Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To email school about them banning any food that "may contain traces of nuts"?

315 replies

PartyGoose · 16/05/2022 15:06

Had an email last night from DD's school (it's a school that goes right through from 3-18 so covers all age groups) saying that as of today give us plenty of notice why don't you no food can be brought onto school premises that contains nuts or "may contain traces of nuts" due to a child with a severe nut allergy starting there.

I can't see how this is workable. It rules out about 50% of bought food, and 100% of food made/prepared in my kitchen as we eat a lot of nuts at home.

Obviously I am more than willing to avoid sending any food that actually has nuts in, and I'm going to take extreme care to check labels etc going forward.

But...surely they can't expect everyone to avoid anything that "may contain traces of nuts"? That's just not doable for most people.

OP posts:
Benjispruce4 · 16/05/2022 16:38

M&S are the worst with the labelling. Such a cop-out!

forlornlorna1 · 16/05/2022 16:36

I'm mom to a dd with a severe nut allergy.

If we didn't buy anything that had "may contain nuts" we'd probably starve lol jk.

Seriously though tescos have bottled water atm that says may contain nuts!

AlternativePerspective · 16/05/2022 16:35

The anaphylaxis society actively advise against nut bans. The reason why is because children then grow up without taking responsibility for their allergies, and the result is that they become complacent as they’ve never had to think about it, and then the number of anaphylactic reactions increase significantly in secondary school where it simply isn’t possible to ban nuts or nut products.

My DS was in a class with a lad who had a peanut allergy, and he had 3 reactions in his first term at secondary.

Children need to learn from an early age that they need to ask if something contains nuts if they’re unsure, that they shouldn’t be accepting food from others, and to make people aware that they have a peanut allergy.

Banning nuts is just lazy. There are several other allergies which can be as severe, but nuts are good headline grabbers plus it would be impossible to ban dairy or eggs for instance, so nuts are an easy target.

Benjispruce4 · 16/05/2022 16:33

My DD has a nut allergy, though not severe. Even though school were aware she often had to deal with teachers bringing in cakes for parties with almonds in them, a prize for a reading challenge? Peanut M&Ms!!!!!
Please spare a thought for the child and family and just don’t send in nuts. Traces is a bit ridiculous though.

MrsAvocet · 16/05/2022 16:31

BigFatLiar · 16/05/2022 16:28

I remember looking a the print on a bag of peanuts and it saying warning may contain nuts

Peanuts aren't nuts - they are legumes. Presumably the factory also handles tree nuts so will be legally required to warn of potential nut contamination. Peanut and tree nut allergies are different things.

MrsAvocet · 16/05/2022 16:29

I think it's unreasonable - and I have a child who is anaphylactic to a number of things including all tree nuts and peanuts.
"May contain" is basically a get out of jail free card for manufacturers so that if they have any nuts in the same factory etc they can say "we told you so" if there is any cross contamination. So it is on lots and lots of things which almost certainly don't contain nuts. Asking a large group of people who have nothing personal to lose to follow such restrictions is bound to fail.
It is one thing for a nut allergic person and their family to exclude "may contain" products (and even that is not always necessary) but I think asking an entire school to do so is probably both excessive and unworkable.
The chances of a child in one year group being harmed by a child in a totally different year group in what sounds like a big school consuming a product that might, but probably doesn't, contain traces of nuts is very small. I can't see that it would be any more risk than passing someone in the street who had recently eaten the same thing. We cannot control the whole environment and people with allergies probably encounter those who are eating or have recently eaten their allergens every time they use public transport or go into a public place. If a child in year R has an allergy, telling year 13 they can't have something labelled "may contain" for breakfast is unreasonable. In fact the danger is that by making the restrictions so onerous, people just ignore them completely - its quite tough even if you are highly motivated, and the vast majority won't be. So potentially the risk for the allergic child actually increases if very strict exclusions are attempted.

MintJulia · 16/05/2022 16:28

The school is doing their best and asking you to be careful too. In our school it is nuts and certain fruit.

it's pretty easy to make food at home that is nut free, and crisps, apples, plums, bottles of water etc are safe. No-one is expecting lab conditions.

