Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask how you think social issue arise?

136 replies

BloomsburyNook · 16/05/2022 19:07

I'm nearly 50, so have seen a few decades. When I was young, if you visited a small handful of rough or run down places, you might see a few drunks or 'miscreants' or young lads messing around, but never anything really threatening or visible.
So it might just be me, and I've led a fairly quiet life, but there seem to be a hell of a lot more issues out there now, especially in ex industrial places and urban towns around the UK. I see a lot more homeless people, many who have evident addiction issues: women as much as men, and there are more gangs of teens smashing stuff, shouting, fighting, etc.
However, in many areas you hear that crime rates have dropped over the years. Perhaps it depends where you go, and many people in bad areas won't report to the police anyway.

I often travel with work, and see this across the uk, much more dereliction and dying high streets, and in many towns there's literally rubbish piling up along embankments and street corners that the councils never clear up. And it's not simple enough to say it's because these are run down areas - they were run down decades ago but not like this.

I know there are many lovely places, and I've lived in a few of those, too, and some go downhill a bit, some remain safe. So if you don't get out a lot you might not know it's going on? I don't know. I asked a few older friends recently had they noticed and they did admit that there were elements of this knocking around in the 70's, 80's, etc, but not to this extent.

How did it become worse? What is your opinion? What could be done to help? Are people generally poorer than 20 yrs ago? This is presuming poverty as a causation - is it? The news headlines often affirm this, but I don't really know across the board. I know there are a lot of very closed off towns that might make these issues worse due to people rarely leaving them, but is the issue more cultural than economical?

I think people are generally angrier and less satisfied on the whole, we are all a lot more stressed out even if some of us report we are doing great and don't notice it! It just seems like a different world from when I was in my 20's. And of course, it is! Imma gettin old!

OP posts:
basketb · 17/05/2022 09:59

An ageing population doesn't mean the young stay ;

I don't disagree & said I think we will see more of it in the UK. China have been trying to push more incentives though eg 3 child thing so I assume they will do more.

I don't think means testing would be popular but it would be more popular than increasing taxes across the board. The basic rate taxpayers would pay nothing for healthcare under this plan.

I just don't think that plan would generate enough money as the majority of people are basic tax payers.

onthefencesitter · 17/05/2022 09:46

@basketb i think the opposite actually, i think chinese workers will leave. As people become richer, they go up maslow hierachy of needs and the top tier is self-actualization. Self actualization can come in various forms, but a big way how many people rediscover themselves is through travel. An ageing population doesn't mean the young stay ; in fact in many eastern european countries, the population is ageing but the young leave. China is also looking at relaxing immigration rules particularly of overseas Chinese; something like 14% of Thai people are of chinese descent.

Immigration is not popular in most countries tbh. But the factors that lead to higher immigration often are not within the population or sometimes even the government's control. Australia and Canada's points based system led to more immigrants, not less. If the ingredients are right- universal common language (English), business friendly environment, cosmopolitan cities, property rights, the immigrants would come. I mean, America's economy has been in decline for years, their healthcare is horrendously expensive, property tax is high (my uncle's property tax is US$10,000 a year in california but he says all his new immigrant friends want to buy property in the USA). I am sure they can buy very nice properties back home and not pay such high property tax, and can then rent in the USA, but they don't want to. They want to settle in the USA.

I don't think means testing would be popular but it would be more popular than increasing taxes across the board. The basic rate taxpayers would pay nothing for healthcare under this plan. As for early retirement, I think the people who are likely to be able to afford to retire in their 50s are likely to live in Band E and above properties (though there are exceptions, my MIL's £750k terraced house is Band D; but then again someone of her age group who earned well enough to retire at 55 would probably not live in her house, my MIL only has state pension). the Boomers I know seem very keen to move into large properties despite their kids flying the nest; so perhaps they wouldn't downsize because of potential medical bills. But if they do, i can think of worse things...

AffIt · 17/05/2022 09:43

On a slight tangent, for those interested in the effects of endemic poverty and the associated epigenetic phenomena (which also touch on widescale trauma, such as war etc), I highly recommend a book called 'The Tears That Made the Clyde', by the social researcher Carol Craig*.

Its focus is Glasgow, obviously, but it also looks at other post-industrial cities such as Liverpool and Manchester.

*I am not Carol Craig, btw, nor do I know her: I just think it's a very interesting book.

basketb · 17/05/2022 09:24

@onthefencesitter I personally think that any means testing for the NHS which only looks at income will go down like a lead balloon. Covid lead to the "silver exodus" where large numbers of people in their 50s left the workforce & I think this would encourage more.

I also think any more burden on the young will lead to increased brain drain.

Do you not think the Chinese workers will become more incentivised to stay in China as they have a big demographic change looming?

I'm all for migration (I'm 2nd gen) but it's not very popular hence Brexit.

onthefencesitter · 17/05/2022 09:21

@AffIt I watched 'Cornwall' on iplayer last night, a young cornish guy said 'his friends couldn't get jobs, so they turned to crime and all wound up in jail'. His female friend also said that anyone who wanted a job has left.

