Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

So called 'paedophile hunters'

160 replies

motherofdragons33 · 16/05/2022 09:00

Apologies for sensitive subject but am I the only person who finds these so called hunters problematic?

There is a video currently circulating my social media of a 'sting' on a young man from a town not far from where I live. He has allegedly been talking sexually to who he believed was a 13 year old girl but was actually a decoy. The video shows the sting and is 45 minutes long. During the video he faints and his parents are involved, presumably this is a huge shock to them and they seemed confused and were defending their son.

The comments were terrible. Lots of people saying the parents must have known and should be arrested too. Comments about them looking like 'nonces' themselves. This is where I have the issue - people who have no involvement get dragged into the public lynching and have their lives ruined when it's probably come as a horrible shock to them too.

I'm not sympathising with this person of course, if he's done what he's accused of then it's sickening and he should be punished. But is this the right way to go about things? I can't help but feel like this type of Facebook vigilante justice is a bit of a glory hunt and is quite irresponsible. There are many cases where genuine police investigations have been hampered by them. And do the immediate family whether it's parents, spouses, children deserve to be dragged into something they know nothing about?

OP posts:
ldontWanna · 16/05/2022 20:54

The issues I see with this :

1.the effect on any justice actually being done ,be that interfering with an active investigation, the right to a fair trial etc.

2.the effect on innocent family members, wives,parents,children etc. Once the videos ,names and addresses are posted everyone becomes fair game. Everyone wants their pound of flesh too. So family members get threatened,attacked, their homes defiled etc.

3.the comments that incite violence and escalation. You are deluded if you think it stops with the offender, or that his presence is even needed for a violent attack in real life.

  1. They get it wrong,sometimes on purpose sometimes not. There have been cases where they targeted certain vulnerable people. There have been cases where the "offender" was 16 and the "victim" 14. There have been cases where they "got" the wrong man but still ran with it. There are other examples too. None of these ended up in court(some i'd say rightly so) ,but the effect on the community and the "offender" have been massive.

5.their motives. Some might think the end justify the means and their motives are irrelevant. I don't believe that.

NC1010 · 16/05/2022 20:51

Blossomtoes · 16/05/2022 20:11

we can protect our children from said nonce

You wouldn’t have to protect your children if they were in prison and there’s a much better chance of getting them there if it’s not broadcast.

Unfortunately only a third of all sec offenders don't go to prison. I'm that statistic also adults convicting children age 13 under.

I would rather know what the face looks like if In local area.

HollowMollows · 16/05/2022 20:37

Op I agree. It's an emotive subject and no one wants a child to get hurt but condoning vigilante justice is a very slippery slope that ultimately will lead to more injustice, abuse and cruelty in society.

Smartsub · 16/05/2022 20:34

A friend of mine's husband was caught like this. The video posted showed both my friend and their teenage daughters all in shock and all questioning the validity of the "arrest". At that point they had no idea what was going on or what he had done, only that someone with no apparent authority was trying to arrest him. The comments online were more vile towards my friend than they were towards him because of her perceived defence of her husband.

Within a few hours, once she knew what had happened, she'd sent all his stuff to his mother's, but in that moment all she was doing was questioning whether they had the right to behave as they were. She also has to work in the community still.

I can't believe it's legal.

User57327259 · 16/05/2022 20:28

The stings are broadcast so that if any other paedo hunting teams recognise the person being stung they can add their evidence to build the case with even more evidence

Blossomtoes · 16/05/2022 20:11

we can protect our children from said nonce

You wouldn’t have to protect your children if they were in prison and there’s a much better chance of getting them there if it’s not broadcast.

rocksonrocks · 16/05/2022 19:58

@Puzzledandpissedoff

The judge was a she…you might have done better to check your biases. Unless you’re more qualified than a judge, I’m happy to accept that what she said was correct.

NC1010 · 16/05/2022 19:53

Puzzledandpissedoff · 16/05/2022 19:15

It's one thing catching a paedophile and sending the evidance to the police, it's quite another broadcasting it to the world

Exactly - it's the broadcasting which gives away that they're more interested in "hero status" for themselves than justice, and never mind what they're hoping that status will cover up
Their efforts would be better spent pressurising the authorities to act, but probably that wouldn't be as much "fun"

I'd rather it be broadcasted - so we can know the face especially if local, so we can protect our children from said nonce.

Puzzledandpissedoff · 16/05/2022 19:49

The first thing that the judge told us in the courtroom was that vigilante groups act within the scope of the law

He might have done better to say they claim to act within the law

Being a vigilante isn't illegal in itself, but without any proper oversight it's all too easy for the knuckle draggers among their number to indulge their perverted tastes

This is one of many: www.exmouthjournal.co.uk/news/crime/vigilantes-jailed-attack-exeter-8887600

rocksonrocks · 16/05/2022 19:42

Going through counselling*

rocksonrocks · 16/05/2022 19:41

I served on a jury earlier this year where we found the defendant guilty on multiple counts of online child sex offences. The “sting” video was produced as evidence on a TV in court, as was a 400+ page dossier of screenshots from the chat which was our main piece of evidence. The first thing that the judge told us in the courtroom was that vigilante groups act within the scope of the law.

The vigilante group stood in court as witnesses, it was bizarre hearing how much free time they spend sending these messages. Literally all hours of the day for months on end. I found it difficult to understand their true motivations, however it didn’t make the defendant any less guilty.

The screenshots showed us how the inside of a paedophile’s mind truly works: extremely manipulative, calculating and coercive. They make it very clear that they are looking for sexual relations with a child. It was extremely disturbing and I found it very difficult to consume the evidence and various testimonies, I’m going the counselling to try and process it.

