Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask if you took out additional appliance protection?

39 replies

CoffeeFirstPlease · 16/05/2022 17:05

For those of you who don't have home insurance (I'm in rented) did you take out additional protection for the product when you bought it? I've recently had to replace my washing machine, fridge freezer and now I need a new cooker.

The cooker was a cheap one that came with the house (temporary accommodation I have permission to just buy my own more practical one) but the fridge freezer and washing machine were less than 5yrs old and 1.5yrs old respectively.

Just wondering if I should take out the additional care plans for them or out source then like domestic and general for eg which is roughly £15 a month.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
yellowsuninthesky · 17/05/2022 11:05

I also agree the insurance quote seems very high - we pay about £45 a month for combined buildings and contents and I think we have legal cover in that as well.

Getoff · 17/05/2022 11:04

Since the mid-1980's when I arrived in the UK, as far as I know the standard advice from consumer advisors like Which is never to buy product insurance, as it's always extremely poor value.

Major appliances should last six years, I think, under UK law.

I recently had the screen on my just-under-five-years-old TV replaced, because some of the red pixels had worn out. (Where news channel scrolling text appears.) Admittedly this was covered by Curries five-year warranty on large TVs, but I think it would have been covered by consumer rights anyway. (Just to be sure, I reported it 6 weeks before the warranty ran out.)

yellowsuninthesky · 17/05/2022 11:04

senua · 17/05/2022 10:07

I never understand why retailers offer extended warranties. They are effectively saying "our product is rubbish. It is going to break down".
It's terrible marketing.

I agree. I once bought a TV for £200 and they tried to sell me an extended warranty for £80. The guy got quite offended when I said I wasn't having the warranty. I have since always wished I'd been quick enough off the mark to say "well the product is obviously crap if you think I need to spend so much on a warranty".

DigitalGoat · 17/05/2022 10:54

We have bought them in the past but wouldn't anymore. On the occasion when our washing machine finally broke down and couldn't be repaired, we had to pay all the premiums up to the end of the policy year (not so bad if you're towards the end of it but we were only a couple of months in) and pay a hefty delivery charge as well. When added together it was over half the cost of a new machine.

Badbadbunny · 17/05/2022 10:28

No, never bought any of those at all. We "self insure", i.e. just keep our money and buy new appliances when they fail. It works out far cheaper in the long run. Yes, sometimes you're unlucky and something only lasts 2 or 3 years, but the vast majority of appliances last 10+ years (we're still using our original dishwasher, cooker and fridge from when we had our kitchen fitted 20 years ago, and they're just bog standard makes from the likes of Currys & Argos, not Miele, Bosch etc.) But we've gone through 4 or 5 driers in that time!

silverbubbles · 17/05/2022 10:21

I took a domestic and general policy out on a dodgey fridge and got a £900 pay out. I didn't actaully replace the fridge. it is still ticking (dripping) along!

I also got sold it on a very expensive range cooker which really surprised me but after a while it transpired that they shouldn't have done this and they dropped the policy very quietly. I noticed this and picked them up on it and got all my money back plus quite a bit more for their ridiculous behavior.

I currently have one policy in place for a dishwasher that is problematic. They have definitely been out at least twice to fix it.

So I am happy enough but I do think that they can be expensive.

senua · 17/05/2022 10:07

I never understand why retailers offer extended warranties. They are effectively saying "our product is rubbish. It is going to break down".
It's terrible marketing.

BobSacamono · 17/05/2022 10:00

Replaced a washing machine earlier this year, our old one died after 12 years with no problems. The seller was on the phone the same day to set up D&G insurance (3 yr direct debit), but when the machine arrived the manufacturer was offering the same warranty cover for 5 years and for a fixed amount at 30% of what the D&G would have cost. No brainer to cancel the D&G.

I normally wouldn’t register or buy this sort of stuff but I also don’t trust the quality of appliances these days, no matter how reputable the brand and how much research I put in to find it.

HopeIsNotAStrategy · 17/05/2022 07:14

PS your contents insurance quote sounds very high. MSE will tell you how to go about getting a reasonable quote and could be a good place to start.

PortiaFimbriata · 17/05/2022 07:14

78 quid a month quote for contents insurance is really really high. UK average is 135 quid a year. Unless you live in a disastrously high crime rate or you're ground floor in a flood zone you should be able to do a lot better than that. Did you go to a comparison website?

HopeIsNotAStrategy · 17/05/2022 07:13

OP may I make a suggestion? I mean this entirely kindly. You are coming across as someone who doesn't yet have a lot of experience of dealing with this sort of financial issue (and you've done exactly the right thing by asking). I strongly suggest you go to moneysavingexpert.com, sign up for the weekly newsletter and read some of the posts on there. There's loads of really helpful people on the forums who'll help you with any specific questions.

