Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Love from in laws towards my kids is too much

185 replies

feelingwelljell · 16/05/2022 07:23

I know it's unreasonable.

But the love my in laws have for my kids is too much and it annoys me. I must start by saying, I don't get on with them very well. Lots of things have happened.

I think probably if we had a better relationship, it may not annoy me as much, but I don't know.

It's like my kids are the centre of their universe. Everything is about them and they constantly want to see them at every opportunity. If they haven't seen them for a week, I get messages saying they miss them. I also get told I need to send pictures and videos more often. When my in laws can't come, they pretty much send their other kids and they take constant videos of my kids to then show the in laws.

I send pics to them too and videos as they're always asking, but most of the time when I send something, they'll be some over the top concerned comment from my mother in law, about something really minor in the picture. For example, oh his eye looks swollen or - her hair looks pulled a bit tight, is she OK ? Or - if they even have a minor illness, she has to get really involved and push me to get more and more tests done, even though I'm comfortable in whatever the doctors have told me. She just has to be overly involved in everything and she stresses me out and ruins my mood when I send a nice pic, as she can't say anything nice and always knit picks.

Anyway I know how it sounds. How can I be irritated by someone loving my kids too much ? I sound like an absolute idiot. But they're my kids. I'm afraid my in laws want to gain lots of ground with my kids and will try to bring them up their way and be a huge influence on them. I believe kids should be raised by their parents and I don't want them to be raised to be carbon copies of their other kids. I want to have a big role to play ( the main role ) in how my kids will be raised. But I feel these constant demands for their time and having to be so involved in their lives is going to mean that they'll influence them massively. I don't think it's wrong for them to have a role in their lives, but I don't want to be on the sidelines of their lives, because my in laws ads second parents to them.

They can see them once every couple of weeks and I shouldn't need to be made to feel bad for them ' missing them so much ' after just a week. It's OTT. Anyway, I know I'll get my arse handed to me. But perhaps someone has something helpful to say ?

I feel like a tyrant if I ever say that we can't see them. I just can't say no. I've tried a few times and get theatrics. My in laws don't respect any of the boundaries I've ever tried to set. They're constantly wanting to take my kids to their house and away from me. They'll come round unannounced and tell me that they're taking my daughter to their house. Daughter gets excited because they set no boundaries for her there at all and she does what she wants there ( another problem ). And I just have to go along with it.

Any time I've ever stood up for myself and said no, my mother in law shouts, screams and cries and calls me a bad person and a bully. It's very difficult ! So she's managed to get me to a place where I hold my tongue as much as I can, to avoid a big fight and being called names by her. It's very difficult and feels suffocating.

I'm feeling extra territorial as I've just had a baby, so maybe that's what's prompted these feelings to become stronger.

I just feel like I should be the only one to love my kids this much and to show this amount of concern for them ? My parents are totally different. Whilst they love all their grandchildren a lot, I don't feel it's as excessive and overbearing.

OP posts:
butterpuffed · 16/05/2022 08:30

When your MIL shouts, screams, cries, calls you a bad person and a bully, how do you respond ? And how does your DH react ?

ColdColdColdColdCold · 16/05/2022 08:29

Wow. YANBU.

Any time I've ever stood up for myself and said no, my mother in law shouts, screams and cries and calls me a bad person and a bully. It's very difficult ! So she's managed to get me to a place where I hold my tongue as much as I can, to avoid a big fight and being called names by her. It's very difficult and feels suffocating.

This is horrible, unfortunately she's learned that her behaviour gets you to comply and do what she wants.

I completely understand feeling suffocated and like they're just too much, this is a way OTT level of input and stress to come from grandparents! It's lovely to have a nice close relationship with them but you shouldn't have to organise your life around making sure you don't go longer than seven days without seeing them, wtf? I would feel the same, suffocated and like they're trying to take over my children, or like they're trying to insert themselves into our family and take on a role that simply isn't theirs to take. They're grandparents, they're not your children's parents. It's just too much and I think it'd be unwise to swallow your feelings and allow this to continue.

The more someone pushes like that the less I'd be willing to play ball, and the moment someone started to shout at me and call me a bad person would be the point at which I remove myself and the kids from them until an apology was forthcoming. I can't believe you're still allowing them to continue this way after the way they treat you.

Merryclaire · 16/05/2022 08:26

It amazes me how many people think grandparents are ‘entitled’ to see their grandchildren for a certain frequency, eg once or twice a week. If they want to spend so much time with them, then they should be as respectful and supportive to the parents as possible. If they made things pleasant and easy for you, I’m sure you would feel more accommodating. But the overbearing, controlling behaviour just has the opposite effect.

