Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To email school about them banning any food that "may contain traces of nuts"?

315 replies

PartyGoose · 16/05/2022 15:06

Had an email last night from DD's school (it's a school that goes right through from 3-18 so covers all age groups) saying that as of today give us plenty of notice why don't you no food can be brought onto school premises that contains nuts or "may contain traces of nuts" due to a child with a severe nut allergy starting there.

I can't see how this is workable. It rules out about 50% of bought food, and 100% of food made/prepared in my kitchen as we eat a lot of nuts at home.

Obviously I am more than willing to avoid sending any food that actually has nuts in, and I'm going to take extreme care to check labels etc going forward.

But...surely they can't expect everyone to avoid anything that "may contain traces of nuts"? That's just not doable for most people.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
DistantSkye · 03/01/2023 09:49

I agree with the poster who said I don't think other parents will be giving this the same level of thought as you! I think avoiding nuts in things and taking some steps to avoid cross contamination is fine, and if there were any extra steps to take, the class in question would have been told.

For what it's worth, DH has a relatively severe nut allergy and we still use nuts in the home. I don't keep peanuts or peanut butter as he is severely allergic to them, but I have other nuts kept in a sealed container separate from other food. I use a separate nutribullet if I'm making an almond milk smoothie and a separate saucepan if I'm making porridge with almond milk. Take extra care if I have nut butter on toast. All of this seems to have been ok!

If you want to send in a "nut butter" sandwich - wow butter is made with soy beans, and is a fairly good substitute. And certified nut free!

MeJane · 03/01/2023 08:07

Wetblanket78 · 03/01/2023 00:29

Before school needs to be avoided as well. There was a child a few years ago that had cheese thrown on his face in the dinner hall. He had a dairy allergy and died. But you can can guarantee there will be some parents who will say they can't tell them what they can and can't send in.

That had already been very much discussed in this months old three hundred page thread.

Wetblanket78 · 03/01/2023 00:37

As someone has said they only need to speak to someone who has eaten nuts to have a reaction.

Wetblanket78 · 03/01/2023 00:33

Nuts don't even have to be consumed for the person with the allergy to have a reaction. There was a boy a few years ago with a dairy allergy. He had cheese thrown at his face and died.

Wetblanket78 · 03/01/2023 00:29

Before school needs to be avoided as well. There was a child a few years ago that had cheese thrown on his face in the dinner hall. He had a dairy allergy and died. But you can can guarantee there will be some parents who will say they can't tell them what they can and can't send in.

user1492757084 · 23/05/2022 06:35

Do your best to avoid sending nuts. Go to a parents' meeting and voice your concerns. It might be more reasonable when the allergic child grows older and learns never to share food or always to eat next to a minder. (parent or teacher)

Butitssafe · 23/05/2022 06:30

What did they say @PartyGoose

ThatMiddleClassFood · 20/05/2022 08:55

PurpleandPlatinum · 19/05/2022 22:41

You are being completely unrealistic about staffing levels if you think a school is able to prevent children sharing food at lunch. Even if they are told repeatedly, children still do it.

They don't have to watch every child though just the ones with allergies. How do you think they safeguard children with allergies that aren't banned. My son's school sits them at the same table each day with a dedicated seat and the same person supervises them each day.

GoldenGirdle · 20/05/2022 07:15

maddy68 · 20/05/2022 06:21

I don't understand why this is an issue. Just don't send nuts into school
I have a friend that has a nut alergi so severe that if she has a conversation with someone that has recently eaten nuts she ends up in hospital.

Stop being ignorant

And this is the exact problem. That people think they are complying with what's been asked of them. "Just don't send nuts to school" isn't what they are asking.

So you would be merrily sending food in that may contain traces of nuts, such as a bottle of water from Tesco and thinking you were doing what the school wants.

"I don't understand why this is an issue"
Obviously.
You haven't read it properly, that's why you don't understand.

Sally872 · 20/05/2022 06:37

maddy68 · 20/05/2022 06:21

I don't understand why this is an issue. Just don't send nuts into school
I have a friend that has a nut alergi so severe that if she has a conversation with someone that has recently eaten nuts she ends up in hospital.

Stop being ignorant

Have you read the op's posts? She is never going to send nuts in to school. She is worried about how to know it is free of May contains when she makes a pack lunch and has uses nuts regularly at home. She wants to make sure child is safe.

