Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

DH and career, salary

309 replies

hjliu8999 · 16/05/2022 11:31

To preface this with, this issue is not new and has been a source of tension between DH and I ever since we got together decades ago. But just had yet another fight with DH regarding his job and whether he should look for something else.

He's been in his current position for three years now, no salary increase and no promotion - and realistically it just wont happen, they said so. I've been trying to encourage him to move on. He admits he doesnt like his job or sector so it's not like he loves it or anything but just doesn't know how to look for anything else.

And frankly am fed up. We used to live abroad where he was in the same position for ten years - no promotion and just inflationary salary increases. We came back due to my job so he found the first thing he could and basically it's the same thing. But by now we have DC and London is really expensive (his current job is also half the money he earned abroad). By now he's 42 so time is not exactly on his side. And I appreciate that 55k is not nothing, but he has three degrees and is working in a professional job.

From my side I do work full time - in the sector that he used to work in and by now earn more than he does. But it's a public sector ish job and I wont be able to find anything in the private sector (those jobs just dont exist). Realistically my pay progression is rubbish (max I will ever earn is probably 70kish) but I do have a lot more flexibility and annual leave so do more of the childcare.

Am just really fed up. With the cost of living going up along with interest rates - we have a big mortgage - and I dont know how to convince DH that he needs to find something else. He accuses me of wanting him to earn more money - like thats a bad thing or something. Am I being unreasonable or is he? Any tips on how to change things.

OP posts:
KettrickenSmiled · 17/05/2022 12:10

FFS that was a direct hit straight between the eyes @BowerOfBramble

Very well said.

BowerOfBramble · 17/05/2022 12:06

I've read all your posts and I feel sorry for you. When it comes down to it your husband is lazy and whingy. I've dated plenty of men like this in the past and could easily have married one so trust me I relate. Where he's got lucky is he's found you - a clever, high flying, well-organised woman who thinks he's cleverer than her and hasn't yet fired him out of a cannon as a possible cure for his whiny-baby syndrome.

Let's get this straight - you live in London for both your jobs but you could theoretically move somewhere cheaper and do yours. You spend above your (joint) earnings partly because of his unwillingness to live like anything other than a king. He refuses to consider your joint kids in his career choices (dropping kids up at school and picking them up isn't an optional extra, it's a legal requirement!). He assumed you will be a listener, joint (at least) earner, main carer and worship at the tarnished altar of his tired ideals.

He's a pain!!!!

He sounds like he's been in an ongoing midlife crisis since birth possibly.

I respect his ideals (maybe you have some too if you ever have a moment to actually think) but they aren't a licence to lean on your wife and droop about in a sulk. Many jobs will allow him to exercise these ideals, most are not well paying because - and this will be a shock to him - they're mostly public sector/not for profits which DON'T PRIORITISE PAYING BIG SALARIES FOR HIS MEAT BUDGET OVER SERVING THEIR CAUSES.

beechhues · 17/05/2022 12:02

So again @hjliu8999 he missed an opportunity many parents took post covid before going back to the office to barter more flexibility into his contract for the kids.

Paying tax, making charitable donations, investing in small businesses overseas probably more helpful than him uprooting his family to teach English that can be learnt on any number of apps if of use. Not such a high personal benefit though.

Testina · 17/05/2022 12:00

@Tamzo85 see when a thread is on page 13? That’s a sign that “show all” from the OP is a good move.

rookiemere · 17/05/2022 11:53

Ok so going back to your OP it all ties up now.

Him changing job to something with a bit of flexibility to support childcare arrangements and also something he can stay in until retirement, is really the only non nuclear way out of this. So it makes total sense that he needs to get a new job.

I think you need a timeline in your mind for how much longer you're prepared to support this status quo, what are your priority changes and then communicate that to him.

If it's get a new job where he can do 50% of pick ups and drop offs ( with use of before and after school club) then it makes sense for that to be in place before DC starts school in September.

