Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

School, dd with special needs

132 replies

Leftie202 · 16/05/2022 15:35

Dd age 10, struggling significantly at school. They have gone to a reduced Time table, she has a one on one, echp, not yet been diagnosed but all professionals say probably adhd. She’s hard work at school no doubt about it. At home she’s not so bad. She lives full time with her father, only spends weekends and half the holidays with me. It has been this way for a couple years, she seems happy with this arrangement. So here is the aibu… the school struggle so much with her that they have to call me or her dad in to help them quite often, daily, every other day if we’re lucky. Now they usually call her dad first, but he normally says he can’t come in for whatever reason, so it’s left to me. I work full time, im having to leave work, have so much time off which I simply can’t afford to do. Her dad claims all the benefits for her, so I simply have to work to live, so I’ve said to school I can’t come in anymore, sorry, but I can’t. Im going to end up losing my job if it keeps happening. They said that’s not acceptable and I should be available when they need me. But I think her dad should be! He’s the main parent, he claims for her, including dla and carers. Basically he has the option to not work and care for her, where as I do not. So aibu or not? Im so stressed with it because I can’t keep on like this.

OP posts:
Sockwomble · 17/05/2022 11:44

At my son's special school if there are not enough staff due to Covid to run the class safely, they shut the whole class down. They don't tell individual children to stay home.

AReallyUsefulEngine · 17/05/2022 11:23

It happened all the time during the days of Covid.

And look at the uproar from some parents in the lockdowns.

It does not still happen. Whole classes/year groups are not put on long term part time timetables and their parents aren’t asked to go in to school daily.

Saying it is unacceptable in itself isn’t a solution but the solutions lead on from it being unacceptable e.g. an early review, Judicial Review.

Sockwomble · 17/05/2022 10:57

"It happened all the time during the days of Covid. Still is happening. If there is no one to teach the child then the child/ren cannot be in school, obviously. You can say it's unacceptable but that really isn't a solution, is it?"

Really? Children without SEN on part time time tables for months. Parents expected to sit in class with their children. I have not seen that on mumsnet and I would expect to if that was happening.

Don't compare something that happens occasionally and indiscriminately to all children with something that happens only to children with sen and disabilities.

AndAsIfByMagic · 17/05/2022 10:27

Sockwomble · 16/05/2022 21:41

"It's quite likely that the school has tried and failed to recruit support staff. There is a desperate need in this area.

They cannot be magicked out of nowhere."

It would not be it be acceptable to say to parents of a child without SEN ' we can't find a teacher so your child will have to stay home/ be on a permanent part time time table.

It happened all the time during the days of Covid. Still is happening. If there is no one to teach the child then the child/ren cannot be in school, obviously. You can say it's unacceptable but that really isn't a solution, is it?

x2boys · 17/05/2022 09:49

RedHelenB · 17/05/2022 06:19

This has happened to my child without SEN twice this year as they couldn't get enough staff in due to Covid and shut different year groups down. The poster is right, if they can't get the staff, they can't get the staff.

Schools having to send pupils home because there isn't enough staff due to covid
Is completely different to a school illegally excluding a child because they can't or won't meet the child's need s

AReallyUsefulEngine · 17/05/2022 09:06

DixonD doing all she can includes not going every time the school call otherwise DD will not get the support she needs. You wouldn’t deregister if that meant your child received no help.

RedHelenB yes, twice for the whole year. Your child wasn’t discriminated against day in, day out. Not an accurate comparison.

x2boys · 17/05/2022 08:01

DixonD · 16/05/2022 23:41

I voted YABU, because I cannot imagine a time when I would not do all I can to be there for my child. I’m sure it’s not the case, but your OP reads as though you are slightly disinterested.

If a mainstream school cannot cope with her, there’s three solutions - try another mainstream with better provision, a special school, or home schooling.

Because its just that simple 🙄

Riv · 17/05/2022 07:39

*ECHP not EXHP.

www.ipsea.org.uk/Pages/Category/education-health-and-care-plans For ECHP info.

www.ipsea.org.uk/Pages/Category/service-overview Support lines contact details for advice. Be prepared to wait or make an appointment. They’re usually very busy and it’s run by (highly trained) volunteers, usually parents themselves who have been through it all so staffing is variable.

www.ipsea.org.uk/if-you-have-an-ehc-plan Steps to take if the ECHP plan is not being followed or is failing your child.

www.ipsea.org.uk/model-letters Model letters for a variety of SEN needs.

they are good and you will probably find all you need on the site. It’s very well organised but has a lot of tried and tested, very up to date information.

