Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

DH and career, salary

309 replies

hjliu8999 · 16/05/2022 11:31

To preface this with, this issue is not new and has been a source of tension between DH and I ever since we got together decades ago. But just had yet another fight with DH regarding his job and whether he should look for something else.

He's been in his current position for three years now, no salary increase and no promotion - and realistically it just wont happen, they said so. I've been trying to encourage him to move on. He admits he doesnt like his job or sector so it's not like he loves it or anything but just doesn't know how to look for anything else.

And frankly am fed up. We used to live abroad where he was in the same position for ten years - no promotion and just inflationary salary increases. We came back due to my job so he found the first thing he could and basically it's the same thing. But by now we have DC and London is really expensive (his current job is also half the money he earned abroad). By now he's 42 so time is not exactly on his side. And I appreciate that 55k is not nothing, but he has three degrees and is working in a professional job.

From my side I do work full time - in the sector that he used to work in and by now earn more than he does. But it's a public sector ish job and I wont be able to find anything in the private sector (those jobs just dont exist). Realistically my pay progression is rubbish (max I will ever earn is probably 70kish) but I do have a lot more flexibility and annual leave so do more of the childcare.

Am just really fed up. With the cost of living going up along with interest rates - we have a big mortgage - and I dont know how to convince DH that he needs to find something else. He accuses me of wanting him to earn more money - like thats a bad thing or something. Am I being unreasonable or is he? Any tips on how to change things.

OP posts:
hjliu8999 · 16/05/2022 13:36

We probably do need marriage counselling but with two little kids and no family nearby, I just don't see when we'd find the time or money. But I probably should get him to sort out our budget. Currently he thinks as we have savings - we can just live off that, as he says - what are savings for.....I tried to explain that they are for a rainy day but he doesnt listen.

OP posts:
CaliforniaDrumming · 16/05/2022 13:35

Just to give perspective, we live in London and our combined income is £ 150,000. We have two DC. I am by far the lower earner and consequently, I do the lion's share of childcare and housework. He should be doing that. I don't like to use the word "sponger" in a marriage, but certainly the lower earner needs to be doing more of the childcare and hwork ( if healthy). We also budget and save because DH plans to retire early. (By the way, DH is diabetic and needs a special low carb diet, but we manage it at less than half the cost you mention)

I think most posters haven't caught up with your update which is about him being a spendthrift, not about you wanting him to be ambitious.

Topseyt123 · 16/05/2022 13:32

You are being unreasonable to be leaning on him to move jobs to the extent that you are. You have a good joint household income.

£55k is a fairly good salary in my book, even though I realise that it is half of what he used to earn.

I think though that he too is being unreasonable because it seems he is unwilling to cut his cloth to suit the finances. He does sound as though he is a bit profligate with some of his spending habits and this has caused the £10k shortfall that was withdrawn from savings. It is this attitude that is not sustainable. Lean on him to change that more than leaning on him to change jobs. Would that work better, or will he just dig his heels in?

If he does dig his heels in on the spending habits then that rather than the refusal to change jobs would be what would annoy me.

DrinkFeckArseBrick · 16/05/2022 13:31

Hi OP

I initially clicked YABU but reading your updates I've changed my mind.

Essentially you seem to be bearing the main responsibility for family finances. And main responsibility for children. Meanwhile he moans about his job every day (says its soul destroying) but refuses to get a new job (as job hunting is soul destroying) either that he enjoys or that makes more money.

And addition to all of that, he refuses to spend less, and wants to live beyond family means up to 10k pa, which is going to get worse with inflation. This means that it puts more pressure on you to juggle the finances.

He has to do two things -
Decide to make the best of his own job and stop moaning OR take the plunge and find something else

Decide to make more money OR cut back spending, because his current approach to outgoings vs income is not sustainable.

I'd suggest outlining the problems (that you are struggling to hear the same issues with his job year after year, and your family finances are looking increasingly unhealthy) that you want to discuss and setting some time to do so in a netural place away from the kids (coffee shop or something) with all the figures in black and white (perhaps including how much he has complained about his job in the last month) and see if he can come up with some solutions himself. If he can't control spending it might be that you have to take a tighter hold of it (eg transfer him set amounts for set things) but I don't think that will help your relationship

Would he consider marriage counselling otherwise?

Lasana · 16/05/2022 13:29

I can tell you from experience (quite similar experience, sector-wise, even the funding of extended study) that you cannot fix his job for him. You can't make him apply for something he'd like more, or get him to do anything to change his own situation. You will drive yourself mad trying to, and will end up hating him for it (or at least, that's what happened to me).

