Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

So called 'paedophile hunters'

160 replies

motherofdragons33 · 16/05/2022 09:00

Apologies for sensitive subject but am I the only person who finds these so called hunters problematic?

There is a video currently circulating my social media of a 'sting' on a young man from a town not far from where I live. He has allegedly been talking sexually to who he believed was a 13 year old girl but was actually a decoy. The video shows the sting and is 45 minutes long. During the video he faints and his parents are involved, presumably this is a huge shock to them and they seemed confused and were defending their son.

The comments were terrible. Lots of people saying the parents must have known and should be arrested too. Comments about them looking like 'nonces' themselves. This is where I have the issue - people who have no involvement get dragged into the public lynching and have their lives ruined when it's probably come as a horrible shock to them too.

I'm not sympathising with this person of course, if he's done what he's accused of then it's sickening and he should be punished. But is this the right way to go about things? I can't help but feel like this type of Facebook vigilante justice is a bit of a glory hunt and is quite irresponsible. There are many cases where genuine police investigations have been hampered by them. And do the immediate family whether it's parents, spouses, children deserve to be dragged into something they know nothing about?

OP posts:
AlternativePerspective · 16/05/2022 10:02

LanaGardner · 16/05/2022 09:54

What about police officers that do that?
Everything has to come from the paedophile side (language and suggestion of meeting) anyway not the child

The police officers are highly trained, most only manage to do it for a short time, and many need therapy afterwards.

And they don’t broadcast their findings all over the internet in a “look at me” style.

I suspect these so called paedophile hunters are the same types who get involved in brawling in the local pub or at football matches and who beat up their wives.

Reallyreallyborednow · 16/05/2022 10:02

Having them 'outed' as a peado is more than what the police would do behind closed doors in more instances.
Peados are probably more worried about this sort of thing than the police. If anyone Google's their name, they'll know exactly what they are

there are also multiple incidences where their shitty investigative work has “outed” innocent people. And ruined lives. Because a a quick google and they show up as a paedo.

imagine your husband or brother, or son appearing in one of these videos because they’ve got the wrong “tom smith”. Your house is on there, your town.

the police can check online profiles and make sure everything lines up. These vigilantes work on the offender telling them their name and arranging a meet to identify a person. So someone calling themselves tom smith arranges to meet in croydon. If they don’t show they look up a tom smith in that area on the electoral roll and go to that address. So no, they don’t always get it right.

NightmareSlashDelightful · 16/05/2022 10:00

What about police officers that do that?

Officers who do this kind of work undergo a lot of specialist training. They are monitored when interacting online, and have to follow a kind of 'script' which has been developed by child psychologists, lawyers and other experts to safeguard the child at all times, as well as gather crucial evidence in a robust way.

There is a network of support available for the officers who do this work, many of whom find it traumatising and very difficult.

Sirzy · 16/05/2022 09:58

LanaGardner · 16/05/2022 09:54

What about police officers that do that?
Everything has to come from the paedophile side (language and suggestion of meeting) anyway not the child

They are doing it in a control, monitored situation. They have mandated counselling to help them with what is involved in the job. Police in areas like this are highly trained and have to see some horrendous things through their job.

very different to a man sitting in his bedroom deciding to be some sort of saviour while pretending to be a child.

autienotnaughty · 16/05/2022 09:58

I don't have issue with them gathering evidence if they choose to but it should be passed on to police and dealt with in a law abiding way. Videoing their house/other family members puts them at risk potentially including children who could get injured in crossfire.

motherofdragons33 · 16/05/2022 09:55

ittakes2 · 16/05/2022 09:25

"What about the innocent people caught in the crossfire?"
The most innocent people are the children. If that was a real 13 year old girl she would be the most innocent victim. I'm sorry his parents were shocked - but better than than the parents of the young children being shocked and having to rebuild their children's lives after they have been targeted by sexual predators regardless of neurodiversity.