AppleandRhubarbTart · 17/05/2022 11:51

Tamzo85 · 17/05/2022 11:48

Why do some women always seem to need their man to be endlessly progressive upward and onward?
If he got a better job then what? Would you be happy for him to stay in it forever or would you still think he should be trying for more?

Have you read the updates?

And thanks @Testina! Honestly, I have no problem with people wanting what they want, but call it what it is and don't blame the system when apparently your only problem with it is that it hasn't given you quite enough wealth and privilege yet.

Tamzo85 · 17/05/2022 11:48

Why do some women always seem to need their man to be endlessly progressive upward and onward?
If he got a better job then what? Would you be happy for him to stay in it forever or would you still think he should be trying for more?

Testina · 17/05/2022 11:43

“And do ask him how he thinks living off savings in a cheaper country, using money made whilst in wealthy, capitalist economies that rely on exploitation of the global poor to keep functioning fits in with his perception of himself as a left winger destroying right wing bogeymen.”

@AppleandRhubarbTart 👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻 I would bloody love to be a fly on the wall for that. You are spot on.

As is @Movingonup22 - political philosophy. I’m will to bet that this pisstaker doesn’t actually do anything to redistribute wealth - like volunteer to mentor disadvantaged kids, or cut his “special diet” to donate to a food bank.

@hjliu8999 Your youngest starts school in September. Even if there not mad keen on wrap around (and you don’t know that! Mine loved it) it’s only a few hours either side. This is the time for you to push forward what you want!

hjliu8999 · 17/05/2022 11:36

AppleandRhubarbTart · 17/05/2022 11:29

I mean, we all want a lot of things. You have no obligation to keep accepting the blame for this though. And do ask him how he thinks living off savings in a cheaper country, using money made whilst in wealthy, capitalist economies that rely on exploitation of the global poor to keep functioning fits in with his perception of himself as a left winger destroying right wing bogeymen.

Trust me he has already been told just how colonial, white cis privileged that sounds.

OP posts:
AppleandRhubarbTart · 17/05/2022 11:29

hjliu8999 · 17/05/2022 10:07

You are absolutely right and he has had therapy in the past. However, we cant afford years of therapy in the UK like we did in the past. Not sure it really helped. He loved having someone to moan to once a week but neither of us saw any progress.

He absolutely saw his identity as a left wing academic who destroys the right wing bogeyman - and he hates that he now has to work within the system rather than against it. And I appreciate that the UK is fairly right wing especially with the current government and that public sector jobs just dont pay very much while expecting you to work all hours. But again is that my fault. He basically wants to spend his days researching about the evilness of the 'system' while getting paid handsomely for it or he aint interested.

I mean, we all want a lot of things. You have no obligation to keep accepting the blame for this though. And do ask him how he thinks living off savings in a cheaper country, using money made whilst in wealthy, capitalist economies that rely on exploitation of the global poor to keep functioning fits in with his perception of himself as a left winger destroying right wing bogeymen.

Sweetpeasaremadeforbees · 17/05/2022 11:23

But again is that my fault. He basically wants to spend his days researching about the evilness of the 'system' while getting paid handsomely for it or he aint interested.

How do you honestly live with a man who thinks like this?

hjliu8999 · 17/05/2022 11:20

Well not much I guess. The reality is that for most of our 30s we had cash and no kids so never had to budget or answer difficult questions. Then he mostly WFH during Covid (obviously and in his case he loved it and was a bit more hands on with the kids) but now they are back in the office full time and our youngest is going into school in Sept, issues have come back onto the surface

OP posts:
beechhues · 17/05/2022 11:01

Blimey...he wants to be a SAHD as he thinks it's an easy option, an escape hatch. It wouldn't be good for anyone as it's more procrastination. If he missed the kids he'd already have a flexible job.

I'd be having a serious think. I wonder how many chances to pull their head out of the sand you give someone?

With the anxiety/depression/moaning/procrastination - it sounds as though he's never been any different? Literally nothing has worked?

KettrickenSmiled · 17/05/2022 10:45

Plus his industry is London based (exclusively) so it just does what he'd like to i.e. I get a job outside London, we buy a small house outright and he never has to work again. But honestly seeing as he was never all that bothered about having kids etc - I fear that might just make me resentful that I will have to work and pay for both our pensions while he gets to do nothing all because he thinks being a manager is stupid and unfulfilling.