What you can do is sit down together to look at your current income, current outgoings, identify if you are spending too much, and if so, decide as a team where you are going to cut back. Call this a temporary cut back, if you must, until your financial situation changes. But he has to be the one to put that change in motion. It's incredibly frustrating I know.

I ended up leaving the relationship in my case, he was so miserable and life was horrible and I just didn't want to spend my life with someone who was doing naff all to help themselves and making me miserable. We were only in our 20s though, and renting, so an easier decision to make.

Testina · 16/05/2022 13:28

@ThorsBedazzler it isn’t helpful to say “help him find a new job”.

You need to tell her how she does that, if he doesn’t want to engage with that.

notagamer · 16/05/2022 13:28

I’m interested in whether this is just one issue of a highly struggling marriage

i suspect it is

SweetPeaGirl · 16/05/2022 13:28

It's not unreasonable to want to split home and childcare responsibilities 50/50. It's also not unreasonable to want to live within your means rather than using savings for what sounds like luxury day to day spending.

Maybe have a discussion about these things and put the ball in his court to find alternative solutions? "It's fine if you want to stay in your job, but we then need another way to fix these things as this is not sustainable".

If he doesn't agree these are problems, then you can either accept things as they are and wait until kids are older to pursue your career, find a compromise position, or reconsider whether this is the relationship for you.

Nanny0gg · 16/05/2022 13:27

Femalewoman · 16/05/2022 12:29

You sound much more about money that he is. Perhaps he enjoys his position. Imagine being married to someone who constantly moans he is not earning enough money, what a sour marriage.

She's already said that he isn't happy where he is or with the job

BalloonsAndWhistles · 16/05/2022 13:27

Bloody hell, that’s a good household income! I’d move somewhere cheaper if I was you, you’ll feel absolutely loaded.

ThorsBedazzler · 16/05/2022 13:26

Help him find a new job. Not for the money but that he is happy with. And part of that discussion will probably need to be about living within your joint finances.

I've supported my DH in finding a new job. He was miserable before and it impacted on every aspect of our lives. Two new jobs were on the table and I actually initially was more in favour of the lesser laid option as I thought it would be less stressful. But he went for the other one and is enjoying it and life is measurably better too.

Your DH may well be more amenable to discussing how much you spend once he is happier in other aspects of life.

SoggyPaper · 16/05/2022 13:26

There is a difference between ‘£70k is a pathetic salary’ and ‘my pay progression is a bit pathetic - the most I’ll likely earn is about £70k‘.

That seems to have been lost on people determined to tell the OP that she should be grateful they aren’t ‘on the breadline’.

She’s in a senior lecturer/Associate Prof role. Earning c. £60k ish. Promotion opportunities are shit in academia, especially for women who have to do all the family stuff. Progression to about £70k max is quite shit as pay progression goes.

In other industries, someone with comparable experience and qualifications may well be looking at much better pay progression possibilities.

notagamer · 16/05/2022 13:25

6 months after first getting together he was sponging off you OP. It’s now two decades later and no change

no one could say he concealed this side to him!

Testina · 16/05/2022 13:25

This is one of those threads where post 1 makes me think YABU and posts 2-13 make me think - the hell haven’t you divorced this arse yet?!!!

He’s taken you £10K into your savings this year because - as an example - he wants his “special diet” (as you mentioned expensive gyms, I’ll guess there’s a lot of protein going on there…)

This isn’t just him being a bit whiny (which is still fucking annoying) but actually still spending 10-fucking-grand from savings?!

How much do you want to become a professor? Forget the money, forget the practicalities, forget him stepping up. Do you want it?

If so - I’d say go for it! Force him into childcare for conferences (so if you’re away overnight) and let your kids get used to wraparound /switch to a childminder if they really don’t like it. You must surely have a fuckton of savings with a £190K joint income no kids (wherever we’re living) So invest. Get a nanny for a year maybe - don’t see that as an outgoing from your salary, but an investment, like paying for a course. Don’t let him hold you back!

At the very least, I’d read him the divorce level riot act about not touching savings and living only from (perfectly good) income.

I do have some vague sympathy with you not having the right to force him into a career, and maybe the wee snowflake lacks confidence to apply elsewhere… but bottom line, those forgivable things are entirely wiped out by his entitled crap in pissing away your savings 🤷🏻‍♀️

notagamer · 16/05/2022 13:24

hjliu8999 · 16/05/2022 13:22

lets say this discussion started when we first got together and six months after that - his phd funding ran out but he need an extra year to finish off and he just sort of assumed that he could live on my funding so I supported him for a year as a student. the 10k per year that i got at the time was less than what we would have got on benefits - yes it has been a while and yes it's been a bone of contention. we hten got lucky and got well paid jobs for ten years so didn't have to care too much about finances, earned more than we could spend etc etc. This has since come back into the picture since we moved back to the uk and got a couple of kids.