Probably true for many deprived areas.

AffIt · 17/05/2022 09:01

I think you've just led a sheltered life.

I'm 43, and grew up in Glasgow in the early-mid 1980s: my god, what a grim, grey, depressing hole it was.

I was born and brought up in a relatively 'genteel', lower middle class area of the southside and there were definite 'no go' areas in the city centre, east end and parts of the north of the city - not just because they were unpleasant or dirty, but because they were downright dangerous.

Such was the case for many post-industrial areas in Scotland, the North of England and (I daresay, although I have no experience of it) Wales in the 1980s and early 1990s.

I don't think that things have necessarily got worse, but what's more depressing is that, for many areas and many people, things haven't got substantially better, 40 years on.

'Why is this the case?' is the question we should be asking ourselves.

onthefencesitter · 17/05/2022 09:00

@Ticksallboxes coming from a country where our population has grown 20% in the past 20 years (and our healthcare system is not overwhelmed), it's bad governance to not plan for population increases/demographic changes. Even people planning children would try to future proof; no one thinks that someone who plans to have 5 children in a 1 bed flat is being sensible, let alone the government. Numerous studies say that immigrants are net taxpayers i.e. pay more in than they take out; we knew about ageing population and people living longer for possibly decades. But the response to the financial crisis was to cut cut cut and I guess the people worst affected didn't know who to blame so blamed immigrants/benefit claimants? We are returning to the years of higher government spending but I think the damage is done.

Ticksallboxes · 17/05/2022 08:53

I haven't RTFT but isn't one of the main reasons that the population is just so much bigger now and our infrastructure can't cope?

stickygotstuck · 17/05/2022 08:51

This thread has been extremely interesting to read, thanks OP and all who have contributed.

onthefencesitter · 17/05/2022 08:33

@basketb oh and also should mention that even though my grandma is not eligible for hefty government subsidies, she still did not go for private healthcare but used the state system.. my uncle who lives in America and is used to paying the moon asked us if going private would make a difference but my dad (who is paying) said no. I think that if we get our NHS to be halfway decent due to the extra funds, it would be the case here that people who used to spend money on private healthcare would spend money on NHS too. Also my grandma was terminally ill on life support in hospital, I am not sure whether that can even be covered in the UK under private health insurance. I don't think it's covered under the policy I have. So NHS should set it's prices lower than private. And what I imagine is a gradated scale i.e..someone on £150k pays 50% of costs up to a cap. Someone on £100k pays 25% of costs. Someone like my DH on £65k pays 10% of costs (and he would happily do so instead of going private).

onthefencesitter · 17/05/2022 08:17

@basketb I am an immigrant and actually I think the opposite. I mean, my dad back home told me my £400k flat is very cheap and affordable (compared to private housing in my home country) and in truth, London living is relatively cheap compared to many places in the world! Never mind the rest of the UK. Many Asian cities are cut throat places with high cost of living as the economies grow. London is a bit of a respite really from the craziness...I mean, as the pound falls, property will become even cheaper from a foreigner's perspective so an immigrant with savings can pick up a property with relatively low mortgage or as cash buyer and that will help mitigate against the lower earnings/higher taxes. I mean property in many tier 1 Chinese cities far exceeds London/major cities and 90% of Chinese people in their 20s are homeowners (and Chinese banks give small mortgages like 50% so they have a lot of equity!).

And actually as the middle class in China and India grows, the number of people eligible to be interested in travelling/immigration also grows. Many would not be here forever,but in a sense that is good for the NHS if they are paying into the system but not spending their elderly years here.

onthefencesitter · 17/05/2022 08:04

@basketb in my home country, it's based on a mixture of property value and income. My late grandma did not benefit from this system as her registered address is a house worth the equivalent of £4 million (she lives with my parents) but at the same time my parents do have the money to pay for her medical bills. There are people who are v rich but put their parents (who were also rich) in government flats for this reason and get generous subsidies.

@lecreusetpeppermill I think if your income is low, it would override the money in bank. I don't think it would be based on money in bank as that is hard to prove..it would be based on income (can tell from NI band)/council tax band. For older people in band E and above but who get state benefits, they can get free healthcare as well. Might also encourage people to downsize.

mackthepony · 17/05/2022 02:26

I grew up in East Lancashire and honestly I couldn't get away quick enough.

It just seemed so poor, depressed and a general sense of menace anytime you went into town.

I've travelled a lot but honestly the most scared I've felt and the roughest places I've ever been are in the North of England.

I do think education is one of the main keys, but anti intellectualism is rife.

basketb · 17/05/2022 01:59

blanket free prescriptions over 60 is ridiculous though

lecreusetpeppermill · 17/05/2022 01:54

I have money in the bank but currently a low income. A means tested NHS would wipe me out financially with one illness.

basketb · 17/05/2022 01:52

I agree the current NHS model is unsustainable but what would means testing look like. Based on income or assets?

basketb · 17/05/2022 01:50

@onthefencesitter immigration isn't popular though & personally I think it's naive to assume we are as attractive as we once were. An immigrant will face high taxes & high cost of living & don't forget other countries will be vying for immigrants too not to mention the immigrants own country may become more prosperous & there will be less reason to leave.

