Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Love from in laws towards my kids is too much

185 replies

feelingwelljell · 16/05/2022 07:23

I know it's unreasonable.

But the love my in laws have for my kids is too much and it annoys me. I must start by saying, I don't get on with them very well. Lots of things have happened.

I think probably if we had a better relationship, it may not annoy me as much, but I don't know.

It's like my kids are the centre of their universe. Everything is about them and they constantly want to see them at every opportunity. If they haven't seen them for a week, I get messages saying they miss them. I also get told I need to send pictures and videos more often. When my in laws can't come, they pretty much send their other kids and they take constant videos of my kids to then show the in laws.

I send pics to them too and videos as they're always asking, but most of the time when I send something, they'll be some over the top concerned comment from my mother in law, about something really minor in the picture. For example, oh his eye looks swollen or - her hair looks pulled a bit tight, is she OK ? Or - if they even have a minor illness, she has to get really involved and push me to get more and more tests done, even though I'm comfortable in whatever the doctors have told me. She just has to be overly involved in everything and she stresses me out and ruins my mood when I send a nice pic, as she can't say anything nice and always knit picks.

Anyway I know how it sounds. How can I be irritated by someone loving my kids too much ? I sound like an absolute idiot. But they're my kids. I'm afraid my in laws want to gain lots of ground with my kids and will try to bring them up their way and be a huge influence on them. I believe kids should be raised by their parents and I don't want them to be raised to be carbon copies of their other kids. I want to have a big role to play ( the main role ) in how my kids will be raised. But I feel these constant demands for their time and having to be so involved in their lives is going to mean that they'll influence them massively. I don't think it's wrong for them to have a role in their lives, but I don't want to be on the sidelines of their lives, because my in laws ads second parents to them.

They can see them once every couple of weeks and I shouldn't need to be made to feel bad for them ' missing them so much ' after just a week. It's OTT. Anyway, I know I'll get my arse handed to me. But perhaps someone has something helpful to say ?

I feel like a tyrant if I ever say that we can't see them. I just can't say no. I've tried a few times and get theatrics. My in laws don't respect any of the boundaries I've ever tried to set. They're constantly wanting to take my kids to their house and away from me. They'll come round unannounced and tell me that they're taking my daughter to their house. Daughter gets excited because they set no boundaries for her there at all and she does what she wants there ( another problem ). And I just have to go along with it.

Any time I've ever stood up for myself and said no, my mother in law shouts, screams and cries and calls me a bad person and a bully. It's very difficult ! So she's managed to get me to a place where I hold my tongue as much as I can, to avoid a big fight and being called names by her. It's very difficult and feels suffocating.

I'm feeling extra territorial as I've just had a baby, so maybe that's what's prompted these feelings to become stronger.

I just feel like I should be the only one to love my kids this much and to show this amount of concern for them ? My parents are totally different. Whilst they love all their grandchildren a lot, I don't feel it's as excessive and overbearing.

OP posts:
bloodyunicorns · 16/05/2022 10:40

What @KettrickenSmiled says!

Read their posts. Then read them again. They make so much sense.

ClaryFairchild · 16/05/2022 10:38

Ugh, I'd move away. Failing that - anytime they yell at you and call you a bully etc for saying no to something, that would result in an extended time of them not seeing the DC - a time out, as it were.

They will learn quickly enough that trying to escalate things and bullying you into doing what they want will actually end up with them seeing the grandkids LESS.

Cloud16 · 16/05/2022 10:33

Might sound extreme, but is it possible to move away and put some distance between them?

They sound awful. You could also just delete their numbers, tell your DH that it's his mum so he can deal with it and similarly, tell MIL to speak with her son about the kids, not you. Also if they come uninvited, just don't let them in.

KettrickenSmiled · 16/05/2022 10:31

sst1234 · 16/05/2022 07:36

This is MN so in laws are evil.

But in the real world, your thoughts about this would be considered irrational. Which you somewhat acknowledge yourself. Kids are not a possession that only set of people should be able to live then most, while the measure of everyone else’s love should stay below that level. It’s not a competition. You need to figure this one and let it go. Your kids are lucky to have grandparents so loving. That’s their privilege and you trying to meddle us taking it away from them.

But like I say this is MN, so cue the bizarre reponses that will inevitably follow.

