Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Reference request - what to say?

66 replies

HonestyOrExpedience · 16/05/2022 12:14

Posting for traffic, and NC'd in case outing.

Last year I had someone in my team in an administrator role on a fixed-term contract. She was pleasant and hard-working but she just couldn't cut it at the job. I gave her hours and hours of additional support and training over and above what would usually be the case in that (or any) role; she had a lengthy induction; clear action plans; weekly 1:1s; access to all sorts of written guides/training/previous examples of work, including recordings of training sessions that she could repeat as needed; she had a buddy; I encouraged her to join supportive networks; we went through Occupational Health in case there were underlying issues and implemented their recommendations...you name it, I/we tried it but she was simply a square peg in a round hole. Her CV suggested she had done similar roles and she said all the right things at interview (although things she let slip while working with us made it clear there had been some embellishments and omissions) but although she certainly had some strengths and skills, they weren't the ones needed for this job. When it came to the end of her FTC we let her go and didn't seek to explore renewing/extending her contract.

I have received a reference request for her and one of the questions is "would you re-employ X in a similar role?" Now I know I could simply tick 'yes' and she'll be someone else's problem, there'd be unlikely to be any comeback on me, but I have to sign a declaration that I've given honest information and the real answer is no, we absolutely wouldn't employ her again in that or any vaguely similar role!

WWYD?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Brainwave89 · 16/05/2022 17:47

Speak to HR. Unless there is a reason to disclose more (for example if you work in financial services where it is mandatory to provide a reference for some staff),then most companies will provide a reference which says x worked for us from x date to y date in A role. In accordance with our standard reference policy we are unable to provide any further information. To do otherwise with people you do not know could incur significant liabilities for your firm.

2bazookas · 16/05/2022 15:20

Contact the other employer by phone and tell them the truth , verbally.

SarahSissions · 16/05/2022 15:10

You don’t HAVE to do a reference full stop. I would just print out a note on headed paper sting you don’t do references but can confirm the dates of employment and role. It’s very typical and won’t raise any questions.

thecatsthecats · 16/05/2022 14:53

lljkk · 16/05/2022 14:14

OP: do you have a company policy. For all we know, OP is the CEO & gets to decide the policy right now.

Google says, to be successfully sued: You must prove that your employer provided a poor or false reference with malicious intent. If the reference was provided without malice and your employer believed the contents of the reference to be true (even if they are untrue), then they can't be successfully sued for defamation.

That intent part is incredibly important. As long as you're simply being factual you aren't expressing malicious intent.

Again, think about it.

Part of your role is to protect the reputation of the company. That includes not opening them up to the chance of legal action, which is time consuming and expensive. My CEO chose to pay a settlement of notice in a slam dunk gross misconduct case because it was the most expedient way to handle a situation. And he was an ex union boss. He knew every HR trick in the book.

Unless your core business function is to vet staff for new employers, you don't have to do a damn thing to provide a bad reference.

ferneytorro · 16/05/2022 14:43

Crikey no don’t complete it! Email back copying in your hr department and say they will action. If no hr department check your policy. Am laughing at the thought of being able to give honest feedback on a reference.

HermioneWeasley · 16/05/2022 14:33

You do NOT have to fill in their form. Most organisations just give dates and maybe job title.

MarvelMrs · 16/05/2022 14:30

If you think she was hard working and would well in another role perhaps tick yes but then explain in the notes you feel she has skills suited to x,y, z and would not rehire in x role but would consider for y roles as she was good at this or that.

londonrach · 16/05/2022 14:25

Leave blank just put the dates the person worked with you no further details

KatherineJaneway · 16/05/2022 14:22

Don't answer the question. Just tell them the dates she worked for you and her job title. Nothing else.

