Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Love from in laws towards my kids is too much

185 replies

feelingwelljell · 16/05/2022 07:23

I know it's unreasonable.

But the love my in laws have for my kids is too much and it annoys me. I must start by saying, I don't get on with them very well. Lots of things have happened.

I think probably if we had a better relationship, it may not annoy me as much, but I don't know.

It's like my kids are the centre of their universe. Everything is about them and they constantly want to see them at every opportunity. If they haven't seen them for a week, I get messages saying they miss them. I also get told I need to send pictures and videos more often. When my in laws can't come, they pretty much send their other kids and they take constant videos of my kids to then show the in laws.

I send pics to them too and videos as they're always asking, but most of the time when I send something, they'll be some over the top concerned comment from my mother in law, about something really minor in the picture. For example, oh his eye looks swollen or - her hair looks pulled a bit tight, is she OK ? Or - if they even have a minor illness, she has to get really involved and push me to get more and more tests done, even though I'm comfortable in whatever the doctors have told me. She just has to be overly involved in everything and she stresses me out and ruins my mood when I send a nice pic, as she can't say anything nice and always knit picks.

Anyway I know how it sounds. How can I be irritated by someone loving my kids too much ? I sound like an absolute idiot. But they're my kids. I'm afraid my in laws want to gain lots of ground with my kids and will try to bring them up their way and be a huge influence on them. I believe kids should be raised by their parents and I don't want them to be raised to be carbon copies of their other kids. I want to have a big role to play ( the main role ) in how my kids will be raised. But I feel these constant demands for their time and having to be so involved in their lives is going to mean that they'll influence them massively. I don't think it's wrong for them to have a role in their lives, but I don't want to be on the sidelines of their lives, because my in laws ads second parents to them.

They can see them once every couple of weeks and I shouldn't need to be made to feel bad for them ' missing them so much ' after just a week. It's OTT. Anyway, I know I'll get my arse handed to me. But perhaps someone has something helpful to say ?

I feel like a tyrant if I ever say that we can't see them. I just can't say no. I've tried a few times and get theatrics. My in laws don't respect any of the boundaries I've ever tried to set. They're constantly wanting to take my kids to their house and away from me. They'll come round unannounced and tell me that they're taking my daughter to their house. Daughter gets excited because they set no boundaries for her there at all and she does what she wants there ( another problem ). And I just have to go along with it.

Any time I've ever stood up for myself and said no, my mother in law shouts, screams and cries and calls me a bad person and a bully. It's very difficult ! So she's managed to get me to a place where I hold my tongue as much as I can, to avoid a big fight and being called names by her. It's very difficult and feels suffocating.

I'm feeling extra territorial as I've just had a baby, so maybe that's what's prompted these feelings to become stronger.

I just feel like I should be the only one to love my kids this much and to show this amount of concern for them ? My parents are totally different. Whilst they love all their grandchildren a lot, I don't feel it's as excessive and overbearing.

OP posts:
Andromachehadabadday · 16/05/2022 08:00

I think there’s unreasonableness on both sides.

you are the biggest influence on your children and you are bringing them up. But you can’t dictate how much other people love them. You can’t stop grandparents and other family members, teachers, your friends, their friends (when they are older) also influencing children.

Thats not a bad thing. If you were the only influence on your children they would be a carbon copy of you.

However they do seem over baring. I think the problem is that you are both coming at this from complete extremes.

You don’t mention your dp/dh so I am going to assume he doesn’t get involved and that’s usually because they don’t have a problem with it. That’s where the problem is. You and your dp/dh need to work out what you are both happy with (which could be compromise on both sides) and then stick by that.

JanglyBeads · 16/05/2022 07:58

This is not love - if you love a child you want it to have the best possible relationship with its parents - this is an attempt to control.

Do you feel like they don't trust you to bring "their" (grand)children up?

Do they have other grandchildren, how are they about them?

Does your DH acquiesce with them for a quiet life?

Thinkingblonde · 16/05/2022 07:57

Stop biting your tongue and stand up to them, especially to your MIL. She will kick off as she’s always done but let her. Stand your ground. She kicks off because she gets her own way every time.
“No, they can’t come to yours, we have plans.”
” No, can’t do videos, the kids are doing ( whatever).”
If they send others to your house to video them stop them, or stand in the way. This is your house remember.
“No need to worry, I trust my GP, if he thinks they need a second opinion they will arrange it. But they don’t so we’ll leave it there. “
If you send her a pic of them say something to preempt her forensic scrutiny of it. “Here’s a lovely pic of them Ma,
If she finds fault say I think you may need an eye test, there’s nothing wrong with her eye/hair”. Or make a PA comment. “I see you’re wearing your forensic goggles again, isn’t it time you ditched them.? “

miltonj · 16/05/2022 07:56

sst1234 · 16/05/2022 07:36

This is MN so in laws are evil.

