Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Love from in laws towards my kids is too much

185 replies

feelingwelljell · 16/05/2022 07:23

I know it's unreasonable.

But the love my in laws have for my kids is too much and it annoys me. I must start by saying, I don't get on with them very well. Lots of things have happened.

I think probably if we had a better relationship, it may not annoy me as much, but I don't know.

It's like my kids are the centre of their universe. Everything is about them and they constantly want to see them at every opportunity. If they haven't seen them for a week, I get messages saying they miss them. I also get told I need to send pictures and videos more often. When my in laws can't come, they pretty much send their other kids and they take constant videos of my kids to then show the in laws.

I send pics to them too and videos as they're always asking, but most of the time when I send something, they'll be some over the top concerned comment from my mother in law, about something really minor in the picture. For example, oh his eye looks swollen or - her hair looks pulled a bit tight, is she OK ? Or - if they even have a minor illness, she has to get really involved and push me to get more and more tests done, even though I'm comfortable in whatever the doctors have told me. She just has to be overly involved in everything and she stresses me out and ruins my mood when I send a nice pic, as she can't say anything nice and always knit picks.

Anyway I know how it sounds. How can I be irritated by someone loving my kids too much ? I sound like an absolute idiot. But they're my kids. I'm afraid my in laws want to gain lots of ground with my kids and will try to bring them up their way and be a huge influence on them. I believe kids should be raised by their parents and I don't want them to be raised to be carbon copies of their other kids. I want to have a big role to play ( the main role ) in how my kids will be raised. But I feel these constant demands for their time and having to be so involved in their lives is going to mean that they'll influence them massively. I don't think it's wrong for them to have a role in their lives, but I don't want to be on the sidelines of their lives, because my in laws ads second parents to them.

They can see them once every couple of weeks and I shouldn't need to be made to feel bad for them ' missing them so much ' after just a week. It's OTT. Anyway, I know I'll get my arse handed to me. But perhaps someone has something helpful to say ?

I feel like a tyrant if I ever say that we can't see them. I just can't say no. I've tried a few times and get theatrics. My in laws don't respect any of the boundaries I've ever tried to set. They're constantly wanting to take my kids to their house and away from me. They'll come round unannounced and tell me that they're taking my daughter to their house. Daughter gets excited because they set no boundaries for her there at all and she does what she wants there ( another problem ). And I just have to go along with it.

Any time I've ever stood up for myself and said no, my mother in law shouts, screams and cries and calls me a bad person and a bully. It's very difficult ! So she's managed to get me to a place where I hold my tongue as much as I can, to avoid a big fight and being called names by her. It's very difficult and feels suffocating.

I'm feeling extra territorial as I've just had a baby, so maybe that's what's prompted these feelings to become stronger.

I just feel like I should be the only one to love my kids this much and to show this amount of concern for them ? My parents are totally different. Whilst they love all their grandchildren a lot, I don't feel it's as excessive and overbearing.

OP posts:
KettrickenSmiled · 16/05/2022 11:53

RitaFaircloughsWig · 16/05/2022 11:41

You hold all the cards - what an awful sick comment to make.

@RitaFaircloughsWig - are you reading the same thread as me?

The only "sick" here is MiL's revolting & controlling behaviour.
Not PP's sensible advice to OP in how to handle it.

MarieIVanArkleStinks · 16/05/2022 11:51

I've only skimmed the thread. But two points PPs have made stand out for me: one is that your OP makes it sound as though you were the sole parent here, and two is that this is not 'love'. What you're experiencing here is controlling behaviour and a very unhealthy dynamic. From what you've written, your fears for your children's wellbeing should this behaviour continue are legitimate.

It's hard to tackle a situation in which non-compliance with their demands immediately brooks aggression. In the short term this may make life easier, but in the long time it becomes more difficult, to the extent that when you do reach breaking point the blowout risks being much more severe and more likely to end in complete estrangement. And that's an end no one ideally wants, if only people can learn to respect boundaries. Remember, they won't change. They have things exactly as they want them. If you want any behaviour to change, it will first have to be yours. And let your husband know that the least of your expectations is that he is not to sabotage your efforts.

I'd recommend you read Susan Forward's book Toxic In-Laws. This woman is a master at setting realistic boundaries in a non-confrontational way, and tackling any confrontation that does arise using a non-defensive form of communication. She knows her job, and her book is incredibly helpful. I think you'll immediately recognize your in-laws as the engulfers.

