Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think there should be more controls on dogs and more banned breeds

392 replies

Merryclaire · 16/05/2022 08:03

Just seen on the news that another young child has been killed by dogs - that must be at least 4 this year in the UK - there have been a number more that have thankfully not been fatal. Always seems to be (most often) a US bully or sometimes a husky. Why are there not more dog breeds being banned (especially the bully)? And why is there not more noise about dog ownership rules in general being tightened up?
For the record I have always liked dogs but these regular child attacks scare me.

OP posts:
NuttySlacker · 18/05/2022 12:39

fwiw I did not read @WiddlinDiddlin 's post to be anything like that described.

I read it as

a) providing facts to correct the myths surrounding pitbulls rather than defending them.
b) recommending we educate FUTURE dog owners when they are still young, as so many people go on to own dogs (not victims)

I'm not sure I personally agree with b) and realise it's an emotive subject - and not one I've seen successfully debating on mn without insults being thrown - but I don't think widdlin is guilty as accused.

AllThingsServeTheBeam · 18/05/2022 12:32

Merryclaire · 18/05/2022 06:58

@WiddlinDiddlin you actually sound like you are defending pitbulls and putting the onus on children being educated to behave around dangerous dogs in the correct way. How the hell can a baby or toddler (the most likely victims) be educated to not provoke a dog?
You only have to look at the US where the vast majority of dog attacks are pitbulls. Just a few weeks ago a poor woman was torn to shreds by a stranger’s pitbulls and lost both arms.
I’m afraid it is the responsibility of all dog owners to learn how to train and control their dogs. It is not the responsibility of children or any strangers the dog may come across.
I do believe all children should be taught to respect animals but little ones are too young to grasp how to behave so as not to not provoke a dog.

It's not the baby or toddlers that need to know. It's their parents. And if they were shown how to treat dogs as children then they'd pass it on to their own

Flaxmeadow · 18/05/2022 12:26

Last night another child in the Greater Manchester area has been rushed to hopsital with serious injuries from a dog bite attack. This time it happened in a park.

Merryclaire · 18/05/2022 06:58

@WiddlinDiddlin you actually sound like you are defending pitbulls and putting the onus on children being educated to behave around dangerous dogs in the correct way. How the hell can a baby or toddler (the most likely victims) be educated to not provoke a dog?
You only have to look at the US where the vast majority of dog attacks are pitbulls. Just a few weeks ago a poor woman was torn to shreds by a stranger’s pitbulls and lost both arms.
I’m afraid it is the responsibility of all dog owners to learn how to train and control their dogs. It is not the responsibility of children or any strangers the dog may come across.
I do believe all children should be taught to respect animals but little ones are too young to grasp how to behave so as not to not provoke a dog.

OP posts:
WiddlinDiddlin · 18/05/2022 03:11

Pitbulls do not release any magical pain inhibiting hormones - they like all dogs in fact, all of us, experience a rise in adrenaline and other stress hormones that adds to a fairly high pain threshold, which many dogs have been bred for (not just bull breed types, most working breeds have).

They also don't have any inherent 'inability to let go', they're just good at hanging on.

Banning 'fighting dogs' might sound like a great plan - but humans will absolutely try to create some sort of combative, macho 'tough' animal they can pit against another, no matter what you do. Hence cock fighting, fish fighting, horse fighting... all still exist.

It won't stop children being injured or killed by dogs though - none of the kids killed in the last 20 years has been killed by an actual pit fighting dog. Nor even by one bred from pit fighting dogs.

Educating people properly on how to handle, live with and train a dog might help - but we're still happily sitting down to watch idiots push dogs around on tv and label them 'best trainer in britain' - and theres no requirement for our TV channels to show actual safe, sensible, science based training to the masses, its just FINE to promote dangerous methods that increase the risk of dangerous behaviour in dogs, because 'it's entertainment'.

Educating children on how to behave around dogs, what owning a dog means, how to train a dog, how to buy a dog - all dressed up as the various subjects necessary for the curriculum of course (biology, psychology, economics, PSE, maths, geography.. so many subjects!). But again, the anti-dog brigade shout that that is ridiculous... I disagree, it won't change the current generation of dog buying/owning public but would influence the NEXT one..

Lili132 · 18/05/2022 00:53

yellowsuninthesky · 17/05/2022 14:52

And any breed can be threatening. I've just been out for a walk. Minding my own business. Walked past a lady with a small dog (don't know what breed). Thankfully on a lead/leash because it growled and went for me. Normally they just ignore me, which is how I like it.

