Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To email school about them banning any food that "may contain traces of nuts"?

315 replies

PartyGoose · 16/05/2022 15:06

Had an email last night from DD's school (it's a school that goes right through from 3-18 so covers all age groups) saying that as of today give us plenty of notice why don't you no food can be brought onto school premises that contains nuts or "may contain traces of nuts" due to a child with a severe nut allergy starting there.

I can't see how this is workable. It rules out about 50% of bought food, and 100% of food made/prepared in my kitchen as we eat a lot of nuts at home.

Obviously I am more than willing to avoid sending any food that actually has nuts in, and I'm going to take extreme care to check labels etc going forward.

But...surely they can't expect everyone to avoid anything that "may contain traces of nuts"? That's just not doable for most people.

OP posts:
starlingdarling · 16/05/2022 19:32

I don't think the school is being unreasonable. You can do your best to avoid nuts. Obviously traces of nuts isn't quite possible because companies use it as a catch all but it's perfectly possible to avoid nuts. I went to secondary school with a child who was severely allergic to nuts. It's been over 20 years and I still remember the terror of watching him have an allergic reaction. He swelled up incredibly quickly and was clawing at his own throat trying to breath while the teacher tried her best not to panic. He ended up in hospital for several days but made a full recovery. It taught us to stop being so blasé about a life threatening allergy. Several boys had joked about throwing nuts at him but they never joked about nuts again after that happened. We honestly thought he was going to die and he was very lucky he didn't.

Chouetted · 16/05/2022 19:31

Lily452 · 16/05/2022 19:14

We don’t eat may contains at all because of allergies. It’s a lot of reading and a lot of work and I wouldn’t suggest that everyone has to do it. But it’s not quite the starving situation that some people have made it out to be.

Allergy life can be really tough. I understand people being frustrated at being subjected to similar guidelines, especially when they aren’t entirely fair or necessary. I think that there are better solutions out there especially given all the various diets to consider.

But I wish that just once, one of these posts came from a place of empathy rather than outrage or inconvenience. None of us want to live like this. It’s isolating.

I think you've misunderstood the position those of us who are critical are taking. The outrage is mostly because it won't work, and it's actively dangerous

BalloonsAndWhistles · 16/05/2022 19:30

Now re-write your post as if you’re the mum of the child who has the potentially fatal nut allergy.

Then you’ll see who’s being unreasonable 🙄 🙄

Chouetted · 16/05/2022 19:29

PixieLaLa · 16/05/2022 19:25

What a fantastic lunch Hmm

Funny how you missed out all the healthier options that poster suggested isn’t it! - Breadsticks, Babybels, Choobs, sandwiches, fruit, carrot and cucumber sticks. They were all great suggestions.

Can't have sandwiches or cucumber sticks, they all may contain traces of nuts - it's unlikely all parents will comply with proper cross contamination procedures.

Once you start really looking at the implications, it's really quite restrictive.

PixieLaLa · 16/05/2022 19:25

What a fantastic lunch Hmm

Funny how you missed out all the healthier options that poster suggested isn’t it! - Breadsticks, Babybels, Choobs, sandwiches, fruit, carrot and cucumber sticks. They were all great suggestions.

GetTheGoodLookingGuy · 16/05/2022 19:20

I have a life threatening nut allergy (carry an epi-pen and all my reactions have been to traces of nuts in things I've eaten; I've never had an actual nut) and I think this is over the top.

The school I work at is still struggling to communicate/get compliance with banning actual nuts - we'd have no chance of getting people to avoid "may contains" foods. I tend to avoid may contains unless it's something I've had previously (and they haven't changed the recipie recently). I think a child would have to have an extremely severe allergy to react to people around them eating may contains products - for most people I would think banning actual nuts and getting children to wash hands after eating and wiping down tables well (especially if they eat in classrooms) should be enough.

WRT eating nut products for breakfast, I would think you're fine so long as they brush teeth and wash hands after breakfast, and maybe not eat in school uniform, particularly if the child is in their class.

I also suspect that unless your child is in the class with the child with the allergy, and you don't send food with actual nuts in, I doubt school staff are going to have time to check all the ingredients labels. If your child has chocolate spread make sure they know and can tell someone it's chocolate spread rather than nutella, though - in the school I work they all seem to say nutella when they mean any kind of chocolate spread (although I hope they do and it's not actually nutella!)

