Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Is it even worth trying to lost weight?

110 replies

toolatetoloseweight · 16/05/2022 20:06

I am currently in the obese range and about 4 stone over my healthy weight. I basically put on loads of weight in my first pregnancy (6 years ago) and I've never managed to shift it.
I was previously a healthy weight but was a fat child and have always struggled a bit with putting on weight very easily.

I keep reading stats saying how unlikely it is for an obese woman to ever lose the weight and keep it off without bariatric surgery - and it is making me wonder if it is even worth trying at this stage...

For context, I am relatively active - walk the dog twice a day, swim twice a week, run around after kids, occasionally go for a run (3-5km so not massive distances but just to put in context that I'm not so big as to be struggling to get around). I dont have a terrible diet (though obviously could be better!). i know from experience that small changes don't make a difference to me- I need to eat under 1200 calories to lose. I am terribly unhappy with the way I look and dread going out and being see by people. However not sure if it is all just a losing battle at this stage...

OP posts:
CalmerCalmerChameleon · 17/05/2022 09:06

Try doing the 16:8 thing a few days a week or mon to fri if you can. It’s easier than you think. Just don’t eat after 8pm (or 7) and have have lunch about 12.30 or 1pm. Eat only in that 8 hour window. It really helps. (I loose weight when I do this and I don’t count the calories just be sensible).

Also fill up on things like raw carrots as snacks.

SleeplessInEngland · 17/05/2022 09:06

Go for more runs, at least 2-3 a week. They won't make you lose weight but in my experience a good exercise routine makes you want to eat better food, so it's a psychological lift.

Knittingchamp · 17/05/2022 09:05

OP if you just want to give up and not try, nothing will ever change. If you're good with that, then fine.

If you're not, you need to try really hard. Sort out your diet, eat a lot less, exercise every single day. It'd very hard OP, if it was easy we'd all be a size 10 and eat donuts for breakfast. But if you want the change you need to put in that work.

The good news is that you could buck the stats for sure. You can do it.

Sofasogood1 · 17/05/2022 09:01

'All you need is a calorie deficit to loose weight'.

Recent evidence suggests this isn't always true. All calories are not created equally. If you eat 500 calories of processed chicken nuggets and processed potato smiley faces your body will burn energy quite differently to 500 calories of baked chicken breast, booked potatoes and veg.

I recommend a bit of reading around ultra processed food.
Good luck op.

Feckingfeck · 17/05/2022 09:01

GillyGumbo · 16/05/2022 20:16

Huh, preach. I've been frantically trying to get prepared for an upcoming wedding and suddenly realised I can neither a) lose 4 stone in 3 weeks nor b) polish a turd.

I am fat, I'm going to wear a nice dress, put on some slap and enjoy a lovely wedding as MYSELF. Am owning my fat.

Cant polish a turd but can definitely cover one in glitter ... own it! 🤩🤩🤩

Worldgonecrazy · 17/05/2022 08:59

Yes I get my cholesterol tested annually. My numbers are fine, particularly LDL and VLDL which are both in the extremely healthy range.

ItsMutinyontheBunty · 17/05/2022 08:58

As pp suggests, check out Rebelfit. I joined up in 2019. Followed the social media and I’ve done several missions now. I was a yo-yo dieter and got to be obese. Now it’s no quick fix (but those are the ones where you lose the weight and gain it back) but I’ve changed my outlook on food and my body. I stopped dieting. My weight increased a bit then stabilised. I increased my activity, started weight lifting and reduced my stress…suddenly people are commenting that I look trimmer. I don’t weigh myself often any more - that was a hard habit to break! - because I know that there’s other more important factors like body fat %, how my clothes fit, how I look in the mirror. Weight is not always helpful especially when you’re gaining muscle. Actually, Rebelfit is the only thing I’ve stuck to for over 2 years thinking back.

check out the post from last night which talks about what you’re worried about and the best approach. I can’t link it but it’s on Facebook.

Menora · 17/05/2022 08:52

We don’t need to step away from calorie awareness, because losing weight is about energy in vs energy out. You only lose weight when you are in a calorie deficit. If you have no idea what a portion size really is, how can you know you are eating a reasonable amount? Unintentional over eating can be the cause of difficulty losing weight, people see chicken as a lean meat but too much of it could mean you have eaten way more calories than you needed to. it’s very calorie dense

The issue is people having calorie deficits way too low. It’s WW and SW that use low calorie foods with sweeteners in them without even teaching people about calories in real terms.