Gradually start to step back. First thing to do is stop sending so many pictures. Start referring her demands to your husband; it should not be assumed that you're going to pick up all the slack of the wifework. Stop being so readily available. And grey rock. This approach has likely saved many a stilted family relationship; better than letting things drag on, resulting in a Vesuvius-level eruption, and ending in the inevitable No Contact.

Good luck, OP. Unfortunately, you're going to need it. Flowers

Elliania · 16/05/2022 11:51

If your inlaws already think you're a bitch then what does it matter if you stand up to them and set boundaries? You say your DH is the black sheep & you're the terrible influence that has corrupted him - own it. Be firm, calm and state your boundaries.

"No MIL that doesn't work for us."
"We are not available for a visit today. We will invite you when it is convenient for our family."
"You will not be taking the children unless you have checked with me & DH."
"DH and I are confident in the doctor's advice."

If they show up unannounced - don't let them in.
Meet them at neutral places where the kids can have fun - outings to a zoo or a park.
Cut way way way back on the amount of pictures you send and the overall level of contact. Don't reply everytime they demand pictures or videos, you're just feeding the entitlement.

KettrickenSmiled · 16/05/2022 11:50

DirectionToPerfection · 16/05/2022 11:38

Next time MIL criticises you on the WhatsApp group I'd be tempted to say:

"I've had enough of your nitpicking and your lack of respect. Do not turn up to my house unannounced. Do not expect to take my DD away whenever you feel like it. Do not demand constant photos. Do not scream at me or try to bully me. The worse your behaviour is, the less you will see of my children. I'm leaving this group now, contact DH if you must, but don't expect to see my children if you cannot treat their mother with basic respect and decency."

Then leave the group. You have to stand up for yourself. Refuse to talk to any of them and let your DH deal with them.

Perfection by name, perfection by nature.

OP - this would be such a firm line in the sand for you.
Do you feel able to do this?
It will finally burn the bridge that MiL has been holding you hostage on - your own over-concern about what she thinks of you.

Perfection's message tells her that you can no longer be controlled by the threat of her having a bad opinion of you. By the threat of her bullying, or screaming & shouting. By the threat of her just turning up & ordering you about.
I recommend you do it. It will feel scary at first - but so liberating.

The absolute joy for you would be - as soon as you've sent that message, you no longer have to deal with the fallout - because you will LEAVE THE WHATSAPP GROUP IMMEDIATELY.
Let them scream & shout amongst themselves.
You are not longer interested - or bothered.
You don't have to answer phone calls, or open the front door.
You, & your home, are now impenetrable, unless you issue an invitation to visit.

Visualise it OP. How great does that feel?

Change123today · 16/05/2022 11:47

My Mil is a nightmare but no where near as bad as yours. I’m well aware that I’m not good enough and the choices we have made for our children she doesn’t agree with - I got to a point where I just don’t care and put things in place to protect myself and in doing so has protected our children.

  1. I no longer text or respond to messages. If I have been sent one I ask my husband to respond back. I’m not rude so birthdays etc I send a Thankyou but that’s it. It also means she knows less about our lives as my husband will chat about other things and so she only knows very little of our lives.

  2. My husband has to do the birthdays/Christmas thinking for his family - I’m happy to wrap but that’s it. He tries to engage me on my opinion but I refuse to involve myself.

  3. It became obvious that what she actually wanted was my husband full attention, so he now will go to see her alone take her out for a trip/ meal without us. The children didn’t want to go as even they felt very much in the way and also began to be aware of the comments - they didn’t want to hear it or be put in a situation to defend it as they got older.

Everyone is happier, my husband feels less pulled about. I feel better as the LC means I don’t feel so open to the underhand controlling comments.

Zilla1 · 16/05/2022 11:47

HNRTT and I don't want to minimise 'all hell breaking loose' but then what would happen? It sounds like your ILs don't respect you and you are unhappy so what would be the bad things that happen when you establish boundaries they don't like? Is your DP on board?

DirectionToPerfection · 16/05/2022 11:47

feelingwelljell · 16/05/2022 11:43

All hell would break loose! Everyone would rush to defend MIL and how she's just giving advice and how I take everything the wrong way etc.

Maybe it will, but as a PP said, "So what?" What's the alternative? You know you're not the unreasonable one here. It might actually make you feel empowered.

It's clearly a very toxic family and the only healthy thing to do is put firm boundaries in place, and enforce them.

feelingwelljell · 16/05/2022 11:43

DirectionToPerfection · 16/05/2022 11:38

Next time MIL criticises you on the WhatsApp group I'd be tempted to say:

"I've had enough of your nitpicking and your lack of respect. Do not turn up to my house unannounced. Do not expect to take my DD away whenever you feel like it. Do not demand constant photos. Do not scream at me or try to bully me. The worse your behaviour is, the less you will see of my children. I'm leaving this group now, contact DH if you must, but don't expect to see my children if you cannot treat their mother with basic respect and decency."

