Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask how you think social issue arise?

136 replies

BloomsburyNook · 16/05/2022 19:07

I'm nearly 50, so have seen a few decades. When I was young, if you visited a small handful of rough or run down places, you might see a few drunks or 'miscreants' or young lads messing around, but never anything really threatening or visible.
So it might just be me, and I've led a fairly quiet life, but there seem to be a hell of a lot more issues out there now, especially in ex industrial places and urban towns around the UK. I see a lot more homeless people, many who have evident addiction issues: women as much as men, and there are more gangs of teens smashing stuff, shouting, fighting, etc.
However, in many areas you hear that crime rates have dropped over the years. Perhaps it depends where you go, and many people in bad areas won't report to the police anyway.

I often travel with work, and see this across the uk, much more dereliction and dying high streets, and in many towns there's literally rubbish piling up along embankments and street corners that the councils never clear up. And it's not simple enough to say it's because these are run down areas - they were run down decades ago but not like this.

I know there are many lovely places, and I've lived in a few of those, too, and some go downhill a bit, some remain safe. So if you don't get out a lot you might not know it's going on? I don't know. I asked a few older friends recently had they noticed and they did admit that there were elements of this knocking around in the 70's, 80's, etc, but not to this extent.

How did it become worse? What is your opinion? What could be done to help? Are people generally poorer than 20 yrs ago? This is presuming poverty as a causation - is it? The news headlines often affirm this, but I don't really know across the board. I know there are a lot of very closed off towns that might make these issues worse due to people rarely leaving them, but is the issue more cultural than economical?

I think people are generally angrier and less satisfied on the whole, we are all a lot more stressed out even if some of us report we are doing great and don't notice it! It just seems like a different world from when I was in my 20's. And of course, it is! Imma gettin old!

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Codswallop20 · 21/05/2022 01:10

Colourfulrainbows · 17/05/2022 23:20

My opinion is back down in early years family support.

That's how it starts. Not saying single parents. Am saying the foundation that causes the issues is lack of support within the early years.
The dynamics used to be generations would support each other and pass down values and core beliefs. Help to guide offspring to get a comfortable life.

The value being respect for others, work hard and look after things as you worked hard for them.

Due to family breakdowns the values don't stay. Add that to loss of industry. Loss of recreational activies such as working men's clubs and services for youths.

It then becomes no wonder you get a disfunction in society.

Problems now all all secondary ( mental health, crime, poverty) because they were never fixed at a primary source. ( government investing money into early years, making working more beneficial fo couples rather than if single, wages being a certain amount not requiring top up benefit just so some people can live. Affordable rents.).

The infrastructure in these places have broken down due to a number of reasons but mainly because the government was not really bothered about these areas and putting things in place in the primary problem.

So instead they have a secondary problem.

I wonder what cost more? Keeping petty crime down or investing in early years help.

Investment in affordable rents/living wages which would mean passing laws. Or putting someone in the rundown mental health services.

It will all be about money. S**t rolls down the hill.

You are absolutely correct in my opinion.

If people are born in to hopeless environments they will be hopeless people. There is a need for education and also nurture to have generations grow up with self belief.

I didn't think I could be anyone. I didn't think I could do anything. I was one of the kids that was left out, and when I wasn't people felt sorry for me because my parents were poor.

I now have a great career. I have a first class degree. I try to inspire my kids as I send them on school ski trips I wouldn't ever have done.

I am not a big earner in MN terms but my kids will be because they have the belief that they can. I always thought I wasn't worth anything, didn't deserve anything and would always be poor because my parents were. Let's change this. @

Ferngreen · 18/05/2022 10:36

But support for parents and children during early years is probably the most productive thing for the money for improving lives, o as suggested by previous posters.

stickygotstuck · 18/05/2022 10:14

Perhaps resitting your year at school if you fail until you reach a certain level would pull up some kids. We all get 13 years of free education. What percentage benefit fully from this.
Obviously if there are mitigating factors the facilities need to be there to help the child achieve what they can but we are all paying for this education for all and are we getting our money's worth.

