Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask how you think social issue arise?

136 replies

BloomsburyNook · 16/05/2022 19:07

I'm nearly 50, so have seen a few decades. When I was young, if you visited a small handful of rough or run down places, you might see a few drunks or 'miscreants' or young lads messing around, but never anything really threatening or visible.
So it might just be me, and I've led a fairly quiet life, but there seem to be a hell of a lot more issues out there now, especially in ex industrial places and urban towns around the UK. I see a lot more homeless people, many who have evident addiction issues: women as much as men, and there are more gangs of teens smashing stuff, shouting, fighting, etc.
However, in many areas you hear that crime rates have dropped over the years. Perhaps it depends where you go, and many people in bad areas won't report to the police anyway.

I often travel with work, and see this across the uk, much more dereliction and dying high streets, and in many towns there's literally rubbish piling up along embankments and street corners that the councils never clear up. And it's not simple enough to say it's because these are run down areas - they were run down decades ago but not like this.

I know there are many lovely places, and I've lived in a few of those, too, and some go downhill a bit, some remain safe. So if you don't get out a lot you might not know it's going on? I don't know. I asked a few older friends recently had they noticed and they did admit that there were elements of this knocking around in the 70's, 80's, etc, but not to this extent.

How did it become worse? What is your opinion? What could be done to help? Are people generally poorer than 20 yrs ago? This is presuming poverty as a causation - is it? The news headlines often affirm this, but I don't really know across the board. I know there are a lot of very closed off towns that might make these issues worse due to people rarely leaving them, but is the issue more cultural than economical?

I think people are generally angrier and less satisfied on the whole, we are all a lot more stressed out even if some of us report we are doing great and don't notice it! It just seems like a different world from when I was in my 20's. And of course, it is! Imma gettin old!

OP posts:
itsalwaysfriday13th · 16/05/2022 20:54

Wow @BloomsburyNook you really rarely leave your London Town house do you?!

I don't understand how you can't know?!

Thatcherism super charged materialism over community, multiple recessions effectively closing down industries and their respective towns. Then the benefit era where it was easier and more profitable to get pregnant to get a house than to work for it but when your family are more good with their hands then you probably are to so working up to buy a house would be impossible anyway...Benefit squeeze, austerity, broken Britain followed...to the point council's can't afford to remove people's crap and as its on the railway embankment its not their problem...drugs, cheap booze don't help either, exploitation via smart phones of young people and voilà...

BloomsburyNook · 16/05/2022 20:53

Thanks for contributing everyone, I already had my own opinions and thoughts but this has been an education for me.

I agree that northern working class towns never used to come over as bigoted. I think the right wing press have a lot to answer for, stoking the fire of discontent - and they know their audience, and they know their fears.

I also can't see it getting better, I'm sorry to say.

OP posts:
Minimalme · 16/05/2022 20:50

Sorry, just meant to clarity that is in our area - don't know about anywhere else.

Minimalme · 16/05/2022 20:45

I live in an area like this. The general demographic is "skinny man on the brink of death".

The reasons for the increase is that family homes have been broken into bedsits by landlords and rented out via the Council.

Generally it's men who are alcoholics/drug users, who's relationship has broken down and they've been kicked out of the family home.

It is a very weird area to bring kids up in - I always lock the front and back door when we are home but I don't feel unsafe.

Most of these men are too pissed/high/emaciated to harm anyone but themselves. It's very sad.

fallfallfall · 16/05/2022 20:41

@shrunkenhead my dh and i moved to a remote industrial town in the early 80's for work. there was an aluminium smelter, a pulp mill, a dock, and a chemical plant. jobs for everyone. the town had regular "gifts" from the companies; pools, arenas, water fountains etc. people earned well the businesses were profitable and the government covered the bare basics but the companies topped up the hospital the schools almost everything (because of the potential for industrial accidents the town of 10,000 needed higher level of trauma trained staff and equipment for example, because the industries wanted people to stay they paid housing for teachers etc.).
we didn't have a male shelter all homeless men were sent or offered transport elsewhere, we did have a woman's shelter though.
but you can see the problem; first the chemical plant moved, then the mill closed and the dock had little work if any. only the big smelter remains.

homes dropped in value, so did moral, everything started to look dilapidated. alcohol and drug use increased and young people had less and less opportunities.
and when i say remote i mean remote.

