Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask if this childcare model exists?

94 replies

PeopleWillAlwaysNeedPlates · 16/05/2022 18:52

DH and I both teach - me part-time SLT and him full-time headteacher, which I mention only to explain that we are in jobs with almost zero flexibility in term time.

We have two primary-age DC, one of whom has some SEN and health needs. We use a brilliant childminder for wraparound care. Grandparents are very very supportive but 100+ miles away on both sides, so although they are very happy to help with planned childcare they can’t help with emergencies.

I have the opportunity to go for a new role but realistically to make it work we would need an extra element to our childcare, which I’m not sure exists - hence this post. We would need someone who would be willing to be available to pick up the children if, for example, they were unexpectedly unwell in school or to care for them on an ad hoc basis if they were poorly. I imagine we’d have to pay some kind of retainer and then an hourly / daily rate for any care provided?

Does such a thing exist? Most of my friends have grandparents locally enough not to need to pay for this kind of support. Another friend has a similar arrangement with a nanny / housekeeper but we can’t afford this.

OP posts:
SunSparkle · 16/05/2022 21:18

What about finding a regular babysitter or two on sitters.co.uk and then finding out their ad hoc availability? Or nursery staff your kids had when they were at nursery? Or a grandma nearby if you put an ad on a neighbourhood Facebook group or similar?

PeopleWillAlwaysNeedPlates · 16/05/2022 21:10

2reefsin30knots · 16/05/2022 19:23

What job is this where you couldn't go an pick up an ill child? DH and I are both deputies, him of a very big and not very family orientated school. Neither of us is particularly expendable, but if DS is ill we just have to manage between us. We had zero family help when he was little. We'd alternate days/ half days off between us until he was well enough to be looked after by our babysitter if she was available. However, the number of times he had more than two days off in a row was very minimal.

My HT is a single parent, she still sometimes has days off for her teenagers if they need her.

You are not helping the profession by going along with the idea that our lives are suspended during term time.

I missed this little gem. I’ve spent twenty years ‘helping the profession’. I now have a son with an EHCP at the age of four who has also picked up every bug going over the last winter. Multiple d&v bugs which meant three days off minimum because we respect the 48 hour rule, and endless colds which went onto his chest requiring PCRs to rule out Covid and lately hospital stays on O2 and nebulisers. I’d like to take an onward step in my career but I need to be realistic and potentially a bit creative in how DH and I manage this.

OP posts:
DelurkingAJ · 16/05/2022 20:39

Our childminder does exactly this for us. She is, however, officially a nanny as she only covers DC from two families. But we pay as though the DC are full time even though they’re at school so whilst we’ll worth it you it’s not cheap.

ItsDinah · 16/05/2022 20:12

Consider employing a Mother's Help on a regular basis,term time only, to work say 3 hours a day,4 days a week at £10 per hour. £120 per week. Housekeeping/childcare as necessary. This would keep you below the threshold at which you would have to pay employer NI contributions and could well suit another local parent. You would have to judge what hours. Perhaps 10am to 1pm,Tuesday - Friday would catch most of the emergency calls from your children's schools. It would also benefit you with cleaning help too.

Happyhappyday · 16/05/2022 20:06

It seems like an au pair could be an answer, especially if you had light hours for them generally. It also seems like whole it’s not ideal for a sick child to wait an hour at school it’s not the end of the world. I didn’t grow up in UK but the schools I went to had a proper nurses office with curtained beds, I definitely spent an hour+ there.

PeopleWillAlwaysNeedPlates · 16/05/2022 20:00

InChocolateWeTrust · 16/05/2022 19:35

Ps agreed that teachers can and do have time off with sick kids. You don't stop being a parent just because you are a teacher!

My DC teacher took today off to attend a ceremonial event for her child. My sibling took time off last term with a vomiting child.

A school that can't facilitate a teacher having to go and collect a sick child (it shouldnt happen that often) is poorly managed.

How I've seen it managed is:

  • schools have a floating ppa cover person who can fill in
  • a HLTA can cover in an emergency
  • I've seen the head teacher take a class in an emergency
  • I've also seen a school who had a part time teacher who didnt mind being asked to fill in the odd extra day here and there.

With respect, have you spent any time in secondary schools over the last two winters?