You fear you MIGHT get resentful?
You reckon?!!!!

Listen OP - every update you post is sadder than the last. I think you have become so ground down by your H's constant negativity, entitlement, & arrogance that you have lost sight of how very much you are carrying & how very little he brings to the family.

The only thing "stupid & unfulfilling" here is your H.
For all his much-vaunted intelligence - clever is as clever does.
And he is acting like a sulky teenager who knows everything but does nothing.
If he wants to give up work & live abroad, he can do so under his own steam.
He doesn't get to make you pay for it.

rookiemere · 17/05/2022 10:32

From what you've written there's no good reasons - either emotionally or practically - to remain married. He moans, spends more money than he earns, refuses ( by dint of not applying for more suitable roles) to do any childcare, feels ( despite not doing any childcare) that he should be a SAHD.

Do you still love him ?

Movingonup22 · 17/05/2022 10:21

I think you are giving way too much credibility to his “political philosophy” - he’s just lazy and entitled.

sounds like you feel like you still need to buy into his bullshit. You really don’t.

hjliu8999 · 17/05/2022 10:07

Alaimo · 17/05/2022 09:51

OP I sympathise, there are aspects of your story that sound like you could be talking about my husband, specifically the misery about his current job mixed with a lack of initiative to look for other work. It's just so draining. Though in our case DH and I both still work in academia, but he now realises it's not for him.

I know this can be interpreted as making excuses for your husband, but could it be that he's suffering from depression? My DH has suffered from mild anxiety and depression for years (decades), but neither of us had fully realised how much that contributed to his current state of mind. He's now been back on anti-depressants for a few months, and while he still dislikes his job and moans about it a lot, I think the anti-depressants have helped him to gain some clarity and the mindspace he needed to begin considering alternative career options.

I think some of your DH's actions are clearly unacceptable (spending family money that does not match your incomes), but it does sound like there might be some underlying things he's struggling with. Academia does seem to attract people for whom their job is a core part of who they are as a person, and if he has always considered himself as an academic and now needs to readjust his own perception of who he is, he might be finding that difficult (especially since you clearly are very successful in the same job!). Again, no excuse for some of his actions, but I wonder if some sessions with a therapist could be helpful.

You are absolutely right and he has had therapy in the past. However, we cant afford years of therapy in the UK like we did in the past. Not sure it really helped. He loved having someone to moan to once a week but neither of us saw any progress.

He absolutely saw his identity as a left wing academic who destroys the right wing bogeyman - and he hates that he now has to work within the system rather than against it. And I appreciate that the UK is fairly right wing especially with the current government and that public sector jobs just dont pay very much while expecting you to work all hours. But again is that my fault. He basically wants to spend his days researching about the evilness of the 'system' while getting paid handsomely for it or he aint interested.

OP posts:
RandomMess · 17/05/2022 10:07

Honestly tell him not working is not an option it's a marriage deal breaker. If you split he'll have to get a job after all you are main cater and main breadwinner.

Spell it out to him.

I would be tempted to relocate when a suitable role for you comes up, one that makes your life financially comfortable if you divorce.

hjliu8999 · 17/05/2022 10:01

Testina · 17/05/2022 09:15

I did say, that I couldn’t speak for his one current workplace. If the original owners are still there and are 40s, then it sounds like it still has a start up vibe. You can no more compare a privately owned start up to other private sector than you can to a university.

It doesn’t make sense to think he has to have a promotion record. It’s a triangle - not everyone can be promoted. Where do you think all the other 50yos are? Sitting in my office, some of them!

I get that - which is why I would like him to apply for other jobs rather than sit in the one he has.

OP posts:
hjliu8999 · 17/05/2022 10:00

@Portiasparty I think you are right that he needs to get over it. The reality is that he's only really had two jobs in his life (exc student jobs) and with the last one I told him all about our industry and he just relied on that. I have tried to send him job ads for his current sector but he says they dont fit, which is fine but he also says he doesnt really understand how it works. The difference is that this time - I dont work in it so cant help. He's on his own.

