Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To email school about them banning any food that "may contain traces of nuts"?

315 replies

PartyGoose · 16/05/2022 15:06

Had an email last night from DD's school (it's a school that goes right through from 3-18 so covers all age groups) saying that as of today give us plenty of notice why don't you no food can be brought onto school premises that contains nuts or "may contain traces of nuts" due to a child with a severe nut allergy starting there.

I can't see how this is workable. It rules out about 50% of bought food, and 100% of food made/prepared in my kitchen as we eat a lot of nuts at home.

Obviously I am more than willing to avoid sending any food that actually has nuts in, and I'm going to take extreme care to check labels etc going forward.

But...surely they can't expect everyone to avoid anything that "may contain traces of nuts"? That's just not doable for most people.

OP posts:
Pickabearanybear · 17/05/2022 11:24

This reply has been withdrawn

Message from MNHQ: This post has been withdrawn

Imaginary · 17/05/2022 10:51

YANBU
Why does everyone has to suffer because of one person?
It's ridiculous. That child should know not to eat other kids's lunches.

Muffinsorcrumpets · 17/05/2022 10:31

Also, as others have said too, @theobligatorynamechange, I don't have any real problems buying nut-free products in the supermarket. It takes some adjustment at first, but there are plenty of products out there that are safe to eat if you look for them.

So we're not at all miserable and we don't expect anyone to indulge us either.

Muffinsorcrumpets · 17/05/2022 09:57

@theobligatorynamechange

Force other parents to pointlessly police their food in this way, and with the amount of resentment that will build up, they're more likely to snap and stop checking at all. And that's when accidents happen.
I think I've made it clèar in my comments on this thread that the 'may contain nuts' thing is only relevant to people who actually have a nut-allergy, and not to people like the OP. I've already said I think the school has got it wrong here.

It doesn't sound like you have any direct experience of living with allergies. If you're the parent of a small child with allergies, trust me, you and your child will have a very different attitude later down the line.
My child has been living with allergies (nuts and others) for 15 years now so we've quite a bit of experience at this stage.

Anyone with a real allergy knows 'may contain nuts' is a ridiculous legal disclaimer that helps no one. Companies slap it on everything to avoid being sued, even if the changes of coming across nuts are practically non-existent.
You are wrong. Anaphylaxis groups say that eating the 'may contain' products if you have an allergy is risky. The risk any one time may be small, but if you eat these products consistently, then the probability is you'll react sooner or later.

Studies have shown than a certain percentage of foods labelled this way actually do contain nuts or nut traces ( between 5 - 8% of at least some batches of the products, depending on the study iirc). And yes, sometimes companies slap on the label to cover themselves. And sometimes they don't and there actually is a risk. In some cases, different products are manufactured using the same equipment at different times. So say, a chocolate bar with nuts is made, and then a chocolate bar without nuts. The first batches of the plain bar off the equipment are far more likely to have nuts or traces than are later ones. Thus you can eat that brand regularly and all's fine - until one day it isn't. (I've personally found a big chunk of nut in a supposedly plain chocolate bar.)
The problem for allergic consumers is that it's hard to tell which companies are giving genuine warnings and which are not. And there's really lots of products around where you don't have to take that risk.
I think you're giving people dangerous advice here @theobligatorynamechange, I really do.

WalkingOnTheCracks · 17/05/2022 09:19

InkySquid · 16/05/2022 15:32

I've just looked at some oatcakes - they say made in a factory that is nut free but cannot guarantee nut free. Ok or not?

This is an 'unexpected consequences' thing, and it's dangerous. The intention was to make life safer for nut-allergic people by insisting manufacturers make it clear on the packaging if a product contains nuts.

So then, if the packaging doesn't say it contains nuts, it doesn't contain nuts. That was the intention, any way.

But if you're a manufacturer, you've now got the choice between spending thousands and thousands of pounds on processes and machinery to make sure there are no nuts in your product, or spend next to nothing changing the label to say that it may contain nuts. Of course, the second option is easier, cheaper and safer.

So now there are many products that almost certainly don't contain nuts that say on the packaging 'may contain nuts'.

