Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Is it even worth trying to lost weight?

110 replies

toolatetoloseweight · 16/05/2022 20:06

I am currently in the obese range and about 4 stone over my healthy weight. I basically put on loads of weight in my first pregnancy (6 years ago) and I've never managed to shift it.
I was previously a healthy weight but was a fat child and have always struggled a bit with putting on weight very easily.

I keep reading stats saying how unlikely it is for an obese woman to ever lose the weight and keep it off without bariatric surgery - and it is making me wonder if it is even worth trying at this stage...

For context, I am relatively active - walk the dog twice a day, swim twice a week, run around after kids, occasionally go for a run (3-5km so not massive distances but just to put in context that I'm not so big as to be struggling to get around). I dont have a terrible diet (though obviously could be better!). i know from experience that small changes don't make a difference to me- I need to eat under 1200 calories to lose. I am terribly unhappy with the way I look and dread going out and being see by people. However not sure if it is all just a losing battle at this stage...

OP posts:
newnamenellie · 17/05/2022 11:04

Of course it's worth trying to lose weight, but you have to want to! There is no easy route and you need to be strong and focus on the benefits of being slimmer and feeling better/healthier. After a while, the motivation comes from losing weight and should spur you on. Getting started is probably the hardest part.

I think for many it's a case of deciding on what's more important - eating whatever yo want in any quantity you like or getting down to a healthy weight with all of the associated mental and physical health benefits? Once the decision is made, you're on your way, but you have to put the effort in.

Being aware of calories is important as then you can decide what to eat and recognise how calories can add up quickly when you've no idea about them!

I'm currently losing weight on the Fast diet. I find it works for me and have used it before. About a month ago, I had a bit of a moment where I realised that the only way to get rid of my stomach was to diet (exercise alone wasn't working). I don't usually weigh myself, but when I did at the start of this regime, I was shocked to find myself the heaviest I've ever been at 12 st 5 lbs. Ideal weight for me would be around between 11 and 11.5 stone (I'm 5'9"). Anyway, after four weeks of fast diet and mindful eating, I've lost 10lbs and currently at 11st 9lbs on this morning's weigh in! This is what motivates me.

Sofasogood1 · 17/05/2022 11:03

toolatetoloseweight · 17/05/2022 10:54

I really appreciate all the comments and they certainly go to show that there are different ways to do it. I don't think any of the approaches suggested are wrong as they work for different people.

I would say though that the number of calories needed by people does vary massively. When I am not actively trying to lose weight, it is still unusual for me to eat more than 2000 cals per day. When I say I can only lose on 1200, I really have tried all sorts of variations and I do track carefully. I don't know if it's genetics or that our metabolism just gets fucked up from weight yo yoing - but honestly some of us just can't eat a normal diet and take moderate amount of activity and get to a healthy weight. By normal I mean a regular balanced 1800- 2000 calories, of mostly unprocessed, healthy foods, your 5 a day etc, and a few treats or a dessert thrown in every now and and again. By normal activity I mean approx 10,000 steps per day plus a couple of other bits like a swim or a run or a gym session a couple of times a week. I wish I could do that, but if I did I would just get even bigger.

For me, I am not keen on keto or super low carb because I know it isn't sustainable for me. However, I have had some success in the past with lowish carbs and 1000-1200 calories. But it is rubbish. I agree with a pp who mentioned about doing strength training - I did used to do this in the past when I was a better weight but I had a gym buddy and we could spot each other on weights. I need to see if I can find something that I can do alone.

I believe you op. Do have a look at the Andrew Jenkinson book. He talks about patients who come to him eating far fewer calories than others who weigh much less than them but are struggling to lose weight.

LindaEllen · 17/05/2022 10:58

misskatamari · 16/05/2022 20:55

I honestly believe now that diets don't work. They're not sustainable.

I'm reading Anti-diet by Christy Harrison at the moment and it's eye opening. I also really recommend the "out of the cave" podcast by Lisa Schlosberg, which is all about the mind/body connection and our relationship with food.

I have spent my life feeling shit about myself because I'm not thin enough, and I'm sick of it. Dieting and restriction just leads to bingeing in my experience. Which leads to shame and self hatred. I'm done.

I'm focusing on healing my relationship with my body and my relationship with food. Exercising to get strong, eating to nourish my body. Being kind to myself instead of punishing myself. If I get thinner then great, if not, I'm really working on not feeling like my worth is defined by my weight and size.

Diets DO work. The problem is that when people reach their goal weight, they stop the diet and go right back to how they used to eat.

