Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

So called 'paedophile hunters'

160 replies

motherofdragons33 · 16/05/2022 09:00

Apologies for sensitive subject but am I the only person who finds these so called hunters problematic?

There is a video currently circulating my social media of a 'sting' on a young man from a town not far from where I live. He has allegedly been talking sexually to who he believed was a 13 year old girl but was actually a decoy. The video shows the sting and is 45 minutes long. During the video he faints and his parents are involved, presumably this is a huge shock to them and they seemed confused and were defending their son.

The comments were terrible. Lots of people saying the parents must have known and should be arrested too. Comments about them looking like 'nonces' themselves. This is where I have the issue - people who have no involvement get dragged into the public lynching and have their lives ruined when it's probably come as a horrible shock to them too.

I'm not sympathising with this person of course, if he's done what he's accused of then it's sickening and he should be punished. But is this the right way to go about things? I can't help but feel like this type of Facebook vigilante justice is a bit of a glory hunt and is quite irresponsible. There are many cases where genuine police investigations have been hampered by them. And do the immediate family whether it's parents, spouses, children deserve to be dragged into something they know nothing about?

OP posts:
Askinforabaskin · 16/05/2022 17:29

i feel like a lot of these hunters have very little other accomplishments in their lives and that spending time and sharing their ‘catch’ makes up for it.

very few of the hunts lead to convictions because they usually entrap people by pretending to be underage.

I’m not being an apologist, but more needs to be done in schools to educate young people. There appear to be far too many 18 year olds on the sex offenders register for messages/ images to girls a few years younger

Prinnny · 16/05/2022 16:55

The punishment that the courts give these scumbags is often so insignificant and lacking I’m glad in a way that these groups exist. Often you hear that these sickos only get community service, not even a custodial sentence, for violating young minds and attempting to meet for their own sick sexual gratification. At least when they are named and shamed online the local communities are aware and can safeguard children who may have otherwise come into contact with them.

IglesiasPiggl · 16/05/2022 16:06

But I do hear of many cases where prosecutions have been compromised by these morons because those involved were already under surveillance by the police or because the ‘stings’ drive them underground

That's a really good point about people who don't know what they've doing wading in and wrecking an ongoing surveillance because they think they know better.

Onlyforcake · 16/05/2022 15:57

Any kind of 'trial' without actual legal process is just a bunch of self serving twats committing a crime themselves.theyre not protecting anyone, and have been known to make bringing charges impossible.

cantthinkofabetterusername · 16/05/2022 15:56

I know the video you mean I've seen it. In my opinion it should be left to the police, as others have said they should hand evidence to the police without streaming it online

JaniceBattersby · 16/05/2022 15:52

I spend my working life at court reporting on these kind of cases. The vast, vast majority of these men are caught by the police. We get probably one every year in our court that’s a successful conviction brought about by the actions of an online vigilante group.

But I do hear of many cases where prosecutions have been compromised by these morons because those involved were already under surveillance by the police or because the ‘stings’ drive them underground.

The gotcha videos they produce have never once been used as evidence in court as they simply aren’t admissible. So what’s the point of them? They’re for clicks. If these people were genuinely interested in justice being done they would hand over their ‘evidence’ to the police and not stick it up on FB.

Shakeitshakeitbaby · 16/05/2022 15:36

Yanbu. Where I see and appreciate the job they are doing catching potential offenders I have seen numerous of these videos where the offender clearly has complex needs. It also makes family a target for vigilante justice. Give your evidence to the police and let them handle it. Why does it need to be plastered over the Internet?

LauraNicolaides · 16/05/2022 15:30

codeVeronica · 16/05/2022 15:27

What crime is that? Whataw was she breaking?

Exactly - there's a very good example of the problems of giving people who don't know what they're talking about any part in the process.

codeVeronica · 16/05/2022 15:27

Awwlookatmybabyspider · 16/05/2022 13:48

Well for defending the Paedophillic son for a start.

What crime is that? Whataw was she breaking?