BlanketsBanned · 16/05/2022 19:18

The Head, Cook and community nurse and dietician need to hold a parents evening to discuss what can be safely eaten and bought in qnd come up with some alternatives. Anaphylaxis is very serious but there will be staff and parents who really don't know what to cook, what to have in the house and car, how allergic the child is, what poses a risk and the staff need training in recognising anaphylaxis and epipens.

Sally872 · 16/05/2022 19:18

OP realistically they can only check labels. Do your best to be sensible, and don't send in anything containing nuts, you don't have to declare your kitchen/pack lunch as guaranteed nut free.

PartyGoose · 16/05/2022 19:15

cecilthehungryspider · 16/05/2022 17:15

McVities biscuits don't tend to be "may contain" and nor is Hovis or Kingsmill bread. Walkers crisps. Kinder stuff is well labelled and they have things that are ok. Fridge raiders and peperami are ok. Penguin biscuits. Club biscuits. Tesco mini breadsticks. Mini Babybel. Crunchies. Twirls.

There is actually plenty out there (apart from Easter eggs) but you do have to do a lot of label reading. Are you on the Nut Free Food Guide on Facebook? People put finds on there all the time for new ideas. Like I said it is hard but not impossible. And I don't think it is reasonable for a school to ask people to avoid "may contain", just things that actually definitely do contain.

My DC has Wildlife choobs which are not "may contain" a sandwich, fruit and carrot and cucumber sticks.

Please do be careful with the "may contains", my DC has had anaphylactic reactions to them in the past which is why we avoid them altogether now.

Biscuits, crisps, fridge raiders, pepperami, penguins, and chocolate bars.

What a fantastic lunch Hmm

I'd really rather stick with the sort of thing we usually send, if home made food is still permitted!

OP posts:
Lily452 · 16/05/2022 19:14

We don’t eat may contains at all because of allergies. It’s a lot of reading and a lot of work and I wouldn’t suggest that everyone has to do it. But it’s not quite the starving situation that some people have made it out to be.

Allergy life can be really tough. I understand people being frustrated at being subjected to similar guidelines, especially when they aren’t entirely fair or necessary. I think that there are better solutions out there especially given all the various diets to consider.

But I wish that just once, one of these posts came from a place of empathy rather than outrage or inconvenience. None of us want to live like this. It’s isolating.

Blondeshavemorefun · 16/05/2022 19:14

email to school asking for details as to how you can support this child not to have an allergic reaction and what foods do they suggest that are on the safe list

bet they don’t give you many

InkySquid · 16/05/2022 19:11

McVities biscuits don't tend to be "may contain" and nor is Hovis or Kingsmill bread. Walkers crisps. Kinder stuff is well labelled and they have things that are ok. Fridge raiders and peperami are ok. Penguin biscuits. Club biscuits. Tesco mini breadsticks. Mini Babybel. Crunchies. Twirls.

Now try having a coeliac child or a child allergic to milk and see how much of that list is out of bounds

Sally872 · 16/05/2022 19:07

Karmabites · 16/05/2022 18:45

My child has a nut allergy and I don't give them may contains. No, they won't "starve" if I don't give them may contains, as pps have suggested. All those parents who have children with nut allergies and give their child "may contain traces" , and are quite boastful about it , 99 times out if 100 you might be okay but that one time you might not be so lucky. If you want to take that risk, thats fine, it's your child and if anything were to happen to them it will be on you, but you should not take or advocate taking the risk with other peoples children. There are plenty of consumables that don't contain traces. One just needs to make a little effort. To all those arrogant parents whose children don't have allergies and find the schools request ridiculous, be thankful that your child can gobble up anything they want but be mindful that allergies can come about suddenly and at any age, so be humble, you or your child could be next.