The best diet is the calorie counting one. When I lost 12st over the course of 2 years, I used MyFitnessPal to calorie count (and went out for lots of long walks) and started with it set to lose 2lbs a week, then when I'd lost 3 stone set it to 1.5lbs a week etc etc until I had it set to 0.5lbs a week. I left it there, but eventually didn't even need the app, as you start to learn what healthy portion sizes actually are.

I managed to keep it off for almost a decade, until lockdown happened and I pretty much had a mental breakdown and started comfort eating again. But they were such unusual times I can't hate myself for it. I am back on MyFitnessPal now and the weight is gradually coming off again!

PurpleDaisies · 17/05/2022 10:56

When I am not actively trying to lose weight, it is still unusual for me to eat more than 2000 cals per day. When I say I can only lose on 1200, I really have tried all sorts of variations and I do track carefully. I don't know if it's genetics or that our metabolism just gets fucked up from weight yo yoing - but honestly some of us just can't eat a normal diet and take moderate amount of activity and get to a healthy weight. By normal I mean a regular balanced 1800- 2000 calories, of mostly unprocessed, healthy foods, your 5 a day etc, and a few treats or a dessert thrown in every now and and again. By normal activity I mean approx 10,000 steps per day plus a couple of other bits like a swim or a run or a gym session a couple of times a week. I wish I could do that, but if I did I would just get even bigger.

Are you very short or do you have thyroid issues? What you’re describing doesn’t sound right.

toolatetoloseweight · 17/05/2022 10:54

I really appreciate all the comments and they certainly go to show that there are different ways to do it. I don't think any of the approaches suggested are wrong as they work for different people.

I would say though that the number of calories needed by people does vary massively. When I am not actively trying to lose weight, it is still unusual for me to eat more than 2000 cals per day. When I say I can only lose on 1200, I really have tried all sorts of variations and I do track carefully. I don't know if it's genetics or that our metabolism just gets fucked up from weight yo yoing - but honestly some of us just can't eat a normal diet and take moderate amount of activity and get to a healthy weight. By normal I mean a regular balanced 1800- 2000 calories, of mostly unprocessed, healthy foods, your 5 a day etc, and a few treats or a dessert thrown in every now and and again. By normal activity I mean approx 10,000 steps per day plus a couple of other bits like a swim or a run or a gym session a couple of times a week. I wish I could do that, but if I did I would just get even bigger.

For me, I am not keen on keto or super low carb because I know it isn't sustainable for me. However, I have had some success in the past with lowish carbs and 1000-1200 calories. But it is rubbish. I agree with a pp who mentioned about doing strength training - I did used to do this in the past when I was a better weight but I had a gym buddy and we could spot each other on weights. I need to see if I can find something that I can do alone.

OP posts:
FrownedUpon · 17/05/2022 10:39

Low carb has worked brilliantly for me. Have maintained current healthy weight for 4 years now. I’ll occasionally have pasta, bread etc. if I want it. People can dismiss it, but it has been a revelation for me.

puppetcat · 17/05/2022 10:39

hi Op, ignore PP saying fasting is unsustainable. It's one of the most sustainable, easy (and natural) ways to maintain weight loss. 1 - 2 days a week restricted eating (e.g. OMAD) as a habit forever is enough for most people to maintain any weight loss and it keeps you mindful about your calories forever without needing to restrict 100% of the time (so some treats or wild days are allowed!). And it is easy once you get used to it. And it is very very good for you, and completely natural and what humans have done for hundreds of thousands of years. Man was not made to eat all the time and has always historically had periods of sustained no-eating.

Regarding loose skin, fasting also gets rid of this if you do it right. Google "autophagy, fasting and loose skin" to find out more. Once you've fasted a bit your body enters a mode whereby it is able to use up excess skin, get rid of bad cells etc, clear up infections. You need to enter a certain period of fasting for it to occur, which is why a couple of days a month are recommended. But even if you're doing OMAD, some autophagy occurs. It is one of the healthiest thing all humans can do (even if obese or not). The fasting subreddit has a lot of info on it. And if you enter an extended fast your body is also able to produce growth hormones and new stem cells, so it is life extending and anti ageing! (This happens at like 3 - 4 days, so should be done with care).

And also to mention - muscles do not waste away when you're fasting. Again check out Jason Fung on this. It's a common myth. Although doing some mild strength and resistance traning while fasting is recommended.