Ultimately I agree that the groups are probably unethical and I still don’t understand why they feel the need to live stream them - notoriety maybe? But on balance they are ultimately doing a good thing by preventing these men from being able to access real children.

WhoWants2Know · 16/05/2022 19:30

If a person wants to catch criminals, why not join the police force or work with them in a voluntary capacity? That would be the obvious way to go about it.

Why seek out a group of untrained, unknown individuals who lurk in kid's chat rooms in the hopes that someone dodgy turns up? And then go on to livestream it, risking the whole effort being thrown out?

Maybe because it's not about catching criminals? Or maybe the police don't want them for some mysterious reason?

Puzzledandpissedoff · 16/05/2022 19:15

It's one thing catching a paedophile and sending the evidance to the police, it's quite another broadcasting it to the world

Exactly - it's the broadcasting which gives away that they're more interested in "hero status" for themselves than justice, and never mind what they're hoping that status will cover up
Their efforts would be better spent pressurising the authorities to act, but probably that wouldn't be as much "fun"

Isitsixoclockalready · 16/05/2022 18:53

If they can provide evidence to the police that secures a conviction - great. Acting as judge and jury, no. The police should be supported and equipped to bring these people to justice but the cynical in me wonders whether there is an element of enjoying the attention amongst some of these vigilantes. I can understand why people support it because we all find paedophiles abhorrent but I would ask people on here how they would feel if a loved one was wrongly accused by these groups?

motherofdragons33 · 16/05/2022 18:44

CMZ2018 · 16/05/2022 18:06

Glad they’re doing a service on behalf of others. Horrible nonces

Thick as two short planks

OP posts:
LetHimHaveIt · 16/05/2022 18:35

CMZ2018 · 16/05/2022 18:06

Glad they’re doing a service on behalf of others. Horrible nonces

🙄

x2boys · 16/05/2022 18:16

CMZ2018 · 16/05/2022 18:06

Glad they’re doing a service on behalf of others. Horrible nonces

And if the "Nonce" walks free instead of being prosecuted, because they wouldn't get a fair trial??

Blossomtoes · 16/05/2022 18:11

CMZ2018 · 16/05/2022 18:06

Glad they’re doing a service on behalf of others. Horrible nonces

They’re not doing anyone a service if their actions prevent a prosecution. Quite the reverse.

CMZ2018 · 16/05/2022 18:06

Glad they’re doing a service on behalf of others. Horrible nonces

Blossomtoes · 16/05/2022 18:04

x2boys · 16/05/2022 09:29

If the people who carried out these "stings" were really interested in public justice they would just give their evidence to the police
Live streaming it all over the Internet, is just going to jeopardise any fair trial, and the perpetrator is more likely to be acquitted.

This. A guy I worked with was caught this way. Everyone he worked with saw the video of the sting which went on for what felt like hours. He was arrested, charged and sent home where he attempted suicide. The case never went to court.

Florenz · 16/05/2022 17:56

If the police did a better job there'd be nothing for these people to do.

NC1010 · 16/05/2022 17:55

Name changed for this for obvious reasons....

A member of my extended family was court by a sting. None of the family whatsoever were dragged into it.
He had done it twice. One time he was caught by the police, charged, on the offenders list.

Second time he was caught by a hunters group.

He has ADHD and possibly autism. (From his own accord, never proven AFAIK)

I couldn't give two shits about that, he got prosecuted and spent time behind bars. He has been released now he was a few years ago. Most of the family are NC and the remaining are LC.
People in the area know his face from when it was shared on live stream. People know what he looks like. I find it extremely hard to feel sorry for any single person, ND or not, who looks at children and is attracted to them, especially if they act on it. They deserve all they get.

If somebody was abusing your child, had inappropriate pictures, physically abused them, would you think 'oh their poor family getting dragged in it?'

I couldn't give a damn! Yes it's unfair IF they get dragged into it. But the main thing I would think of is the safety of my child and other children. Not the rest of the family related to a nonce.

Nonces deserve every bit of online abuse, sharing what they look like to the local community, raising awareness of where the person is located etc to protect your own children.

Wouldn't wish their families any harm of course (if they weren't involved) but I wouldn't really care about them either.

User57327259 · 16/05/2022 17:50

The stings are filmed so that the hunters can not be accused of hitting or otherwise attacking the predator. Putting it on alerts people in the area.

The case in the OP was a man who fainted when confronted by adults but he was not at all afraid to talk sexually to what he thought was a child. What I don't understand is the attraction to young teens and preteens.

A PP mentioned that quite a number of the persons stung are clearly suffering some mental health or limitations. That does not change the damage they do to children they harm with their filthy talk. If they are se limited they need to be more thoroughly monitored by their carers, social services and police.

There is so much talk on here that the hunters are doing all sorts and their information should go straight to the police. That is all very well but we have seen how the social worker mother re-acted in the case mentioned. Not one single care about the child(ren) victimised by her son. The father claimed to have a shotgun to defend his son. Dear Heavens. How can they defend the indefensible. It is a criminal offence to groom children!

If you were the relative of children who were sexually abused, you really would not care what anyone did to the person responsible. Social workers and police need to be seen to be very proactive in these situations. This is what will lead to vigilante activists

MayorDusty · 16/05/2022 17:46

On the Hunting Warhead podcast, the ethical hacker/journo almost ruined the massive international investigations that could never have been replicated, wasting that million to one shot and leaving some real nasty fuckers at large.
even if the intentions are perfect these things need to be done in professional capacities with the appropriate resources and if we need to do more efforts should be directed to campaigning for better online safety etc not having a go yourself.

Nokiding · 16/05/2022 17:35

Why do they need to film the sting and put it online if their main concern is only with bringing sexual predators to justice?

Why don't they simply hand the evidence to the police?