And of course nut-allergic people know this, and make their own assessment as to whether the product really contains nuts. Otherwise they'd be avoiding a lot of perfectly safe products. On the other hand, they're not getting reliable information, so at some point they're likely to make a mistak.

The whole process is not only useless, it's actually made things riskier for people with a nut allergy.

theobligatorynamechange · 17/05/2022 08:15

Ikeptgoing · 16/05/2022 22:01

Just try your best and don't feed DCs nuts before they go into school or send in nutty food for them

Try to send in foods that contain no nuts or nut oil, you can't control for the "may contain traces of nuts as that's most things (I have peanut allergy and know full well how much food suppliers "cover" themselves) .

Just be careful as there is a child with a severe nut allergy attending school. The child's parents must be very anxious as it'll be an anaphylactic level of allergy for school to send this letter out

Oh, someone's certainly very anxious. Not sure if it's the parents or the school, but this level of anxiety is not healthy.

The allergy is likely to last the whole child's life. They can't live this way forever, it's just no way to live.

As you and I know, food suppliers cover themselves to the point where their disclaimers are unhelpful, and you have to actually read the list of ingredients yourself to work out whether there's an actual danger. But having a real allergy and managing to survive to adulthood with one apparently won't satisfy some of the anxious parents on this thread...

theobligatorynamechange · 17/05/2022 08:11

Muffinsorcrumpets · 16/05/2022 20:46

Cut out nuts and 'may contain traces of' and nut allergy sufferers would starve.

No.
No, they wouldn't.
And you're taking a risk if you eat food labelled ''may contain traces' if you have a nut allergy.
A small risk maybe, but a risk nevertheless.

Just because a bar of chocolate labelled as such is okay ninety-nine times out of a hundred, doesn't mean it'll be okay the hundredth time.

It's a choice to take that risk and that's fine, but don't tell people it's a choice they have to make or they'll starve, because that's just complete rubbish. It really is.

I'm actually a bit shocked at the number of people on here who say they are feeding their nut allergic children food labelled 'may contain nuts'.

Anyone with a real allergy knows 'may contain nuts' is a ridiculous legal disclaimer that helps no one. Companies slap it on everything to avoid being sued, even if the changes of coming across nuts are practically non-existent.

You know, life has traces of nuts. People eat nuts on public transport and wipe their grubby hands on the upholstery. You can't avoid the risk of nuts unless you literally live in a bubble, and that's a miserable existence, reserved only for the people who react to dust in the air rather than direct touch or consumption.

It doesn't sound like you have any direct experience of living with allergies. If you're the parent of a small child with allergies, trust me, you and your child will have a very different attitude later down the line. Plenty of people have already posted on this thread to agree with me that avoiding those disclaimer is no way to live.

Having allergies in the UK is not a big deal and you have to learn to live to it so you still enjoy a decent life. Having to ignore some bullshit disclaimers is a very small inconvenience. Coping with allergies in foreign countries is way more of a major adjustment (and plain impossible in some of them).

Maybe I'm using hyperbole when I say people will starve if don't eat food with the disclaimer on it, but they'll certainly have a miserable time of it. It's a big enough drag making sure your food doesn't have any actual nuts in it.

If you're going to be ridiculous about your disclaimers, don't expect other people to indulge you. And TBH, I think you're doing more harm than good. Force other parents to pointlessly police their food in this way, and with the amount of resentment that will build up, they're more likely to snap and stop checking at all. And that's when accidents happen.

Ponderingwindow · 17/05/2022 00:14

Death isn’t really the only reaction that needs to be prevented. A reaction significant enough to interfere with a student’s ability to learn prevents the student from getting an education and represents a problem from a discrimination standpoint.

A school-wide ‘’ may contains’ ban may or may not be necessary, I really don’t know because we don’t know the school Arrangement or the child’s condition, but the child does have a right to an education free from allergic reactions even if those reactions don’t result in death.

PestorPeston · 16/05/2022 22:07

'Free From' stuff we tried tastes like sadness. totally

GenderCriticalTrumpets · 16/05/2022 22:02

Ah yeah my apologies I was only working from our nut allergy point of view.