What about the children of the person who has had their face, name and whereabouts plastered all over social media on the basis of 'evidence' collected solely by these untrained, unskilled vigilantes? Imagine having to have to go to school knowing that your dad/uncle/brother has been stung for one of these highly emotive crimes. There's a reason why peoples identities are kept private until they have had a fair trial.

Of course the victims are the priority but there are often other innocent people who have their lives destroyed and sometimes even face physical threat when they themselves haven't done anything wrong.

I actually agree that the hunters get a thrill out of it. If not the chat itself then definitely from the accolades, likes and adoration of people who think they are keeping their kids safe. It's a grim way to boost ego in my opinion. I remember the documentary of Stinson hunter and his group who went as far as having merchandise created. How is that purely about protecting children? It's about wanting to be recognised as some sort of hero or celebrity.

OP posts:
LanaGardner · 16/05/2022 09:54

AlternativePerspective · 16/05/2022 09:41

I think these people are probably sexually deviant themselves. There’s something sinister about pretending to be a 13 year old and indulging with sexy talk with a paedophile.

What about police officers that do that?
Everything has to come from the paedophile side (language and suggestion of meeting) anyway not the child

AlternativePerspective · 16/05/2022 09:53

I suspect a lot of them are paedophiles. It’s much easier to defend your being on a site where child abusers go when you say you’re a “paedophile hunter.” Clearly they get a kick out of child abuse or they wouldn’t be indulging in this kind of chatter.

How would people here feel about their husbands, brothers, sons, fathers, being on the internet pretending to be a sexy 13 year old? Proud? Or repulsed?

Reallyreallyborednow · 16/05/2022 09:52

Well, they seem to be finding a lot more than the police are managing so that’s th problem

how do you know? The police don’t livestream their arrests therefore they aren’t doing anything?

think about it. A police investigation will be done by under cover operators. Telling the public what they are doing and how they are doing it will lead to offenders evading more easily.

there was an article the other day where a vigilante group got involved with an offender that two police undercover units were already on. It just puts the investigation at risk.

which is why I think these vigilante groups tend to catch the more vulnerable end who don’t realise they’re being stung, anyone can watch and see how they operate.

as for the hunters themselves they’re just big bullies. I hate watching the “stings”. They put people at risk. Like others have said there’s no need to livestream. Their tactics also mean fewer actually go to court as the evidence isn’t documented properly. Coercing a “confession” from vulnerable people like that will not stand up.

NightmareSlashDelightful · 16/05/2022 09:50

I have family in the police and friends in the probation service, both of whom regularly deal with crimes of this type.

The 'hunters' cause many times more problems than they solve. Many times. They are a scourge. They often get the wrong person, target the wrong house, or publicise case-sensitive information that can go on to affect crucial potential evidence.

A significant number of them actually turn out to be child abusers themselves. Child abusers often set up complex networks and seemingly helpful 'look at me!' activities to deflect attention from their own activities, and this is one of those.

They frequently target people with learning difficulties or disabilities, again with little to no understanding of how carefully cases need to be built against people with additional needs in order to secure a conviction in the appropriate way. (On the occasions that the person in question has actually committed the crime, which isn't always the case.)

They are almost always narcissists with an inflated sense of their own importance, and a minimal understanding of how case-building happens in police investigations.

The system isn't perfect. (In some police services the framework and investigative support for crimes of this nature are better than others.) But it's not 'broken' either. And lowest common denominator mob justice like this is 100% not the way to 'fix' it.

ThatAnnoysMeToo · 16/05/2022 09:46

x2boys · 16/05/2022 09:39

So how is blasting all over the Internet, in anyway helpful to anyone ?

Having them 'outed' as a peado is more than what the police would do behind closed doors in more instances.
Peados are probably more worried about this sort of thing than the police. If anyone Google's their name, they'll know exactly what they are.

