Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

DH and career, salary

309 replies

hjliu8999 · 16/05/2022 11:31

To preface this with, this issue is not new and has been a source of tension between DH and I ever since we got together decades ago. But just had yet another fight with DH regarding his job and whether he should look for something else.

He's been in his current position for three years now, no salary increase and no promotion - and realistically it just wont happen, they said so. I've been trying to encourage him to move on. He admits he doesnt like his job or sector so it's not like he loves it or anything but just doesn't know how to look for anything else.

And frankly am fed up. We used to live abroad where he was in the same position for ten years - no promotion and just inflationary salary increases. We came back due to my job so he found the first thing he could and basically it's the same thing. But by now we have DC and London is really expensive (his current job is also half the money he earned abroad). By now he's 42 so time is not exactly on his side. And I appreciate that 55k is not nothing, but he has three degrees and is working in a professional job.

From my side I do work full time - in the sector that he used to work in and by now earn more than he does. But it's a public sector ish job and I wont be able to find anything in the private sector (those jobs just dont exist). Realistically my pay progression is rubbish (max I will ever earn is probably 70kish) but I do have a lot more flexibility and annual leave so do more of the childcare.

Am just really fed up. With the cost of living going up along with interest rates - we have a big mortgage - and I dont know how to convince DH that he needs to find something else. He accuses me of wanting him to earn more money - like thats a bad thing or something. Am I being unreasonable or is he? Any tips on how to change things.

OP posts:
FacebookPhotos · 16/05/2022 13:16

I was all ready to say YABU based on your OP, but your updates indicate he is a childish dick tbh. Relying on savings for day to day spending is a fool's game, unless there is a very good, short-term reason. He either needs to get a better paying job or agree where your outgoings can be cut.

cookiemonster2468 · 16/05/2022 13:14

It sounds like budgeting is what you both need to do rather than looking for new jobs. Well, budgeting and couples counselling, probably.

On a combined income of £110k+, you should actually be able to afford those luxuries your husband wants.

But it sounds like the two of you are struggling to actually come together as a team and resolve any of this. It takes both of you at the end of the day, you have a communication issue.

NightmareSlashDelightful · 16/05/2022 13:14

I think my original point, about the two of you being engaged in a familiar but crappy dance that you both hate but continue to do because you both know the steps, still stands.

I don't think anyone here can solve this issue, because it's decades old and you've both internalised it. It strikes me that your frustration and anger has welled up from a set of circumstances or a version of him from some years ago, and the situation now is simply triggering it again. I feel like you (both) need external help really. Couples therapy or something.

notagamer · 16/05/2022 13:14

this issue is not new and has been a source of tension between DH and I ever since we got together decades ago

he is 42
have you honestly been having this discussion and tension since he was 22? Presumably in the middle of doing one of his degrees?

MRex · 16/05/2022 13:14

You certainly have some issues between you and your DH. The difficulty is that you are not debating the problems as a team, instead you are deciding solutions by yourself and dictating to your DH things that simply are not your business. It's baffling to me that you are expecting him to earn more by changing job, when you refuse to do the same. Be the change you want to see, don't go ordering him to do it instead.

Discuss with him the problems;

  1. Money. As a family you've dipped into savings and that isn't sustainable. Write all the income and expenditure down, plus childcare costs as per point 2, and review options with him from there. It isn't up to you to dictate any of it, it's a discussion.
  2. You want to expand your career so there needs to be more childcare that isn't you; either you two pay for childcare or he adapts his hours (very few jobs have no flex, you're right on that). If it's being paid for then agree together how to fund childminder, au pair, after school club, whatever it is.
  3. His job dissatisfaction. The ridiculous capitalist rantings would irritate me, but he's your DH and presumably you have shared values. If he isn't sure how to go about making changes but isn't happy, then it may be worth investing in a life coach. If he just wants to jump ship then he can do a CV and send it to niche recruiters, who are incentivised to help him. Whatever he does though, you should stay out of the decisions because sounds like you're on the fast track to wrecking your marriage if you keep fighting about things that are firmly his remit and not yours.
  1. I know it's just a thread, we don't have all of your life on display so you've left stuff out. I hope you've left out a whole lot of fun and happiness in your lives generally. If you haven't, then you need to take a massive step back and reevaluate your life priorities, because it reads very bleakly. I can't imagine even bitching anonymously about my DH without including how sweet and funny he is, how he picks up all the shitty tasks etc.
Ecclesfreckles · 16/05/2022 13:13

