Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

So called 'paedophile hunters'

160 replies

motherofdragons33 · 16/05/2022 09:00

Apologies for sensitive subject but am I the only person who finds these so called hunters problematic?

There is a video currently circulating my social media of a 'sting' on a young man from a town not far from where I live. He has allegedly been talking sexually to who he believed was a 13 year old girl but was actually a decoy. The video shows the sting and is 45 minutes long. During the video he faints and his parents are involved, presumably this is a huge shock to them and they seemed confused and were defending their son.

The comments were terrible. Lots of people saying the parents must have known and should be arrested too. Comments about them looking like 'nonces' themselves. This is where I have the issue - people who have no involvement get dragged into the public lynching and have their lives ruined when it's probably come as a horrible shock to them too.

I'm not sympathising with this person of course, if he's done what he's accused of then it's sickening and he should be punished. But is this the right way to go about things? I can't help but feel like this type of Facebook vigilante justice is a bit of a glory hunt and is quite irresponsible. There are many cases where genuine police investigations have been hampered by them. And do the immediate family whether it's parents, spouses, children deserve to be dragged into something they know nothing about?

OP posts:
LetHimHaveIt · 16/05/2022 11:48

Of course you're not the only one 🙄 and they're more than 'problematic' -
they're a bloody menace: self-proclaimed 'heroes' who are invariably just thick as fuck inadequates. They act illegally and they make prosecution impossible, usually. I detest them.

wonderwoman26 · 16/05/2022 11:34

I agree with you OP, but only because these so called 'paedophile hunters' only do it for the live feeds. From first hand experience, they are then very reluctant to actually work witht he police to provide evidence that can actually be admissable in court.

Majority of the time doctoring their own evidence, only providing parts and thats if they even bother to return calls and give statements. Half the time they then refuse contact with the police and nothing can actually be done.

AstroSurf · 16/05/2022 11:30

I'm ambivalent on the subject. On the one hand paedophiles who act on their desires are monsters who can do lasting damage. And if the only way to stop these people is to be a vigilante, so be it.

On the other hand, I suspect the vast majority of these stings would never have got to this stage IRL. It's only because there's a '13 year old' eager and 'gagging for it' that the conversation continues to where it does and they even think of meeting up. So the vigilantes aren't so much exposing the problem as causing it.

Dbank · 16/05/2022 11:15

We seem to think own judgement is what matters, not a judge or jury, it's a dangerous road to mob rule and unfounded oppression.

These "hunters" aren't just hunting they are acting as self-appointed judge and juries.

Innocent until proven guilty, doesn't matter if you're Jimmy Saville, Price Andrew or the Yorkshire ripper.

Reallyreallyborednow · 16/05/2022 11:03

Again, “stings” aren’t needed for any sort of crime.

Police can go through proper legal channels to identify the owner of an online account, whether it’s chatting to children, sharing images, whatever. Then they make conventional arrest enquiries.

at no point is it necessary to “sting” anyone. The only reason hunters need to arrange a meet is because they cannot correctly identify an online account so the way they do it is arranging a meet and assume the person who turns up is the offender.

shoehornartth · 16/05/2022 11:03

There's that TV show Criminal, this is an episode - the paedophile didn't give the correct name / details so they falsely accused someone else who committed suicide when 'exposed'

I've heard it prevents justice because of the way in which it has been done. There's an episode documentary on C4 about it - the police also do what paedophile hunters do but are far more careful with it to ensure prosecution.

Ferngreen · 16/05/2022 11:01

Low hanging fruit really , catching a learning disabled person - ok good but that's not really sorting the global problem.

pollypokcet · 16/05/2022 10:57

I meant CSA images, whoops. Vigilantes aren't looking for images, there's no real children involved. I've confused myself now.

pollypokcet · 16/05/2022 10:56

Reallyreallyborednow · 16/05/2022 10:20

In general? well, somebody has to do stings for trafficking, CSA. Someone has to see the material and investigate. I wouldn't want that job

there is no need for “stings” at all.

the only reason vigilantes have to “sting” is they don’t have the resources and legal authority to identify the person behind an online profile.

that and obviously the facebook likes.

I kind of agree. I think to catch a predator was good, some of them really needed to be caught.

These people don't need to be on the streets. Of course we need police officers doing stings for CSA, that can't be debated. Vigilantes aren't doing stings for CSA, I was talking about officers.

MayorDusty · 16/05/2022 10:42

I had a change of heart about this a few years ago.
after seeing To Catch a Predator type programmes I thought it was a needs must situation and even if it wasn't palatable the benefit of having someone do it outweighed the cons.
as it's evolved, Facebook live streams and mob justice etc I've realised it's not only unproductive with removing real paedophiles it's a very sinister vehicle for paedophiles to exploit as well as the potential for errors being devastating.
Better policing and justice goes without saying and I'd support a civilian task force with the correct training and scrutiny but these latest vigilante types, at best are glory hunters and at worst the fox is in the hen house. What better defence to a murky hard drive than public, well documented crime fighting?

