Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think there should be more controls on dogs and more banned breeds

392 replies

Merryclaire · 16/05/2022 08:03

Just seen on the news that another young child has been killed by dogs - that must be at least 4 this year in the UK - there have been a number more that have thankfully not been fatal. Always seems to be (most often) a US bully or sometimes a husky. Why are there not more dog breeds being banned (especially the bully)? And why is there not more noise about dog ownership rules in general being tightened up?
For the record I have always liked dogs but these regular child attacks scare me.

OP posts:
ItsDinah · 16/05/2022 11:58

Dog killings in UK are now running on level with mass shootings in USA. There have been at least 5 this year. US has a strong pro gun lobby and UK a strong pro dog lobby. I support a simple annual licensing system. It would not restrict dog ownership in any way. It would not be compulsory except if you wanted to take a dog off your own property. If you want to take a dog off your own property,you would need to get an annual licence. The licence would be for you and any dogs. You would need to take annual tests showing you can control the dog - i.e. it responds to walk ,heel,sit, and stay and you remain in control despite sudden loud noises and triggers like other dogs, cyclists,children etc. The licence fee should cover the costs of running the system. This should gradually deter many irresponsible dog-owners.

Flaxmeadow · 16/05/2022 11:50

wonderwoman26 · 16/05/2022 11:41

2 people were killed earlier this year by falling tree's - shall we ban certain tree types too?

Dogs are a part of nature and are animals, there are things we can do to protect children from animals - but how could you even determine what could be a 'dangerous breed' and what couldnt?

I remember reading a story not long ago about a pack of jack russells attacking and killing an elderly person - hardly the usual 'dangerous dog breed'.

It should always be on the ownership of the parents of the child and the dog owner. I suspect most sensible humans would not allow a known dangerous dog to be in a situation that would kill a human, resulting in their pet being killed and a potential prison sentence. The same way a sensible human doesnt allow a child to play with a toaster in the bath. Common sense and observation is needed all round.

Dogs kept as pets are definatley not part of nature. They did not evolve naturally. Dogs were intensively inbred to service humans and perform tasks. To work, to kill for sport. Whete people think the term pit bull comes from? Its from bull baiting and dog fighting, fighting to the death in a pit for 'sport' and gambling. It amazes me that anyone would want this type of dog in a family home, but they do and its a ticking time bomb

Lovemusic33 · 16/05/2022 11:49

A pit bull isn’t a actual breed, it determined on a number of measurements and characteristics so it’s really hard to prove a dog is a banned breed.

A lot of dog attacks are actually not bull breeds but the deaths are, the bully has the body weight, strength and jaw to cause serious damage making it hard for anyone to pull the dog off. I do think there should be rule around owning a dog, especially a powerful breed and especially if you have children. Many times these dogs are rescue dogs that have been stupidly homed with people who have no idea about the breed and people with children.

I’m a huge fan of the Staffordshire Bull and the English bull terrier, they have amazing personalities and are very loyal, they get a bad press due to getting into the wrong hands and due to the American bull terrier. Huskies are another breed that get into the wrong hands, they are not a easy dog, they tend to have poor recall and like to chase, they don’t make the best pets but people went through a stage of wanting them because they look similar to wolves. People really do need to do their research before buying any breed and need to think long and hard before having a dog around children. Sadly anyone can just go and buy a puppy, this is something that needs to change.

BeautifulWar · 16/05/2022 11:41

There's a terrifying American Bully near us and I dread seeing it. The owners struggle to contain it, it goes for anything and anyone that is anywhere near it (in public spaces). The owners are not nice people, they are smell time drug dealers and keep the dog in a flat, so whether the dog's temperament is due to nature or nurture, or a combination of both, who knows?

wonderwoman26 · 16/05/2022 11:41

2 people were killed earlier this year by falling tree's - shall we ban certain tree types too?

Dogs are a part of nature and are animals, there are things we can do to protect children from animals - but how could you even determine what could be a 'dangerous breed' and what couldnt?

I remember reading a story not long ago about a pack of jack russells attacking and killing an elderly person - hardly the usual 'dangerous dog breed'.

It should always be on the ownership of the parents of the child and the dog owner. I suspect most sensible humans would not allow a known dangerous dog to be in a situation that would kill a human, resulting in their pet being killed and a potential prison sentence. The same way a sensible human doesnt allow a child to play with a toaster in the bath. Common sense and observation is needed all round.