@Karmabites do you believe your child is at risk from another child eating a may contains nearby? I have a child with peanut allergy we never give them may contains, but we do have them in the house for others to eat. If there is a trace (which is unlikely) the chance of it touching something my allergic child will then eat is not possible.

myfifyhun · 16/05/2022 19:06

A child in my son's (secondary school) class had a full blown anaphylactic reaction having borrowed a marker pen from a child who had been handling almonds 2 hours previously. I used to think it was ridiculous until I realised how much responsibility that child's parents must be carrying every day. I'd be terrified.

tempester28 · 16/05/2022 19:06

The school should check first whether this child does eat the "may contain nuts" items before banning those items in addition to nuts as it would make quite a difference. Nut allergies are no joke so ultimately you have to accept it but also I think you will find that many nut allergy sufferers do eat items that say "may contain nuts" where it is in fact that the factory the food is made in also produces food that contains nuts.

PartyGoose · 16/05/2022 19:05

@Aprilx You sound very unsympathetic regarding this child with a life threatening allergy. You just need to use your common sense and don’t send anything that with nuts in. That’s all, it’s not rocket science.

I'M NOT GOING TO SEND ANYTHING WITH FUCKING NUTS IN

Sorry for shouting but I've said this at least 3 times on this thread and still people don't seem to be reading what I'm actually saying.

But I have questions about the banning of anything that "may contain traces" (which would mean a ban on any home cooked food for most families) and apparently so does a leading anaphylaxis organisation so yes, I'll be emailing school to clarify it.

No nuts = sensible, fair, proportionate, I'm in agreement!

No food that "may contain traces of nuts" - a massive PITA for most people and I want to know if this is really what they mean!

OP posts:
JustLyra · 16/05/2022 19:05

strict no swapping food rule

this is one of the key rules in DD’s school. Touching other children’s food is one of the major rules and carries heavy sanction.

This has been strictly in place ever since a child had a major reaction a chicken crisp swapped with another kid (turned out they were cooked in nut oil).

ZoyaTheDestroyer · 16/05/2022 19:04

whenwillthemadnessend · 16/05/2022 18:55

As a mother of a nut allergy sufferer I do feel
This is ott

Dd can not consume nuts and we are lucky she never reacts to others eating them in the same room.

She eats may
Contain herself

So I appreciate we are lucky

But
This school
Seems
To be going way over what's needed

Contact anaphylaxis.com for advise.

I’m sorry, I don’t mean to make light of a serious post, but whatever MN’s formatting has done to your message has made it read exactly like a William Carlos Williams poem Grin

Shamplade · 16/05/2022 19:03

Tryhard40 · 16/05/2022 15:10
I think what they basically mean is "don't send in nutty cereal bars /things with proper nuts in". They are not going to ban your dd from entering school if she has a peanut butter sandwich for breakfast or whatever. How could they, they wouldn't even know?
**
Just be sensible.

HRTFT but just in case no one else picked you up on this, peanut butter sandwiches would NOT be ok.

If a child has a serious nut allergy, that means potentially fatal. So it’s actually really important to take what the school are saying VERY seriously. Unless you are happy to risk causing the death of a child because you wanted your child to have peanut butter.

JustLyra · 16/05/2022 19:02

Every nursery/school has this policy and your school is merely reinforcing it.

that’s not remotely true.

Many now realise that those policies are unhelpful and follow guidance about working around allergies rather than being complacent (which happens with a ban).

ZoyaTheDestroyer · 16/05/2022 19:02

A lot of posters are missing the point.

The rule is unenforceable. To enforce it would require every label in every child’s lunchbox to be carefully checked, and that’s before you consider home-made products. How are you going to check if a sandwich has been made with bread that may contain nuts?

Any rule is totally meaningless if it can’t be enforced and this will lead to complacency, and people completely ignoring the rule because they know it won’t be enforced. Much more effective is a less restrictive set of rules which are strictly upheld:

  • lunchtime supervisors walk around checking lunchboxes. Parents contacted if they have sent in nuts or legumes.
  • strict no swapping food rule
  • all children wash their hands before and after eating and all surfaces wiped down (which should be happening for basic hygiene anyway)
PartyGoose · 16/05/2022 18:59

badhappening · 16/05/2022 18:06

You obviously haven't seen a child having an anaphylactic shock.

You won't be so ignorant if that day ever comes.

Every nursery/school has this policy and your school is merely reinforcing it.

Don't complain because you'll just show yourself up.

Please, tell me exactly where and how I'm "being ignorant"?