Yes any breed can be aggressive but powerful dogs cause much more damage and are much less likely to let go of the victim. Pitbull type dogs even release pain inhibiting hormones when they attack and often won't let go even when beaten with sticks and bricks etc. The power of the bite and inability to let go is what makes attacks by powerful breeds more fatal and rescue efforts less successful.

People always say its the owner not the dog but how do we control the owners? Many attacks on children happen in apparently normal homes and parents swear the dog wasn't train to be aggressive and was treated properly like a family member. Maybe there were mistakes made but my point is they weren't obvious.

I think people should have training and licence to own midium and larger dogs but I also believe fighting dogs should absolutely be banned because there is no foolproof way to make sure they are in the right hands. A right to own a certain breed should never come at the expense of people's safety, especially children.

And going by the popularity of "cute" pictures and videos with big dogs "cuddling", "kissing" small children, majority of people have no idea about dog's body language and how to socialise dogs with kids. It's not only abusive or neglectful people who make bad owners.

montysma1 · 17/05/2022 23:12

How do you know it hasnt prevented dog attacks?
It hasnt stopped them but it may have prevented attacks which might have occurred.

Flaxmeadow · 17/05/2022 22:53

Interesting video on frustration at the lack of awareness about dangerous dogs
From a former dog owner.

TruthHertz · 17/05/2022 21:25

There is a cult like side of it tbf. Look at all the bully breeders on youtube who sell puppies for thousands. Also plenty of videos showing 'defence' dogs that are trained to grab onto an arm etc. Every bully owner I've met has been a bit of a chav if I'm honest.

Flaxmeadow · 17/05/2022 21:02

@Lansonmaid
What conspiracy theory stuff?

Lansonmaid · 17/05/2022 20:53

Flaxmeadow · 17/05/2022 20:12

There is a cult like worship of aggressive powerful dogs amd the owners are always minimising attacks, always defending the dog above anything

Pet dogs aren't even a natural product of evoluton. They've been inbred for millenia to have certain traits, including aggression. Many of them have severe physical and mental deformities due to inbreeding. Some are in constant pain

There may be a 'cult of worship of aggressive dogs' in a small minority of people but the majority of dog owners want an affectionate obedient companion. And there are a myriad of purposes dogs have been bred for- you wouldn't want an aggressive Border Collie that would herd sheep and then attack them as an example (yes, I am a BC fan), or an aggressive Labrador or Golden Retriever guide dog. I'm afraid you are losing any good points you might make (E.g extreme breeding leading to deformed and unhealthy dogs) in all the conspiracy theory stuff.

Merryclaire · 17/05/2022 20:44

orwellwasright · 17/05/2022 20:30

Mumsnet is dotty about dogs. They're more important than hoomans doncha know.

I assume that the pro dog rights posters on this thread aren’t the kind of owners of the types of dogs this thread was aimed at.
In my view, tighter restrictions on breeding, selling and owning dogs benefits dog owners as much as anyone else. Because you will have more assurance about the dog you are buying, clueless buyers shouldn’t end up with a completely inappropriate dog - and if they do they will be made to train it - and people and dogs will face less threat of being attacked by dangerously out of control dogs.
As far as I’m concerned the only losers should be bad breeders and bad owners.

OP posts:
orwellwasright · 17/05/2022 20:30

Mumsnet is dotty about dogs. They're more important than hoomans doncha know.

AllThingsServeTheBeam · 17/05/2022 20:17

Someone need to switch you off @flaxmeadow. What are you going on about. Who are you even talking about? Do these people have secret meetings?

Flaxmeadow · 17/05/2022 20:16

...and instead of suggesting ways of protecting children from these aggresive amd powerful dogs. They lobby for LESS restriction on dogs, less laws. They want more dogs, and many more aggresive dogs. They want no restriction on breeds at all

Flaxmeadow · 17/05/2022 20:12

There is a cult like worship of aggressive powerful dogs amd the owners are always minimising attacks, always defending the dog above anything

Pet dogs aren't even a natural product of evoluton. They've been inbred for millenia to have certain traits, including aggression. Many of them have severe physical and mental deformities due to inbreeding. Some are in constant pain

AllThingsServeTheBeam · 17/05/2022 20:02

WiddlinDiddlin · 17/05/2022 19:55

Let me explain.