Menora · 17/05/2022 10:32

Low carb is cutting or restricting a food group and an energy source. No one is going to advise putting pastry or cake as a food group these are processed sugary carbs. Pulses, beans and grains are a food group. You can eat sensible amounts of brown bread or Wholegrain pasta/rice, with health benefits and they are not empty useless carbs. Food is fuel. Where are you guys getting any fibre from. Can you actually go to the toilet. I’m concerned for all of your bowels ya know. Yeah; low carb gave me migraines too. Might be a sign

the weight fell off you becasue you were not eating sugary processed foods and exercising a lot. Well done, but you can do that eating carbs. FYI

ChristinePerfect · 17/05/2022 10:29

I tried and failed at calorie counting/ MFP because I found it too restrictive, I would feel hungry and after a few days would sabotage it because I felt so miserable. I couldn't see how I could possibly lose weight if I couldn't even stick to it for a week!

Last ditch attempt, I was obese most of my adult life, I joined SW.
I know it's not for everyone, but for me it worked. I don't eat much processed food now, although I do still snack, and I never feel hungry.
My BMI is 23 and people are telling me I've lost enough.
I still can't believe I'm a healthy weight, I keep expecting to wake up big again.
Friends of mine have tried SW and didn't like it, they do calorie counting instead, they said SW is too restrictive, which is the exact opposite for me, so I really think it's a case of finding out what works for you as an individual.

cherrytree63 · 17/05/2022 10:09

I unsuccessfully tried MFP and calorie counting. MFP had too many variables ie 2 x beans on buttered toast had different calories to toast + butter + beans × 2. Maybe its different these days.
I was brought up the old fashioned way, you can't have a pudding unless you finish your dinner. I carried this into adulthood, if I wanted a chocolate bar I made myself eat something savoury first, even if it was a bag of crisps!
I worked long shifts on a ward, and got into the habit of eating when I wasn't hungry, whenever I had a spare 5 minutes, stuffing myself at lunch time and having a big meal when I got home.
I then got whooping cough, followed by non stop respiratory infections, I was off work for 6 months and ate non stop through boredom. I was due a double mastectomy but I was too ill for the anaesthetic.
I stepped on the scale and was horrified to see that I was 14 stone. That was my turning point. I wanted to be fit to recover from my surgery.
I followed loosely the low carb bootcamp on here. Stopped eating bread, biscuits, cakes, chocolate, pasta, pastry.
I found it really easy as I was never hungry.
The weight literally fell off me, I started walking every day and did HIIT routines 3 x pw.
Six months later I hit the scales at 8.10, the lightest I've ever been.
I'm now at 9.7 simply because I'm unable to exercise as much as I used to because of some disabilities, but I still low carb and most days 16:8. The only time I crave rubbish is if I get a migraine.
Low carb is not cutting a food group out, just making better carb choices.

HelenHywater · 17/05/2022 09:48

I disagree with the PP, it is sustainable to exist on fewer calories.

I have found the Fast800 diet has worked really well for me, although I don't manage to eat 800 calories a day. But sticking to higher proportions of protein together with having a fasting window each day works. Then to maintain you do need to stick to a cal limit of (say 1500) cals a day. That enables you to have blow out days, or even blow out holidays. I find that it has become a way of life to me now I know about calories in/calories out. I just don't want empty calories anymore.

Ciko · 17/05/2022 09:47

If you look back to peoples diets and eating habits in the 60’s and early 70’s (when the majority of people weren’t overweight or obese) it’s very different to today.
In the past people had structured, smaller meals with very little snacking in between. It was mostly home cooked.
I remember Milky Ways usp in the 70’s was “The sweet you can eat between meals without ruining your appetite”. Fudge had a song in the advert that said “A finger of Fudge is just enough to give your kids a treat, a finger of Fudge is just enough until it’s time to eat”. They were pushing overeating.
Back then it was normal to be hungry and be told “You’ll ruin your appetite, wait until dinner” but now it’s almost like there’s guilt if children say they are hungry so it’s snacks here, there and everywhere.

Food companies have been thinking up ways to get us to eat/spend more with great success. Supermarkets are strategically set up to tempt us and to make us buy more. Companies even make their food addictive so we “have” to have it. Couple that with an array of takeaway delivery companies and quick and easy fast food places.