Then leave the group. You have to stand up for yourself. Refuse to talk to any of them and let your DH deal with them.

All hell would break loose! Everyone would rush to defend MIL and how she's just giving advice and how I take everything the wrong way etc.

OP posts:
Fraaahnces · 16/05/2022 11:42

Actually… what she ⬆️⬆️⬆️ said is perfect. (I would edit to “Don’t scream like a neurotic harpy on my doorstep. It’s not going to work.”

RitaFaircloughsWig · 16/05/2022 11:41

cptartapp · 16/05/2022 07:31

You don't 'have' to do anything. You hold all the cards.
Ignore the drama. Don't answer the phone. Cut down on the photos. Their behaviour would make me even more determined to 'win'.

You hold all the cards - what an awful sick comment to make.

DirectionToPerfection · 16/05/2022 11:38

Next time MIL criticises you on the WhatsApp group I'd be tempted to say:

"I've had enough of your nitpicking and your lack of respect. Do not turn up to my house unannounced. Do not expect to take my DD away whenever you feel like it. Do not demand constant photos. Do not scream at me or try to bully me. The worse your behaviour is, the less you will see of my children. I'm leaving this group now, contact DH if you must, but don't expect to see my children if you cannot treat their mother with basic respect and decency."

Then leave the group. You have to stand up for yourself. Refuse to talk to any of them and let your DH deal with them.

AskingforaBaskin · 16/05/2022 11:36

feelingwelljell · 16/05/2022 10:56

Anytime they notice anything is even slightly wrong with my kids ( I never tell them ) they will make a massive deal out of it on the family WhatsApp. Including everyone else in the conversation, rather than just talking to me directly. It irritates me so much.

My mother in law makes me find things to worry about. I'm a bit anxious anyway and she heightens it so much
When my first was a newborn she convinced me to take her to the doctor / hospital at any given opportunity. If I then reported back, doctor said she just has colic or whatever it was, she would push and push and push - well did you ask why ? How long it will last ? Is it something you've eaten that's caused it ? How long will it last ? Will they see her again ? You get the drift..whatever I had found out from the doctor, it was never enough and would make me feel like I had failed. My first starts nursery and gets every bug going.. surely something is wrong ! You need to push the doctors for a blood test. Something is wrong with her ! Every other parent says it's normal for her to pick up bugs at Nursery when she's new.. etc. nope, my MIL has to push it.

The other day I was in the shower and my mum was round. They turned up, saying they'll take my DD to their house.. my mum said to them she is uncomfortable to let them take her as she'd rather check with me first.. that didn't even cross their mind
! My bro in law said last week to my DD that she would come and pick her up the next day and take her to her house.. to which I could not bite my tongue and said, well mummy would like to approve that before you do it. I can 100 percent guarantee that bro in law took that badly and like me being a massive bitch. I am a bitch to them as soon as I show any kind of boundary. It's always been that way and will always be that way. They guilt my dh and I with all the , we just love them so much and mean well. We are your parents ( to my DH ) and love you so much. They basically only tolerate me though ..

Leave the WhatsApp group

Blinkingbatshit · 16/05/2022 11:30

Gosh - this sounds awful! How close do they actually live? Would you consider moving a little further away to put in some distance that would make it hard for them to ‘just turn up’?….I know that seems quite drastic but Jeez, I’d hate to live with this level of interference!! I’d stop engaging on the family WhatsApp, do they have keys to your house? If so get the locks changed and make it clear that all family need to ask before they visit…dropping in should not be an option. It’s hard but you need to learn to not worry about what they think of you - they don’t like you anyway so stop trying!! You need to speak with your dh and come up with a joint plan to sort this out, it’s obviously not healthy for either of you. Are yours the only grandchildren or are there others they’re as crazy with?

Fraaahnces · 16/05/2022 11:27

I honestly think you need to think of this as dog training. You reward good behaviour and ignore bad. To do this, you’re going to have to start organizing things to do with your kids and/or have a long list or reasons (excuses) not to go along with their plans (tyranny). You will have to follow through or the kids will report back. Make sure that you tick things off the list so that you are not repeating yourself to arouse suspicion.

Then have bags, jackets, keys, etc. all by the door for when they “drop by” and say, “Oh we’re just on our way out. You should have rung and seen if it suited me. Maybe next week…” (Make sure you use “me” because that puts you in the position of power.) Don’t give them any inroads into coming along too. Let them know that you have plans that don’t include them.