Tamzo85 · 16/05/2022 08:22

@feelingwelljell perhaps the kids are like there parents because they were raised well and like the way their parents live? Living in a similar way to your parents hardly means you’ve been brainwashed. If you really want to be nothing like your parents that’s hardly a good relationship is it?

bloodyunicorns · 16/05/2022 08:21

Don't feel bad! You're right to feel uncomfortable with this controlling, overbearing behaviour. Why are you the one sending them pics and videos? Your h should be doing this. And what does he think about his parents' behaviour?? You need to sit down together with them and set out ground rules. Tell them these are your dc; they have had their chance to bring up their Dc. You are in charge. If they can't respect that and your boundaries, they don't see the dc. And you will need to be firm. They sound awful.

Andromachehadabadday · 16/05/2022 08:21

However my in laws have somehow managed to create children who don't have minds of their own. I don't want them to do that to my children. I'm afraid they will do that if they spend too much time with them.

They won’t spend more time with them that you. Even now, you said it can be a week between visits.

They didn’t raise carbon copies, you claim your husband isn’t. Maybe their raised their kids and their kids, who are like them, are so because that’s how they genuinely want to live their lives.

You will raise your kids and they will, probably, have a lot of similarities to you.

Time2Move · 16/05/2022 08:20

Tamzo85 · 16/05/2022 07:53

Anyone think maybe DP doesn’t think grandparents coming round or asking for pictures or occasionally giving annoying or over worried advice is actually the huge deal OP does? Perhaps he considers it normal. I would.

If that's the case, perhaps he needs to be the one facilitating it all...

Tamzo85 · 16/05/2022 08:20

@sst1234

Totally agree. Grandmothers fussing is a pretty standard thing. To be laughed off or if it really goes to far then gently told not to do that. To reasonable people that is, others need to call it abuse and quietly stew until they blow up and cause a estrangement between grandparent, grandchild and parent and child. Brilliant stuff.

feelingwelljell · 16/05/2022 08:19

HaveringWavering · 16/05/2022 08:13

Why are you ignoring the repeated questions about what your DH thinks- and is doing- about all this?

Sorry not on purpose. Just doing a million things.

He finds them annoying of course and overbearing and he does stand up to them. But they use the same bullying tactics on him too. It's tough !

OP posts:
Mybestyear · 16/05/2022 08:18

YANBU OP and the fact that you thought you’d get your arse on a plate shows how skewed your ‘normality’ has become. It is 100% NOT reasonable for your ILs to act in this way and how dare they undermine you by taking your DD without a pre-arrangement. They sound batshit and exhausting. They are YOUR DC and you need to get angry!!

MrsToothyBitch · 16/05/2022 08:18

Where is your partner and their son in all of this? Why is he letting them bully you?
I understand not wanting them to have your Dd.

You've had some good advice upthread. Stock phrases on repeat- saying that you trust the gp, they're your children to parent your way and that why must she always find & only focus on the negatives in photos - will show up her constant picking. I'd agree a day once every 3 weeks or so for a couple of hrs. Attempts to barge in between times would be refuted with it not being convenient and reminders of next diary date- although arranging another time in advance can be done. If they're that pushy I'd advise the standard mn rulez- no keys and a ring doorbell. I'd also stop sending constant photos etc- you're too busy enjoying them and interacting with your dc to be behind the lens all the time right?

It might sound ott but it will be worse when your children are older with hobbies, clubs & play dates and your MIL kicks off about them not being glued to her. Unless you nip it now.

Option b is just lose your shit.

darlingdodo · 16/05/2022 08:17

One of those threads where I would love to hear MIL's side.

OP, you haven't said, despite being asked several times, where your DH is in all this.

Fizzgigg · 16/05/2022 08:16

I wouldn't send ANY pics! Her son can send pics if he wants to. I wouldn't have any direct communication with her.

CheekyHobson · 16/05/2022 08:15

You need an extremely firm conversation about expectations and boundaries when the kids aren’t present. That way they can scream and shout that you’re a bad person and a bully as much as they like and you can stand there calmly and say “I find the way you’re speaking to me very disrespectful. I’m not bullying you, I’m letting you know how our relationship can work well for me as well as you. I’m sure that’s what you want too, isn’t it?”

If they carry on, you can say “I’m really surprised and upset that you have such a negative view of my character and to be honest it makes me reluctant to send the kids to spend time with you alone in case you’ve been speaking poorly of me. I had no idea you felt this way about me.”

At this point they may well realise where the actual balance of power lies in the relationship and back off. If they protest they didn’t think you were a bad person until you started trying to keep them apart from their grandchildren, you can clarify that you don’t want that, you just want a little notice of visits so that your day isn’t disrupted. Now the situation is clear for them and they can’t push you around. If they try showing up again, you’ll just have to do a fake nice act. “Oh, Martha, I’m so sorry but perhaps you’ve forgotten the chat we had the other day about giving notice on visits? Today’s not possible as I had some plans with the kids but let’s make a time now, how’s Wednesday?” Then, when she’s gone, make sure to do something extra fun with the kids so that they feel like they got the good end of the deal by staying home.