Separate note - all the 'Free From' stuff we tried tastes like sadness.

Ikeptgoing · 16/05/2022 22:02

megletthesecond · 16/05/2022 16:20

Yanbu. I have a child who carries an epi-pen.
SO many products are labelled as 'may contain nuts' it would be impossible to tighten it up that much.

As long as they aren't bringing nut products in then I think that's all they can ask.

This ^

Ikeptgoing · 16/05/2022 22:01

Just try your best and don't feed DCs nuts before they go into school or send in nutty food for them

Try to send in foods that contain no nuts or nut oil, you can't control for the "may contain traces of nuts as that's most things (I have peanut allergy and know full well how much food suppliers "cover" themselves) .

Just be careful as there is a child with a severe nut allergy attending school. The child's parents must be very anxious as it'll be an anaphylactic level of allergy for school to send this letter out

LittleOwl153 · 16/05/2022 21:53

My biggest issue with this kind of ban is the impact on the diet of all the other kids. And I'm not just talking about the protein advantages of nuts as many pp have highlighted.

Last week I was working through a budget with someone who had turned up for help at our foodbank. I was amazed at her shopping bill until she told me that her children's primary school had taken this same line - no nut traces as well as no Kiwi. Which had left this mother spending half her food budget on school lunches for 3 kids as they had to meet all these requirements. (She had no choice because the kids weren't eligible for FSM and she couldn't afford to pay for them at £7.50 a day or £37.50 a week). Her food budget for her family of 5 was £60 a week. She'd tried doing the foodbank favourites of homemade flapjack - porridge, butter and sugar as a filler - it got taken off the kids because it might contain nuts. Another day they had cheese sandwiches taken off them because 'somebody' decided the bread looked nutty - it wasn't it was basic brown (YS) bread. That day they gave the kids school meals - and told her she had to pay for it afterwards (and buy more bread for the next day).

I do absolutely feel for these kids and life is going to be tough for them. But schools really do have to think about how their rules impact others. Yes it's not nice to separate the allergy kid for lunch - but they are going to have to learn to eat differently to their friends. But it's also not nice to not have enough money to feed your family because the only way you kid can eat in school is by spending half your food budget on prepackaged expensive foods - and this in many areas will impact hundreds of times more kids.

InkySquid · 16/05/2022 21:52

Chunky kit kat have a may contain peanut and free nut warning on them, I think regular kit kats don't.

Most of that list is again not suitable for coeliacs, including kit kats.

PestorPeston · 16/05/2022 21:51

@GenderCriticalTrumpets almost everything on your good to eat list contains or may contain my severe allergens: soy and milk.

A request to not have nuts in lunches - fine
A reminder that Nutella and many chocolate spreads contain nuts - fine
For severe allergies a request of no nuts for breakfast or teeth cleaning and handwashing - OK in extreme circumstances
May contain - really not workable.

My mother hand a severe allergy to the Solanaceae family (potatoes, tomatoes, chillies, peppers, paprika, aubergines) plus coeliacs disease. She had to accept that it was her responsibility to safe guard herself.

Nobody here has been unwilling to take two steps to the left to protect a child while they develop their own safe guarding skills. But banning all may contain foods is unreasonable.

saraclara · 16/05/2022 21:47

BalloonsAndWhistles · 16/05/2022 19:30

Now re-write your post as if you’re the mum of the child who has the potentially fatal nut allergy.

Then you’ll see who’s being unreasonable 🙄 🙄

Several parents of children with anaphylactic nut allergies have posted here in support of the OP. Because they know it's an unreasonable ask, and they know that because it's so close to impossible to confirm to, parents will break the rule, and then end up sending stuff that ACTUALLY contains nuts, therefore putting those poster's children at more risk.

User56785 · 16/05/2022 21:45

Bloody Kit Kats! My dc had the worst cross contamination reaction ever to a Kit Kat. Aren't there peanut butter Kit Kats. I wouldn't know as obviously I don't buy them any more.

saraclara · 16/05/2022 21:33

Have you actually read the OP and many responses? The school is not going nut free. It's going 'no foods where the packaging says "may contain traces of nuts" ' which simply means food produced in a factory that might have nuts elsewhere in the building. Just like our own kitchens.