But in the real world, your thoughts about this would be considered irrational. Which you somewhat acknowledge yourself. Kids are not a possession that only set of people should be able to live then most, while the measure of everyone else’s love should stay below that level. It’s not a competition. You need to figure this one and let it go. Your kids are lucky to have grandparents so loving. That’s their privilege and you trying to meddle us taking it away from them.

But like I say this is MN, so cue the bizarre reponses that will inevitably follow.

I see where you're coming from, but this MIL is turning up at the OPs house declaring that she's taking the kids, despite not knowing what's planned for the day. And kicking off/playing the victim when not getting her way. If anyone's treating the kids like a possession it's the MIL. And it sounds like she knows she's got OP to the point where she feels uncomfortable saying no and is using it to her advantage.

LetItGoHome · 16/05/2022 07:55

I'm surprised to hear some think this is a normal grandparent interaction. It's not in my view. Where is the children's father in all of this?

southlondoner02 · 16/05/2022 07:54

If anyone shouted and screamed and cried whilst calling me a bad person I'd be telling them to get out of my house (or hang up if on phone) and refusing future contact. Let your child's father deal with it if they can't be civil.

They can't make you do anything you don't want to do

SaulTheHamster · 16/05/2022 07:53

How old are your dc?

First of all I would stop sending any pictures or videos. You are violating your dc privacy. They will soon be teenagers and then adults, believe me it goes faster than you'd think and they will not appreciate other people having gigabytes of photos and videos of them.

You need to stand up for yourself and draw a nice big boundary around your family, you are the boss when it comes to your children (as well as your husband of course).

Tamzo85 · 16/05/2022 07:53

Anyone think maybe DP doesn’t think grandparents coming round or asking for pictures or occasionally giving annoying or over worried advice is actually the huge deal OP does? Perhaps he considers it normal. I would.

WildCoasts · 16/05/2022 07:51

Tamzo85 · 16/05/2022 07:45

Your in laws sound a little out of line but honestly you sound a little irrational about it all too. Pictures and wanting to see grandkids are quite normal. Occasionally DIL’s can get quite stroppy and take totally normal interaction as some big “threat” to them.

Constantly criticising, coming and demanding to take the kids and taking them, demanding excessive amounts of videos, playing the victim by crying and screaming. None of this is 'normal interaction'.

SidSparrow · 16/05/2022 07:50

YANBU whatsoever!! They would do my head in. My Dad and SM are slightly similar, not as overbearing though thank God!! But I have had to withdraw from them. Similarly spoil my children - I prefer the word ruin, as that is exactly what they're doing.

I think you're going to have to get tough with them and stand your ground. Write down for yourself the boundaries that you want. You're going to have to get very poker face as well, the 'that's nice but no thanks' look. I would say little to them but be straight to the point. And tell them if they are coming round to message you in advance because their showing up is not alwaye convenient. Don't have to say anything else. If they show up unannounced, answer the door. 'I'd invite you in but we're off out.' Reiterate, 'In future, please message me in advance of you visiting'.

Be consistent, keep your answers and requests to the point, don't over explain. I know it's not easy, but eventually they'll get the message and you'll feel more empowered in dealing with them.

Your kids, your rules.

WildCoasts · 16/05/2022 07:48

The problem is that they are overbearing, too involved and too critical. Why does it fall on you to send pics? Why not their own son? I'd make him responsible for all that. If MIL makes a critical comment, call it out. If she says your daughter's hair is too tight, ask if she thinks you can't parent your children. I'll say to you what I wish someone had said to me when I was a young Mum - you don't have to allow someone to treat you badly and you're not responsible for the relationship between your DH and his parents, or your DC and his parents. Start setting some boundaries.

Beamur · 16/05/2022 07:46

Another one here saying where is your DP/DH in all this?
Why is he letting his Mum bully you?
Frankly, let her scream and shout. It's one thing (and a very good thing) to have grandparents who are loving and involved, but this is too much.

ComDummings · 16/05/2022 07:45

They sound very controlling and suffocating; I would hate that! I think backing off a bit or ignoring their silly messages is the way forward. Obviously if it’s something important reply but they can only be super involved if you let them.

Tamzo85 · 16/05/2022 07:45

Your in laws sound a little out of line but honestly you sound a little irrational about it all too. Pictures and wanting to see grandkids are quite normal. Occasionally DIL’s can get quite stroppy and take totally normal interaction as some big “threat” to them.

DDivaStar · 16/05/2022 07:43

They do seem a bit out and the video stuff is weird. But seeing their grandchildren once a week doesn't seem excessive. You may find the more you try to keep them at arms length the more they push back.

