Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Reference request - what to say?

66 replies

HonestyOrExpedience · 16/05/2022 12:14

Posting for traffic, and NC'd in case outing.

Last year I had someone in my team in an administrator role on a fixed-term contract. She was pleasant and hard-working but she just couldn't cut it at the job. I gave her hours and hours of additional support and training over and above what would usually be the case in that (or any) role; she had a lengthy induction; clear action plans; weekly 1:1s; access to all sorts of written guides/training/previous examples of work, including recordings of training sessions that she could repeat as needed; she had a buddy; I encouraged her to join supportive networks; we went through Occupational Health in case there were underlying issues and implemented their recommendations...you name it, I/we tried it but she was simply a square peg in a round hole. Her CV suggested she had done similar roles and she said all the right things at interview (although things she let slip while working with us made it clear there had been some embellishments and omissions) but although she certainly had some strengths and skills, they weren't the ones needed for this job. When it came to the end of her FTC we let her go and didn't seek to explore renewing/extending her contract.

I have received a reference request for her and one of the questions is "would you re-employ X in a similar role?" Now I know I could simply tick 'yes' and she'll be someone else's problem, there'd be unlikely to be any comeback on me, but I have to sign a declaration that I've given honest information and the real answer is no, we absolutely wouldn't employ her again in that or any vaguely similar role!

WWYD?

OP posts:
tcjotm · 16/05/2022 13:29

By couldn’t complete it I mean you can say that you’re only able to confirm dates of employment and job title and the form didn’t let you do that.

starfishmummy · 16/05/2022 13:28

LanaGardner · 16/05/2022 12:36

I had to go and check something, I honestly thought it was against the law to write a bad reference but that's apparently a myth.
I'm another one for leave it blank.
Unless her new position is exactly the same as the job with yourself I don't think you need to worry about it.

It's a very common myth.
It has to be true, that's all.

tcjotm · 16/05/2022 13:27

HonestyOrExpedience · 16/05/2022 12:27

Thanks all. Unfortunately the reference is set up as a form within an IT system with mandatory fields, so I can't submit it without ticking either yes or no. If it were just a Word form or an email that I could send back while leaving things blank I'd have much less angst!

In that case don’t complete it. When they chase you, you should hopefully get a chance to explain why you couldn’t.

It sucks for their future employees that there’s a delay but they can’t force you to complete it.

SecretVictoria · 16/05/2022 13:26

I have been that employee. I was in an admin role that I couldn’t handle, I wasn’t given any training though and they had mentioned at interview that I would need it. I was also on a FTC. I asked them directly about references, they said they would be honest and say they wouldn’t employ me again in a similar admin capacity, but would absolutely give me a job in a customer service role (like on reception) or doing basic admin.

SamMil · 16/05/2022 13:21

Do you have an HR department? If so, forward to them.

If not, then contact the company, tell them you only send standardised references and email your own letter. I have worked in HR for many years and the only information we include is:

  • Full name
  • Dates of employment
  • Job title
Leftbutcameback · 16/05/2022 13:18

For those interested in the law around this Spring is the first case I remember

www.lawteacher.net/cases/spring-v-guardian-assurance.php

By the way referring to it as illegal isn't correct, we're taking about civil law here

Alwayshoovering · 16/05/2022 13:16

LanaGardner · 16/05/2022 12:36

I had to go and check something, I honestly thought it was against the law to write a bad reference but that's apparently a myth.
I'm another one for leave it blank.
Unless her new position is exactly the same as the job with yourself I don't think you need to worry about it.

No not illegal to provide a bad reference illegal to provide a false / non factual reference that could cause loss to the person it is about or the person seeking to rely on it.
What so many people don't realise is a false positive reference could get you into a lot of trouble if someone uses the glowing reference to employ someone and then realise they are a total lemon.

Leftbutcameback · 16/05/2022 13:16

Sorry - just read the post again and see that my answer doesn't make sense!

Leftbutcameback · 16/05/2022 13:15

Whilst I don't agree that you can never give an substantive reference, I wouldn't ever give one about suitability for a role unless you already manage that role in an organisation. How do you know what they would be asked to do and it what circumstances.