Rewritethestars1 · 17/05/2022 09:42

People will come on here and say cut calories to 1200, cut out carbs keto, fast etc etc don't bother with any of this. It is unsustainable. You might lose a few pounds initially but you'll put it all back on. Losing and maintaining a healthy weight is a lifestyle. No diet in the land is going to become your forever lifestyle.
You need to walk more, get over 10k steps in a day, reduce your portions and feed not fill. Listen to your body. Don't eat just because its a meal time, eat because you are hungry whatever time that is and eat well. If you feel hungry eat a reasonable portion of protein and veg. Stop when your full don't finish the plate just because. The weight loss won't be quick but it will be sustainable.
It is absolutely worth doing no matter what your size and it is doable. I have lost the two stone I put on in pregnancy. Two of my friends have gone from size 20s to 12s. They and I have had to change our lifestyle. I no longer eat crisps as a 'treat' on a Saturday night for example. I don't need it, im not hungry its just a habit. Stop seeing food as a reward and treat.
I'm not saying its an overnight fix and easy to get into this mindset but its doable.
Your size dosnt define you of course but your health does and despite the exercise you do your health will be affected at 4 stone overweight. Also your confidence does define you too and its very very difficult to feel confident when you are larger. Its almost impossible change the mindset to loving yourself larger despite what others say. You are modelling a healthy relationship with food/body/exercise to your dc too and they deserve to see healthy choices and that eating well and exercise and staying a healthy weight is important.
You can do it op. Good luck.

LeeMucklowesCurtains · 17/05/2022 09:26

Now I just do intermittent fasting as I fell so good on it, eating no processed food (but like I said, being coeliac is a blessing in that department as I don’t like any of it, processed gluten free food is the work of the devil!!).

PurpleDaisies · 17/05/2022 09:26

The trouble with a lot of diets is when you reach the end point, there’s not a lot of advice on how to maintain that weight loss. That’s why I think doing something you can envisage a less strict version of being a long term way to eat is usually a good option.

1dayatatime · 17/05/2022 09:24

I genuinely do get what you are saying and some days when I've been really careful with what I ate, to then discover that I haven't lost any weight does get me down. Plus working at a desk either in the office or WFH doesn't help with this.

BUT what does keep me going is the knowledge that if I'm careful with what I eat then at least I won't put on any more weight.

Menora · 17/05/2022 09:24

Siameasy · 17/05/2022 09:19

I don’t know your age but I’m in a FB group “intermittent fasting for women over 40” and there have been some big losses.
IF is a lifestyle though and most women tend to go for lower carb options during their eating window and avoid “fake food”.

I got into it by reading Taubes’ “Why we get fat” and Dr Jason Fung’s books. I don’t believe calories in/out is the full story. We are biology, not physics. Fung and Taubes explain how weight gain is all about hormones, particularly insulin. Have a read about how insulin is the fat storage hormone.

Are you saying that biology and physics are 2 unconnected types of science and only 1 of them relates to the human body? Are you saying there is no physics or chemistry in the function of a human, just biology? Just to be clear.

LeeMucklowesCurtains · 17/05/2022 09:23

the reason (and the only reason) people put the weight back on is because they start overeating again. Ask me how I know!

Yup.

Diets don’t fail - people do. I get fed up of people saying “diets don’t work”. All diets work. They limit the calories you take in. But people don’t want to do that, they want to eat whatever they like, due to SO MANY issues.

I was very fat until I was 22 becuase I ate my way through a bad childhood and bullying. Then one day, I had enough and lost ten stone in just over a year by not eating my body weight in crap all day.

I kept it off until I was 36, 6 years ago when my life fell apart and I ate to get through it again. I gained that 10 stone back in 2 years.

A year ago, I had enough again. I’ve lost 5 stone now, 5 more to go. I have to limit the calories I eat as I would rather not eat much than exercise. I just make sure what I do eat is nutrient dense.

The amount of people who knew me when I lost weight at 22, who said “I told you that diet would fail!” Even though I had been a stable weight for 14 years inbetween is insane.

The diet didn’t fail. I hadn’t been on a diet - I just ate normal, small portions of healthy food and didn’t eat sugar or carbs (being coeliac helps as I can’t stand gluten free carbs or sweet food).

I just started eating all day everyday again and so I got fat again (even ate all the gluten free bread and cake that I usually hate, I just ate and ate to try and help my misery).

PurpleDaisies · 17/05/2022 09:22

stimpyyouidiot · 17/05/2022 09:13

This thread is why I struggle. So many different suggestions, which one do you do?

Pick what you think would work best with the way you want to eat. Fasting doesn’t suit me. As a veggie, low carb is really hard. I enjoy cooking so I just measure carbs so the portions don’t get out of hand and base meals mainly around veg.

There isn’t only one way to lose weight. Whatever you choose has to be realistic and sustainable over a decent amount of time.

Menora · 17/05/2022 09:21

stimpyyouidiot · 17/05/2022 09:13

This thread is why I struggle. So many different suggestions, which one do you do?