BigFatLiar · 16/05/2022 16:28

SleeplessInEngland · 16/05/2022 16:25

It's just the school covering its arse. Almost every food product 'may contain traces of nuts' so the makers don't get sued. Just don't send in anything that's obviously nutty.

I remember looking a the print on a bag of peanuts and it saying warning may contain nuts

SleeplessInEngland · 16/05/2022 16:25

It's just the school covering its arse. Almost every food product 'may contain traces of nuts' so the makers don't get sued. Just don't send in anything that's obviously nutty.

ZoyaTheDestroyer · 16/05/2022 16:23

YANBU and I say this as the parent of a peanut-allergic child. The rule is impractical and unenforceable. It needs to be much simpler - no peanuts or tree nuts, and no swapping of food from lunchboxes.

BigFatLiar · 16/05/2022 16:21

Ask the school for examples of what they consider will make a healthy nutritional lunch for a child and be nut free.

Do they provide school lunches?

ginnybag · 16/05/2022 16:21

I have a friend who is allergic to potatoes.

Even being in the same room with a potato product will cause swelling, breathing difficulties, skin rashes, the whole nine yards. Just breathing the air of a room with anything potato based in it - so someone opening a packet of crisps in her vicinity - and she's potentially reaching for the epi-pen (which is not a safe option for her, because she has multiple health issues).

Substitute 'Nut' for 'potato' and imagine this policy applied to that. No potato based or potato containing anything in the building at all - in a primary school.

It's easy to say, yes, but no-one needs to eat nuts, but for vegans and those with dairy or gluten issues and allergies, nuts form a large part of the substitutes. And it remains the case that what is applied to one should be applied to all, so:

Nuts
Milk
Fish
Potatoes
Tomatoes
Gelatine
Pork
Beef
Gluten (so wheat)

Those are all in the circle of people I know, all to a serious, time in hospital, call an ambulance level.

Vegan/vegetarian/religious diets, and I don't know what's left to feed kids. Plain pasta, maybe?

Allergy aware is better than allergy ban, and the school should be actively managing it rather than left-shouldering to parents and then wringing their hands saying, 'but we told them!' when it all goes wrong.

Theluggage15 · 16/05/2022 16:20

It’s just the school being lazy. So much easier for them to tick a box and say they’ve done all they can by sending this, even though it’s unworkable. As PPs have said, they should be following the advice of Anaphylaxis U.K.

megletthesecond · 16/05/2022 16:20

Yanbu. I have a child who carries an epi-pen.
SO many products are labelled as 'may contain nuts' it would be impossible to tighten it up that much.

As long as they aren't bringing nut products in then I think that's all they can ask.

Tdcp · 16/05/2022 16:15

DDs school is nut free. It basically means don't send in food that obviously has nuts in it i.e nutty cereal bars, peanut butter, chocolate spread etc. It hasn't been a big deal at all but please don't just send children in with something obviously nutty anyway because a child at our school went into anaphylaxis at dinner time the other week because someone had bought in a peanut butter sandwich and their parents said they didn't agree with the rules which is why they did it...

cattanoogacats · 16/05/2022 16:14

My children have attended 5 schools between them and they have all been nut free. It seems to be fairly standard practice where I live. I'm happy to stick to it even though one of my children has ARFID and peanut butter is one of the only sources of protein he will eat. I know that a potentially fatal reaction is way more serious than diet restrictions. Also with children with SN it can be more difficult to enforce rules to stop cross contamination.

However, none have them have gone as far as to ban food which "may contain traces of nuts". I think this is unworkable and hasn't really been thought through properly, so you are not unreasonable to email.

Mally100 · 16/05/2022 16:13

Yanbu, first I adhered to the rules of no nuts but then noticed other kidd bringing in items that did have trace of them. It makes it incredibly difficult to be so strict, my ds is a very picky eater (sensory issues) so restricting his diet even further caused many issues for us. I just stick to no nuts but include items that contain trace.

PartyGoose · 16/05/2022 16:11

musicviking1 · 16/05/2022 16:07

I think some compassion could be a consideration here. My son has a sesame seed and chickpea allergy, he does food tech at school and it's an absolute nightmare to get the teachers to understand just how dangerous his allergy is. Frequently he's told to make food which contain sesame or chickpeas, he has even been told off for not washing up someone else's pots who had used chickpeas. Like someone else said thank your lucky stars that your child doesn’t have a life-threatening allergy.