Flaxmeadow · 16/05/2022 11:36

'reactive' is a new word used by dog owners to minimise what is dog aggression
Same with 'nip' when what they're really describing is a bite

Notcontent · 16/05/2022 11:35

There should be more controls on ownership. Around my part of London the situation is getting quite ridiculous. There is dog poo everywhere and out of control dogs in the park. I like dogs and I am not scared of them in general but there are some dogs that are quite scary and intimidating.

Merryclaire · 16/05/2022 11:33

To all the people saying it’s the owner’s fault and not the dog’s - I largely agree with you (even though anyone can be caught out).
That’s why the onus should be on people selling, breeding, buying and owning dogs.
You wouldn’t drive a car without passing a test and paying money to learn, be taxed and insured, and follow the rules of the road.
Owning a dog should also be treated as a big responsibility - for the sake of the animals and the people that come into contact with them.

OP posts:
MisguidedSheep · 16/05/2022 11:30

Saucery · 16/05/2022 09:43

I met loads of dogs on my walk this morning.
Collie
Jack Russell
2 Staffies
3 Labradors
About 6 Poo crosses
Lurcher
Bichon Frise
Bull Lurcher
Springer spaniel.

Guess which one went for my dog while the owner laughed and said “oh, he’s only playing!”

That’s right, one of the Poo crosses. Little fluffy teddy bear things that are ridiculously popular at the moment. Dog most likely to be untrained with clueless ineffectual owners round here.
I doubt that’s one of the (cross) breeds you want banned though, OP? Hmm

Speaking from personal experience, poo crosses can become reactive because people see a fluffy puppy and allow their "friendly" (aka untrained dog with no recall) to bounce all over a young pup/ teen that is still in its socialisation phase.

Or they allow their dog to come up to an on lead dog despite requests to not allow their dog to approach.

It doesn't matter what the breed is if the owner is a fuckwit! Both of mine have been trained, have excellent recall and are the gentlest creatures around humans. However, because some humans aren't responsible dog owners I'm now having to manage a scared and fig reactive poo cross.

A properly trained dog can bring a lot of joy. But training is a lifelong commitment which people forget. Totally agree with PP who point out that requiring licences isn't the answer.....it would be pretty much unenforceable without other whole scale changes in the way dogs are bought/sold.

Banning breeds isn't the answer though.....just makes the dogs (either pure bred or cross bred) more desirable. There are no easy answers, but on the whole dogs do more good than harm.

Merryclaire · 16/05/2022 11:30

@OldWivesTale Yes, because another child has just been killed.

OP posts:
Flaxmeadow · 16/05/2022 11:28

cupofdecaf · 16/05/2022 10:29

One of the issues is who is going to regulate any new rules? The government is already wanting to reduce the civil service to austerity levels. There's no one to do it. Frankly there's not enough civil servants and police etc to do the basics already.
I do agree though dogs are inherently dangerous and people underestimate them (I like dogs usually so not a dog hater).

Dog owners should be made to pay for a regulatory system via dog licensing

Flaxmeadow · 16/05/2022 11:25

This year in the UK a child has been killed in a dog attack almost every month.
Sadly too many dog owners simply do not care. They just dont give a damn and will use every excuse they can to defend dangerous dogs
Yes OP many more breeds/breed types need to be banned but it won't happen, those who defend dogs are part of an increasingly powerful cult like lobby, and more children will be maimed and killed. Nothing will happen. It never does

OldWivesTale · 16/05/2022 11:24

Here we go again...

LolaButt · 16/05/2022 11:17

The etiquette of having your dog off lead should be clearer - dog only a few metres ahead or behind you. Good recall. If you see another dog walker in the distance put the dog on a lead until the dogs have passed each other.

I have a small terrier who is generally calm. Never seen aggression from him. Still wouldn’t leave him alone with a young child as his bite strength and ability to tug is surprisingly strong despite his miniature status.

Phrenologistsfinger · 16/05/2022 10:35

I want to ban irresponsible, stupid, inconsiderate and negligent dog OWNERS.

so many of these cases occur in chaotic and dysfunctional homes. Or at least careless ones.

It’s always the humans underlying this issue. Dogs are just victims of those who are meant to care for them (and train and protect them).

cupofdecaf · 16/05/2022 10:29

One of the issues is who is going to regulate any new rules? The government is already wanting to reduce the civil service to austerity levels. There's no one to do it. Frankly there's not enough civil servants and police etc to do the basics already.
I do agree though dogs are inherently dangerous and people underestimate them (I like dogs usually so not a dog hater).

KevinTheKoala · 16/05/2022 10:18

*where their dog isn't used to children.