Trifecta · 20/05/2022 06:26

Our school has a “nut free” zone in the lunch area for those with allergies. Those who get a school lunch can eat there as well because school food doesn’t contain nuts.

maddy68 · 20/05/2022 06:21

I don't understand why this is an issue. Just don't send nuts into school
I have a friend that has a nut alergi so severe that if she has a conversation with someone that has recently eaten nuts she ends up in hospital.

Stop being ignorant

wtftodo · 19/05/2022 22:49

I am a parent of a severely peanut allergic child (used to be all tree nuts, too, and sesame, which can be a total nightmare to avoid. It is a huge relief for me that the school does not allow nut or peanut containing foods on site.

BUT. May contain is completely ridiculous. I let her eat food which “may contain” traces (with sensible exceptions eg I wouldn’t let her eat a nature valley oat bar as they are made on the same lines that make the peanut bars). I certainly wouldn’t expect other people to effectively only be buying or making entirely free from products for their own kids.

we have had issues with “friends” feeding small children peanut butter sandwiches when they are with us, or with people on trains eating roasted peanuts at the same table (we had to move), or at an extra curricular group where nuts are banned but some kids had been sent in with peanut bars which then ended up everywhere. Oh and with mini snickers or peanut M&Ms in party bags or as treats/rewards in classes outside school etc.

i have to teach my child to always be wary. It’s great when everyone avoids actual peanuts at school. But this school is just going to annoy other parents with an unworkable and unfair rule.

PurpleandPlatinum · 19/05/2022 22:41

You are being completely unrealistic about staffing levels if you think a school is able to prevent children sharing food at lunch. Even if they are told repeatedly, children still do it.

TiptoeThroughTheToadstools · 19/05/2022 22:40

My DCs school also has a ban on nuts, but hasn't specified as far as "traces" , for the school to be so specific, the allergy suffered by this particular pupil must be very serious. There used to be a boy at my DCs school who was at serious risk of death even just being next to someone who was eating them

ThatMiddleClassFood · 19/05/2022 22:32

stopwaitingforpermissiontobeyou · 19/05/2022 00:27

foods can be made in the same factory as nuts. whcih poses the same risk to the chid. I'm not sure why this is so hard to understand.

My friend is a vegetarian but wont eat Burger king vegetarian burgers because theyre made on the same bloody grill.

eating anything with traces of nuts could kill this child.

im appalled at the responses.

But other parents aren't making or buying food for the nut allergic child to eat it's for their own child. The child with allergies should be well aware of not sharing foods with others and a teacher/dinner staff should be observing to make extra sure. The school should educate the kids regarding not sharing foods and have stringent cleaning processes.

I feel everyone saying it's very easy to avoid may contain labels have never actually had to spend hours of their life reading labels. I also think if this was any other allergen it would be received different imagine if a school said no soya, kiwi, milk, wheat, lentils, egg, beans, sesame, fish, garlic etc including may contains. Everyone with an anaphylactic allergy has a risk if eating the foods but they wouldn't ban most allergens they'd find a work around to keep the kids safe therefore it can be done without food bans.

cecilthehungryspider · 19/05/2022 13:20

Muffinsorcrumpets · 16/05/2022 18:21

@cecilthehungryspider

Kinder now make large Easter eggs that are nut-free and the Kinnerton ones work too of course - Tesco had a Crayola egg with Kinnerton chocolate this year.

I didn't know that about the kinder easter eggs! Thank you.

Lima1 · 19/05/2022 10:29

Muffinsorcrumpets · 19/05/2022 10:17

DS is under the care of one lady and she is amazing. She said that in all her years she has never experienced a child having an anaphylactic reaction from eating a product that said "may contain traces of nuts" and DS could eat those products.

I'm surprised by this, @Lima1, as our consultant told us the exact opposite - that DC was to avoid eating anything that may have nut traces. He is also very good, an authority in his field with many papers to his name.

I do think there's only a tiny chance that classmates eating 'may contain' products will cause a serious reaction in DC, and I would not expect the school to ban these products.

The consensus at the moment from experts is that schools needn't ban nuts either.
However, they also state that the certainty of evidence for this position is low and that it's a conditional recommendation for now. They also say that more care may be needed for very young children and for people with disabilities.