My mum looked after my daughter at her house from an early age and has always enjoyed time with her alone as its a different dynamic than when we are there too.

Surely a couple of hours at their house would give you some 1to1 time with baby it doesn't have to be a bad thing.

Gazelda · 16/05/2022 07:41

Take a big step back from them and let their Dad deal with it. He can take the DC for visits. He can invite them over for coffee on Sunday morning so they can see the new baby. He can send pics and videos.

Make sure you agree beforehand that one visit a week is plenty. And one visit by them to your house too. And that he'll phone once a week and send pics once a week. That's 3/4 days out of 7 they'll have some sort of contact.

The children will still get to spend lots of time with their grandparents, which can be such a positive element to childhood. And the love the grandparents have is so precious.
the first sign of bullying or histrionics the arrangement will be reviewed.

StEval · 16/05/2022 07:40

CloseYourEyesAndSee · 16/05/2022 07:25

It's not about how much they love them it's about their awful controlling behaviour. What does your husband think about it?

I agree with this.
This isnt love, its manipulative, controlling behaviour and designed to undermine you.
The shouting, screaming is not acceptable and she has you treading on eggshells.

Decide on your boundaries.
Photos on days out for example.
Dont reply or explain to nitpicky, silly questions.
DH might be more tricky as hes been brought up within the toxic family environment.
Its also likely as you pull away it will ramp up.

leavethewallalone · 16/05/2022 07:39

I thought you were BU until I got to

*They're constantly wanting to take my kids to their house and away from me. They'll come round unannounced and tell me that they're taking my daughter to their house. Daughter gets excited because they set no boundaries for her there at all and she does what she wants there ( another problem ). And I just have to go along with it.

Any time I've ever stood up for myself and said no, my mother in law shouts, screams and cries and calls me a bad person and a bully.*

This is not OK. What does DH say?

Testina · 16/05/2022 07:37

Are you a widow?
I bet not.
Where the hell is your husband in all this?
Even if there was no issue at all, I’d be rolling my eyes that all the videos etc are from you.

I expect that he will be no help to you at all. I couldn’t be kind and say he’s been conditioned by them, but I suspect he’s just a useless “hand off” unsupportive type.

In which case, if you’re on your own, back to those boundaries.

Set them, enforce them - and give yourself permission not to give a shit. So she calls you names? Less important to you, than enforcing your rules.

Then:


  • limit the photos / videos you send

  • ALWAYS push back if she says something critical, “MIL, stop find things to criticise.”

  • Any criticism, don’t send the next planned video (so say you send one a day, don’t send next day)

  • any relatives that are “sent round” but invited - tell them it’s not convenient, don’t let the stay

  • refuse any babysitting (visits to their house) when you’re actually available yourself


There is no way to do this without standing up for yourself.

You are absolutely not unreasonable here!

Summerholidayorcovidagain · 16/05/2022 07:37

My ils were the same. They never had my mobile number and it made for an easier life. Leave it to their ds to send all that stuff should he bother.....

Merryclaire · 16/05/2022 07:37

How dare they just turn up unannounced and tell you they are taking them to their house! What a nightmare. It puts the rest of your comments into perspective - they don’t love them too much, they are just massively controlling, interfering and have no boundaries. You need to properly confront this and be strong.
It’s not about them not seeing them - but it needs to be arranged with your consent. If they can’t accept that, then I would minimise contact until they can act in a more appropriate manner.
Once a fortnight sounds very reasonable to me if they’re not doing childcare. I saw my grandparents much less than that.
What’s DH doing in all this? He needs to have a word!

sst1234 · 16/05/2022 07:37

worriedparent12 · 16/05/2022 07:33

Maybe I'm paranoid, but this would raise some safeguarding concerns for me as well. In my opinion, people not respecting your boundaries about your kids are a bit of a red flag.

Safeguarding? Really? But then I saw your username and you may be projecting.

sst1234 · 16/05/2022 07:36

This is MN so in laws are evil.

But in the real world, your thoughts about this would be considered irrational. Which you somewhat acknowledge yourself. Kids are not a possession that only set of people should be able to live then most, while the measure of everyone else’s love should stay below that level. It’s not a competition. You need to figure this one and let it go. Your kids are lucky to have grandparents so loving. That’s their privilege and you trying to meddle us taking it away from them.

But like I say this is MN, so cue the bizarre reponses that will inevitably follow.

MolliciousIntent · 16/05/2022 07:36

Disengage entirely and let your husband deal with his family

ChubbyMorticia · 16/05/2022 07:35

Your MIL is projecting when she calls you a bully. Her tantrums are her way of bullying you , and it’s worked.

Say no. When she throws a fit, hang up or tell her it’s time to leave. Her behaviour should not be enabled anymore than you’d allow your children to get their way by throwing tantrums.