*It helps to have friends/family ready to back you up at short notice.
*Maybe start booking your wee ones into mum and baby groups/music lessons/kindergym, etc. That gives you more reason to say no. (And have fun with your own kids.)

GettingItOutThere · 16/05/2022 11:22

start turning this around on them... "coming to take little ariel home with me now",
erm no...mummy didnt say nanny could, next time nanny needs to ask first

put your foot down. They are YOUR kids. not hers. why on earth is this allowed to continue.??

Calphurnia88 · 16/05/2022 11:18

sst1234 · 16/05/2022 07:36

This is MN so in laws are evil.

But in the real world, your thoughts about this would be considered irrational. Which you somewhat acknowledge yourself. Kids are not a possession that only set of people should be able to live then most, while the measure of everyone else’s love should stay below that level. It’s not a competition. You need to figure this one and let it go. Your kids are lucky to have grandparents so loving. That’s their privilege and you trying to meddle us taking it away from them.

But like I say this is MN, so cue the bizarre reponses that will inevitably follow.

Of course children aren't possessions, but OP is the primary care giver, and if anyone is acting possessive it's MIL.

They're constantly wanting to take my kids to their house and away from me. They'll come round unannounced and tell me that they're taking my daughter to their house.

This behaviour (along with everything in the OP) is overbearing and would upset most parents, especially one with a new baby.

I agree with PP who advise OP to back off and let DP/DH deal with his family. She doesn't need this.

KettrickenSmiled · 16/05/2022 11:12

Anytime they notice anything is even slightly wrong with my kids ( I never tell them ) they will make a massive deal out of it on the family WhatsApp. Including everyone else in the conversation, rather than just talking to me directly. It irritates me so much.
Delete yourself from the family Whatsapp.
Why would you give a flying fuck what these idiots say on it?
There - sorted!

My mother in law makes me find things to worry about. I'm a bit anxious anyway and she heightens it so much
When my first was a newborn she convinced me to take her to the doctor / hospital at any given opportunity. If I then reported back, doctor said she just has colic or whatever it was, she would push and push and push - well did you ask why ? How long it will last ? Is it something you've eaten that's caused it ? How long will it last ? Will they see her again ? You get the drift..whatever I had found out from the doctor, it was never enough and would make me feel like I had failed. My first starts nursery and gets every bug going.. surely something is wrong ! You need to push the doctors for a blood test. Something is wrong with her ! Every other parent says it's normal for her to pick up bugs at Nursery when she's new.. etc. nope, my MIL has to push it.
"Our GP isn't worried, & neither are we."
"Can you cut it out with the cross-examination?"
"As I said, everything's fine, you don't need to worry"
"Going to stop you there now, as I don't need to justify my decisions to you - see you next weekend, BYE"
& HANG UP

The other day I was in the shower and my mum was round. They turned up, saying they'll take my DD to their house.. my mum said to them she is uncomfortable to let them take her as she'd rather check with me first.. that didn't even cross their mind
Your mum has good instincts.

My bro in law said last week to my DD that she would come and pick her up the next day and take her to her house.. to which I could not bite my tongue and said, well mummy would like to approve that before you do it. I can 100 percent guarantee that bro in law took that badly and like me being a massive bitch.
Again - you need to channel your inner "so what?"
Well done for speaking up.Have a good long think about why you ever felt it necessary to "bite your tongue". Stop biting it. Your house, your child, your rules.
Next time one of MiL's Flying Monkeys proxies show up to help themselves to your child - be harsher.
"You don't get to decide when DD is visiting - that's my job. Stop intefering. If MiL wants to see DD, she can ask me herself directly. And if my answer is no, MiL has to learn to deal with that without having a hissy fit, because I'm no longer tolerating her bullying - ok?"

I am a bitch to them as soon as I show any kind of boundary. It's always been that way and will always be that way. They guilt my dh and I with all the , we just love them so much and mean well. We are your parents ( to my DH ) and love you so much. They basically only tolerate me though ..
Again - SO WHAT?
As PP upthread observed - they dislike you anyway - use that.
When you stop expecting or hoping for some kind of ... validation from these awful people, you will free yourself to maintain boundaries, protect your children, & see yourself & DH as the sole decision-makers for your DC.
They think you're a bitch anyway. So be one.
How you haven't already told them to just fuck off is beyond me. But baby steps OP - get practicing with speaking up & ENFORCING your boundaries.

musicviking1 · 16/05/2022 11:10

When i had my children my parents ignored all my views about how I want to raise my children they also tried to over take Christmas and birthdays. I really had to put my foot down. However, as soon as my children got a bit older my mother especially lost all interest in my kids and all her other grandchildren too mainly because the children could say no themselves.