Reallyreallyborednow · 16/05/2022 10:40

What difference does that make If they are getting involved with underage children??

it makes a difference as procedure for evidence needs to be followed.

vulnerable adults need another appropriate adult present for questioning. They need an assessment as to their level of understanding and competence to answer any charges.

cornering a vulnerable adult and bullying them into agreeing they’re a dirty nonce is a surefire way to get the case dismissed.

i saw a sting with one man who clearly had no understanding of the questions the big man in the “official” hig viz police- like outfit was asking him. He replied yes to every single question. A half decent solicitor will get that thrown out in seconds.

Narwhalelife · 16/05/2022 10:39

10HailMarys · 16/05/2022 09:32

I get the strong impression that a lot of the 'paedophile hunters' get quite a thrill from pretending to be little kids on line and having sexy conversations with paedophiles, to be honest. It's all deeply grim, like people who read nothing but child cruelty memoirs under the guise of 'concern'.

On a practical note, they don't do a great job of catching paedophiles or getting convictions. They don't share videos of the times when they've got it wrong and they don't tell you about the (many) times when they actually hinder a police operation or prejudice a court case.

They're self-styled vigilantes with a prurient obsession, basically.

Absolutely this!

I always see these in the same way as when people film themselves giving a homeless person a greggs sausage roll (and then say they won’t give money incase it’s used for drugs 🤦‍♀️)

It is extremist behaviour really.

It is also entrapment.

All of this being said, paedophilla is abhorrent and more should be done to help victims

AlternativePerspective · 16/05/2022 10:35

for those who have no issue with this think about this:

Imagine. Your husband, brother, family friend is online, pretending to be your 13 year old daughter, or niece, in order to lure child abusers. Because that’s essentially what they’re doing.It may not be an actual named person they’re pretending to be, but they are pretending to be a child, it could be your child, in order to talk sexily to paedophiles and to then claim the glory of having talked sexily to paedophiles

You’re comfortable with that are you?

Maybebabyno2 · 16/05/2022 10:30

*paediatrician

Mally100 · 16/05/2022 10:29

SafeguardingSocialWorker · 16/05/2022 09:12

There's obviously a different set of concerns with that but it's a completly inappropriate way of approaching someone who is themselves very vulnerable.

What difference does that make If they are getting involved with underage children??

veronicagoldberg · 16/05/2022 10:29

As far as I'm concerned they can fill their boots.

Maybebabyno2 · 16/05/2022 10:29

Always reminds me of the peaduotrision who was hunted down and killed as someone mistook the title of a child doctor and thought he was a child rapist.

Also I don't know how they differentiate the kids from the adults. When i was a child, I regularly lied about my age online, what if they are talking to an actual child, are they then grooming them?

thevanilla · 16/05/2022 10:28

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

🙄 use your brain a little before you speak

thevanilla · 16/05/2022 10:27

yanbu. they’re doing it for their own glory and never show the videos of where they fucked up a police investigation or got the wrong person. I feel like the paedo hunter/ EDL member Venn diagram is more like one circle

topshotta · 16/05/2022 10:23

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Reallyreallyborednow · 16/05/2022 10:20

In general? well, somebody has to do stings for trafficking, CSA. Someone has to see the material and investigate. I wouldn't want that job

there is no need for “stings” at all.

the only reason vigilantes have to “sting” is they don’t have the resources and legal authority to identify the person behind an online profile.

that and obviously the facebook likes.

Georgeskitchen · 16/05/2022 10:16

I get what you are saying. I think the best way forward is to hand the video evidence to the police . To say they won't do anything is slightly unfair, they have dedicated units to trap these people:, but unfortunately with social media and smartphones there are just so many of them at it, it's a very uphill task

fromdownwest · 16/05/2022 10:15

I saw one video of a previously convicted offender, he had been caught again, far worse than his previous case.
However, the case was thrown out of court, as the evidence was deemed to be gathered under duress. In the video, they physically restrain, intimidate, chase after him, and corner him down an side street and tackle him to the ground.

Had they just handed the evidence to the police, this awful being would be behind bars, now he is I imagine, back doing what he is doing.

If they stopped at the evidence gathering, and then handed the evidence over, it is a good thing. However, they appear to thrive on the fame and hunt more than the cause.

pollypokcet · 16/05/2022 10:12

AlternativePerspective · 16/05/2022 09:41

I think these people are probably sexually deviant themselves. There’s something sinister about pretending to be a 13 year old and indulging with sexy talk with a paedophile.

For these particular individuals? I think you're right for some of them. In general? well, somebody has to do stings for trafficking, CSA. Someone has to see the material and investigate. I wouldn't want that job.

Random vigilantes on the street making it their mission? I question their motives, they do seem to enjoy the power, some of the groups.

pollypokcet · 16/05/2022 10:08

SafeguardingSocialWorker · 16/05/2022 09:10

A lot of the time the people they are 'catching' are neurodiverse or have some level of learning disability themselves.

There's obvio

That doesn't stop them making graphic texts towards young teens. Possibly younger if they had access to younger. Confused

They're not meeting up for friendship, they are talking about sex to minors.