ArseInTheCoOpWindow · 16/05/2022 20:38

Tgatcher dismantled the heavy industries that employed the working class. She was determined to turn the U.K.( particularly the north) into a low pay, low skill service economy. That’s where it started.

Ans she famously said ‘There's no such thing as society’

ButtockUp · 16/05/2022 20:34

I'm a 60s child.
Lived in a few places due to my dad's job.

I remember many council estates that were neat and tidy and one estate, in particular, that was so lovely. Front gardens kept , flowers, hedges clipped.
Many council ( or rather ex council as they're mostly HA properties) look very run down, front gardens looking derelict, rubbish left out.
There's no pride in one's home , it seems.
I don't know why but it's like 'well it's not my house so why should I look after it.'

Even private rentals near where I live, the tenants can't be bothered, and expect 'someone else' to mow the front lawns or take care of the gardens.
Not being able to afford a home doesn't mean that you can treat the property badly.

That being said, the housing market is ruthlessly different now with people needing vast deposits just to rent a room and then being outbid by someone with even more money.

A pp mentioned life under Thatcher, well I can well remember how awful it was under Callaghan ... no rubbish collections, bodies not buried or cremated, 3 day week, blackouts , endless strikes.

What is so frighteningly different now is food bank usage and how it's grown exponentially.

Why that issue alone isn't being addressed, I don't know.
But to have MPs and ministers saying shite like being able to create 30p meals or get a better job, work more hours whilst claiming over £200k a year in expenses makes my blood boil.

ArseInTheCoOpWindow · 16/05/2022 20:33

Yeah, I’m a working class northerner. Don’t remember much flag flying either.

Apart from the National Front. Working class were solidly Labour and not that patriotic. Patriotism was for the well off.

AmIinthewronghere · 16/05/2022 20:32

Wages are shit for many people. So many jobs don't pay enough to live on anymore, at least not without government top up. That surely has an impact?

I can't see things getting better frankly. A lot of us will have even less money, so less to spend on nice things like getting hair done or going out for a meal.

How will small local businesses manage to survive if a huge per centage of people have no disposable income?

It's a bit scary.

ghostyslovesheets · 16/05/2022 20:28

Thehonestybox · 16/05/2022 20:14

In poorer communities, the only thing people could be proud of was their cultural identity, and working class northerners have had years of people telling them things like they're racist bigots for flying the St George's Cross. Meanwhile factories and industry have closed, so you no longer have estates where everyone works in the same place. They've lost their identity. And without that, you've nothing to be proud of, and therefore you don't take any interest in helping to keep the community and streets happy and nice looking.

There are also lots more rich people visible, and wealth resentment is a real thing that makes people angry and bitter with their lot. Middle class kids used to go to grammar schools. Now everyone's mixed, the poorer kids look at the middle class kids and grow up thinking "how is that fair that they're going skiing and I'm going to Skegness, when their parents don't work anymore hours than mine do?". It builds up generations of resentment, apathy and overwhelming "why even try?" feeling.

No idea what the solution would be. Bring back industry I guess. Make a minimum wage living be enough for a family of four to live off.

Northern working class town dweller here from 1970 - no one I saw flew a flag - people worked in steel and car production or had skilled trades - pride came from community and still does on the whole - and no grammar schools either - all comprehensive
Crime and anti social behaviour existed as it does today
I do have an issue with is all being a working class 'problem' it's a state issue - if you don;t invest in jobs, regeneration, education and have ambition for people why DO you expect them to care - the class system needs the poor and disenfranchised otherwise you can't exploit them in low waged jobs and blame them for all your fuck ups

BogRollBOGOF · 16/05/2022 20:26

Fewer basic jobs that can be done by people with poor education (inc unidentified/ supported SENs), probably harder to be empoloyed with a criminal record too. Lack of educational aspiration where education is the biggest stepping stone to change. Education didn't matter so much 40+ years ago. Education is less practical and supposedly more "academic", this lets so many young people down where the system clashes against individual needs.

Transport to jobs. Industrial areas were a mix of employment and accessible housing. Not attractive but it was practical. When the slums were cleared post-WW2, many people were moved out to peripheral estates which had fewer opportunities.