There is a major crisis within social care & the NHS & if it's like this now what will it be like with millions more elderly.

onthefencesitter · 17/05/2022 01:41

@basketb immigration should theoretically help to balance out the ageing population.A big issue however is balancing the elderly's healthcare needs using a healthcare system that was devised in the 1940s! I actually think we should start means testing the NHS. I know they say that would mean the rich have less of a stake in the NHS but there isn't really a system outside the NHS for the serious difficult stuff so they have no choice but to use the NHS.and even if they could go private,NHS would still charge them less than the private healthcare provider would. I have private medical insurance and there are plenty of exclusions so most rich people would have to pay a bomb for private medical care so we might as well redirect that money to the NHS where it is needed.

CherryBlossomAutumn · 17/05/2022 01:35

Yes I’ve noticed this also. I think there has always been violence, homelessness, drunkenness. However I grew up in a rough area of London, and there wasn’t a feeling of ‘meanness’ on the streets. People did get attacked or mugged. But generally there weren’t gangs hanging around taking up the centre of places.

I think it’s similar level of problems, but it looks different.

onthefencesitter · 17/05/2022 01:32

I live in a leafy suburb of north London so I don't see any of this in my high street. I do see homeless people in central London and there are more women than there used to be..What I do see is an alarming reliance on parents for my generation (I am in my 20s). I know of no one my age in London who has not received substantial parental help as an adult to buy their home. Even DH and I lived at home for 3 years to buy our flat. So if you are poor and don't have local parents, I don't know what one can do. This must create a lot of bitterness and anger. And the common refrain 'leave London for somewhere cheaper'... Well it doesn't really help genuinely poor people right? A cheaper area may not have a lot of jobs; if you are renting, it will still not be cheap; I have seen apartments in Manchester for higher rent than my mortgage. I had a friend in Yorkshire whose outgoings were the same as mine despite her household income being 25% of our household income (due to needing to run 2 cars and private rental). The moving to a cheaper area works better if you already have savings and some sort of career but that doesn't really apply to people who are struggling; and it's more of a question of preference. Poor people need max job opportunities (so they can work max hours to make up for low pay) and affordable housing in areas with good public transport (urban areas), near lots of amenities (this saves money and means that they can access cheaper retailers and supermarkets). You can only get that in cities which have become very gentrified. So a lot of poorer people are forced out to towns with fewer job opportunities and this impacts on their future... And there is also no investment in these towns to make them more attractive to businesses so it's like a downward spiral..

If I was the government, I would invest in high speed rail to connect many northern towns to Manchester and even London. Give each low income earner a discount off a rail season ticket (many lower paid jobs cannot be done from home). As for housing, I would build more social housing. The government can also partner with builders to build subsidized housing to be sold to FTB with the caveat that the FTB can only sell onto other people earning below a certain income threshold; these would be modest 2-3 bed maisonettes with shared gardens. And they are not allowed to be rented out unless the owner has a legitimate reason to leave the area; job or divorce etc. They would not appreciate as much as normal houses but that is what would keep them 'affordable'. Some people might think renting a house with garden for life is preferable to owning a government subsidized maisonette but I guess that is their choice.

basketb · 17/05/2022 01:15

Things won't change because we have a huge looming problem which is the ageing population. Our demographics are going to completely change & there is little planning for that change.

onthefencesitter · 17/05/2022 00:50

@Nat6999 after ww2, the vast majority of people didn't own their homes, London was covered in rubble, many middle class families had lost their money due to the war; even upper class families would have suffered due to their staff/men going to war. People supported an egalitarian state because people had little and they learnt during the war that the only way to survive was to lean on each other.Wars are actually quite effective in redistributing wealth.. now, 66% of the population own their home and for the older people who form the larger percentage of voters, it is much higher. They now feel like 'asset owners'.. and the ageing population has less incentive to vote for a change in the status quo as they have already amassed assets.. and their heirs are also less likely to vote for change.

lecreusetpeppermill · 17/05/2022 00:40

I have noticed most newspapers fail to mention any of this.

Codswallop20 · 17/05/2022 00:22

BloomsburyNook · 17/05/2022 00:10

Thank you <3

Most welcome! All of it is quite easy to identify, and probably not that difficult to solve.

Just the people who can don't want to, because they profit from all of this. And get away with it whilst laying the blame anywhere else

DdraigGoch · 17/05/2022 00:22

I have noticed way more issues in Labour areas too

Look at the areas with grooming gangs.

Any government (national/regional/local, of any colour) which stays in power for too long will rot. Good governance requires a strong opposition. In many of these towns Labour has been in charge for decades with little in the way of competition so corruption has become endemic.

Swipe left for the next trending thread