When I joined my school eight years ago there were three full-time cover supervisors on the staff. Due to funding issues the two who have left haven’t been replaced. We now have one and she is being used every period, every day.

We do not have HLTAs. TAs can’t be asked to cover whole classes.

The headteacher has stepped in to cover my lesson when I had to leave in an emergency.

We have recently retired teachers who live locally and do ad hoc supply but can’t generally make themselves available in the middle of the day.

If I have to be off then I have to be off but I have the benefit of eight years of goodwill in my current role. I am not prepared to give this up lightly and so I am considering contingencies if I were to go for a new role.

OP posts:
Bobbybobbins · 16/05/2022 19:53

We both have inflexible jobs too, no family help and two children with SEN. If one is I'll we have found the best solution is to work half days each as far as possible (though appreciate this doesn't help if you are meant to be working a long way away! My school starts at 8.30 so if I leave at 1 I only miss 1.5 lessons and my DH can start at 2 and work til 6. (He is not a teacher though similarly inflexible)

Mammyloveswine · 16/05/2022 19:48

Of course teaching staff and SLT can take emergency leave? What a ridiculous idea! It's not ideal and actual rarely happens that much!

Im SLT and have had to take emergency leave as have other members of SLT including the headteacher!! It might be unpaid but it's certainly not frowned upon as long as it's shared between parents!

It is very rare we have to take time off for our children and my in laws have driven over 100 miles to help us!

Honestly don't worry, you will be fine-good luck with the new job!

GettingItOutThere · 16/05/2022 19:45

au pair?

iif you have the room? doubles up as a very light housekeeper but there for emergancies?

might work well having someone there for the kids after school? as well as someone to call on emergancies until your parents get there?

cansu · 16/05/2022 19:43

I think the answer is no unless you can afford to pay a nanny housekeeper who will for the vast majority of time have an easy role. I have faced this and agree that it is helpful to have built up goodwill. However you can do this again in a new role. In all honesty it depends how much money you have to chuck at it.

Seashor · 16/05/2022 19:41

When my husband and I were both shift workers we employed a nanny and that worked out perfectly.

Itsrainingatlast · 16/05/2022 19:40

I know it is much harder post-Brexit, but as a single parent DHT I had au pairs. It meant I had someone else living in the house, but always had emergency childcare.

SofiaAmes · 16/05/2022 19:40

PS. Both my DC's and the other family's DS had significant health issues and SEN that resulted in an anticipation of more frequent "emergencies" than a NT family.

SofiaAmes · 16/05/2022 19:39

I had this type of arrangement with another family who lived nearby. I was a single parent working from home and lived a few minutes from the DC's schools. The other mom and dad both worked 45 minutes away from the schools in somewhat unflexible jobs. Most of the time I was doing the daytime emergency pickups from school, but it was easy for me as I was nearby with flexible hours. In return it was very reassuring to know that I had backup to look after my dd for the many overnight hospital stays that my ds had. We had this arrangement all the way through from elementary school through high school. And ironically now our two youngest are at the same university, so could even utilize the arrangement there if we needed!

InChocolateWeTrust · 16/05/2022 19:37

Which is to say - ill children need to be at home, w their own carer: parent, nanny, relative. Not a role for a childminder

My DC have been with the same childminder since they were 1. They know her far better than their grandparents. Her house is a familiar happy place for them. Why is a nanny or relative better?

People are so snobby about childminders.

InChocolateWeTrust · 16/05/2022 19:35

Ps agreed that teachers can and do have time off with sick kids. You don't stop being a parent just because you are a teacher!

My DC teacher took today off to attend a ceremonial event for her child. My sibling took time off last term with a vomiting child.

A school that can't facilitate a teacher having to go and collect a sick child (it shouldnt happen that often) is poorly managed.

How I've seen it managed is:

  • schools have a floating ppa cover person who can fill in
  • a HLTA can cover in an emergency
  • I've seen the head teacher take a class in an emergency
  • I've also seen a school who had a part time teacher who didnt mind being asked to fill in the odd extra day here and there.
PeopleWillAlwaysNeedPlates · 16/05/2022 19:33

KarrotKake · 16/05/2022 19:27

My Mum used to come up on a days notice quite often. She's 150 miles away and our closest relative.
So we would do the drop everything and collect bit, but could often have childcare for the following few days (DS1 was most miffed when he got chicken pox a few weeks after his brother, and my Mum couldn't come up!).
In all honesty, by the time you've located a pick up person, and they've got there, it probably wouldn't be much quicker than traveling an hour yourself.