Hi OP, there has been a similar situation with my DP and I, in that the main wage earning falls to me as he is just not very driven to progress. Despite being immensely capable and having a lot of support at work to enable this. I think it was just complacence and a lack of forward planning that stopped him pushing himself when we first met.

I have accepted that the onus is on me to maintain our lifestyle as mine is the higher paying career and i am driven i.e I have taken a higher paying job/more stress that I don't particularly enjoy so he can carry on at the progression pace he's at. Yet he still enjoys the lifestyle my sacrifices enable, and I'm not sure he would now be happy to see a drastic change in that.

So what helped us is me doing the maths for him. How much things cost, the savings/pension we need to worry about, how it limits how many children we can have, potential caring responsibilities for parents, not to mention a buffer in case i get sick and can't work. When it's an abstract - "you need to push for promotion/progression at work", that feels like an attack on his choices, he gets defensive. When you say "in order to sustain our lifestyle we need to earn at minimum this amount as if we don't, it means selling up, moving out, having 1 child instead of 2, less savings etc - how can we get to this amount". That certainly put a fire under the bum of my DP - and he's realised he sort of takes for granted that we'll always live like he's used to.

We too live in London and costs are absolutely ridiculous here - yet we can't move too far out as the commuting costs/time for my DP would be ridiculous. So whilst I would normally support his reticence to advance as a personal choice, I'm aware that we don't live in a world that allows us this luxury. Even without the money element, if we don't constantly learn, grow, progress we're likely to get phased out of work for younger, more dynamic people. When I explained to DP that he was likely to be managed by a 20 something he had once trained, who considered him a dinosaur (because i was that 20 something doing exactly that once!) he would very much wish he'd taken opportunities more seriously. That definitely woke him up!

CaliforniaDrumming · 16/05/2022 13:12

Second Monzo for budget planning. I find it really helps.

AppleandRhubarbTart · 16/05/2022 13:11

MindPalace · 16/05/2022 13:09

Many women admit openly on here that they are not ambitious and are comfortable with staying in an easy ish low paid job rather than progressing in a career. Surely men are entitled to feel the same? And he is not even low paid.

Those women are usually doing a job that allows them to take on the majority of the childcare however, often facilitating their husbands to earn more as a consequence, whereas the DH here is the opposite. They're also not usually overspending because they don't want to cut their cloth according to their means. Granted OP didn't include this information in the original post so could understand if you'd missed it.

CaliforniaDrumming · 16/05/2022 13:10

hjliu8999 · 16/05/2022 12:25

I dont think 70k is rubbish but my husband also thinks that forcing him to spend less than 170-200 quid per week on food is against his basic human rights. He got used to us having a combined income of 190k per year without kids - so now doesnt want to cut back on anything, adjust to our lower income, or get a better paid job.

This is the real problem. He is a spender and you are a saver. I would find it hard to live with a spender because I am very frugal. YANBU.

LouisCatorze · 16/05/2022 13:10

OP you're being greedy. Not everyone is driven to be on the professional 'up' all the time! Cut your DP some slack.

On a combined income of over £100K a year, you're a helluva lot better off than many families.

MindPalace · 16/05/2022 13:09

Many women admit openly on here that they are not ambitious and are comfortable with staying in an easy ish low paid job rather than progressing in a career. Surely men are entitled to feel the same? And he is not even low paid.

hjliu8999 · 16/05/2022 13:09

I didnt mean to drip feed but also didnt want to write an even longer essay. It's hard to summarise all the issue and a long marriage into a short post. I would be ok if he liked his job or even if he engaged with our current finances. But thats not happening either.