Totally agree. I've been saying this for years.

It would also teach responsibility, the law of consequences, and the value of applying yourself and trying hard. Just about the main thing school should teach.

CulturePigeon · 18/05/2022 09:42

I think PPs have pretty much answered this question, so I will just add a couple more points.

Obviously the cycle of deprivation which some families get into is at the bottom of the problem, but also...

There may not have been a 'golden age' of law-abiding in this country, as some people might think, but attitudes to anti-social behaviour have changed. We are much more tolerant, and I don't think it does any of us any good (including the perpetrators).The permissiveness of the 60s brought many good things (enlightenment and toleration in sexual matters for example) but inevitably, the non-judgmentalism has eroded social taboos which were probably useful in terms of public conduct. Overseas teachers I've worked with are often shocked at what is tolerated in UK schools, for example. Teachers being told to fuck off by students is a day-to-day experience for many of them, where once it would have meant expulsion/exclusion.

Public facilities such as playgrounds and bus shelters are often seriously vandalised. Who would have thought say, 150 years ago, that if you had a society in which such facilities were provided to make everyone's lives better, that elements within that society (and often the very people they are created for) would try their best to destroy them? It would be incomprehensible to people in the past - so why does it happen?

Not expecting answers - politicians and sociologists wrestle with these issues all the time. I suppose I would sum up by saying that you can take non-judgmentalism too far. As a society we need boundaries and we do need to show disapproval for anti-social behaviour which actually makes the lives of the most vulnerable people (not the elites) harder.

Ferngreen · 18/05/2022 08:14

Perhaps resitting your year at school if you fail until you reach a certain level would pull up some kids. We all get 13 years of free education. What percentage benefit fully from this.
Obviously if there are mitigating factors the facilities need to be there to help the child achieve what they can but we are all paying for this education for all and are we getting our money's worth.
In the past there was a stigma to not following rules, that's no longer the case, people do what they want but there is no downside to eg being the parent who berates and complains loudly to the teacher.

fallfallfall · 18/05/2022 02:31

the problem with increased taxes is that the money generated is often misspent, and doesn't address the problem.

which may also include how offenders are released early.

there is just no trust in how politicians spend the money received.

Colourfulrainbows · 17/05/2022 23:21

Colourfulrainbows · 17/05/2022 23:20

My opinion is back down in early years family support.

That's how it starts. Not saying single parents. Am saying the foundation that causes the issues is lack of support within the early years.
The dynamics used to be generations would support each other and pass down values and core beliefs. Help to guide offspring to get a comfortable life.

The value being respect for others, work hard and look after things as you worked hard for them.

Due to family breakdowns the values don't stay. Add that to loss of industry. Loss of recreational activies such as working men's clubs and services for youths.

It then becomes no wonder you get a disfunction in society.

Problems now all all secondary ( mental health, crime, poverty) because they were never fixed at a primary source. ( government investing money into early years, making working more beneficial fo couples rather than if single, wages being a certain amount not requiring top up benefit just so some people can live. Affordable rents.).

The infrastructure in these places have broken down due to a number of reasons but mainly because the government was not really bothered about these areas and putting things in place in the primary problem.

So instead they have a secondary problem.

I wonder what cost more? Keeping petty crime down or investing in early years help.

Investment in affordable rents/living wages which would mean passing laws. Or putting someone in the rundown mental health services.

It will all be about money. S**t rolls down the hill.

Breakdown in families*

Colourfulrainbows · 17/05/2022 23:20

My opinion is back down in early years family support.

That's how it starts. Not saying single parents. Am saying the foundation that causes the issues is lack of support within the early years.
The dynamics used to be generations would support each other and pass down values and core beliefs. Help to guide offspring to get a comfortable life.

The value being respect for others, work hard and look after things as you worked hard for them.