It's not "bizarre" or "irrational" to not want to be bullied, screamed at, & controlled by a personality disordered individual, @sst1234

In the real world, those of us with experience of these types of people fully understand that their outrageous demands are nothing to do with "love", & everything to do with control & domination.

OP - ignore the #BeKind Brigade - if you note the scolding, disapproving tone, you'll see how ironically unkind it is of them to misunderstand your situation & blame you for it.

Order this book, & pop along to the "Stately Homes Thread". You will find PP with actual experience there, who can advise & commiserate, & who won't give you this kind of codswallop.
www.amazon.co.uk/Toxic-Laws-Susan-Forward/dp/0060507853

billy1966 · 16/05/2022 10:23

What you are describing is a bullying, controlling relationship that you and your husband are colluding with instead of protecting your children from.

These are awful people and you are allowing them to tell you that they are taking YOUR child when they just turn up.

They are not normal.
This is not a normal situation.
YOU are not normal to be tolerating this.

Most people would not tolerate this.
They would go LC or NC.
They would not answer the door.

They would tell their husband to sort his parents out.

Screaming and shouting if his mother doesn't get her way?

Not normal and awful that you would hand over your children to such people.

No videos, no pictures.
Block them on the phone.
Don't answer the door.

TELL them that they can see the children on X date and mean it.

You need to stand up for your children, not allow these awful people bully and control their parents.

This is not normal behaviour.

Stand up for yourself and your children.
They do not need people like this in their lives.

KettrickenSmiled · 16/05/2022 10:22

I think that some of it is new birth hormones. I'd say that I was co-parented by my maternal grandparents and I have lovely memories of our times together.

How lovely for you to be raised by kind & reasonable GC @@Ponoka7
But your experience really has nothing to do with OP's, so I'm not sure why you trotted it out.

I also dislike the patronising way you dismiss her difficulties as being down to "hormones". Stinks of DARVO, & OP will have enough of that on her plate already - www.banyantherapy.com/darvo/

Unless your GC regularly nit-picked, demanded, screamed, shouted at & bullied you - you haven't got a clue what OP is enduring.

As I said - people with no experience of what it is like having a Cluster-B type personality disorder in the family will Just Not Get It ...

gwanwyn · 16/05/2022 10:22

My in laws don't respect any of the boundaries I've ever tried to set.

They won't even when you do establish them they'll still occaionally test them.

Maybe try Toxic In-Laws: Loving Strategies for Protecting Your Marriage - to see if there are statergies you could use. I think I just got to the no point - I saw my own mother bitter due to her ILs and didn't want that. I'm probably more bitter than I realise but still not as bad and hopefully set a good model for our own children.

Watermill · 16/05/2022 10:20

Any time I've ever stood up for myself and said no, my mother in law shouts, screams and cries and calls me a bad person and a bully.

So what? Let her rant and rave. Why should her needs trump yours?

Fuck the lot of them OP. You need to put far better boundaries in place, and that may involve relocating physically.

gwanwyn · 16/05/2022 10:16

And my s in law actively competes with me over “her special kid” with me - it is extremely disconcerting.

Yes - had the with pfb. Oddly a lot of other upsetting comments- house cooking washing, eating all seemed to come from idea she was competing with me.

She does it with other women - though took me a while to realise it wasn't all directed at me - but more I just refused to engage the better it got.

I did spend years having to make sure MIL didn't on days out disappear with pfb and leave rest of us hanging around and I put a stop to the bad mouthing of me to pfb or any of them. I also had to deal with bizzare idea of her being called mama and lots of digs that everyone thought she was the mum - they didn't but first year that really bugged me. Then pfb ran across kitchen floor to me ignoring MIL arms and the look of pure jealousy on MIL face made me realise what she said it didn't really matter.

She actually worked out as a very good GM - but easily have gone another way without boundaries.

KettrickenSmiled · 16/05/2022 10:12

My in laws don't respect any of the boundaries I've ever tried to set.
You need to rethink this mindset - urgently.
Stop "setting" boundaries. Enforce them.
Because when you 'set' a boundary, & MiL ignores it - look what you are allowing to happen - And I just have to go along with it.

In what way do you "have to go along with it"?
You don't.
You DO have decide that the alternative - which is obviously this -
Any time I've ever stood up for myself and said no, my mother in law shouts, screams and cries and calls me a bad person and a bully. It's very difficult ! So she's managed to get me to a place where I hold my tongue as much as I can, to avoid a big fight and being called names by her. It's very difficult and feels suffocating.
is way worse that the short term pain of choosing to enforce your boundary.