Morph22010 · 17/05/2022 07:14

Sockwomble · 17/05/2022 07:10

"This has happened to my child without SEN twice this year as they couldn't get enough staff in due to Covid and shut different year groups down."

Your child has been on a part time timetable for months on end and you are expected to go in at the drop of a hat to sit with them or take them home when other children in the class get to stay there all day?

Exactly, their child has not been able to go into school due to staffing issues twice in a whole year and somehow they think it’s comparable.

Sockwomble · 17/05/2022 07:10

"This has happened to my child without SEN twice this year as they couldn't get enough staff in due to Covid and shut different year groups down."

Your child has been on a part time timetable for months on end and you are expected to go in at the drop of a hat to sit with them or take them home when other children in the class get to stay there all day?

Riv · 17/05/2022 06:57

Here’s the information about legal and illegal school exclusion in the U.K..
www.ipsea.org.uk/pages/category/exclusion-from-school
chech out the rest of the site for advice on EXHP and reviews.
IPSEA - Independent Provider of Special Education Advice, offers independent legally based advice, support and training to help get the right education for children and young people. They are the go to charity. Loads of free legal advice on their website and sample letters etc. well worth a look.

Morph22010 · 17/05/2022 06:55

DixonD · 16/05/2022 23:41

I voted YABU, because I cannot imagine a time when I would not do all I can to be there for my child. I’m sure it’s not the case, but your OP reads as though you are slightly disinterested.

If a mainstream school cannot cope with her, there’s three solutions - try another mainstream with better provision, a special school, or home schooling.

That is very easy to say as a throwaway comment when you have never been in that situation. Being there for your child does not always been going in and picking them up at the drop of a hat. By doing this the op is providing a convenient solution to an immediate problem and no one has any incentive to sort out a real long term solution. My son is now in specialist but it was a massive fight with lots of evidence and involved going to tribunal. Part of our evidence was formal school exclusions. He is now doing amazingly well but if I’d carried on going to collect him every time school phoned we wouldn’t be where we are, he would no doubt still be struggling in mainstream, I’d have lost my job so we’d have no money and I’d possibly have had a nervous breakdown. It’s very easy to give your three choices like it’s some sort of simple solution but it’s very clear from your post you have absolutely no idea at all about how the system works

Luculentus · 17/05/2022 06:53

DixonD · 16/05/2022 23:41

I voted YABU, because I cannot imagine a time when I would not do all I can to be there for my child. I’m sure it’s not the case, but your OP reads as though you are slightly disinterested.

If a mainstream school cannot cope with her, there’s three solutions - try another mainstream with better provision, a special school, or home schooling.

Would you really risk your job and the roof over your heads purely to help out a school that can and should get help through the system set up for the purpose?

Luculentus · 17/05/2022 06:51

FortniteBoysMum · 16/05/2022 23:07

Tell the school unless you receive formal paperwork stating your child is excluded you will not be picking up during the school day. Literally just had this conversation with my sons school. Lasted less than 30 minutes before sent home the other day we are currently on a 5 day exclusion due to his asd and them not knowing how to deal with him in a better way. The school is shit. Thankfully we are awaiting specialist provision. Down side is only 1 school can meet needs and its an hour away. Tell the school you want an emergency ehcp review as they are not meeting their legal obligation to educate your child.

Have you been told the governors are reviewing the exclusion? I think they have to for 5 days. You should make representations to them that this was a breach of the School Exclusions Guidance and disabiity discrimination.

Morph22010 · 17/05/2022 06:43

Notagoodnight · 16/05/2022 17:55

the OP is correct when they say that the LA's are basically taking the resident parent's wishes as gospel regardless of the circumstances.

Nope. At the moment the residents parent acceptance of the status quo is convenient because its cheaper. The LEA can tick the parental preference box.

Its naive to think its anything to do with being the "main" parent.