Due to family breakdowns the values don't stay. Add that to loss of industry. Loss of recreational activies such as working men's clubs and services for youths.

It then becomes no wonder you get a disfunction in society.

Problems now all all secondary ( mental health, crime, poverty) because they were never fixed at a primary source. ( government investing money into early years, making working more beneficial fo couples rather than if single, wages being a certain amount not requiring top up benefit just so some people can live. Affordable rents.).

The infrastructure in these places have broken down due to a number of reasons but mainly because the government was not really bothered about these areas and putting things in place in the primary problem.

So instead they have a secondary problem.

I wonder what cost more? Keeping petty crime down or investing in early years help.

Investment in affordable rents/living wages which would mean passing laws. Or putting someone in the rundown mental health services.

It will all be about money. S**t rolls down the hill.

lameasahorse · 17/05/2022 22:56

This reply has been withdrawn

Message from MNHQ: This post has been withdrawn

lecreusetpeppermill · 17/05/2022 17:23

Yes it's very complex :(

basketb · 17/05/2022 14:45

If we go down the tax route then it has to be a wealth tax. Why should my aunt who has a 2m house not pay anything towards the NHS? There could maybe be a charge on something so houses don't have to be sold.

Imagine the sudden inrush of interest to care work if those people were given career prospects and a good wage.

But what will that do to care costs? People don't want to pay it. There is thread after thread on here about avoiding costs, IHT etc

basketb · 17/05/2022 14:40

So much comes back to housing. Too much of people's income is tied up in it.

We could move to a different health model where people have insurance etc but so many people just don't have any money.

Neverreturntoathread · 17/05/2022 14:24

Er what.

Clearly you never visited East or South London in the 1980s! “Cardboard city” they called it, because there were so many homeless people crammed there trying to keep warm with cardboard. Now areas that I used to be scared to walk through in daytime are relatively safe even at night time and full of cute arty cafes.

I remember the miners’ strikes, the poll tax riots, the axing of free milk for kids. I heard the Docklands bomb go off and I’ll never forget that sound. Also was in 4 different IRA-related bomb scares, plus was at Kings Cross in 2007 when those nutters blew up the train. Fun times.

I think you may be looking at the past through rose-tinted glasses a bit.

Ferngreen · 17/05/2022 13:11

I'm mid 60s - I would say 2/3 of my family and friends around my age have had emergency admission or operation . I can see exactly where the money goes.

lecreusetpeppermill · 17/05/2022 12:35

I agree with Arse, there's enough going around to save the NHS, just as there always is when something is needed. I'm just not falling for the crap we are fed by lousy right wing rags regarding the NHS. It has been broken intentionally. It isn't a side effect of Tony effing Blair or Population growth Grin

Imagine the sudden inrush of interest to care work if those people were given career prospects and a good wage. I doubt their current reticence has anything to do with there being too many old people to care for.

onthefencesitter · 17/05/2022 12:18

@ArseInTheCoOpWindow my home country does have 89% home ownership so i guess that reduces bills significantly! in america, there is no direct subsidy to the medical bills and the medical bills are already very high because its all privately run. Thats not the situation in the UK.

I am not sure what is the alternative then? Higher taxes, but as you said people are squeezed?

ArseInTheCoOpWindow · 17/05/2022 12:06

But in the US people go bankrupt when their ‘insurance’ pays out.

I think people have too much payout in the U.K. for this. Childcare, high rents and mortgages, increasing food and power bills, subsidising children through university and then said children coming home because they can’t afford to rent or buy.

Most people are pretty squeezed including those who just hit the high tax band. My point was, that even when NHS dentistry is available a significant number of people can’t afford it.

onthefencesitter · 17/05/2022 11:07

@ArseInTheCoOpWindow under my proposed plan, only higher rate taxpayers would really be paying and it would be gradated. And even the top tier(income of £150k) wouldn't pay the full amount, perhaps 50%. I mean, my DH is a higher rate taxpayer so this plan is not favorable to us, but at the same time, I don't want to spend all our disposable income on private healthcare if we need it in future.