Breakdown of communities. Ghettoisation when people move on as soon as they can leaving those who are struggling behind. Familes being less local for support. Loss of community activities and venues, communal religion, pubs, social outlets like Miner's Welfare ( bands, sports clubs...) Life has become more commercial, formal and less affordable.

Stronger, cheaper, more accessible drugs. Alcohol liscening relaxed a few decades ago.

Lack of mental health support. More seriously ill people in the community rather than in specialist units.

Generational trauma. It's always been around, but in the 20th century two world wars caused significant damage to two generations of young men. It can take several generations to break the cycle. There are parents of children now affected by the parenting of their post-war parents. Back to education/ SENs, parents that were traumatised by the education system struggle to support their children.

BloomsburyNook · 16/05/2022 20:23

fallfallfall · 16/05/2022 20:17

the reason it's hard to address is that it's multifactorial. outsourcing of jobs to developing nations (lower salary) is part of the problem as is the loss of long term mental health institutions.

Probably the most bang on reason, I agree. I wish there were politicians who would talk about this instead of populist crap, and I am including Starmer!
Corbyn grabbed it by the horns but he simply wan't popular...in other ways.

OP posts:
BloomsburyNook · 16/05/2022 20:21

By 'making it hard to get off benefits' I am referring to a poster from a few weeks ago who is disabled on ESA. She is afraid to move out of her 'bad' area as she will be put on UC just for making the change. Her UC entitlement is less than her ESA. It's a minefield.

We are lucky to have these services, and god knows this lot would love to dissolve them, but they do render people helpless and immobile generally.

OP posts:
BloomsburyNook · 16/05/2022 20:18

shrunkenhead · 16/05/2022 20:14

Really interesting post, OP. I've been asking myself this for a while too. Also, and not to de-rail your thread, how do places become "run-down" in the first place? I hear so often around where I live (North ) from the older generation " it used to be a lovely area this....." where I live there is a lot of racism and it is often blamed on people coming from overseas but I honestly don't think it's that simple!

Yep, my DH was born in the north too, his old town is struggling now. He remembers it fondly and says there were a handful of rough folks you just avoided, and that was it.
I think, in the past, people had to move to chase work. Much like immigrants do, and always did. In the UK now people get stuck in one place and when the work goes, they have to rely on benefits. Whilst this is a good thing, the gov make it difficult for people to move around and get off benefits, and many landlords won't accept waiting for new cashflow after a house move.

OP posts:
fallfallfall · 16/05/2022 20:17

the reason it's hard to address is that it's multifactorial. outsourcing of jobs to developing nations (lower salary) is part of the problem as is the loss of long term mental health institutions.

BloomsburyNook · 16/05/2022 20:15

We found some of the nicer areas are cheaper (we rent and don't wish to buy at our age). Some of the more run down areas were more expensive to buy or rent due to good transport links and such. There were just pockets of unrest all over.

True that having a vehicle is key. I stopped driving for 10 years and feel forced to take it back up. Especially since Covid.

OP posts:
Thehonestybox · 16/05/2022 20:14

In poorer communities, the only thing people could be proud of was their cultural identity, and working class northerners have had years of people telling them things like they're racist bigots for flying the St George's Cross. Meanwhile factories and industry have closed, so you no longer have estates where everyone works in the same place. They've lost their identity. And without that, you've nothing to be proud of, and therefore you don't take any interest in helping to keep the community and streets happy and nice looking.

There are also lots more rich people visible, and wealth resentment is a real thing that makes people angry and bitter with their lot. Middle class kids used to go to grammar schools. Now everyone's mixed, the poorer kids look at the middle class kids and grow up thinking "how is that fair that they're going skiing and I'm going to Skegness, when their parents don't work anymore hours than mine do?". It builds up generations of resentment, apathy and overwhelming "why even try?" feeling.

No idea what the solution would be. Bring back industry I guess. Make a minimum wage living be enough for a family of four to live off.

shrunkenhead · 16/05/2022 20:14

Really interesting post, OP. I've been asking myself this for a while too. Also, and not to de-rail your thread, how do places become "run-down" in the first place? I hear so often around where I live (North ) from the older generation " it used to be a lovely area this....." where I live there is a lot of racism and it is often blamed on people coming from overseas but I honestly don't think it's that simple!