Currently, 4 breeds, and their crossbreeds and 'pitbull types' are banned. If you simply ban a breed, then people crossbreed and say 'well it's not xyz breed'... so the ban is appearance based, not DNA based.

However this means you can buy a cross breed or indeed a pedigree of certain breeds, and if it LOOKS like a banned type, then it is illegal, you are now a criminal.

So you go out and buy a labrador x staffy, in six months time your puppy and two or three others from the litter fits the criteria for 'pitbull type', but the other 8 don't. You are a now a criminal.. the buyers of the non-type puppies are not.

Fair? Useful? No.

So we have more illegal type dogs now because you can 'make' an illegal dog by breeding two legal dogs together.

Three of those breeds were never or almost never seen in the UK at the time of that ban - but it looked 'good' like the government were doing something useful, to ban four breeds - four breeds unrecognised by the UK kennel club, three of whom had not been seen here at the time and were not involved in any of the then recent dog attacks.

Breed Specific Legislation does not work - the proof of that is in the rise in incidents involve dogs injuring and killing. If it worked... we wouldn't be seeing this.

So how does doing MORE of a thing that has had over 30 years to work... and hasn't worked... work?

If you go back to the start of the pandemic, and listened to what dog trainers and behaviourists were saying at the rise in prices of puppies and in sales of dogs/purchases of dogs during lockdown though... we predicted this rise in dog attack cases back then.

Because the common denominator in dog attacks is... people.

People who don't understand dogs, haven't the time for dogs, haven't the ability to train dogs, who use heavy handed aversive methods they see on TV as a result, buy dogs from the wrong places, on a whim, in a rush, for all the wrong reasons.

They are the problem. They have always been the problem. Very very few, an infinitesimally small number of dog attacks, have occurred with dogs bought from decent breeders, sold to people who know what they're doing - and in those cases there is some mitigating circumstance as well, some stressful change to normal routine, some stressor on the dog.

The bottom line is, well trained, well bred dogs with responsible owners do not attack and kill people, no matter what breed they are.

I think I love you

XenoBitch · 17/05/2022 20:01

Flaxmeadow · 17/05/2022 18:33

Any dog that bites someone should be put down immediately. This used to be the case years ago, why has this changed? Why is it seen as saying something controversial now?

Another thing is how aggressive and defensive dog owners are nowadays. If, in a discussion, you suggest a ban on more breeds or suggest stricter laws, eg leashes and public spaces, some dog owners go completely bonkers, as if you've said something really terrible or attacked them personally.

Don't we all want to reduce the life changing injuries and deaths from dog attacks?

Young dogs explore the world via their mouth. It is mostly just mouthing and nipping. If it is aggressive, it is because they don't know any better. You can nip it in the bud but swapping one item for another. Dogs have their own language. They should not be punished if you can't be assed to learn it.

WiddlinDiddlin · 17/05/2022 19:55

Merryclaire · 16/05/2022 08:10

I don’t see how banning certain breeds can increase dog attacks and if it’s not reducing them then there needs to be tighter controls about ownership in general.
And this is not a commentary at all the gentle dogs out there, which I know are the majority.

Let me explain.

Currently, 4 breeds, and their crossbreeds and 'pitbull types' are banned. If you simply ban a breed, then people crossbreed and say 'well it's not xyz breed'... so the ban is appearance based, not DNA based.

However this means you can buy a cross breed or indeed a pedigree of certain breeds, and if it LOOKS like a banned type, then it is illegal, you are now a criminal.

So you go out and buy a labrador x staffy, in six months time your puppy and two or three others from the litter fits the criteria for 'pitbull type', but the other 8 don't. You are a now a criminal.. the buyers of the non-type puppies are not.

Fair? Useful? No.

So we have more illegal type dogs now because you can 'make' an illegal dog by breeding two legal dogs together.

Three of those breeds were never or almost never seen in the UK at the time of that ban - but it looked 'good' like the government were doing something useful, to ban four breeds - four breeds unrecognised by the UK kennel club, three of whom had not been seen here at the time and were not involved in any of the then recent dog attacks.

Breed Specific Legislation does not work - the proof of that is in the rise in incidents involve dogs injuring and killing. If it worked... we wouldn't be seeing this.

So how does doing MORE of a thing that has had over 30 years to work... and hasn't worked... work?

If you go back to the start of the pandemic, and listened to what dog trainers and behaviourists were saying at the rise in prices of puppies and in sales of dogs/purchases of dogs during lockdown though... we predicted this rise in dog attack cases back then.