We pay for private dental care and private dental insurance. My last dental bill was £1000. I would have liked nhs dental care, but they were not accepting new patients. This is what would happen to NHS healthcare if we don't reform. I have to pay through the nose for private for the privilege of not dying while other people who can't afford private suffer.

The wages in my home country are higher (on par with London), but the income thresholds for means testing are lower and even for the average person, the healthcare subsidy is not 100%. But this is normal, in other countries, people don't expect healthcare to be free. They also save for it (mandatory savings scheme) and buy insurance (which is mandatory). What I am suggesting is far more generous, its 100% subsidy and no change for basic rate taxpayers.

ArseInTheCoOpWindow · 17/05/2022 10:58

But maybe in the country you know about people are paid higher wages? So could afford it?

Sonething like a third of the population can’t afford dental charges. Imagine paying for health care too.

onthefencesitter · 17/05/2022 10:57

@ArseInTheCoOpWindow free healthcare is useless healthcare if you can't access it. It might as well be million pound healthcare. If you have to wait 9 hours for A & E after a heart attack which is what is happening in the SW, it doesnt really matter if the healthcare is free, you wouldn't need it.

MrOllivander · 17/05/2022 10:55

It's the teenagers that are the issue near me. All walk about with gloves/balaclavas, dressed in black like they're in some kind of street gang in Manchester. They're maybe 13? Roaming around stealing, breaking stuff, banging on windows, just generally causing trouble and don't care about a criminal record

onthefencesitter · 17/05/2022 10:55

@ArseInTheCoOpWindow i guess most of these people wouldn't be higher rate taxpayers. and probably disabled people would be exempt from paying charges.

Thats the thing, we can put our heads in the sand and say that the NHS should be free at the point of service. But we are actually engineering an unfair system where in future only people who can afford private healthcare will get healthcare. The rest of the people can go and wait 1 year until they drop dead. Or suffer in pain for years and years. We could have a European style insurance system and I have lived in germany before, it works well. But it costs more for the average person/low earners. the disposable income of lower income Britons is lower mainly due to private rental and high childcare fees. I would rather pay something for NHS than have to pay for private healthcare. Of course the people who can't afford it shouldn't have to pay.

The people who rely on the NHS would be screwed in future if we don't do anything because they will be like sitting ducks, they will die if they can't access private healthcare.

ArseInTheCoOpWindow · 17/05/2022 10:40

like my DH would not be too pissed off because he has paid for healthcare before and doesn't need a lot of it as he is relatively young.

But what about people who aren’t young, or are disabled? Or people who had shit childhoods who rely on the NHS as bad home environment causes mental health issues, addiction issues, pain issues.

ArseInTheCoOpWindow · 17/05/2022 10:37

I’m not sure how a government comingbto
piwer on the slogan ‘education, education, education’ is responsible for a decline in living standards or lack of social cohesion Hmm

Education is generally a good thing. I was a teacher then. There was suddenly lots of money everywhere you could tap into. Small class sizes. Unlike now where it’s one textbook between 3.

I think one of the reasons behind Blair’s policy was Britain had a very low number of graduates compared to the rest of the world. He believed better education would lead to better productivity and would make us equal to other countries.

onthefencesitter · 17/05/2022 10:16

@basketb I think increasing NI for basic rate taxpayers would generate more money but would be tone deaf considering cost of living crisis. At least with this proposal, even higher tax rate payers like my DH would not be too pissed off because he has paid for healthcare before and doesn't need a lot of it as he is relatively young.

Most people say they would be willing to pay more taxes for good healthcare but tbh for lower earners, I think that might be a considerable hardship. I don't think we can continue like this; i would rather pay for NHS healthcare than go for private for everything. I am fine with private GP appointments and simple operations, but i think the more complicated stuff would be extremely expensive.