I hope everyone eating cheese eggs and meat for all their meals with 20cals of veg gets their cholesterol tested

JazzHandsYeah · 17/05/2022 08:29

My sister in law has lost just under 5 stone (over 4 years) with Slimming World. She has been obese all her life, but said she never felt hungry and has more energy now than ever.
You can do this, and it is worth it. For your physical health, mental well being and for your future.

Worldgonecrazy · 17/05/2022 08:17

Low glycaemic is probably easier than low carb, though if you like eggs and meat, low carb is easy and sustainable long term. It doesn’t feel restricted in any way. I have actually lost the taste for things like pizza and chips, never thought that would happen, but I no longer want to eat them when there are so many tastier and healthier options out there.

We really need to step away from counting calories- that really is restricted and encourages the use of artificial additives which do our gut health no good.

I suggest spending a couple of hours going down the rabbit hole if fasting and keto on YouTube. It will blow your mind and change your way of thinking about food.

Merryclaire · 17/05/2022 08:14

I’ve been overweight all my adult life and am classed as obese, even though I don’t think I look it! (In denial, clearly!) I’ve tried weight watchers, fasting, Atkins, Dukan and general calorie restriction. But the only thing that has made any lasting difference for me was making permanent, sustainable changes. I stopped introducing or restricting anything I couldn’t stick to. Over the course of 2021 I managed to lose 20 pounds. It was slow (painfully slow at times), but steady, and by the end of it I realised I felt better than a year ago and could happily continue long term.
However, then I fell pregnant at Christmas! So I’m now gaining weight again. But I know afterwards I will continue with my ‘lifelong’ plan - tweaking and refining it along the way.
Some of the changes I made were: running 30 mins twice a week (sadly I’ve had to stop that in pregnancy due to a bleeding scare), walking a fair amount (though I would like to increase that once the baby is here), eating a small fruit plate every afternoon, eating two vegan/veggie evening meals a week, an oily fish dish once a week (was all meat before), having two veggie-heavy stir fries with just a little meat and brown noodles or rice, only eating my own homemade sourdough bread, cutting down to just one sweet treat per day (arguably that could be reduced still!), switching to mostly whole grains. We made Friday treat tea night, when we have something like fish and chips, pizza or pie, so always look forward to that.
There is still more I could do to refine and improve my diet and lifestyle, but taking it slowly and making changes gradually has been the only lasting success I’ve ever achieved. If I hadn’t fallen pregnant, I would likely be another 7-8 pounds lighter by now too. But I’m relaxed about that!
Eating 1200 calories a day doesn’t sound very much if you’re active. I wonder if you’re not eating enough good food and slowing your metabolism by being too restrictive. Or going through that old cycle of working at it really hard for a while, then ultimately failing to stick to it and overeating again. All I know is that dieting rarely works as you can’t keep it up.
Yes, it’s slow and boring and won’t get you quick results, but making sustainable diet and lifestyle changes will work in the long run.

Menora · 17/05/2022 08:10

Dinoteeth · 17/05/2022 07:37

Reading this thread, I know WW and SW are both criticised for the number of people who yoyo diet on them. But are they maybe the best way to go?

I lost about a stone following SW years ago, but weight has slowly crept back on. I found the classes very patronising hence followed the diet without classes.

I'm currently about 3st too heavy.

They really promote bad thinking about food groups. The word syns is the clue. They are not good food psychology

Menora · 17/05/2022 08:09

ObjectionHearsay · 17/05/2022 07:59

Thank you, I fear I'll get drowned out by people promoting skipping meals, cutting carbs and listening to a hypnotic pod cast. When really it's simple.

All you need is a calorie deficit to loose weight, and if you manage the calorie deficit slowly and gradually giving yourself time to adjust and learn it will work and it will last.

But everyone always wants to loose 14stone in a day, rather than the realisation that you didn't get overweight in 12 weeks, so why do you expect to loose it all in 12 weeks.

Weight loss should be gradually done, and over a long period of time. Your body needs time and your mind to adjust to a calorie deficit. Stop pressuring your body to loose 2lb a week and aim for maybe 3- 4lb a month.

Relax it will happen.

Hallelujah!

PurpleDaisies · 17/05/2022 08:05

I would have a week where you record and measure everything you’re eating. It’s really easy for portion sizes to inflate over time. It absolutely is worth addressing your weight. There are so many risks to being obese.

ObjectionHearsay · 17/05/2022 07:59

SMUnz · 17/05/2022 03:40

@ObjectionHearsay is speaking a lot of sense!

Thank you, I fear I'll get drowned out by people promoting skipping meals, cutting carbs and listening to a hypnotic pod cast. When really it's simple.

All you need is a calorie deficit to loose weight, and if you manage the calorie deficit slowly and gradually giving yourself time to adjust and learn it will work and it will last.