None of the ones that sound ridiculous, restrictive or unrealistic

you work out your TDEE, start to move around more, and then learn about what calories actually look like in terms of food portion sizes. You eat less (but not none at all) processed foods and more whole foods. You address your issues around food and your body image. You set realistic goals for yourself. Ultimately you need to balance enjoying your life and whatever your goal is of being healthier/losing weight/gaining mobility back. You could get advice from a qualified professional

Siameasy · 17/05/2022 09:19

I don’t know your age but I’m in a FB group “intermittent fasting for women over 40” and there have been some big losses.
IF is a lifestyle though and most women tend to go for lower carb options during their eating window and avoid “fake food”.

I got into it by reading Taubes’ “Why we get fat” and Dr Jason Fung’s books. I don’t believe calories in/out is the full story. We are biology, not physics. Fung and Taubes explain how weight gain is all about hormones, particularly insulin. Have a read about how insulin is the fat storage hormone.

stimpyyouidiot · 17/05/2022 09:13

This thread is why I struggle. So many different suggestions, which one do you do?

Googlecanthelpme · 17/05/2022 09:12

OP if at over 4-6 stone overweight you are not able to lose on a diet of about 1800 cals a day then I would suggest there is another issue at play.

it could be hormonal, or could be that your metabolism is shot. Or it could be that you are not sticking to it as long as your body needs - you’d think after dropping your cals for a week you’d see a change on the scales right? And most people will but some people won’t. Some people have other factors which make the calories in / calories out not as simple as you’d like.

I obviously don’t know your body as well as you do but based on general nutrition and science which applies to the majority of people - you can drop your average calories by just a few hundred a day and you will see a difference if you stay consistent.

Staying at a low calorie such as 1200 for more than about 12 weeks will cause metabolic issues - meaning you then need to reverse diet to get your body used to burning more than the measly amount it’s been getting.

it is all totally personal of course but I would be willing to bet you not a small amount of money that you are wildly eating over your required calorie amount - let’s say for arguments sake you are fairly active and quite big at this stage so you might need 2000 cals to maintain. I would suggest you’re probably eating 2700/3000 a day.
cut that to 1900, stick to it for 2 weeks. You will lose weight.

All of this is highly personal of course but the key thing is consistency and being honest and accountable. If you’re not loosing weight at 1500/1800 cals when you’ve got 6 stone to lose - you’re not being honest sorry

Menora · 17/05/2022 09:11

Sofasogood1 · 17/05/2022 09:01

'All you need is a calorie deficit to loose weight'.

Recent evidence suggests this isn't always true. All calories are not created equally. If you eat 500 calories of processed chicken nuggets and processed potato smiley faces your body will burn energy quite differently to 500 calories of baked chicken breast, booked potatoes and veg.

I recommend a bit of reading around ultra processed food.
Good luck op.

The point about eating whole foods and avoiding processed foods was already made. Obviously eating highly processed foods is not advisable if you want to lose weight or be healthy - I am saying you do not need to cut our entire food groups to lose weight, you need to create a sustainable, balanced diet to lose weight in a calorie deficit.

You would actually still lose weight if you ate only chicken nuggets within a calorie deficit. You would just feel like shit. It’s scientifically still a calorie deficit. You would still lose weight, right? Or are you saying that thermodynamics don’t count 🤣

and my point about cholesterol - exactly, you are advising people online to do the Atkins diet (just renamed something else) without knowing anything about their health or whether it’s safe for them to do so, if they have a history of heart disease or already have high cholesterol or that it’s even something that needs to be mentored if you eat a high fat diet!

ObjectionHearsay · 17/05/2022 09:08

Sofasogood1 · 17/05/2022 09:01

'All you need is a calorie deficit to loose weight'.

Recent evidence suggests this isn't always true. All calories are not created equally. If you eat 500 calories of processed chicken nuggets and processed potato smiley faces your body will burn energy quite differently to 500 calories of baked chicken breast, booked potatoes and veg.

I recommend a bit of reading around ultra processed food.
Good luck op.

The general Joe Public trying to loose weight need not worry about macro's to begin with.

They need to learn to reduce overall intake and make healthier choices. Nobody wanting to loose weight thinks I know I'll smash out a MC chicken nugget meal at 800 calories twice a day.

But that they need to learn is what is a visual of 150kcal of rice (white or brown) how many calories are in one slice of bread so I don't have 2 slices of toast for breakfast and then a sandwich for lunch. And use up 400kcal on 4 pieces of bread.

Macro tracking and using energy in and energy out for beginners is overcomplicating the process for them.

Eat less move more. Start there. If you then want to go on to shred and macro nutrients then perhaps further down the line.

But we are talking about people wanting to loose 3 or 4 stone or more, and stick with it. Make it simple, make it enjoyable and make it realistic.