OP posts:
PartyGoose · 16/05/2022 18:58

Muffinsorcrumpets · 16/05/2022 18:21

@cecilthehungryspider

Kinder now make large Easter eggs that are nut-free and the Kinnerton ones work too of course - Tesco had a Crayola egg with Kinnerton chocolate this year.

Right so are you suggesting I send a sodding Easter egg as my child's packed lunch? I'm not sure I know of much else out there that guarantees absolutely zero potential nut contamination Confused

OP posts:
AgeingDoc · 16/05/2022 18:57

Many still die despite adrenaline being administered
Actually, they don't. People do die of course, but not "many".
I've got 2 allergic children and I worked in Intensive Care Medicine for 30+ years so I have probably got more experience of anaphylaxis than most, and I am not intending to trivialise it. It's horrible, terrifying to treat and worse to experience - but things need to be kept in perspective. People are not dropping dead all over the place from food related allergies.
There was an excellent review article in the BMJ last year showing that although rates of hospital admission are going up, death rates have decreased significantly. www.bmj.com/content/372/bmj.n251
It's very interesting to find that the commonly held belief (and I did think the same) that deaths from food allergy are rapidly increasing is just not true. More people are reacting, but better recognition and treatment mean the percentage who die is actually falling.
There were 187 documented fatalities from food related anaphylaxis in the years 1992-2018 - just under half were nut or peanut related. Of those deaths, 66 were in school aged children, and the most frequent causative allergen was cows' milk.
For context, over 1400 people died as a result of road traffic collisions in 2020 alone, and more children die from cancer every year in the UK than all the paediatric food allergy deaths recorded over the 26 years of this review.
Obviously that is no consolation to the families who have lost loved ones, and of course it is right to take reasonable precautions to protect people, but the data just do not support the idea that children are dying because a school mate in another class eats a biscuit that may contain nut traces at lunch.
Someone mentioned planes earlier. They are a special case, partly because of the air circulation systems, but as a PP mentioned, it's now thought that a significant proportion of reactions on flights are due to direct contact not airborne particles. Fast turnaround times mean that hygiene standards on board planes are not great. Tray tables and seats are often not cleaned, blankets get resused by multiple passengers between washes, and so on. So if an airline is not permanently nut free there's always a chance that nut particles are present on surfaces which the allergic person then touches with their hands or their own food and accidentally ingests. It will be interesting to see if enhanced cleaning post covid decreases these issues.
As schools are also not super hygenic places, it makes sense to prevent actual nuts being brought in as much as possible. But banning all items labelled as possibly cross contaminated with nuts seems excessive.
I don't suppose anyone has accurately calculated the risk of death to an allergic child from a schoolmate's lunch as it's probably impossible to do so. But if you consider how improbable the chances are that a product labelled may contain actually does contain a significant amount of nuts, the likelihood that a child eating such a product leaves enough residue somewhere that an allergic child in a completely different class comes into contact with it in sufficient quantities to cause a reaction and the quoted death rate of around 0.2%- 0.3% of those who are unwell enough to be admitted to hospital with anaphylaxis, then the overall risk must be very small indeed.
Not I hasten to add, am I advocating ignoring the issue, and I understand very well the anxiety of leaving a child at risk of anaphylaxis in an uncontrolled environment, but there have to be limits on what restrictions are attempted. Make the school nut free, ok. Maybe even have tighter restrictions in the child's specific class if there is genuine evidence that they are so sensitive that a "may contain nuts" item poses a real threat.
But to attempt to make an entire 3-18 school follow those rules is almost certainly unnecessary, and futile. People don't follow rules they view as excessively restrictive so they will start breaking them. Then if they don't see any adverse effects, they break them some more, which may well lead to actual nut products being brought in and a real risk developing.
It is an illogical knee jerk reaction on the part of the school in my opinion. It won't achieve what they hope and does not absolve them from the responsibility to provide appropriate care and supervision for the allergic child/ren. Time would be much better spent on delivering the Anaphylaxis Campaign's allergy awareness courses than trying to control the entire school's diet.

whenwillthemadnessend · 16/05/2022 18:55

As a mother of a nut allergy sufferer I do feel
This is ott

Dd can not consume nuts and we are lucky she never reacts to others eating them in the same room.

She eats may
Contain herself

So I appreciate we are lucky

But
This school
Seems
To be going way over what's needed

Contact anaphylaxis.com for advise.