CannibalQueen · 16/05/2022 14:14

I employed a nanny once who screwed me over financially. Silly girl kept sending reference requests to me. I wrote them - stressing that I had no problems with her care of my child (which I didn't) - but writing the rest in such a way that it triggered the 'something is off here' response in prospective employers. I got a few phone calls from people asking about her, and one dad triumphantly said 'I KNEW there was more to this.' Again I stressed that she was a very good nanny and I had no complaints at all about the care of my child, but that she had taken her two weeks holiday pay in advance along with her months pay, and then cleared off and never came back. Basically warning them not to make the same mistake of paying the way I had. I guess she got in somewhere but I am still disappointed the way she treated me even now.

lljkk · 16/05/2022 14:14

OP: do you have a company policy. For all we know, OP is the CEO & gets to decide the policy right now.

Google says, to be successfully sued: You must prove that your employer provided a poor or false reference with malicious intent. If the reference was provided without malice and your employer believed the contents of the reference to be true (even if they are untrue), then they can't be successfully sued for defamation.

That intent part is incredibly important. As long as you're simply being factual you aren't expressing malicious intent.

thing47 · 16/05/2022 14:11

thecatsthecats · 16/05/2022 14:03

This.

Ironically, one thing I have coached staff on is automatically obliging with requests for people we have no vested interest in helping. Not refusing to help - but not, by default, doing a task assigned to you by someone external that doesn't benefit the company.

Provide a reference in a format you are comfortable with and that complies with your employer's policy.

It is a new employer's responsibility to vet the staff they employ appropriately.

Quite. I couldn't give a toss what some company or organisation, to which I have no connection, thinks is 'mandatory'.

It's actually quite cheeky of a company to think they have the right to expect you to spend any time on this at all. You have no obligation to them whatsoever.

NowThatsWhatICall22 · 16/05/2022 14:06

Oh please OP, give this person a chance at another path in life. How is it within your domain to decide whether they can pay their rent this month or progress in their working life?

They’ve clearly carried on trying to get another job, not giving up after being somewhere that didn’t work out.
There’s being resilient and there’s being knocked down so far you can’t get back up again. Help them make a fresh start.

yesthatisdrizzle · 16/05/2022 14:04

I'd do a bog-standard reference and send that to them, with a note saying that it is not company policy to go into the level of detail they have asked for in the online form.

thecatsthecats · 16/05/2022 14:03

HummingQuietly · 16/05/2022 12:41

It's not your problem that they have created a "mandatory" form. It doesn't oblige you to jump through all their hoops. Lots of big companies won't do more than confirm they worked there and for how long. I suggest you imagine you were in that position and do that. Be polite and happy to help but do it in your chosen medium (an email or letter) not their form. It is really normal these days for people to be unable to provide what they are asking, form or not.

This.

Ironically, one thing I have coached staff on is automatically obliging with requests for people we have no vested interest in helping. Not refusing to help - but not, by default, doing a task assigned to you by someone external that doesn't benefit the company.

Provide a reference in a format you are comfortable with and that complies with your employer's policy.

It is a new employer's responsibility to vet the staff they employ appropriately.

Nogoodusername · 16/05/2022 14:00

As others have said - if I ever get that kind of reference request, even if an online form, I ignore it and email their HR/ the person who emailed it to me saying apologies, our policy is to confirm job title and employment dates only, which are xyz

Watermill · 16/05/2022 13:56

As PP have said, it is unusual to provide anything aside from confirming that Ms X was employed from this date to that date in Y role.

Just ignore the form and send back an email saying you only provide basic info as outlined above.

wallpoppy · 16/05/2022 13:54

I personally would never say ANYTHING that could hurt someone's chances to find a new job unless they had done something dangerous or illegal that could come back on me if it wasn't disclosed. Even if they were lazy, even if I personally disliked them, I would not fuck with their livelihood and future with a bad reference. There's just too much at stake for them. If a request for reference comes through as a form with a tickbox for "would hire again yes/no" and I can't honestly say yes, I just ignore the form and send a reference in the format I prefer.