I have given references in the past where I've reported on factual matters such as timekeeping and disciplinary record.

BarbaraofSeville · 16/05/2022 13:14

Not replying will probably have the same affect to replying no.

You'd have to be fairly naive to not spot that someone who won't answer the question with a yes, wants to say no but is avoiding doing so for whatever reason.

Those saying that people have been sued over bad references, surely that the claimant would only win if it can be proven that the bad reference is unfair. If you have evidence that the person in question wasn't competent, then you have nothing to worry about.

Mumwantingtogetitright · 16/05/2022 13:09

In these situations, I just ignore the form that the prospective employer has sent me, and I send a brief factual statement instead of dates worked, job title etc. I don't think I have ever had this approach questioned by a prospective employer...I assume that they interpret it in whatever way they see fit!Grin

Irishfarmer · 16/05/2022 13:05

I would respond to who ever sent you the survey/ non amendable reference form and tell them you will supply role title and dates only.

traintraveller · 16/05/2022 13:04

In my area the reference forms ask for much more than dates employed and are completed by managers rather than HR. They also ask this question. I am always honest and on one occasion ticked no and gave the reason why. So long as references are honest and factual they don't need to be positive.

TheMysteryLady · 16/05/2022 12:55

Please just confirm her dates and job title. If you’re being asked for a reference then she’s probably been successful at interview. It seems really nasty to think her offer could be revoked because of you. How is she supposed to get another job if you do this? If you’re her last employer what else is she supposed to do?

I get that you don’t think she was very good. But she might have learnt from her mistakes and you don’t know how she will be in a new environment. If she really is rubbish at her job they can let her go after the probation period.

Notbluepeter · 16/05/2022 12:50

I'm not sure some of the posters who have replied here have ever actually worked in HR.
Please ignore the "tell the truth, I would" replies.
Exposing the company to a defamation suit, no matter the documentary evidence to support your position is NEVER advisable. Refuse to complete the form. Confirm employment dates and job title and nothing more.

whynotwhatknot · 16/05/2022 12:43

I thought they coldnt ask those things anymore

id try and get hold of the employer myself and say youd rather just give dates

GodspeedJune · 16/05/2022 12:42

Leave blank if you haven’t got good feedback. It seems spiteful to tick no when you said yourself she was pleasant and hard working, but just not a good fit for the role. She could potentially persue you if she’s given feedback that her offer has been revoked due to references.

HummingQuietly · 16/05/2022 12:41

It's not your problem that they have created a "mandatory" form. It doesn't oblige you to jump through all their hoops. Lots of big companies won't do more than confirm they worked there and for how long. I suggest you imagine you were in that position and do that. Be polite and happy to help but do it in your chosen medium (an email or letter) not their form. It is really normal these days for people to be unable to provide what they are asking, form or not.

catgirl1976 · 16/05/2022 12:40

As others have said just confirm her job title and dates of employment. You’re not obliged to give any further information than that and most companies only give this “tombstone” type of reference now to avoid issues.

BritInUS1 · 16/05/2022 12:39

I wouldn't complete it if it was set up like this

They can either email it so that you have the option to complete the parts you want to or you don't do It at all !

Searchingsound · 16/05/2022 12:36

Don’t fill in it. People have been sued over bad references - never say anything else apart from confirming dates worked

LanaGardner · 16/05/2022 12:36

I had to go and check something, I honestly thought it was against the law to write a bad reference but that's apparently a myth.
I'm another one for leave it blank.
Unless her new position is exactly the same as the job with yourself I don't think you need to worry about it.

AlternativePerspective · 16/05/2022 12:35

I didn’t think that was even legal any more?

My understanding is that the only information an employer can give now is whether someone worked for them and what dates.

Ilovewillow · 16/05/2022 12:35

I would tick no and state that it isn't company policy to remploy or if you do remploy state you are unable to provide comment due to company policy

Notadramallama · 16/05/2022 12:33

I wouldn't fill in the form then. Just send a message confirming the job title and dates of employment. I would never complete a form like that for a previous employee.