OP posts:
Mimijamroll · 16/05/2022 13:09

Downsize and thus reduce your mortgage.
And /Or move to a cheaper area.

notagamer · 16/05/2022 13:08

Bones of arse

notagamer · 16/05/2022 13:08

You should not have named figures here op

Very little understanding on mumsnet unless on bones of worse

and even less understanding of talking about London living

AppleandRhubarbTart · 16/05/2022 13:08

KettrickenSmiled · 16/05/2022 13:01

It isn't sustainable at all - it must be worrying & stressful.

As must be DH's apparent lesser engagement with the DC.

But these are each very mighty dripfeeds.
Not mentioned at all in the OP - just the focus on DH having to earn more money.

Yes. When in fact based on what you've subsequently said OP, you'd likely be better off with a husband who earned bit less but was willing to live according to his means and was content in his job.

anotherbrewplease · 16/05/2022 13:08

@Traumdeuter

What they said

SoggyPaper · 16/05/2022 13:07

Blaze1886 · 16/05/2022 13:02

I'll let you in to a little secret, you'll never have enough money

Try and be more grateful with what you've got

She’d likely have enough money if her husband were to stop overspending.

Should she just be grateful for that?

SoggyPaper · 16/05/2022 13:05

Babyvenusplant · 16/05/2022 12:56

Realistically my pay progression is rubbish (max I will ever earn is probably 70kish)

You're completely out of touch, thats a lot of money

You also sound insufferable

How is this helpful?

Pay Progression in academia is a bit pathetic. Just because this group of highly educated and experienced professionals earn more than the national average, doesn’t mean the pay offer isn’t a bit shit, especially for women whose careers are impacted by family commitments.

Looking at the number and deciding it’s more than you could earn doesn’t mean anything.

Bluetrews25 · 16/05/2022 13:02

Your updates have illustrated the real problem which is his inability to cut his coat according to his cloth.
What a shame none of his three degrees were in maths or economics (I assume). And he clearly has no idea what a spreadsheet is for.
Maybe get him to train as an accountant.
Sorry, OP. I was a bit sceptical of you at first, but now I see the real issue, and I have sympathy.
Can you sit down with him and do a budget?
This is where he needs to be on that old TV show where you are given cash for the week and have to make it last.

KoblinsGiss · 16/05/2022 13:02

What are the goals as a household? Being mortgage free in X years? Saving for kids’ university? Upsizing and buying ambitious house in Y years? Having more disposable money? What is the plan and do you both agree on the plan itself and the timeline to it?

if yes - then surely it is a case of considering what’s doable, what’s not, and what plans B and C might be whilst staying happy and sane.

if you don’t agree on the plans - and have wildly different visions of the next 5 10 15 years then that’s a whole different conversation

wherethecityis · 16/05/2022 13:02

I'm an academic so I do know what it's like. It's not as if you can just do all the grocery shopping instead of him because you're already having to do more than your fair share with pick-ups/drop-offs and catching up on work on evenings to make up for that.
I couldn't cope with his attitude. He is being very selfish.

What would happen if you didn't have those savings? Because unless you have an awful lot of savings at this rate you won't have them for long.
If they were maybe paid off the mortgage (leaving some as a buffer obviously) and weren't available to spend, would he cut back or would he just rack up debt instead?

Blaze1886 · 16/05/2022 13:02

I'll let you in to a little secret, you'll never have enough money

Try and be more grateful with what you've got

KettrickenSmiled · 16/05/2022 13:01

PriestessofPing · 16/05/2022 12:51

10k into savings because he won’t adjust his spending is not sustainable as you say. Either he needs to cut back on expenditure or get a better paid job.

It isn't sustainable at all - it must be worrying & stressful.

As must be DH's apparent lesser engagement with the DC.

But these are each very mighty dripfeeds.
Not mentioned at all in the OP - just the focus on DH having to earn more money.

notagamer · 16/05/2022 13:01

Take this issue out of the equation

what is your marriage like with him?