endless. Also lot of people I have seen who have had gastric surgery have a lot of problems with their teeth health and loose skin due to dramatic fast weight loss

you need to repair your relationship with food, not find a way to make it even worse

eating no carbs is by far the worst idea for someone who already struggles to stick to a healthy eating plan and just makes sticking to it near impossible. Eating no carbs is fine if someone wants to eat virtually no fruit or veg or most of their energy sources and spend all their money on meat and eating eggs and being constipated to lose 10lbs

losing weight, really losing it and repairing your relationship with food and your body is really hard work. But it’s not impossible. It really can be done you just have to stop looking for quick answers. It’s like starting a new job for life. You will make some sacrifices (eating less of the foods you rely on for comfort or undoing bad habits), learning new skills like cooking and reading labels. You will have to sometimes make hard decisions to eat less of or avoid something you really love. But you do not have to give up food groups or eat dust all day long. Those are extreme. There is middle ground. You just have to believe you can get to where you want to be and start every day as a new one. Weight loss takes months, but it’s worth it because you do feel so good, you have more energy, you feel brighter, you want to move more, you feel proud of yourself and healthier. If you want to do it, you can do it.

The NHS weight loss apps are free and easy to use, I would download those to start

MrOllivander · 16/05/2022 23:33

I'm just aiming for health really. 5ft 10 and size 16-18 and about 18 stone Sad
I do spin classes 4-6 days a week from 30-60 mins and am building up to 90 min ones. Trying to eat more veg, and more protein

CabbageBabbage · 16/05/2022 23:31

Absolutely it is worth it. I think the figures that get thrown around about the percentage of diets that fail can be a bit misleading- yes most diets fail but many of us have been on a lot of diets. It’s a bit like smoking- most of my attempts to give up failed but I still gave up, because the last one succeeded. You only need to diet and keep it off once 😎

Also bear in mind that any weight loss is beneficial. It’s not a failure because someone didn’t get to target weight.

What i would advise is looking into the causes of your weight gain- what are your triggers for overeating? If you can address those you hugely increase your chances of long-term success.

What worked for me was keeping a vague eye on calories, increasing veg, cutting out sugar and alcohol. It has to be something you can
keep up. Try to get out of the binge/restrict mindset where you’re either off your diet (bingeing) or on a diet (harsh restrictions).

SausagePourHomme · 16/05/2022 23:20

cherrybonbons · 16/05/2022 22:16

NO one and I mean NO one should be eating 1200 calories a day. Especially if you are classed as overweight. 1600 MINIMUM if you want to be successful. Enjoy food. Do it in moderation. Increase your runs to 6-7km 2-3 times a week. Drink lots of water.

Just not true. At 5 ft tall, a woman eating 1600 cals per day with sedentary lifestyle will gain weight.

vrrnbb · 16/05/2022 23:20

Zaab213 · 16/05/2022 21:54

@vrrnbb do you mind sharing what you eat on a typical day? Well done for losing weight without excercise. I personally eat more when I’ve gone to the gym, do others feel the same?

In a way I skip breakfast, I will have coffee though with heavy cream and stevia. Lately for lunch I have been packing a sandwich using zero carb bread, and a no sugar drink. For dinner, I would have some type of protein, like Chicken or Steak with a side of vegetables, like broccoli, asparagus or brussels sprouts. I don't shy away from eating fats, it helps keeps me full. When I want to snack I eat berries, nuts or cheese. I used to have a lot of keto snack bars but I've found that it stalled me. I'll have those though when I go on hikes, and supplement with no sugar electrolyte drinks. So I do feel like I eat more when I exercise, but I don't think it sets you back.

The hardest thing for me was cutting out sugar. But I found alternatives.

I try to intermittent fast, but I don't have a true eating window. I just try my best to not eat so late if I'm actually not really hungry. I feel like it's almost a mindset. It took a while for me to not feel so hungry all the time though. You can start small, just don't go back to old bad eating habits. Also, stalling is your body's way of being stubborn. So don't let it trick you and keep at it.

PakkaMakka · 16/05/2022 23:00

I don't think you should value yourself according to your size, though I totally understand the pressures that lead you to do so.

I'd recommend looking up a podcast, MindPump 'why women should bulk'

We all lose muscle as we get older, and the amount of muscle we have has a direct correlation with how many calories we need in a day. Focusing on getting stronger (and as a side effect, building muscle - not bodybuilder style, just to the levels we had in our twenties) feels a much more positive way of doing things compared to depriving/limiting/restricting. In the short term, it'll make us motivated by being able to do things we couldn't do before. In the longer term, more muscle means we need more calories to get by, so no more sub 500cal dinners or cutting things in half.

