Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Love from in laws towards my kids is too much

185 replies

feelingwelljell · 16/05/2022 07:23

I know it's unreasonable.

But the love my in laws have for my kids is too much and it annoys me. I must start by saying, I don't get on with them very well. Lots of things have happened.

I think probably if we had a better relationship, it may not annoy me as much, but I don't know.

It's like my kids are the centre of their universe. Everything is about them and they constantly want to see them at every opportunity. If they haven't seen them for a week, I get messages saying they miss them. I also get told I need to send pictures and videos more often. When my in laws can't come, they pretty much send their other kids and they take constant videos of my kids to then show the in laws.

I send pics to them too and videos as they're always asking, but most of the time when I send something, they'll be some over the top concerned comment from my mother in law, about something really minor in the picture. For example, oh his eye looks swollen or - her hair looks pulled a bit tight, is she OK ? Or - if they even have a minor illness, she has to get really involved and push me to get more and more tests done, even though I'm comfortable in whatever the doctors have told me. She just has to be overly involved in everything and she stresses me out and ruins my mood when I send a nice pic, as she can't say anything nice and always knit picks.

Anyway I know how it sounds. How can I be irritated by someone loving my kids too much ? I sound like an absolute idiot. But they're my kids. I'm afraid my in laws want to gain lots of ground with my kids and will try to bring them up their way and be a huge influence on them. I believe kids should be raised by their parents and I don't want them to be raised to be carbon copies of their other kids. I want to have a big role to play ( the main role ) in how my kids will be raised. But I feel these constant demands for their time and having to be so involved in their lives is going to mean that they'll influence them massively. I don't think it's wrong for them to have a role in their lives, but I don't want to be on the sidelines of their lives, because my in laws ads second parents to them.

They can see them once every couple of weeks and I shouldn't need to be made to feel bad for them ' missing them so much ' after just a week. It's OTT. Anyway, I know I'll get my arse handed to me. But perhaps someone has something helpful to say ?

I feel like a tyrant if I ever say that we can't see them. I just can't say no. I've tried a few times and get theatrics. My in laws don't respect any of the boundaries I've ever tried to set. They're constantly wanting to take my kids to their house and away from me. They'll come round unannounced and tell me that they're taking my daughter to their house. Daughter gets excited because they set no boundaries for her there at all and she does what she wants there ( another problem ). And I just have to go along with it.

Any time I've ever stood up for myself and said no, my mother in law shouts, screams and cries and calls me a bad person and a bully. It's very difficult ! So she's managed to get me to a place where I hold my tongue as much as I can, to avoid a big fight and being called names by her. It's very difficult and feels suffocating.

I'm feeling extra territorial as I've just had a baby, so maybe that's what's prompted these feelings to become stronger.

I just feel like I should be the only one to love my kids this much and to show this amount of concern for them ? My parents are totally different. Whilst they love all their grandchildren a lot, I don't feel it's as excessive and overbearing.

OP posts:
MzHz · 16/05/2022 13:18

@feelingwelljell i too say LET HELL BREAK LOOSE!

if they all rush to defend her, and you have left the WhatsApp group, let them crack on!

If they Do and say what you say they are going to do, it’s the same old shit but different voices.

the reason they are holding you hostage in their drama is because you’re allowing it

follow the advice here to free yourself and let the chips fall where they may

the pp who said that the kids will start to talk to you the way the in-laws do is right. That’s exactly how these dynamics turn out.

trust your instincts and follow through, distance yourself

the worse they are, the more you back off.

gwanwyn · 16/05/2022 13:04

The situation you're describing matches my own experience with my in laws and (unfortunately) also with my own mum.

Me to - and on MN this mean I'm the issue - but it think I married into a similar dynamic/pattern - which TBH I think my parents did as well.

Actually within the family we tend to get on best with IL possible because we have put in boundaries - and I have a less combative relationship than siblings often have with our parents.

Fraaahnces · 16/05/2022 12:58

You’ve already established that she doesn’t like you. That’s not going to change, is it? What’s the worst that could happen? She STILL doesn’t like you. Why are you even entertaining the opinions of her and her minions? Stop reacting (especially with fear) and they may eventually respect you. Whose kids are they?

strawberriesarenot · 16/05/2022 12:50

I understand. Thank goodness that mine were little before videos were everyday. It sometimes seemed that every bite they ate was a need for discussion, and everything they wore supplied by my dm. And their school reports, everything, it was relentless.
I know it was love, but it was hard at the time, and harder when it was withdrawn. It stopped when they were very uncute teens.

Reservoir13 · 16/05/2022 12:48

The situation you're describing matches my own experience with my in laws and (unfortunately) also with my own mum.
Just like some other posters, I've never had a big confrontation with them. That would only end in tears/screaming/hysterics.
Instead, I've adapted my responses to them. I've left all contact with the in laws to my husband. And - just like some other posters - this has resulted in them getting virtually no photos/videos etc. He cannot even remember their birthdays or mothers/fathers' day (things that I used to remember on his behalf before). So they are much worse off than before. Too bad.
Calls with my own mum I limit to once a week. She also had a phase in which she wanted immediate updating after each doctor's visit/school report/birthday party etc. but I won't do that any more. The good thing is that my kids are by now very clued in to her manipulative behaviour. If she tries to do the fake crying with them ("oh, I miss you so much, I wish your mummy would live closer"), they just ignore her or pass the phone around.
We live 1000s of kilometers apart from them which of course makes unannounced visits a lot harder. When they come, it is immediately for days at a time though and it is often very tough.