@Pipsquiggle He should definitely just move to a bigger corporate but he doesnt like applying for jobs, finds it soul destroying and think the current work model is all b s. Whilst I dont disagree with David Graeber - he's done nothing to manage without such a job.

@RandomMess Honestly if things dont change then I might have to but it will take a while etc. Plus his industry is London based (exclusively) so it just does what he'd like to i.e. I get a job outside London, we buy a small house outright and he never has to work again. But honestly seeing as he was never all that bothered about having kids etc - I fear that might just make me resentful that I will have to work and pay for both our pensions while he gets to do nothing all because he thinks being a manager is stupid and unfulfilling.

OP posts:
notagamer · 17/05/2022 10:00

Op

you don’t seem to like your husband let alone love him
he is moany and negative and sounds a bit depressed
you have very different approaches to finances, savings and lifestyle
he doesn’t support you with the children
its been going on for decades
you fundamentally don’t respect him and he doesn’t seem too bothered about that fact

and I’m guessing your sex life with him is non existent

this isn’t a happy marriage even if you took away the money issue. In fact this is the polar opposite of a happy marriage. This can’t be a pleasant environment for you, your dh and most importantly - your children

Alaimo · 17/05/2022 09:51

OP I sympathise, there are aspects of your story that sound like you could be talking about my husband, specifically the misery about his current job mixed with a lack of initiative to look for other work. It's just so draining. Though in our case DH and I both still work in academia, but he now realises it's not for him.

I know this can be interpreted as making excuses for your husband, but could it be that he's suffering from depression? My DH has suffered from mild anxiety and depression for years (decades), but neither of us had fully realised how much that contributed to his current state of mind. He's now been back on anti-depressants for a few months, and while he still dislikes his job and moans about it a lot, I think the anti-depressants have helped him to gain some clarity and the mindspace he needed to begin considering alternative career options.

I think some of your DH's actions are clearly unacceptable (spending family money that does not match your incomes), but it does sound like there might be some underlying things he's struggling with. Academia does seem to attract people for whom their job is a core part of who they are as a person, and if he has always considered himself as an academic and now needs to readjust his own perception of who he is, he might be finding that difficult (especially since you clearly are very successful in the same job!). Again, no excuse for some of his actions, but I wonder if some sessions with a therapist could be helpful.

Sweetpeasaremadeforbees · 17/05/2022 09:47

He also refuses to learn anything about his industry (private sector) or network, which is fine but he hates his current job

I'm not sure that is fine actually. I really hope he hides his disdain for the private sector from his colleagues or they probably will try to gently get rid of him.

The more you post the more unpleasant he sounds OP. Resentful of your success, arrogant (he clearly thinks he's worthy of an expensive lifestyle above what he can afford) and a bit thick (how the hell does he think academia is funded if it isn't by the evil capitalists - does he think the money comes from the magic money tree?). Honestly, I would be protecting your savings and having a very serious talk about the future of your marriage.

Testina · 17/05/2022 09:15

I did say, that I couldn’t speak for his one current workplace. If the original owners are still there and are 40s, then it sounds like it still has a start up vibe. You can no more compare a privately owned start up to other private sector than you can to a university.

It doesn’t make sense to think he has to have a promotion record. It’s a triangle - not everyone can be promoted. Where do you think all the other 50yos are? Sitting in my office, some of them!

RandomMess · 17/05/2022 07:27

Considering how many good universities there are across the UK and many in much cheaper areas I seriously would look at securing a job for yourself elsewhere.

£400k would get you a prestigious detached 4 bed house in a good location on the doorstep of the uni and great schools where I am. 3 bed standard semi start in the same location start at £200k and that is after the Covid massive price hikes.

At least it gives you options to end the relationship if his appalling attitude carries on.

Fact of life is that once DC are at school not working is a huge and rare privilege. Pension, DC getting more expensive, cost of living rocketing.