That is interesting @Muffinsorcrumpets the lady I am speaking about is a vice chair of an allergy association, is involved in a number of immunotherapy studies and trials and has written a large number of papers. One thing she works on is building tolerance of products (under strict controls of course). She is very interested in the impact of of allergies on parents/families and said you have to balance trying to live a somewhat normal life with managing the allergy. I was very very strict with checking products, she said there is still a risk from "may contain traces.." but it is very low and unlikely to cause a severe reaction.
I

Muffinsorcrumpets · 19/05/2022 10:17

DS is under the care of one lady and she is amazing. She said that in all her years she has never experienced a child having an anaphylactic reaction from eating a product that said "may contain traces of nuts" and DS could eat those products.

I'm surprised by this, @Lima1, as our consultant told us the exact opposite - that DC was to avoid eating anything that may have nut traces. He is also very good, an authority in his field with many papers to his name.

I do think there's only a tiny chance that classmates eating 'may contain' products will cause a serious reaction in DC, and I would not expect the school to ban these products.

The consensus at the moment from experts is that schools needn't ban nuts either.
However, they also state that the certainty of evidence for this position is low and that it's a conditional recommendation for now. They also say that more care may be needed for very young children and for people with disabilities.

melj1213 · 19/05/2022 10:01

stopwaitingforpermissiontobeyou · 19/05/2022 00:49

Yeah, but then youve at least tried.

all of this "il be sending my wean with crisps and i dont give a shit" isnt much comfort really, is it?

"Well we tried 🤷‍♀️" isn't good enough if it ends with a child going into anaphylaxis because you weren't careful enough.

This is why it is important for the school to clarify the issue. If they are just being overzealous then people aren't going to comply strictly with the rule and the more times people send their children in with items that "may contain nuts" and there is no issue then the less careful people will be and the lass likely they are to follow any of the nut rules, until the day someone sends something in that causes anaphylaxis and then the parents are blamed for not following the rules.

If the child can't have/be around actual nuts then go nut free as that is easy to follow and can be policed easily - separate table, wiped sown before and after use; hand washing before and after meals; lunches checked for no nut products before they sit at the table with the child with allergies etc - but the more rules put in place the less people will follow them and the more the child will be endangered.

Daphodils · 19/05/2022 09:20

no food can be brought onto school premises that contains nuts or "may contain traces of nuts" due to a child with a severe nut allergy starting there

This seems entirely pointless and harmful. Excessively anxious and rule-abiding parents will be changing their own shopping habits and reading all the labels. Cavalier parents will (not unreasonably) think the whole dictat is ridiculous and carry on as before.

If someone is so vulnerable to exposure to nuts that they cannot be in the same room as a product that has been prepared in a kitchen where nuts have been used then really they have to take necessary precautions, not the rest of the world.

Lima1 · 19/05/2022 09:02

I have a son with a peanut allergy and I understand the anxiety of parents of children with allergies sending them to school. I am in Ireland and we only have 2 allergy consultants here. DS is under the care of one lady and she is amazing. She said that in all her years she has never experienced a child having an anaphylactic reaction from eating a product that said "may contain traces of nuts" and DS could eat those products.
As an ingredient reader for 12 years, I know it is virtually impossible to pack a lunch with products without this warning. It is unsafe and unfair to expect parents to comply.
The best way is to educate children, parents and teachers. My DS's school was nut free, his consultant disagreed with this. She said she advocates for schools to have a policy whereby children understand if they eat nut products they wash their hands afterwards. The school wouldn't do this as it was easier for them to just ban and ignore the reality that children would continue to bring in nut products. A boy at DS's table regularly brought in peanut butter sandwiches, I asked the teacher to request that the boy wash his hands afterwards and wipe down the table, the school wouldn't do this, this just told the boy no more PB sandwiches.

I understand the worry about allergies but seriously it is virtually impossible for a child to have a serious reaction because they were around your child that ate something that may have contained traces of nuts. How does that child function through the rest of his/her day? Using public transport, activities, play dates, etc. OP tell you child to wash their hands after they eat to remove any potential traces.

Overthebow · 19/05/2022 08:26

If the school insist that their email is correct with banning ‘May contain’ foods, just send an email back saying you will not be able to guarantee all food you send in will be compliant as you if have nut products in the house. They can provide free school lunches that comply with their policy for all children if they want that to happen. Completely unreasonable to expect families to be able to comply with this, if it were me I simply wouldn’t do it and would tell them that. Not bringing actual nuts in is one thing but banning ‘May contain’ is not reasonable.

Marvellousmadness · 19/05/2022 05:33

Nah. Thats rediculous.

PixieLaLa · 19/05/2022 05:30

I have a nut-using kitchen

🐿