Smartsub · 16/05/2022 20:08

I've only lived 'near' it, and it seems to have become even worse since the pandemic. Most old phone boxes are smashed, and if you visit town on any day of the week you have to step over drunks. I'm not exaggerating either.

We don't go anymore, only for the bank really. We don't drive so get a 5 min train to another town to shop.

I think this is part of the problem actually. Town centres and local shops have been abandoned by people who can chose to go to the out of town places (ie have cars and funds), leaving the town centres exclusively used by the serially disadvantaged and the less people with money go to the centres, the "worse" they get.

TheYearOfSmallThings · 16/05/2022 20:08

You clearly did not live in Ballyfermot in the 1980s Grin

BloomsburyNook · 16/05/2022 20:06

FieryPitOfMordor · 16/05/2022 20:01

But this is what people keep voting for.

But who is there to vote for? Tories have never given a shit about people in difficulty and Labour (who you might think should give a shit) are tying themselves in knots with identity politics / trying to appeal to the professional left.

Maybe the rise in politicians (from all parties) that have never done actual jobs hasn’t helped?

I agree with you, but if you research funding for the NHS during each party's tenure, the tories have almost starved it. Even if Labour are a bit shitty right now, our services are safer with them, I think. It doesn't feel like much of a democracy with only two parties to me, I would prefer a good coalition of the SNP, Lab, LD's and Green.

OP posts:
BloomsburyNook · 16/05/2022 20:04

pointythings · 16/05/2022 19:55

This has been going on since Thatcher came into power and has accelerated since 2010. Alongside the by-design increase in inequality there's also as has been mentioned the steady defunding of council services and the massive cuts in the number of mental health inpatient beds. To get an inpatient bed now the bar is increadibly high - which means an awful lot of very unwell people with MH and addiction issues who are getting little to no help are out there, struggling and impacting a lot of other people.

But this is what people keep voting for.

I agree with the Thatcher part, and also I have to suggest that manufacturing was going south regardless. My DH blames everything on Thatcher, it's a running joke, except...not so funny :(

I honestly noticed it first in 2007. I left my old town due to the sudden influx of motorbikes, crime and arson. Prior to this is was a lazy Sunday kind of place. No idea what happened, but it was bloody awful. It shits on your memories. I do agree that 2010 accelerated it though. But no one seems to care if they're not living in it.

I've only lived 'near' it, and it seems to have become even worse since the pandemic. Most old phone boxes are smashed, and if you visit town on any day of the week you have to step over drunks. I'm not exaggerating either.

We don't go anymore, only for the bank really. We don't drive so get a 5 min train to another town to shop.

OP posts:
FieryPitOfMordor · 16/05/2022 20:01

But this is what people keep voting for.

But who is there to vote for? Tories have never given a shit about people in difficulty and Labour (who you might think should give a shit) are tying themselves in knots with identity politics / trying to appeal to the professional left.

Maybe the rise in politicians (from all parties) that have never done actual jobs hasn’t helped?

BloomsburyNook · 16/05/2022 19:59

I don't know why there's so many more people like this around now and where the regular people have gone. It's like they've been replaced.

Seriously, I've asked myself this very question. I think they're shopping or moving elsewhere. My closest town lost it's M&S, Debs, Topshop, Next, Body Shop and several other stores. The only ones that remain are Primark, B&M's, Poundland.

Our Tesco is pretty good, as is the Sainsbury's but the Lidl is a bit depressed. The only one which really went sour is Asda. I think it depends where they are positioned. Our Asda is in a rough place, and it ain't cheap either!

OP posts:
pointythings · 16/05/2022 19:55

This has been going on since Thatcher came into power and has accelerated since 2010. Alongside the by-design increase in inequality there's also as has been mentioned the steady defunding of council services and the massive cuts in the number of mental health inpatient beds. To get an inpatient bed now the bar is increadibly high - which means an awful lot of very unwell people with MH and addiction issues who are getting little to no help are out there, struggling and impacting a lot of other people.

But this is what people keep voting for.

Swipe left for the next trending thread