But everyone always wants to loose 14stone in a day, rather than the realisation that you didn't get overweight in 12 weeks, so why do you expect to loose it all in 12 weeks.

Weight loss should be gradually done, and over a long period of time. Your body needs time and your mind to adjust to a calorie deficit. Stop pressuring your body to loose 2lb a week and aim for maybe 3- 4lb a month.

Relax it will happen.

CandyApplePie · 17/05/2022 07:55

I seen that comment and I’m also dieting I have lost 3 stone so far but still more to go but that comment really knocked me as well.

cherrybonbons · 17/05/2022 07:49

@SausagePourHomme
It is true. It's not sustainable and quite frankly, not a nice way to live. 1200 is extremely restrictive.

AllyCatTown · 17/05/2022 07:43

It’s not realistic to cut out carbs etc. Only do that if you’re prepared to never eat them again. Otherwise you’ll just gain the weight when you go back to them. I cut out fizzy drinks and I won’t go back to them as it’s been over a decade.
It doesn’t need to be complicated. From living in countries with high obesity to low I think the main difference is portion size. You can still enjoy food. Best of luck.

Dinoteeth · 17/05/2022 07:38

I should add I struggle with low carbing and fasting.

Dinoteeth · 17/05/2022 07:37

Reading this thread, I know WW and SW are both criticised for the number of people who yoyo diet on them. But are they maybe the best way to go?

I lost about a stone following SW years ago, but weight has slowly crept back on. I found the classes very patronising hence followed the diet without classes.

I'm currently about 3st too heavy.

Menora · 17/05/2022 07:29

This is what 100 calories looks like. Look how small the cheese is. Meat is the same it’s dense. It’s so calorie dense it doesn’t have any volume and people will be hungry all the time this is why it’s hard to stick to.

https://www.bhf.org.uk/informationsupport/heart-matters-magazine/nutrition/weight/what-does-100-calories-look-like

Menora · 17/05/2022 07:10

KellynchHall · 17/05/2022 01:54

Another who would recommend low carb. It sounds impossible at the start but it soon just becomes normal. I usually skip breakfast then have salad for lunch which will be lots of leaves with chicken or cheese and usually coleslaw. Dinner is meat or cheese with veg or salad. So halloumi with roast veg for example. Carbs still comes out at less than 50g.

I know it gets a lot of hate because you are excluding a food group but we didn't evolve to eat carbs like we do. Carbs trigger insulin and if you are secreting insulin you are storing fat. Get blood sugar low enough for long enough and you switch to burning fat. But it is forever in so far as if I stop and start eating pasta, rice, bread etc all the time the weight will go back on. I feel better on the diet as I don't suffer cravings like I usually do. I actually eat more varieties of veg and greater quantity on this diet than I ever would on my usual carb heavy diet.

I am sorry but this is rubbish. Humans invented bread 10,000 or more years ago. Fruit and veg are carbs. We didn’t evolve to eat meat and cheese.
if you want to do a low carb diet as you like it then that’s fine but this is not even true. It’s not just avoiding the pasta and bread that is making you lose weight it is that you are eating less than 1000 calories a day and it’s the low calories that are making you lose weight. I take it you are not diabetic so why are you monitoring your insulin. Insulin sends glucose to your muscles, fat and liver, what makes fat on your body is consuming more calories than you burn. not eating carbs. Look up the law of thermodynamics.

I did do low carb once it was brutal and I injured myself working out. I have lost more weight eating a balanced diet with whole grains carbs than I ever did on the low carb diet, which I couldn’t stick to and was stupidly restrictive

LimeSegment · 17/05/2022 05:14

If you don't want to lose weight, that's fine of course.

If you do though, don't let perfect be the enemy of good. You don't have to become a size 8 and Olympic athlete and maintain that forever, or it's all pointless. What's wrong with losing a bit, maybe you are still overweight but not obese. And so what if you put some back on in a few years? Better than not losing weight now, and still putting on more in a few years.

Weatherwax13 · 17/05/2022 04:32

I also read an article on bariatric surgery recently OP. And I was really surprised by the percentage of people who gradually increase their food intake till the surgery fails and they're piling on weight. I thought it was a bullet proof procedure. Very eye opening.
So maybe cut that possibility right out of the equation. It could free your mind up to consider all the approaches PP describe above.
I don't believe any of them are correct that their way is 100% the best.
But there are a heap of ideas on this thread now.
Maybe there's one that strikes a chord. In which case do that!

SMUnz · 17/05/2022 03:40

@ObjectionHearsay is speaking a lot of sense!