EmeraldShamrock1 · 16/05/2022 15:25

And that's fine it's when the Hunters ,blast the evidence all over the Internet jeopardising any fair trial it becomes a big problem.
I agree that uploading stings online is wrong, I have no problem with the hunting itself just the catch.
The information should be handed to the police so the perpetrator can get a suspended sentence and registered.
There has to be a better way of changing things.
I can't remember where I saw the study people are born attracted by same sex, opposite sex, or under age minors.
Conversion therapy doesn't work, castration or hormone blockers maybe? It wouldn't work for those who enjoyed it.

x2boys · 16/05/2022 15:08

Blowyourowntrumpet · 16/05/2022 14:55

I personally know of one man who was "caught' by paedophile hunters. The evidence was handed to the police and he was prosecuted and imprisoned. Sometimes the end justifies the means.

And that's fine it's when the Hunters ,blast the evidence all over the Internet jeopardising any fair trial it becomes a big problem .

Lastqueenofscotland2 · 16/05/2022 15:00

Apparently the videos they take can mean that taking these offenders to court is impossible due to issues around right to a fair trial.

motherofdragons33 · 16/05/2022 14:57

@Awwlookatmybabyspider I wasn't directing the last comment at you. I meant that the hunters should seek their desperately craved glory and validation elsewhere.

I'm not trying to change your opinion. It's a discussion. We don't need to agree.

Judging by the comments on the video
I saw, a lot of the supporters are somewhat lacking in intelligence or at least basic understanding of how the criminal justice system works. I don't sympathise with the perpetrators but I do support the need for a fair trial. And I do fully sympathise with the family members who knew nothing about it yet still find themselves in the firing line from a bunch of idiotic keyboard warriors and these glory hunting vigilantes.

OP posts:
Blowyourowntrumpet · 16/05/2022 14:55

I personally know of one man who was "caught' by paedophile hunters. The evidence was handed to the police and he was prosecuted and imprisoned. Sometimes the end justifies the means.

iloveeverykindofcat · 16/05/2022 14:52

As significant proportion of MN is oddly pro-vigiliante justice. I've noticed this before. I've worked with criminologists before, who assure me it's not remotely helpful. For anyone, including the victims. Its just a way for people to feel emotionally vindicated and good about themselves. Pps are right that it's far more likely to result in trials being compromised and the offender - if there is one - going free.

topshotta · 16/05/2022 14:50

thevanilla how was i not using my brain in that sentence

LauraNicolaides · 16/05/2022 14:49

The more I read about these stings, the more I think that the people who perpetrate them and the people who defend the people who perpetrate them are somewhat lacking in inteligence.

Agreed, this is entirely obvious from watching the stings and reading the justifications.

MaryAndHerNet · 16/05/2022 14:45

There's a documentary on Netflix called Pedophile Hunters I think.
It's about Stinson Hunter.

Now all the rest of it aside.
They talk to a cop during the show and he says he encountered 2000+ me approaching what they thought was underage girls. In all of them, only 2 ever said no, you're too young.

I've no sympathy for the men that get caught I'm afraid. They don't have to be on apps, don't have to talk to underage girls, don't have to send underage girls images and videos and the certainly don't have to travel many many miles to meet what they believe is a 13 year old girl.

I'll save my sympathies for victims of these men

steppemum · 16/05/2022 14:42

ittakes2 · 16/05/2022 09:25

"What about the innocent people caught in the crossfire?"
The most innocent people are the children. If that was a real 13 year old girl she would be the most innocent victim. I'm sorry his parents were shocked - but better than than the parents of the young children being shocked and having to rebuild their children's lives after they have been targeted by sexual predators regardless of neurodiversity.

That is not completely true.

I know someone who's husband was arrested and later sentenced. Until the police turned up on her doorstep she had no idea. She was devastated. I know her really well, and I know she had not a clue. Their marriage was going through a rough patch, but she had no idea that this was the reason.

The thing is, they have 3 children. At the time they were primary school age.

I am eternally grateful that in the process of reporting etc on her bastard dh, her name, and that of her kids, was left out of it. It was hard enough for them as a family trying to live in the aftermath of the discovery.

If he had been found by a vigilante group, I am sure her kids' faces would now be plastered all over social media. As it is they have all suffered long term mental health issues as a direct result of who their father is.

Why are her kids less important than his victims? They are all sufferers. And they are all kids.