Sirzy · 16/05/2022 09:41

AlternativePerspective · 16/05/2022 09:41

I think these people are probably sexually deviant themselves. There’s something sinister about pretending to be a 13 year old and indulging with sexy talk with a paedophile.

I agree

AlternativePerspective · 16/05/2022 09:41

I think these people are probably sexually deviant themselves. There’s something sinister about pretending to be a 13 year old and indulging with sexy talk with a paedophile.

Deadringer · 16/05/2022 09:40

It's one thing catching a paedophile and sending the evidance to the police, it's quite another broadcasting it to the world. Aside from the fact that yes, innocent people will be hurt, it will more than likely damage any subsequent court case.

x2boys · 16/05/2022 09:40

10HailMarys · 16/05/2022 09:32

I get the strong impression that a lot of the 'paedophile hunters' get quite a thrill from pretending to be little kids on line and having sexy conversations with paedophiles, to be honest. It's all deeply grim, like people who read nothing but child cruelty memoirs under the guise of 'concern'.

On a practical note, they don't do a great job of catching paedophiles or getting convictions. They don't share videos of the times when they've got it wrong and they don't tell you about the (many) times when they actually hinder a police operation or prejudice a court case.

They're self-styled vigilantes with a prurient obsession, basically.

Indeed it's all a bit within plain sight isn't it?

bedsidetab · 16/05/2022 09:39

But, it's the inevitable consequence of the lacklustre justice that is achieved between the police and the judicial service. If it cannot and will not put the resources in to keeping children safe then there will always be support for this kind of retribution.

yep

Awwlookatmybabyspider · 16/05/2022 09:39

Exactly! Moomintrolls

x2boys · 16/05/2022 09:39

ThatAnnoysMeToo · 16/05/2022 09:35

The thing is, if they gave it to the police, they wouldn't do anything.
I would agree with you if the system wasn't so broken.

So how is blasting all over the Internet, in anyway helpful to anyone ?

Awwlookatmybabyspider · 16/05/2022 09:37

I'm afraid I'm with Ittakes2 on this one. He turned up to meet what he believed was a child.!!! and to do (well it doesn't bare thinking of does it) Children aren't even safe in their own homes now because of these disgusting predators.

ThatAnnoysMeToo · 16/05/2022 09:35

The thing is, if they gave it to the police, they wouldn't do anything.
I would agree with you if the system wasn't so broken.

Sirzy · 16/05/2022 09:33

x2boys · 16/05/2022 09:29

If the people who carried out these "stings" were really interested in public justice they would just give their evidence to the police
Live streaming it all over the Internet, is just going to jeopardise any fair trial, and the perpetrator is more likely to be acquitted.

Exactly.

and I doubt having faces and details posted over social media will help the victims either. They won’t see proper justice but will see the face of their abuser over social media.

I know of a family impacted by child sex offences recently, they dealt with it amazingly but when things where public knowledge they found it hard having those reminders and people talking about it. The family weren’t named in the media but he was and people put two and two together to link them.

10HailMarys · 16/05/2022 09:32

I get the strong impression that a lot of the 'paedophile hunters' get quite a thrill from pretending to be little kids on line and having sexy conversations with paedophiles, to be honest. It's all deeply grim, like people who read nothing but child cruelty memoirs under the guise of 'concern'.

On a practical note, they don't do a great job of catching paedophiles or getting convictions. They don't share videos of the times when they've got it wrong and they don't tell you about the (many) times when they actually hinder a police operation or prejudice a court case.

They're self-styled vigilantes with a prurient obsession, basically.

moomintrolls · 16/05/2022 09:30

So campaign for the police to arrest them so the public don't have to do this.

IglesiasPiggl · 16/05/2022 09:29

This is precisely why vigilante justice is illegal.

x2boys · 16/05/2022 09:29

If the people who carried out these "stings" were really interested in public justice they would just give their evidence to the police
Live streaming it all over the Internet, is just going to jeopardise any fair trial, and the perpetrator is more likely to be acquitted.

Swipe left for the next trending thread