Your MiL is used to getting her own way.
She has trained you to allow your boundaries to be trampled.
She is behaving like a giant toddler & I think it would help you to start viewing & responding to her as one.

So give yourself a good talking to, brace yourself for the explosions that are going to be coming your way - & JUST SAY NO!
When she asks for pics -
"my phone's on charge, I'll do it later"
"I'm a bit busy right now, can you ask DH?"
You could even, eventually, work yourself up to some radical honesty:
"No. I can't be arsed, because you will start nitpicking something & I can't be bothered dealing with your insane questions today."

When she sends DH's siblings round to video/take pics -
"Give it a rest, my kids will think they're film stars the amount of pics you're taking"
"OK it's time to put the cameras away & live in the moment for a change"
Working up to -
"If you've come round on MiL's orders again, just to take pics, I'm not facilitating that today. If you've come round because you actually want to see us, you're welcome though ..."

When she rings you - or turns up on your doorstep - & you don't want to deal with her - don't even engage. You simply tell her "gotta run" and HANG UP or SHUT YOUR DOOR.
You have gone along with her bullying for so ling that it's going to feel very strange standing up to it. But you have to, or she will drive you demented.
You are also likely to experience an Extinction Burst as MiL loudly expresses her outrage at no longer being allowed to steamroller you -
fortestrong.com/extinction-burst-what-is-it-and-how-can-you-use-it-to-your-advantage/

You need to ride it out.
I know how you will dread it - but what's the alternative? You, squashed & suffocated & miserable, & your DC spoiled & made into carbon copies of MiL's other DC & GDC, & everybody still dancing only to MiL's tune?
If you drop the rope, & refuse to engage beyond a simple statement of your boundary - but then move to enforce that boundary no matter what insane outbursts MiL produces - you will eventually retrain yourself to stop accepting this ridiculous & damaging dynamic.
It will be ugly, possibly even frightening at first - MiL will escalate, recruit Flying Monkeys, bad mouth you to all comers - but frankly, why do you need to give a shit about that? Because your response will now be -
"Sorry, can't talk now gotta dash" & end the phone call - switch your phone off if need be - &
"Sorry, not convenient for a visit now, DH will give you a call to arrange something later" - & shut the door in her face.
If she kicks off? - so what? She's not on the phone to you, she's not in your house. Win!
If she screams outside the house? - so what? - Let her. If she's making a public nuisance of herself, call the cops.

In short - you have to STOP caring what this awful woman thinks, & STOP giving into her. It's only fear of her reaction that's preventing you from enforcing your boundary. Remember - enforcing. Because you can set as many boundaries as you like, & they will all be useless if you allow them to crumble as soon as MiL says "jump". So take the consequences, ride out the extinction burst, & get your life back.

Also - He finds them annoying of course and overbearing and he does stand up to them. But they use the same bullying tactics on him too. It's tough !
Move. Far away.
You will never completely escape this toxic nonsense until DH is able to fully inhabit the "black sheep" role MiL has assigned him in his family.
Until you can move away, you are going to have to summon all your courage & - very simply - start believing in the power of your own "NO!" & that you have the ability to enforce that no. You have to decide to be tough enough to ride out the punishment & control MiL will try to force on you when you resist doing her bidding.

Best of British OP.
People without a Cluster-B type personality disorder in the family won't get how exhausting & terrifying it can be. But enough's enough now. MiL doesn't own you. Get her to fuck.

Bordesleyhills · 16/05/2022 10:12

At least they acknowledge- mine don’t or ever say anything like doesnt x look nice or oo he’s had his hair cut doesn’t it look nice...

gwanwyn · 16/05/2022 10:05

You're already the villain in her eyes, OP - might as well live up to it!!

It helped when I got this mindset.

It is odd though many of MIL friends now have young GC and she relays their conversations and there seems to be so much taking offense at small talk conversation and upset because it doensn't seem to occur to them that they need to check things with the GC parents - though sometimes it DS not relaying/consulting the mothers is teh issue. There's also a lo of thinking they know better or even that they have a closer bond with GC than mother.