It is too easy to say the innocent children are the sufferers. Life is often more complex, which set of innocent children take priority here?

Neverreturntoathread · 16/05/2022 14:38

FourTeaFallOut · 16/05/2022 09:22

The reason why we don't tolerate vigilante justice is because the punishment meated out is unfair, incorrect and violent.

But, it's the inevitable consequence of the lacklustre justice that is achieved between the police and the judicial service. If it cannot and will not put the resources in to keeping children safe then there will always be support for this kind of retribution.

This.

The criminal justice system was created to make sure that punishment was fair. Without effective and proper procedure, humans have a tendency to lynch people, often the wrong person.

The problem is that the legal system is falling apart. Most rapists don’t end up in prison, child abusers are rarely caught, courts have huge delays. So vigilante justice inevitably emerges. We need a better funded and better trained police force that has better priorities, or we’ll end up lynching people and burning witches again.

I’m particularly interested in the way social media justice warriors try to destroy careers/livelihoods in a way that is way out of proportion to the perceived ‘offence’ (which is usually the terrible crime of disagreeing with the loudest mob du jour). Courts don’t do that. They issue fines and prison time but they don’t deliberately destroy livelihoods. It’s an interesting difference.

AlternativePerspective · 16/05/2022 14:35

MrsGinaHarrison87 · 16/05/2022 13:55

The decoys do not do sexy talk, send photos or approach the paedophile first as that is entrapment. The decoy usually responds with things like " I don't understand", " I'm scared", " I'm only a child". Every chance is taken to ensure that all the evidence comes from the paedophile and that they've in no way been led into anything and that the hunters can say with all certainty that the paedophile believed they were talking to a child.

They don’t have to. The people they’re talking to do. So essentially they’re getting off on a paedophile talking about what they would like to do to a 13 year old. You don’t think that’s perverse?

These so called paedophile hunters are just as much perverts as the people they claim to be outing.

AlternativePerspective · 16/05/2022 14:32

Awwlookatmybabyspider · 16/05/2022 13:48

Well for defending the Paedophillic son for a start.

You do know that we have innocent until proven guilty don’t you?

Oh but wait, how dare someone defend their child who they as yet have no idea whether they courted a crime apart from the fact that a group of thugs turned up on his doorstep with a facebook live feed.

The more I read about these stings, the more I think that the people who perpetrate them and the people who defend the people who perpetrate them are somewhat lacking in inteligence.

LauraNicolaides · 16/05/2022 14:32

motherofdragons33 · 16/05/2022 09:00

Apologies for sensitive subject but am I the only person who finds these so called hunters problematic?

There is a video currently circulating my social media of a 'sting' on a young man from a town not far from where I live. He has allegedly been talking sexually to who he believed was a 13 year old girl but was actually a decoy. The video shows the sting and is 45 minutes long. During the video he faints and his parents are involved, presumably this is a huge shock to them and they seemed confused and were defending their son.

The comments were terrible. Lots of people saying the parents must have known and should be arrested too. Comments about them looking like 'nonces' themselves. This is where I have the issue - people who have no involvement get dragged into the public lynching and have their lives ruined when it's probably come as a horrible shock to them too.

I'm not sympathising with this person of course, if he's done what he's accused of then it's sickening and he should be punished. But is this the right way to go about things? I can't help but feel like this type of Facebook vigilante justice is a bit of a glory hunt and is quite irresponsible. There are many cases where genuine police investigations have been hampered by them. And do the immediate family whether it's parents, spouses, children deserve to be dragged into something they know nothing about?

YANBU

The reasons why there are checks and balances in the criminal justice process is to prevent innocent people from being wrongly punished.

These vigilantes want to sidestep the safeguards for their own glorification and moral crusade.

LoveLarry · 16/05/2022 14:31

AlternativePerspective · 16/05/2022 09:41

I think these people are probably sexually deviant themselves. There’s something sinister about pretending to be a 13 year old and indulging with sexy talk with a paedophile.

Well quite

These sorts of mobs usually attract the hard of thinking

Hiding in plain sight, as a PP said.

FabFitFifties · 16/05/2022 14:28

Glory hunting. It is disgusting. They should be arrested themselves. Nil other reason for posting it on social media.

Swipe left for the next trending thread