Yes, this is much like what we do now. However it isn’t infallible. My parents are ageing and my mother is losing her sight. PILs are younger but MIL does not drive. They do a lot to help SIL as well as having other commitments.

OP posts:
nearlyspringyay · 16/05/2022 19:32

DH is a HT. I'm lucky that I can be flexible in my work.

Realistically with two teachers you need a nanny.

dogschewbones · 16/05/2022 19:29

I think this is why one parent’s career stagnates tbh. And that you are right, there is no good answer.
i have a teaching friend whose ex did ask me once to have their son on a day when I was home w my baby, when their son was being sick everywhere (was his day to have the son but he was Too Important to stay at home). Was awful as I didn’t want to screw my friend about, but nor could I manage him and baby.
Which is to say - ill children need to be at home, w their own carer: parent, nanny, relative. Not a role for a childminder.
If it’s a job you really want then I think I’d try to find several options - nannies who have after school jobs, students, other babysitters, maybe an emergency agency. Agree what you’ll pay if they work - prob twice the going rate - and agree that they can always say no.
I reckon if you need to pick an ill child from
school though, that’s a hard one to sub out (other than to close friends) as nobody knows how ill child is…

Magicandspiders · 16/05/2022 19:28

Teacher here- this problem ranges across lots of professions not just ours. Our children have been unwell recently and my DH and I have split childcare between us. Yes, it isn't ideal being off school and yes cover is needed but that's the way it is. You can't expect someone else to look after poorly children.

PeopleWillAlwaysNeedPlates · 16/05/2022 19:28

Rosebel · 16/05/2022 19:19

Surely you have the same problem now if your children are ill? I don't understand why it would be any more difficult if you changed jobs?
What do you do now? Why wouldn't it work in your new job?
I don't think a childminder would be willing to care for a child who was ill. A nanny might but would probably cost quite a bit. It's worth looking in to though.
Other than that take it in turns to stay home with the children. It's not great but it's what all couples with children have to do.

I’m in a less senior role with eight years of reciprocal goodwill built up in the bank.

OP posts:
KarrotKake · 16/05/2022 19:27

My Mum used to come up on a days notice quite often. She's 150 miles away and our closest relative.
So we would do the drop everything and collect bit, but could often have childcare for the following few days (DS1 was most miffed when he got chicken pox a few weeks after his brother, and my Mum couldn't come up!).
In all honesty, by the time you've located a pick up person, and they've got there, it probably wouldn't be much quicker than traveling an hour yourself.

PortiaFimbriata · 16/05/2022 19:26

Unless your DC's needs are very specific and can't be managed by a competent and qualified stranger then the answer is an emergency nanny from an agency.

You'll pay through the nose for the times when you need them, but at least you'll only be paying for the times you do need them: you just need to budget a set amount for emergency child care each year.

To some extent I guess it depends where you live - you'll have much more choice in a big city.

NumberTheory · 16/05/2022 19:26

This is one of the reasons a large number of well educated women don't go back to careers full tilt after children - there isn't the flexibility in a lot of professional jobs to cater for caring responsibilities that might take you out of work at a moment's notice more than once in a blue moon. And there aren't good childcare options to plug the gaps.

Do you have a spare room? Could you look for some kind of semi-au pair type arrangement where they get board for free and you guarantee them x hours of paid work a month. If you don't them to use those hours looking after your kids then they do housekeeping instead?

I don't think a childminder on retainer will work as you want them to look after your kids when they're sick and most childminders would not want to mix sick kids with their own.

InChocolateWeTrust · 16/05/2022 19:24

A childminder can do this? Although might be difficult if a child is vomiting etc.

Childminders can only have 3 under 5s usually, but can have extra school aged kids on top. They wouldn't need to charge you during the day for holding space as a place for a school aged child between 9 &3pm isnt one they can usually fill since children that age are at school.

Are you children poorly that often?