Because the common denominator in dog attacks is... people.

People who don't understand dogs, haven't the time for dogs, haven't the ability to train dogs, who use heavy handed aversive methods they see on TV as a result, buy dogs from the wrong places, on a whim, in a rush, for all the wrong reasons.

They are the problem. They have always been the problem. Very very few, an infinitesimally small number of dog attacks, have occurred with dogs bought from decent breeders, sold to people who know what they're doing - and in those cases there is some mitigating circumstance as well, some stressful change to normal routine, some stressor on the dog.

The bottom line is, well trained, well bred dogs with responsible owners do not attack and kill people, no matter what breed they are.

AllThingsServeTheBeam · 17/05/2022 19:19

Flaxmeadow · 17/05/2022 18:33

Any dog that bites someone should be put down immediately. This used to be the case years ago, why has this changed? Why is it seen as saying something controversial now?

Another thing is how aggressive and defensive dog owners are nowadays. If, in a discussion, you suggest a ban on more breeds or suggest stricter laws, eg leashes and public spaces, some dog owners go completely bonkers, as if you've said something really terrible or attacked them personally.

Don't we all want to reduce the life changing injuries and deaths from dog attacks?

No I don't agree with any dog ever that bites needs to be put down. It completely depends on the situation in which the dog bit.

It was the same years ago too.

Flaxmeadow · 17/05/2022 19:08

Some people care more about aggressive powerful dogs, in some cases even banned dogs, than they do about the safety of children and nothing is being done about it. Everytime a serious injury or death happens, nothing changes.

That's the terrible truth of it.

TruthHertz · 17/05/2022 18:48

I'm more for vetting of owners of 'dangerous' breeds than outright banning. If somebody has an aggressive breed but lives on a farm and trains/manages it well then there's no issue.

The main issue with bullies is the owners IMO. One of the builders I see regularly at work has one and mentioned the other day that it 'went for him' while he was play fighting with his brother and thankfully only managed to grab the edge of his coat, which it started ragdolling. He said "should've given him a whupping really" (meaning the dog).

It's these types of people that are the issue. From what he says the dog is around his young kids all the time and I always think that it's this type of situation that can end badly.

Although I also agree that strong bull breeds have an intrinsic risk factor attached just because of their tremendous strength.

Flaxmeadow · 17/05/2022 18:33

Any dog that bites someone should be put down immediately. This used to be the case years ago, why has this changed? Why is it seen as saying something controversial now?

Another thing is how aggressive and defensive dog owners are nowadays. If, in a discussion, you suggest a ban on more breeds or suggest stricter laws, eg leashes and public spaces, some dog owners go completely bonkers, as if you've said something really terrible or attacked them personally.

Don't we all want to reduce the life changing injuries and deaths from dog attacks?

Saucery · 17/05/2022 17:03

We’re not in the US and ‘rescues’ like Battersea and Dogs Trust are a bit too quick to PTS rather than put the work in ime. Dogs Trust prefer to keep their euthanasia at arm’s length though.
I believe in the right environment for the right dog. In the case of many serious and fatal attacks the right environment is missing, which leads to tragedy. I have my own thoughts about the case that sparked this thread off, but out of respect for the child who died I’m going to keep them to myself.
Shut Pets4Homes etc down, legislate breeders far more heavily than currently and take dog ownership much more seriously.

I have a friend who had a Presa Canario. Great big soppy thing, he was. Much loved but always, always treated like the large guarding breed he was. Not in this country, before anyone loses their shit Smile

Flaxmeadow · 17/05/2022 15:02

@Saucery
I suppose that depends how you define conspiracy but there is certanily a powerful, heavily funded and active dog lobby, especially in the USA and unfortunately its increasing here too.
This would be
No bans on any pet dog breed at all, even a dog the size of a pony
No dog ever put down, even in the case of fatal attacks
The rehoming of dangerous dogs by charities by deceit, that is not being honest about the breed or the dogs history
Charities, solicitors, lobby groups that will defend a dog and its owner in court to the extent of preventing prosecution and prevent a dog being put down and encouraging it to be placed back in communities
In the USA even if a dog kills someone, lobby groups will protest it being put down through the courts. These idiots honestly believe that a dog that's killed can never ever be blamed and can be rehabilitated into a family home. In fact some of them even believe spaying dogs is genocide and any criticism of dogs is racism
They cannot face reality, that some dog breeds are genetically just too dangerous.