KevinTheKoala · 16/05/2022 10:16

Is it any wonder that some children are petrified when a dog 4x the size of them is bounding up to them faster than they can get away? There should be tighter controls on dog ownership, too many people get dogs without wanting to put the effort in to training them correctly, exercising them enough, getting them vetinary care when needed and that leads to problems. It's not fair on anyone - it's not fair on the dog that will be put down because it has been raised to be dangerous, it's not fair on the people who might be hurt or killed by the dog and its not fair on the good owners who do train their dogs properly and care for them.

The thing is a good, responsible owner is not the problem, the problem is the lazy, irresponsible owners who have no control their dogs and think its OK to allow their dogs to approach people who don't want to be approached, or have visitors in their home when their dog isn't children but insist that their precious dog wouldn't hurt a fly. I refused to have my children around one dog because it bit its owner - which caused huge offence to the owner and my children's dad who thought I was being unfair. These sort of people should not have dogs.

Grumpybutfunny · 16/05/2022 10:02

I grew up with dogs big and small it's the handler that's the issue (and kids being petrified doesn't help)! Banning breeds doesn't help as any dog can be nasty, we had a King Charles spaniel I wouldn't trust with a baby and a rough collie that would have protected it's baby until the ends of the earth.

Maybe a system should be in place for people to report dangerous dogs and the police dog handlers can asses and take action. But if someone is on someone else's property without permission and is attacked no further action should be taken.

Excited101 · 16/05/2022 09:56

In the time it took a 5 year old to eat a cupcake, I had to physically pull 2 dogs off of her who had come running over ‘just being friendly’ at a local park. Dog owners wonder why kids are so nervous around dogs but (too many of them) don’t put any effort into making dog interactions safe and enjoyable. I was dog phobic as a child and have had to work really hard on it not being an issue when I’m looking after kids but it’s a bit of an impossible task for children not to gain fears of their own when it’s so frequent.

No, it wasn’t a dog ‘attack’ but I’ve had enough and agree op.

Merryclaire · 16/05/2022 09:54

@Saucery when it comes to dog attacks that result in deaths, it seems to be largely certain breeds. However, I agree any dog can be out of control - I’ve been bitten by someone’s yappy small dog who just launched at me as I walked past, and its teenage owners just gawped at me and didn’t even apologise when I confronted them.
Someone on my street has just been attacked by a black labrador which resulted in a trip to hospital - yet the police haven’t done anything about it.
For all the people saying ‘where will the resources come from to police tighter controls?’, surely that should come from the cost of a licence on the owners.
And for everyone rolling their eyes, saying it’s a non issue, I’m sure you’d feel differently if your child or grandchild - or even your dog - was attacked by a bad owner’s dog.

OP posts:
BigDayToday · 16/05/2022 09:50

No. But there should be far more restrictions on breeding and ownership.

Maybe if owners researched and understood dogs and dog behaviour instead of choosing one based on looks or fashion or some other ridiculous reason, and treated and respected them as dogs, not 'fur babies', there would be less problems.

LakieLady · 16/05/2022 09:44

I've just seen that there have been previous "dog-related incidents" at the address where this poor child was attacked.

Why the fuck were these people allowed to have more dogs if they already had a history of not being able to control them? If they weren't allowed to have dogs, it's another failure of enforcement.

Imo, any dog bite to any child should be a safeguarding matter and investigated as such. No child should be in a house where there are dogs and a history of dog-related incidents.

That poor child.

Should perhaps say, I'm not anti-dog at all, quite the opposite. I love them and have spent more of my life owning dogs than not.

stuntbubbles · 16/05/2022 09:43

It is the dogs, not the owners, though. Saying it’s not the dogs is equivalent to “guns don’t kill people” – they’re a pretty huge contributory factor! Banning dogs would wipe out maulings, fatalities, the bloody dog shit everywhere, no need for the cost implications of tighter controls and legislation.

Saucery · 16/05/2022 09:43

I met loads of dogs on my walk this morning.
Collie
Jack Russell
2 Staffies
3 Labradors
About 6 Poo crosses
Lurcher
Bichon Frise
Bull Lurcher
Springer spaniel.

Guess which one went for my dog while the owner laughed and said “oh, he’s only playing!”

That’s right, one of the Poo crosses. Little fluffy teddy bear things that are ridiculously popular at the moment. Dog most likely to be untrained with clueless ineffectual owners round here.
I doubt that’s one of the (cross) breeds you want banned though, OP? Hmm