Unanananana · 16/05/2022 08:14

Where is your husband in all of this?

HaveringWavering · 16/05/2022 08:13

Why are you ignoring the repeated questions about what your DH thinks- and is doing- about all this?

Testina · 16/05/2022 08:13

Loving your tactic @PeterpiperpickedapeckofpickledPEPPAS

riotlady · 16/05/2022 08:13

sst1234 · 16/05/2022 07:36

This is MN so in laws are evil.

But in the real world, your thoughts about this would be considered irrational. Which you somewhat acknowledge yourself. Kids are not a possession that only set of people should be able to live then most, while the measure of everyone else’s love should stay below that level. It’s not a competition. You need to figure this one and let it go. Your kids are lucky to have grandparents so loving. That’s their privilege and you trying to meddle us taking it away from them.

But like I say this is MN, so cue the bizarre reponses that will inevitably follow.

Sorry are you seriously saying in the real world it’s normal for your in laws to scream at you and call you a bully if you don’t see them weekly? To constantly demand pictures and videos and then nitpick every one of them? Because it’s certainly not how my in laws or any that I know would behave

Indicatrice · 16/05/2022 08:12

PeterpiperpickedapeckofpickledPEPPAS · 16/05/2022 08:10

Can you send pics/vids that are a few days old? Then when MIL nitpicks, you can say it’s all sorted, pic is from X day.
So, ´he sounds snuffly, you should take him to the dr because it might be pneumonia’
ˋvideo is from last Friday, his cold has already cleared up.’
´His hair is too messy.’ ´Pic is from yesterday, his hair was washed and combed last night before bed.’
´He should be wearing a jacket, it’s a bit cold today’ ´Pic is from last week, it was very warm in the sun’.

Please don’t do this, never appease bullies.

Indicatrice · 16/05/2022 08:11

However my in laws have somehow managed to create children who don't have minds of their own. I don't want them to do that to my children. I'm afraid they will do that if they spend too much time with them.

You’re over complicating things. They are abusive to you so they need to go from your lives. That’s it.

PeterpiperpickedapeckofpickledPEPPAS · 16/05/2022 08:10

Can you send pics/vids that are a few days old? Then when MIL nitpicks, you can say it’s all sorted, pic is from X day.
So, ´he sounds snuffly, you should take him to the dr because it might be pneumonia’
ˋvideo is from last Friday, his cold has already cleared up.’
´His hair is too messy.’ ´Pic is from yesterday, his hair was washed and combed last night before bed.’
´He should be wearing a jacket, it’s a bit cold today’ ´Pic is from last week, it was very warm in the sun’.

Indicatrice · 16/05/2022 08:09

I also get told I need to send pictures and videos more often.

Why are they asking you and not their son?

Any time I've ever stood up for myself and said no, my mother in law shouts, screams and cries and calls me a bad person and a bully.

This alone is grounds to go no contact with them.

They sound awful, don’t let them in to your home again.

feelingwelljell · 16/05/2022 08:08

JanglyBeads · 16/05/2022 07:58

This is not love - if you love a child you want it to have the best possible relationship with its parents - this is an attempt to control.

Do you feel like they don't trust you to bring "their" (grand)children up?

Do they have other grandchildren, how are they about them?

Does your DH acquiesce with them for a quiet life?

Yes this exactly ! I think they don't trust me ! We have quite different views on life and I think they want to make sure my kids spend as much time with them as possible so they can be less influenced by me.

If you look at my in laws children, they're carbon copies of them. They pretty much live their lives in exactly the same way and share exactly the same views ( apart from my husband who is the black sheep ). But apparently my husband used to be good, but because of me he's now not good- as I've influenced him negatively ( MIL's words ).

So yes I do get that children will have different influencers in their life. In my opinion being an adult means, being able to hold different views to your parents. I'm happy for my children to do that. I don't need them and don't want them to be like me.

However my in laws have somehow managed to create children who don't have minds of their own. I don't want them to do that to my children. I'm afraid they will do that if they spend too much time with them.

OP posts:
saraclara · 16/05/2022 08:05

I was about to call sorry for the in laws when I tread the thread title. But the years and tantrums and controlling behaviour is not grandparent love.

They announce they're talking your daughter? Just say no and let the screaming wall over you (preferably get your daughter out of the way first, by telling her to go and play in the garden or something). And make it clear that you're in charge and they talk to you in advance in future.

The videos? "Talk to your son about this, I'm busy with the new baby"

MajorCarolDanvers · 16/05/2022 08:03

That sounds horrendous. What does your DH do in all this?