Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To expect a real apology? Reposting for traffic

159 replies

danny735 · 16/05/2022 17:05

My DH was at the FA Cup final yesterday. Football is a huge hobby for him and he's had a season ticket for his club since he was a child.

We had a DD, 8 months old and he hasn't been able to go as much since she arrived. He's a good dad and he's very hands on but I will say he seems to be struggling since she was born. He doesn't stay in control of his emotions (whereas before DD he was my rock and showed high emotional intelligence).

He's been lashing out a lot but more than that hasn't showed the ability to take responsibility for his actions. He tends to externalise blame. We are in couples therapy already. I understand that he needs outlets and he was very much looking forward to the match yesterday. I've been unwell this weekend with a bad cold and DD is teething. I assured him he should still go, it was just a cold and whilst I felt a bit miserable I was able to look after DD. I left him through it throughout the day - just sending occasional pictures or videos of DD like I normally would. He left the house at 12:30 and was home at 9:30. I asked him to bring me a bar of chocolate. He messaged to say he was walking up from the station (an 8 minute walk) but didn't get home for another 20 minutes. I said "What took you so long?" He immediately flared up, swore at me and told me to "fuck off and go away" as well as another below the belt comment.

This morning he externalised blame - apparently his reaction/ swearing was because I asked him "What took you so long?" when he was still on the doorstep. He will apologise in one breath and externalise blame in the next which makes it quite difficult to accept the apology. He will then say "I should only have to apologise once". He didn't give any thought to the fact that I might have been exhausted from looking after a teething baby all day while feeling unwell. He didn't ask how I was feeling - he started swearing so I went to bed. When I suggested this morning that he had been taking his disappointment that his team lost out on me - he hotly disagreed. I was trying to understand his behaviour/ reaction but he just seems to take it as a slight.

What upsets me the most was the contempt in his voice / body language last night. Is it unreasonable to expect a meaningful apology?

OP posts:
TadLlama · 16/05/2022 17:54

If you think he's having a breakdown then help him. Don't badger him for a "real apology".

StrangeCondition · 16/05/2022 17:52

But you didn't leave him alone all day, you said you were sending him pictures and videos of your daughter - do you really need to do that when he's out?

ShirleyPhallus · 16/05/2022 17:48

He sounds awful honestly, I never understand these men who act like tantrumming toddlers when their team loses. It’s a game ffs, not an excuse to use your partner as a punchbag (verbal or literal)

That said, I read a lot of these threads where the OP posts about having colds /teething babies / sendin pictures /videos / asking partners to pick up stuff for them on the way home. I think if a partner has a free pass you should basically leave them to it, they don’t need to be sent yet another pic of the baby doing the same thing they do every day. The mothers should have exactly the same free passes and be able to be completely off duty too without feeling any guilt of leaving the baby at home with a snotty partner.

BogRollBOGOF · 16/05/2022 17:47

His reaction was OTT and a decent person would appologise.

However, your accusatory tone on his arrival over something trivial wasn't a warm welcome to bring out the best in him (not a justification for unapologetic swearing)

Does he appreciate the photo/ video updates through the day? They're not going to enhance his enjoyment of the FA Cup. Does he find them intrusive like he can't escape from family life? A baby isn't going to change that much in 9 hours to require regular updates.

There's clearly an issue here, how much depends on his willingness to listen and talk but it's not entirely one-sided either.

Womencanlift · 16/05/2022 17:47

I would have flared up to if I got that response as I walked through the door. It shows you were clock watching. An extra 10 minutes or so isn’t even a thing I would notice. I would just assume he had bumped into someone on the street and was having a chat (or in his case commiserating about the result). I think you are the one the needs to apologise.

Also if he is out at the football, I assume with friends, why were you sending pictures and videos? I am sure they could have waited until he was home to see

fluffycereal · 16/05/2022 17:44

OP you are speaking of him defensively. He is being abusive and even if he is having a breakdown nothing excuses his behaviour. You are going to couples therapy because of his behaviour. An apology is not what you need. It's a clean break away from this so you are not scared in your own home. I'm sickened at the amount of posters suggesting this is your fault for asking him a question.

Shoxfordian · 16/05/2022 17:42

It sounds like he’s showing you his abusive nature now you’ve had a baby

GarlicGnocchi · 16/05/2022 17:41

But he shouldn't have yelled at you no

GarlicGnocchi · 16/05/2022 17:41

I get you wanted him to hurry up and come home but a lot of people need a bit of a breather when they get in. Take coat off have a piss etc.

danny735 · 16/05/2022 17:40

fluffycereal · 16/05/2022 17:33

I think everyone is missing the key part of the OP and it has nothing to do with the situation mentioned...