NotSorry · 16/05/2022 11:05

galvanizethis · 16/05/2022 11:03

None of the grandparents of my children want to see them at all - ever. I have to force them to have a relationship with them... I can't even imagine this!

We had this problem too - only my dad left now and he has no interest in my children and then wonders why they don't want to visit - errrr... because they don't know you?

NewandNotImproved · 16/05/2022 11:04

You don’t need to be typing out essays about these people, it’s your husbands issue to sort. Get him to sort this nonsense, no excuses. Advocate for yourself and your kids.

NotSorry · 16/05/2022 11:04

I think you need to develop a thicker skin OP - people can't "make" you feel guilty, only you can do that - you need to let any comments roll off you - if they are going on about your child's health, just brush them off - she's fine, she doesn't need a blood test - rinse and repeat.

If they come over and say "we're taking dd to our house" practice some answers eg. not today thank you - let's make an arrangement for when she can go - so you are not saying "no" you are just saying "not at the moment"

galvanizethis · 16/05/2022 11:03

None of the grandparents of my children want to see them at all - ever. I have to force them to have a relationship with them... I can't even imagine this!

feelingwelljell · 16/05/2022 10:56

Anytime they notice anything is even slightly wrong with my kids ( I never tell them ) they will make a massive deal out of it on the family WhatsApp. Including everyone else in the conversation, rather than just talking to me directly. It irritates me so much.

My mother in law makes me find things to worry about. I'm a bit anxious anyway and she heightens it so much
When my first was a newborn she convinced me to take her to the doctor / hospital at any given opportunity. If I then reported back, doctor said she just has colic or whatever it was, she would push and push and push - well did you ask why ? How long it will last ? Is it something you've eaten that's caused it ? How long will it last ? Will they see her again ? You get the drift..whatever I had found out from the doctor, it was never enough and would make me feel like I had failed. My first starts nursery and gets every bug going.. surely something is wrong ! You need to push the doctors for a blood test. Something is wrong with her ! Every other parent says it's normal for her to pick up bugs at Nursery when she's new.. etc. nope, my MIL has to push it.

The other day I was in the shower and my mum was round. They turned up, saying they'll take my DD to their house.. my mum said to them she is uncomfortable to let them take her as she'd rather check with me first.. that didn't even cross their mind
! My bro in law said last week to my DD that she would come and pick her up the next day and take her to her house.. to which I could not bite my tongue and said, well mummy would like to approve that before you do it. I can 100 percent guarantee that bro in law took that badly and like me being a massive bitch. I am a bitch to them as soon as I show any kind of boundary. It's always been that way and will always be that way. They guilt my dh and I with all the , we just love them so much and mean well. We are your parents ( to my DH ) and love you so much. They basically only tolerate me though ..

OP posts:
MaudieandMe · 16/05/2022 10:47

Good grief, they sound completely ridiculous and far too over-invested.

As a MIL, I am very conscious of not being too intrusive because I want to have a great relationship with my adult DC. and their partners too, as well as the grandchildren.

Honestly, she’s not your boss so you do not have to do as she bids. The first time she was rude and had a strop, I’d have shown her the door. You need to be much, much firmer with her and stand your ground.

Anyone that sulks or calls me names would be treated like an overgrown toddler who needs reminding of the rules of good behaviour.

You decide how often your children see their grandparents and I’d cut it right back to almost never for now and only increase visits when your MIL behaves herself. Make it clear to her that any more of her nonsense results in loss of privileges just like you’d do with a naughty child.

You need to protect your kids from her interference so stand up to her. You can do this. 👍🏻

autienotnaughty · 16/05/2022 10:43

YANBU!! This is awful. The truth is they don't respect you so stop worrying what they think.
I'd arrange a weekly/fortnightly afternoon for them to have/spoil dc and explain it's better as you may have plans on other days. I would go out lots for a few weeks if they don't get the hint.
Photos/ videos great but only on your terms, any negative comments I'd say 'try not to worry yourself we would tell you if something was wrong'
Don't try to change them/justify yourself you won't win just smile politely or leave dh to manage them.

I had this my ex in laws were on tap babysitters which was fab but too much and too opinionated. If I got their hair cut, Mil would say to dc 'we will have to smack mummy's bum if she does that again' I just ignored it. As kids got older they now find their dgp annoying as they are too involved in their business and will moan they never see them anymore(they are all adults now)