It's all very odd - and MIL likes to pretend she never did any of that - though she was often made worse by her friendship group and FIL was all about his rights - but they were slightly nuts in early years and are "normal" now.

CocktailsOnTheBeach · 16/05/2022 10:03

I could have written your post, my in laws are the same, I think in my case its made far worse because we really don't get on. I used to get on with them but when we got engaged they changed, it's like they decided I wasn't actually good enough (although we'd been together 10 years!). Once we got married and had children the relationship completely broke down and their bizarre overbearing behaviour started. It's like they saw my kids as theirs and they do this weird thing where they stress our children are part of their family, they don't say you are not but it's what they infer. My family on the other hand consider my husband part of their family, they see him as an extra son and treat him accordingly. My parents are involved with our children but they follow our lead, whatever we say they go with. My in laws on the other hand will undermine us and do things we ask them not to just because they know better. Eg during covid we went to visit them in the garden when we were allowed to socially distanced and I said before we arrived we'll be keeping our distance so please don't hug the children, we'd said to our children the same. As soon as we arrived my fil scooped up our children and walked off with them down the bottom of their garden!! I couldn't believe what I was seeing.

We've now ended up going very low contact as the lack of respect towards me is awful. It sounds ridiculous when you tell other people that your in laws are completely obsessed and over bearing with your children but yet won't even acknowledge you. I get that many people would love to have grandparents that care so much but when it's coming from a very controlling place it's too much. The only way we could deal with them was to take a step back, thankfully my husband can see what they are doing and is on my side. It has meant that his extended family have cut us off completely, which is sad for my husband, but we are much happier not having his controlling parents around wanting us to live our life under their ruling.

Ruraljurer · 16/05/2022 10:01

I could have written your exact post! I feel the exact same way about mine. The only difference is I do not feel like a tyrant - they are objectively awful. There are 3 relatives (in laws) and they have effectively divided up the 3 kids between them. And my s in law actively competes with me over “her special kid” with me - it is extremely disconcerting. Two of the 3 have very warped ideas about what love is. I have also had a rocky relationship with them - they are an extremely dysfunctional family, my husband had to put a lot of distance between them and him as soon as he could. That being said he has no idea how to deal with them. When they come for a weekend he basically becomes mute for the entire time, and just allows everything to wash over him as he cannot cope. He shuts down. I find myself having a fight or flight response in the run up to their arrival, my heart rate quickens and I my body temperature changes.

there’s so much more I could say on this and I have literally no words of advice but I just wanted to share that you are not alone with these feelings.

my mum (very very sensible, grounded person) says that they all live quite lonely lives and I should not get upset by their behaviour as it’s for a short space of time however I cannot help it. Their controlling and possessive behaviour makes me very territorial.

WildCoasts · 16/05/2022 10:00

You're already the villain in her eyes, OP - might as well live up to it!!

This. The final straw was when MIL visited and didn't speak to me or even look at me. And that's about what I said to DH. "Since I am completely invisible, I have decided I will be invisible. From now on, you are the one who will send them pictures, buy and send gifts, invite them over, call them. If you don't, it won't happen." Guess who didn't do any of that? DH agrees, the last 18 years we haven't seen then have been so much more peaceful.

StaunchMomma · 16/05/2022 09:53

I'm afraid you only have 2 choices, OP, either speak up and risk her wrath (but let her know where she stands) or put up with it.

She's clearly not going to change. The longer her behaviour is tolerated the more she will ride rough-shod over you.

I think the Mumsnet mantra of 'Sorry, that doesn't work for us' would help you out, here. It's a firm but polite NO!

Things like turning up and demanding to take your DD to their house for a sleepover is just outrageous. I can see how saying no would cause an argument and potentially some tears from DD BUT she'd soon get over it and it would send a clear message of who's boss.

You're already the villain in her eyes, OP - might as well live up to it!!

gwanwyn · 16/05/2022 09:53

WildCoasts · 16/05/2022 09:29

I'll tell you what happens when these things aren't addressed, especially with a passive husband. Tensions brew until there is a huge an ugly explosion, even from the husband who never made a peep before it. It's better to try to work out some boundaries now, if MIL is someone who is is even possible to do that with. Then maybe relationships can be salvaged.

This.

I got fed up before that - but only just - unleached my toungue stepped massively back - photos phone calls, presents etc go through DH.