He doesn't stay in control of his emotions (whereas before DD he was my rock and showed high emotional intelligence). He's been lashing out a lot but more than that hasn't showed the ability to take responsibility for his actions. He tends to externalise blame. We are in couples therapy already.

^honestly OP what are you doing with this man?

This.

I was actually worried when I said "What took you so long?". He'd mentioned seeing a few arguments earlier (football is emotive and lots of fans had been drinking). There were drops of dried blood in the bathroom the next day (he does not have form for fighting physically ever but he can be too vocal with his opinions about football when he's had a few)

I don't think i deserve to be swore at under any circumstances. I was unwell with a teething baby and I made sure I left him alone all day.

If he'd just said "sorry" it would be forgotten but he blamed me for his unreasonable reactions.

I think he's having some sort of breakdown. He used to be my biggest cheerleader. Now I feel alone.

OP posts:
Inklingpot · 16/05/2022 17:40

I have to say, if my partner kept telling me I’m ‘externalising blame’ every time we had a disagreement, I’d be pretty annoyed too. It comes across that you’re using counselling terminology as a stick to beat him with.

flaxensunshine · 16/05/2022 17:38

DashboardConfessional · 16/05/2022 17:27

OP says they lost, so in that case his team have lost 3 FA Cup Finals in a row and already lost to Liverpool on penalties at Wembley this year. He would have been gutted!

Oh I missed that sorry!! So he would have been gutted and then met with what took you so long… sorry he was rude but so were you.

the game went right to the wire with extra time and penalties so he was probably not in a good place, doesn’t excuse him swearing at you but you didn’t have to pounce on him the minute he came in!

YetAnotherChanger · 16/05/2022 17:37

Did he bring the chocolate?

fluffycereal · 16/05/2022 17:33

I think everyone is missing the key part of the OP and it has nothing to do with the situation mentioned...

He doesn't stay in control of his emotions (whereas before DD he was my rock and showed high emotional intelligence). He's been lashing out a lot but more than that hasn't showed the ability to take responsibility for his actions. He tends to externalise blame. We are in couples therapy already.

^honestly OP what are you doing with this man?

DashboardConfessional · 16/05/2022 17:27

flaxensunshine · 16/05/2022 17:23

Also he would have either been elated or crushed depending on what team he supports.. so to then have you say what took you so long is a bit much I think!

OP says they lost, so in that case his team have lost 3 FA Cup Finals in a row and already lost to Liverpool on penalties at Wembley this year. He would have been gutted!

WhackingPhoenix · 16/05/2022 17:25

What was the other ‘below the belt’ comment?

Ducksinthebath · 16/05/2022 17:25

Your response to him was rude. You could have asked if everything was ok, you were worried, etc. rather than the more challenging language you used.

However, the way he is behaving towards you generally and in his response to this issue specifically is not appropriate at all. I hope the counselling helps.

VeryTrying22 · 16/05/2022 17:25

Bwix · 16/05/2022 17:19

an 8-minute walk that took 20 minutes? There’s something which doesn’t sit quite right. Clearly his behaviour is shitty but idk there’s something amiss. Are you reacting to your own loss of agency and control that naturally came with motherhood by being more controlling of your DH? Are you externalising blame?

He must have has his OW waiting outside the shop on the way home for a 12 minute sex session up against the bins…

Christ some on here are crackers

TigerLilyTail · 16/05/2022 17:25

Maybe he was just looking at something on his phone for 12 minutes. I don't think his lateness is a problem, but his anger is not ok.

flaxensunshine · 16/05/2022 17:23

Also he would have either been elated or crushed depending on what team he supports.. so to then have you say what took you so long is a bit much I think!

TigerLilyTail · 16/05/2022 17:23

It's not ok for him to take his anger out on you. It sounds like he is unhappy.

Would it be worth trying to separate for a while?

Crunchymum · 16/05/2022 17:23

Did it take him so long as he was pissed?

Does booze effect his responses to you?

Is he drinking more now then before DD arrived?

LetitiaLeghorn · 16/05/2022 17:22

Bwix · 16/05/2022 17:19

an 8-minute walk that took 20 minutes? There’s something which doesn’t sit quite right. Clearly his behaviour is shitty but idk there’s something amiss. Are you reacting to your own loss of agency and control that naturally came with motherhood by being more controlling of your DH? Are you externalising blame?

Yeah, you're right. Very suss. He must given someone a quickie on the way home. 🙄

Binsk · 16/05/2022 17:21

His reaction was way out of line, but I wouldn't be pleased at being jumped on over something so petty before I was even in the house.

VeryTrying22 · 16/05/2022 17:21

I’d have told you to fuck off as well tbh

He was 12 mins ‘late’ and you moan the moment he comes in the house? Very unreasonable behaviour