It's close to impossible then, to send in foods that 'may contain traces of nuts' because in addition to must supermarket labels saying that, if you have any nuts on your kitchen anywhere, then every single thing you send in with your own child, 'may' contain traces of nuts.

GenderCriticalTrumpets · 16/05/2022 21:30

Totally confused at what people are finding difficult about finding food that doesnt have "may contain". Off the top of my head DS has kitkats, caramel wafers, McCoy's crisps, baby bel, peperami, fruit, a cheese sandwich with a bread roll... loads of other snacks. Its really easy to feed him now we know to check everything. Most beige buffet stuff doesn't have "may contain" either

Ben and Jerry's ice cream used to be nut free but recently changed grrrr. So I get a different brand and make my own cookie dough to shove in.

DS is far from starving

splishsplashsploshsplish · 16/05/2022 21:28

I certainly understand where you are coming from OP and would do as you are.
DH's family have many life threatening allergies and when we are in close contact or they are visiting us we do our best. But we all eat at restaurants together and go to parties together.

The school will be prepared with the required medical instructions and the teachers will be well informed.
I would email the school for further clarification, if you feel it is needed. (I personally would, just for reassurance).

Doing what you can is the best that you can do. Good luck!

GenderCriticalTrumpets · 16/05/2022 21:25

Muffinsorcrumpets · 16/05/2022 20:46

Cut out nuts and 'may contain traces of' and nut allergy sufferers would starve.

No.
No, they wouldn't.
And you're taking a risk if you eat food labelled ''may contain traces' if you have a nut allergy.
A small risk maybe, but a risk nevertheless.

Just because a bar of chocolate labelled as such is okay ninety-nine times out of a hundred, doesn't mean it'll be okay the hundredth time.

It's a choice to take that risk and that's fine, but don't tell people it's a choice they have to make or they'll starve, because that's just complete rubbish. It really is.

I'm actually a bit shocked at the number of people on here who say they are feeding their nut allergic children food labelled 'may contain nuts'.

God, same. I check every single thing my DS eats, even if he has eaten it before because sneaky companies like to change things. Although it's a faff it is absolutely fine - he has crisps, biscuits, ice cream, all sorts. We just check the label and I make most things from scratch.

The reaction he had to eating peanuts a few years ago was the most terrifying moment of my life and one I'm not in a rush to repeat.

sheepandcaravan · 16/05/2022 21:19

Op I agree with you, I could do no more than you say.

But, what are the school doing? I'm rural Scotland, 70 in school, plus five nursery. Lots of allergies. Nobody sends packed lunches. I'm assuming it's different England? But here there are say four a day to chose and I'm looking now and no way they would all comply. Some might, but even bread seeing peoples comments here?

AxolotlEars · 16/05/2022 21:04

The only way to completely ensure this is to buy "free from food" ...we certainly could not afford this. However I know how dangerous anaphylaxis is so would prefer to stick to the guidelines to protect those who are vulnerable. Others have commented on whether this is really the advice that is suggested by organisations/help groups.

YouHaventDoneAnyWork · 16/05/2022 21:03

I understand what you’re saying OP.

It sounds to me like the school have potentially been clumsy in their wording and this needs clarifying. As it’s currently stated it’s unreasonable in the sense it’s not realistic. If they intended this worded that’s crazy because again it’s not realistic.

To seek clarification is neither unfeeling nor creating chaos for schools. Teachers won’t be yanked out of class for this, it will be handled be the school office team.

PestorPeston · 16/05/2022 21:02

IDidntKnowItWasAParty · 16/05/2022 17:24

Virtually every item in the supermarket has a disclaimer 'may contain' or similar, just to cover themselves. If you ruled out all of those, there's very little left to bring in!
BTW if anyone needs a nut-free peanut butter alternative, we use Wow Butter made from soybeans for DC's school sandwiches.

That's me hitting the epi pen or maybe I have just developed fastidious food hygiene practises.

Much better that you have a no nuts policy and remind people that Nutella contains nuts.

May contain drives us all mad.