So you’re not pissed with him being i unambitious. You’re pissed because he has, from day 1, taken the piss out of fact you are financially comfortable?

Zeus44 · 16/05/2022 13:24

£100k salary in London does not touch the sides.

You need to either move some where cheaper or get an additional income.

CaliforniaDrumming · 16/05/2022 13:24

I would never use savings to pay those exorbitant food bills. Has he not realised a recession is coming?

KettrickenSmiled · 16/05/2022 13:23

hjliu8999 · 16/05/2022 13:09

I didnt mean to drip feed but also didnt want to write an even longer essay. It's hard to summarise all the issue and a long marriage into a short post. I would be ok if he liked his job or even if he engaged with our current finances. But thats not happening either.

OK OP - understood.

Then you need to reframe it.
Instead of pushing him to change jobs, sit him down with the understanding that you are going to have a long talk.

Explain that you are not prepared to live off savings due to his overspending, & if he wants YOU to work harder to increase your salary, he needs to step up more on childcare & household management.

Given that - as PP rightly noted - you have been trapped in this unsatisfactory 'dance' for decades, he's unlikely to surprise you by offering solutions instead of moaning.
But at least your cards will be on the table.
So when you eventually reach your limit, & tell him you will not allow him to fritter the family's savings away, & are prepared to divorce him to protect your & DC's financial wellbeing, he can't act shocked.

He'd also have to parent his own DC at least occasionally if you divorced him. Just a thought ...

notagamer · 16/05/2022 13:22

@Ecclesfreckles

if you are having to sit down and explain to your husband the link between earnings and life choices, then you have to ask yourself - is promotion even possible for him?

Hallyup89 · 16/05/2022 13:22

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

hjliu8999 · 16/05/2022 13:22

notagamer · 16/05/2022 13:14

this issue is not new and has been a source of tension between DH and I ever since we got together decades ago

he is 42
have you honestly been having this discussion and tension since he was 22? Presumably in the middle of doing one of his degrees?

lets say this discussion started when we first got together and six months after that - his phd funding ran out but he need an extra year to finish off and he just sort of assumed that he could live on my funding so I supported him for a year as a student. the 10k per year that i got at the time was less than what we would have got on benefits - yes it has been a while and yes it's been a bone of contention. we hten got lucky and got well paid jobs for ten years so didn't have to care too much about finances, earned more than we could spend etc etc. This has since come back into the picture since we moved back to the uk and got a couple of kids.

OP posts:
VanGoghsDog · 16/05/2022 13:19

hjliu8999 · 16/05/2022 12:21

Ideally I would like him to find a job he enjoys rather than tell me on a daily basis that it's pointless and soul destroying. But any suggestion that he finds something else are met with complaints about the capitalist system and how it's exploitative. So I would like him to either find a job he likes or find one with more money that would both enable us to get some more childcare or for him to go part time or something.

My other concern is that unlike in my sector (his previous sector) you can literally stay in the same job until retirement this simply isnt the case where he works now. If you dont go up, eventually you end up getting out.

If he hates his job and all you want is for him to be happy you'd presumably be happy if he got a minimum wage job, as long as he was happy. Or, he can go part time in his current role and reduce his misery.

But no, you really just want more money.

He doesn't.

The only solution is to tell him that his job is his business and as long as he pays his share of costs and does his share of household chores and childcare, it's fine with you.

CloudPop · 16/05/2022 13:19

@hjliu8999 I don't think you are being unreasonable at all. He can't expect to maintain a lifestyle that costs more than he is prepared to go out and earn, and also not pull his weight around the house.

AppleandRhubarbTart · 16/05/2022 13:19

cookiemonster2468 · 16/05/2022 13:14

It sounds like budgeting is what you both need to do rather than looking for new jobs. Well, budgeting and couples counselling, probably.

On a combined income of £110k+, you should actually be able to afford those luxuries your husband wants.

But it sounds like the two of you are struggling to actually come together as a team and resolve any of this. It takes both of you at the end of the day, you have a communication issue.

TBF if they have a large London mortgage and wraparound childcare costs, I can see how dropping £200 a week on food, nearly a grand a month, might be unaffordable even on that income. 10k into savings definitely suggests a deep problem though, I agree on that point.

MindPalace · 16/05/2022 13:17

@AppleandRhubarbTart Yes, I did miss it, apologies. OP is right to be frustrated by the other issues she raises.