Totally agree it’s definitely a convenient reason for la to keep her in mainstream. Its a big enough fight anyway even when both parents agree they want specialist

Morph22010 · 17/05/2022 06:37

Best piece of advice I received from sendias when my son was in mainstream is that you don’t have to go and pick up when they call. It took all the pressure off. Even if they formally exclude you don’t have to pick up immediately you have to be given notice. Sendias did say you may find that if you don’t pick up unless it’s a formal exclusion then you may find school do a longer formal exclusion say 2 days instead of the half day informal exclusion, however I didn’t find this to be the case. When you drop everything and pick up you are solving the immediate problem which gives no one any incentive to sort things out long term which isn’t doing your daughter any favours in the long run. I found then when I didn’t pick up the school somehow just managed, sometimes he was formally excluded but this was evidence towards when I went for specialist as you have to remember even if her dad decided he wanted her in specialist she most likely wouldn’t get it without a long fight

RedHelenB · 17/05/2022 06:19

Sockwomble · 16/05/2022 21:41

"It's quite likely that the school has tried and failed to recruit support staff. There is a desperate need in this area.

They cannot be magicked out of nowhere."

It would not be it be acceptable to say to parents of a child without SEN ' we can't find a teacher so your child will have to stay home/ be on a permanent part time time table.

This has happened to my child without SEN twice this year as they couldn't get enough staff in due to Covid and shut different year groups down. The poster is right, if they can't get the staff, they can't get the staff.

PickAChew · 16/05/2022 23:52

Who would do the homeschooling, given that op isn't the rp, @DixonD ?

DixonD · 16/05/2022 23:41

I voted YABU, because I cannot imagine a time when I would not do all I can to be there for my child. I’m sure it’s not the case, but your OP reads as though you are slightly disinterested.

If a mainstream school cannot cope with her, there’s three solutions - try another mainstream with better provision, a special school, or home schooling.

FortniteBoysMum · 16/05/2022 23:07

Tell the school unless you receive formal paperwork stating your child is excluded you will not be picking up during the school day. Literally just had this conversation with my sons school. Lasted less than 30 minutes before sent home the other day we are currently on a 5 day exclusion due to his asd and them not knowing how to deal with him in a better way. The school is shit. Thankfully we are awaiting specialist provision. Down side is only 1 school can meet needs and its an hour away. Tell the school you want an emergency ehcp review as they are not meeting their legal obligation to educate your child.

Luculentus · 16/05/2022 22:58

AndAsIfByMagic · 16/05/2022 21:26

It's quite likely that the school has tried and failed to recruit support staff. There is a desperate need in this area.

They cannot be magicked out of nowhere.

Then they should look at recruiting a supply teacher.
What they cannot do is insist that parents act as support staff.

AReallyUsefulEngine · 16/05/2022 21:48

Exactly Sockwomble.

If the school really cannot recruit or redeploy anyone they should put the onus on to the LA as the responsibility to make sure 1:1 (if that is specified and quantified in the EHCP) is provided rests with them. The LA may need to fund the 1:1 at a higher rate. A lack of funding and/or struggling to recruit doesn’t prevent the school from asking for an early review or incorrectly telling the OP the resident parent’s opinion counts for more either. Neither does it excuse unlawful part time timetables.

Sockwomble · 16/05/2022 21:41

"It's quite likely that the school has tried and failed to recruit support staff. There is a desperate need in this area.

They cannot be magicked out of nowhere."

It would not be it be acceptable to say to parents of a child without SEN ' we can't find a teacher so your child will have to stay home/ be on a permanent part time time table.

AndAsIfByMagic · 16/05/2022 21:26

It's quite likely that the school has tried and failed to recruit support staff. There is a desperate need in this area.

They cannot be magicked out of nowhere.

x2boys · 16/05/2022 19:38

AndAsIfByMagic · 16/05/2022 18:26

If both parents refuse what happens to the child? or the other children in the class?

If she is distressed what do people think should happen?

OP's Ex is being an absolute prick but that doesn't resolve what happens if the phone goes tomorrow. The school may have tried and failed to get support staff.

Schools are horribly underfunded and this is what is happening everywhere.

But OP needs to push for a specialist school, this can't go on.

The child has an EHCP which should detail the child's needs including 1:1 support etc
If the needs still can't be met then an emergency EHCP review needs to be called .