What have I said or done that is not compassionate?

Your son's school sounds appalling, but I'm not suggesting I send peanut butter sarnies or almond milk smoothies, am I? It's hardly comparable.

Unsure how much clearer I need to be here but once again I will avoid sending any food that has nuts in, I will check labels, and I will try and avoid cross contamination in my nut-using kitchen

I'm just not sure if that's good enough given the request from school to avoid anything that may contain traces of nuts!!

OP posts:
lanthanum · 16/05/2022 16:11

I suspect it's far more important to make sure that children (especially those in that class) clean their teeth and wash their hands after their breakfast if that contains any nuts.

Banning all "may contain traces of..." products is not going to work - that's on so many things just to cover the manufactuers' backs.

SavoyCabbage · 16/05/2022 16:10

Could he wash the dishes if the ingredients had said 'may contain traces of chickpeas'? That's what we are talking about here. They

Midlifemusings · 16/05/2022 16:08

cecilthehungryspider · 16/05/2022 15:51

I love all the comments saying it is "impossible" what do you think people with nut allergies eat?! My DC doesn't eat anything that says "may contain" they used to but after having several reactions we stopped it and there haven't been any reactions since (touch wood) for several years now. It is hard but it is not impossible.

All that said I prefer the Anaphylaxis Campaign approach of being "allergy aware" rather than banning lots of foods. Banning foods can create a false sense of security with the child believing that all food in school is safe but there will always be times that people do bring things in that they can't have. It is better to teach the child from a very young age how to check and be safe themselves. I don't think it is unreasonable to ask that children don't bring in foods that contain nuts, we know children aren't the best at washing hands, but I don't think it is necessary to ban "may contain" foods as well. I suspect this has been done at the request of an (understandably) anxious parent and not properly thought through.

OP perhaps you could direct the school to the Anaphylaxis Campaign website for resources on how to manage it in school?

So what would you do if your school said no dairy, no eggs, no wheat, no tree nuts, no peanuts, no soy. Would you stop shopping for any products that had those ingredients and no longer bring any of them into your home just to be sure no one ever took it to school? Managing your own home for your own child is very different than being expected to take into account an entire school full of children and all their particular needs when feeding your family.

musicviking1 · 16/05/2022 16:07

I think some compassion could be a consideration here. My son has a sesame seed and chickpea allergy, he does food tech at school and it's an absolute nightmare to get the teachers to understand just how dangerous his allergy is. Frequently he's told to make food which contain sesame or chickpeas, he has even been told off for not washing up someone else's pots who had used chickpeas. Like someone else said thank your lucky stars that your child doesn’t have a life-threatening allergy.

savoycabbage · 16/05/2022 16:06

@cecilthehungryspider my dd does have a nut allergy. She's anaphylactic. I still think it's almost impossible to send a child to school every day with a packed lunch with no foods labelled 'may contain traces of nuts'.

What are these foods? What bread? What biscuit?

Midlifemusings · 16/05/2022 16:03

"May contain traces of nuts" is just a CYA packaging strategy by companies. It doens't mean there are any nuts in it or that it even came in close contact iwth nuts. They put that on many things now - even if the company has nuts somewhee int he factory even if no where near that asesembly line, they might say may contain traces of nuts. It isn't reasonable to not bring in "may contain traces of nuts". Completely different from a product that has a small amount of nuts in it.

Nut free has been shown to not decrease incidents of allergic reactions and in some cases it increases it. There is no proven benefit to anyone to being nut free.

savehannah · 16/05/2022 16:02

I totally agree with the anaphylaxis council on this. People have severe allergies to all sorts of things and we cannot demand the whole world stops eating nuts eggs milk bananas etc etc etc so that a person with a severe allergy can live a risk free life. Much more important that a child with an allergy is taught from a young age never to share food, ask people to wash hands after eating food etc. Unfortunate though a severe allergy is, it is ultimately for the person with the allergy and their family to deal with not everyone else.

Swipe left for the next trending thread