Investing some of your time to learn about personal finance is one of the wisest things you can do, and will make a real difference to your life outcomes in the longer term. Good luck! 😊

UserError012345 · 17/05/2022 07:01

*now

UserError012345 · 17/05/2022 07:00

Oh gawd I did and when I was reviewing bills to look at cutting costs I was spending about £30 a month. I've not cancelled them all.

I had to buy a washing machine recently and decided not to insure. My last one lasted 8 years the cost to insure in that time was double that.

CoffeeFirstPlease · 17/05/2022 06:49

Thank you all for your replies.

I know a few have mentioned contents insurance I did get a quote but it was £78 a month and I just can't afford to pay that I understand it maybe worth it in the long run but at the moment it's not something I can afford to do.

I did look at d&g I was paying £15 for three items about 2yrs ago but stopped as was too pricey I will see if its any cheaper. I agree that I would expect these appliances to last 5+ yrs given the price of them. I won't take out any extra plans as its usually for the period covered by the warranty anyway.

OP posts:
Owaf4 · 16/05/2022 22:14

Hi, I have the same dilemma about D&G extended cover for my appliances. Realised I have been paying for 5 items over three years and never called them out. Their premiums go up each year which means I could have bought at least two items twice over. I have just cancelled as I think I was naive when I took it out, felt pressured moving into a new home with all new appliances. Have I acted in haste?

Which provider are you with that is only
£3 a month for washing machine and dishwasher? D&G started @£3 but now are £6 a month for a washing machine.

allboysherebutme · 16/05/2022 21:52

I have plans with domestic and general for all my kitchen appliances, I love the peace of mind no extra bills. X

Vsirbdo · 16/05/2022 18:23

We pay £3 per month for washing machine and £3 for fridge freezer. We’ve had so many issues with the washing machine that I’m very glad we did but no issues with fridge freezer

yellowsuninthesky · 16/05/2022 18:22

The problem is, who keeps receipts that long

if you buy online you might have the order in your email!

yellowsuninthesky · 16/05/2022 18:21

There is a fundamental misunderstanding (egged on by the retailers) that you need to take out an extended warranty to get protection if your appliance fails. This is not true. Under the Consumer Rights Act you have protection against the retailer. Any free guarantee offered by the manufacturer is in addition to your rights under the CRA and not instead of.

Once the guarantee expires, that does not mean that you no longer have rights - it depends on the item and the value, but I wouldn't expect a washing machine to give up the ghost after two years, if that's the length of the guarantee, and would expect to go back to the retailer. Under English law you have up to six years and in Scotland five.

However, I had my gas boiler replaced in December and paid £100 for a ten year warranty - it is worth it when an appliance is expensive. And it has broken since we got it and they came out and fixed it within 48 hours.

FourTeaFallOut · 16/05/2022 18:21

No. Never.

Surely you can still get contents insurance if you rent?

Smartsub · 16/05/2022 18:17

I never take it. It's expensive and anything to do with wear and tear isn't covered anyway.

I figure over the last 30 years the money I've saved on the premiums more than covered the odd one that packed up too quickly. Most last way beyond the extended warranty period.

I'm not sure what the link is to house insurance though. You still need to insure the house contents in rented accommodation, but faulty appliances wouldn't be covered.

YorkshireDude · 16/05/2022 18:12

In my opinion appliance insurance schemes are usually poor value for money, but I generally invest in high quality appliances and rarely buy the cheapest, so perhaps that influences my experience and opinion.

One thing that can be said with certainty is that most appliances that survive the first few hours of operation will then go on to give a long service life. In the world of reliability engineering this is a well known phenomenon, with the early failures being termed 'infant mortality'. As the warranty covers the period when so-called 'infant mortality' failures may occur, it makes little sense to pay for insurance after the warranty has expired.

Here's a handy graphic that illustrates the failure rate phenomenon I described. This is sometimes known as a 'bath tub curve'.
www.weibull.com/hotwire/issue21/ht21_1.gif

Of course there will always be exceptions. For example, people with very large families, or who have personal reasons for heavy usage of a particular appliance, may find appliance insurance worthwhile.

ButtockUp · 16/05/2022 18:09

I'm probably out of date , but when I last looked, The Sale of Goods Act assumes 6 years
Of reasonable use for white goods and that you are within your rights to a repair , replacement or refund.

The problem is, who keeps receipts that long?

Did you register your purchase?

Places , like Curry's, are very tricky to deal with.

PillowySoft · 16/05/2022 17:59

When my husband and I first moved in together we looked in to it and decided we would be far better off putting the money into a savings account, as a previous poster said. I also looked at the yearly cost of various insurances and split that into 12 and put that away into the account every month, so we always have money to pay the insurance premium upfront for a year as usually you get a bit of discount by doing this rather than paying monthly.

nearlyspringyay · 16/05/2022 17:55

Never.