If I didn't do strength training, at my age I'd be putting on weight if I averaged 1600 calories a day. With strength training, I most likely average 2000-2400. I don't calorie count and don't need to.

blameitonthecaffeine · 16/05/2022 22:50

I saw that stat posted (the 1 in 1200 thing?) and, to be honest, my first thought was that it was a typo for 1 in 12. Then my second thought was that, if it is accurate, then it must refer to the super morbidly obese not 'just' the obese. You don't even need to be visually that big (to our modern eyes) to be classed as obese and I know loads of people who were 'a bit fat' who have lost weight and kept it off permanently (or at least for several years so far). I don't think surgery is a good answer for people without massive amounts of weight to lose, personally. I can see that it could be the only realistic way forward for people with serious food addiction whose health is already massively compromised.

stimpyyouidiot · 16/05/2022 22:50

I'm the same as you. Nothing happens unless I starve myself harshly. It's demoralising.

curlymom · 16/05/2022 22:48

I’m overweight too and having lost almost two stone in last year still overweight. I do slimming world. Just keep doing it keep going. Some of the food is lovely if you get the recipe books. But you do have to keep your eye on it at all times whichever diet you do. Good luck

SkaterGrrrrl · 16/05/2022 22:26

My understanding is the diets only work while you are on them, and the minute you come off them, the weight comes back on.

There is an excellent podcast called Maintenance Phase about the diet and wellness industry, well worth a listen.

puppetcat · 16/05/2022 22:19

Hi op, ignore that stupid comment about bariatric surgery. It sounds like the person they mentioned said it has an agenda to sell gastric sleeve ops! Complete rubbish. And check out that fasting subreddit for inspiration :)

i do think doing a day or two a week even when you’re normalised is helpful because its a reminder to be mindful ongoing as well as helping keep weight off.

And what is a world without some treats eh?

I’ve also found slimpod hypnosis course good. 9 mins a day podcast to listen to while you’re drifting off to sleep and seems to help. A trial is free i believe. Try it!

I fundamentally disagree with clubs like slimming world etc. They work while youre on them but not after.

check out james clear talking about atomic habits on youtube. Great inspo for habit building and changing bad habits. His book Atomic Habits also great but the videos enough to get you going. I add a reminder in my calendar to watch once a month or so to remind me how to keep my good habits on track. So inspiring!

cherrybonbons · 16/05/2022 22:16

NO one and I mean NO one should be eating 1200 calories a day. Especially if you are classed as overweight. 1600 MINIMUM if you want to be successful. Enjoy food. Do it in moderation. Increase your runs to 6-7km 2-3 times a week. Drink lots of water.

ObjectionHearsay · 16/05/2022 22:12

The reason most people fail is because a massive calorie deficit to 1200 just causes exhaustion and low mood, so they binge after a while, loose motivation.

The other thing they do is concentrate on weekly weighing. Worst thing you can do especially as a woman as our weight changes so much during our cycle.

Cutting carbs and so forth keto, all shit, don't bother, whatever you loose you'll gain back after such restriction.

Best way to loose weight. Weigh yourself once a month mid cycle. Also reduce your daily intake by 15% see how that goes for a month, if no loss or you find yourself on a plateau increase the deficit to say another 15% see how that goes. And so on and so on. You can't go from eating 2500 calories a day to 1200 overnight and think your body isn't going to start screaming "I'm starving" after 3 days, because that's the intake it's used to.

So maybe if you average 2500 drop to 2375 for 4 weeks when you eventually plateau on the losses, drop again by 15% to say 1807, then again wait for the plateau and drop but less this time to maybe 1500. If you step and stage your calorie deficit you are more likely to achieve a long term weight loss, because you are giving your body time to adapt and change, rather than shocking it. You'll also naturally find you "maintenance" intake and find you keep it off as you have retrained your brain and body.

Reducing to 1200 calories for 2lb a week on MFP is never going to work in the long term. It's pants.

Whybot · 16/05/2022 22:02

you are worth more than you believe but your health is important too. May I suggest joining a group like slimming world or weight watchers ?
all the best x

Zaab213 · 16/05/2022 21:54

@vrrnbb do you mind sharing what you eat on a typical day? Well done for losing weight without excercise. I personally eat more when I’ve gone to the gym, do others feel the same?

JaceLancs · 16/05/2022 21:53

I dieted after DC and lost 8 stone
over a few years (10+) I regained 6 stone
which I then lost doing slimming world
kept it off for a few years until covid then put back on 4 stone
currently dieting again but for me it’s the only way

Zaab213 · 16/05/2022 21:50

I know exactly how you feel. I’m 4 stones overweight than I should be. I start off really good on Mondays but by Wednesday/Thursday I just binge. I wish I knew the secret to losing weight!

if I think back to my younger days I was really skinny and the “secret” was I didn’t have time to eat. I lived alone and didn’t buy chocolate, crisps etc. but now I have a family and I can’t forget to eat as I need to feed the kids and DH! It’s difficult isn’t it. Why don’t we start together eating healthy tomorrow? I will join you and we can support each other.