At same time - they were told no - I'd agree stance with DH before hand and if he didn't say no I did. Made me the wicked witch for a while - among their friends but so what and I refused to be pushed out or have DH or me undermined.

Much to my surpised turned out we could put boundaries in - it was very tiring to be around had to be constatly on guard but they are good for the children to have a relationship with. So I think we got to an okay place - though I do feel slightly bitter at the work that put on me and it probbaly helped we've moved further away each time.

So I'd have a frank talk with your DH - agree were you boundaries are and stick to them with a smile but firmly - lots of ways to say no without saying no- and ignore any tantrums in reponse.

picassobride · 16/05/2022 09:48

My MIL declared some years ago that she loves her grandchildren more than she ever loved her son, my DH.
In front of said DH.
She is a truly stupid woman.
I get where you're coming from,OP. On paper it looks YABU but it can be so overbearing and disturbing.
I feel for you.

chiangmai · 16/05/2022 09:45

Its time to stop holding your tongue. If your DH isnt going to set boundaries then your going to have to do it. Your MIL is a bully and you need to protect yourself and your DC from her. They shouldnt be brought up watching their parents being bullied by there grandparents. You will have a nightmare when your DC are older as they wont respect your boundarie as they have seen you being bullied into silence. You need to reset their expectations by resetting your own.

TimmyHos · 16/05/2022 09:41

Their behaviour is not normal. It sounds very much about control rather than love.

You haven't mentioned your DH at all?? He should be the main one dealing with their bad behaviour and setting boundaries. You do not need to engage with people who treat you badly. Don't worry about upsetting them, because they sure aren't worried about upsetting you!

HaveringWavering · 16/05/2022 09:40

feelingwelljell · 16/05/2022 08:19

Sorry not on purpose. Just doing a million things.

He finds them annoying of course and overbearing and he does stand up to them. But they use the same bullying tactics on him too. It's tough !

No, you’re missing the point. They are his family and he needs to protect you from the upset they are causing you, and use his position as their son to say things to them that you cannot. He can’t just pathetically say “oh they are being awful to both of us” and leave you to deal with the requests for pictures, visits etc. He needs to step up.

Why do you live so close to them anyway if he lives a different life to his siblings- can you move?

zafferana · 16/05/2022 09:36

They sound batshit and controlling.

Can you move away from them so it's much harder for them to insert themselves into your lives in this overbearing way? I couldn't cope with your MIL at all, but since she's so foul to you already you don't have a lot to lose by standing up to her and saying No more often. IME, that's the way to deal with bullies - stand up to them and show them you won't be pushed around. She'll shout and screech initially, but you need to show her that you are the equal of her and that you're not going to just do her bidding. Fuck her.

Youseethethingis1 · 16/05/2022 09:36

I'm afraid anyone shouting and screaming at me in my own home would be told to get the fuck out and never darken my door again.
Do you feel beholden to the in some way? What have they go over you? Realistically, what would happen if you cut ties? What positives would you, your husband, your children miss out on?
They sound utterly toxic, not loving at all.

ArmWrestlingWithChasNDave · 16/05/2022 09:33

Any time I've ever stood up for myself and said no, my mother in law shouts, screams and cries and calls me a bad person and a bully. It's very difficult !

How is that difficult? You don't like her and think she's a bad person, so who cares if she's upset with you?

"It's a shame you feel that way, MIL. Anyway, as I said, [daughter] can't come home with you today."

Nanny0gg · 16/05/2022 09:32

feelingwelljell · 16/05/2022 08:08

Yes this exactly ! I think they don't trust me ! We have quite different views on life and I think they want to make sure my kids spend as much time with them as possible so they can be less influenced by me.

If you look at my in laws children, they're carbon copies of them. They pretty much live their lives in exactly the same way and share exactly the same views ( apart from my husband who is the black sheep ). But apparently my husband used to be good, but because of me he's now not good- as I've influenced him negatively ( MIL's words ).

So yes I do get that children will have different influencers in their life. In my opinion being an adult means, being able to hold different views to your parents. I'm happy for my children to do that. I don't need them and don't want them to be like me.

However my in laws have somehow managed to create children who don't have minds of their own. I don't want them to do that to my children. I'm afraid they will do that if they spend too much time with them.

So does that include your husband?

Where is he in all of this?

(And anyone who shouts, screams, cries and carried on to get their own way can get lost)