You are not legally required to answer the question much less expand on it, in spite of the field being marked "mandatory". 99% of the time, the person has already been selected and the references are just a formality. A breezy cheerful reference where you say generic positive things instead of answering specific questions will be very unlikely to cause the hiring manager to start again with their search, but a negative reference very likely would. I don't want that kind of power over someone, and I also know from experience (as an employee and as a manager) that the wrong fit in one job may be the perfect fit in another.

I feel like it's borderline psychopathic to do anything to that might harm someone's chance at being hired (with the exception of dangerous or illegal activity as noted above), especially if you are a reference they can't do without because you were their manager at the last-but-one job. If you absolutely cannot bring yourself to find one or two positive things to say, ask your HR department to send a generic reference confirming their employment dates and nothing else. That's all some companies will do, anyway, even for star employees, out of (misguided) fear of legal reprisals.

GrassWillBeGreener · 16/05/2022 13:53

I've been that employee albeit in the NHS. One job was a bad fit for my personality and life situation at the time, and they supported me moving into something very different and exploring other longterm career options. When I had to add them as a referee for something I needed to apply for it turned out they had a tick box referencing system that included "would you employ this person". So they ticked no, which was perfectly true, and there was no space for comment or clarification. The role I was trying to move into was a much much better fit for all the reasons the first one wasn't.

16 years later I'm finally revisiting the possibility of clinical work ...

OP, I really don't know what to advise you. The fact that there is room to comment is good, if you do decide to fill it in, for I think honesty should be applied. Hopefully someone in your HR department can advise you whether there is appropriate wording you can use or if you should decline.

NeverDropYourMooncup · 16/05/2022 13:52

Would you employ the pleasant and hardworking employee in a job that was easier/within her capabilities? One that was similar in that it was on the same site? Then that's good enough.

If she isn't able to do your one job, which sounds quite complex going by the amount of things you gave her, it seems unkind to render her unemployable to anybody else.

It doesn't oblige you to take her back. But it does mean she isn't on the dole because nobody looked at the nice and hardworking bit.

girlmom21 · 16/05/2022 13:44

Put a dot in their mandatory box to save yourself the headache.

FatOaf · 16/05/2022 13:42

these references that just give dates are worse than useless. I want to know what the person was like as an employee so that I don’t waste my time and resources by offering the job to someone who won’t be able to do it.

But referees have no legal right to give you this information, and you shouldn't be asking for it. There are no circumstances under which you are going to be able to make reliable comparisons between candidates on the basis of references. You should sort out your recruiting practices so you can find out whether someone is capable of doing the job. If you are relying on CVs and conventional panel interviews to select staff it's your own fault if you get duds: you can't expect referees to compensate for your HR practices being stuck in the nineteen-fifties.

BalloonsAndWhistles · 16/05/2022 13:33

She was wrong for your company but maybe she’d be right for them. Surely, she must have been able to do some things, even if it’s just using Office, Teams etc. It might be that her new role focusses on the skills she has and she may have realised what she’s crap at. If it were me, I’d tick yes just so I didn’t fuck up her chances of hopefully getting better. She may be struggling financially too and really need the job.

Madickenxx · 16/05/2022 13:32

If you work for a company with an HR department, I'd simply respond to the reference request with their contact details. I sometimes get these reference requests when a former colleague have given my details to the agency / new employer. Our reference policy is that only HR can provide references and they only give date of employment and job title on the date of leaving (might have got that wrong but something like that).

Alicetheowl · 16/05/2022 13:30

AgentProvocateur · 16/05/2022 12:28

Tell the truth. Tick the no
box and say that despite additional
support and training, she was unable to fulfil the requirements of the role. And then give your phone number so that they can call you if they need more detail.

these references that just give dates are worse than useless. I want to know what the person was like as an employee so that I don’t waste my time and resources by offering the job to someone who won’t be able to do it.

They might not be much use, but in lots of cases where departments have changed around or there has been high staff turnover, it might be impossible to find a staff member who knew the person. So that's all a lot of people will have.