TheCatterall · 16/05/2022 12:38

You can’t have it every way.

you either need strict boundaries and to deal with the initial fallout.

or you continue as you are and have an unhappy life to appease a bullying domineering manipulative MIL.

mute the WhatsApp group if you can’t leave it.

tell the DH that it’s his job to stand up to his Mother.

change the locks and get into the habit of locking the doors so folks can’t come in unannounced.

stop answering the door and state you were busy. Or take the kids out the minute you see them on the doorstep and tell them next time to let you know they are coming as you’ve got plans. You don’t need to tell them the plans.

if folks drop on your daughter without your prior agreement that they will take her out etc - tell them it’s a pity they didn’t arrange it with you in advance before upsetting your daughter but that you have plans or ‘that doesn’t work for me’.

so what if they hate you? These people are never going to be your best friends. They are never going to be the family you want. So establish the bloody boundaries you want and control how much impact and access they have to your family.

push back on everything. They’ll learn or you will have to go low/no contact.

honestly I’d be doing low contact for now.

your DH needs to support you and be active in this.

Gerwurtztraminer · 16/05/2022 12:35

I suggest you go over to the Relationships board (or get this one moved there) and also look at the Stately Homes thread. There is recommended reading there about this type of family dynamic.

If you don't stop them now it will only escalate. Your In laws that will not stop with this behaviour until they 'break' you and you give in.

They don't 'love the kids too much' they are trying to control you and as you have realised, trying to transfer your children's primary affections and loyalties to them and create more mini-me's in the grandchildren.

The only way to deal with it is to take the risk of "all hell breaking loose" and step back as previous posters have advised, leaving the family What's app group and stop sending any information. Refuse to deal with them or to allow them to simply take your kids without asking (seriously - who does that?). Leave all contact to your husband and support him in standing up for himself - he will need after years of being bullied and doing what he's told for the sake of an easy life.

ChoiceMummy · 16/05/2022 12:32

feelingwelljell · 16/05/2022 10:56

Anytime they notice anything is even slightly wrong with my kids ( I never tell them ) they will make a massive deal out of it on the family WhatsApp. Including everyone else in the conversation, rather than just talking to me directly. It irritates me so much.

My mother in law makes me find things to worry about. I'm a bit anxious anyway and she heightens it so much
When my first was a newborn she convinced me to take her to the doctor / hospital at any given opportunity. If I then reported back, doctor said she just has colic or whatever it was, she would push and push and push - well did you ask why ? How long it will last ? Is it something you've eaten that's caused it ? How long will it last ? Will they see her again ? You get the drift..whatever I had found out from the doctor, it was never enough and would make me feel like I had failed. My first starts nursery and gets every bug going.. surely something is wrong ! You need to push the doctors for a blood test. Something is wrong with her ! Every other parent says it's normal for her to pick up bugs at Nursery when she's new.. etc. nope, my MIL has to push it.

The other day I was in the shower and my mum was round. They turned up, saying they'll take my DD to their house.. my mum said to them she is uncomfortable to let them take her as she'd rather check with me first.. that didn't even cross their mind
! My bro in law said last week to my DD that she would come and pick her up the next day and take her to her house.. to which I could not bite my tongue and said, well mummy would like to approve that before you do it. I can 100 percent guarantee that bro in law took that badly and like me being a massive bitch. I am a bitch to them as soon as I show any kind of boundary. It's always been that way and will always be that way. They guilt my dh and I with all the , we just love them so much and mean well. We are your parents ( to my DH ) and love you so much. They basically only tolerate me though ..

So, if put succinctly, you dislike the inlaws and it wouldn't matter what they did, they'd be in the wrong?

I've no doubt that they may have been ott at times, but the majority of your objections come down to your insecurities. If you felt a good enough mother, you wouldn't feel threatened in this way that extended family also wish to spend time with your children. Maybe focus on why you feel this way and work through that?

My child so benefits from being with extended family, as do yours no doubt.

You quite clearly have anxieties etc that need pulling into check as your attitude is not normal imo to resent this contact how you do.

As for the medical questions she asked, they're all very reasonable questions imo and if you hadn't asked them, that's more of a reflection in you than them, if that's why you feel threatened.

This doesn't need to be a competition. You are the mother and should feel secure in this role. Why are you creating this competition? Embrace what they offer. Have boundaries such as you'll confirm if available on x date etc. Don't start an unnecessary war due to your insecurities.

If they do dislike you, I imagine that's due to how you come across and the role you've played in this.

iRun2eatCake · 16/05/2022 12:31

OP - if you're not going to take the advise of PP and stand up to them - then there is no point moaning about it.

Just accept that is how your life will be and make peace with it.

DirectionToPerfection · 16/05/2022 12:26

Quitelikeit · 16/05/2022 12:17

I’m going to go against the grain. I don’t think these people are coming from a place of malice.

their nurturing approach will benefit your children and I think it’s great they want to be involved.

some things you have said it seems like it’s a clash of personalities and you’ve not said anything too dreadful.

the kids uncle was offering to take your child to see their cousins surely that’s not harmful or rude? I doubt he was trying to arrange it with your child without going through you at some point? I mean you were there when he said it?

Have you actually read the thread?

Screaming at OP, constant nitpicking, trying to take her DD away on a whim without prior approval. Do you really think these are the normal behaviours of a kind and loving person?

You're lucky you've never had to deal with personality disordered individuals.

Blahburst · 16/05/2022 12:18

They’re giving you plenty of great opportunities to practise saying “no”. You will feel so good when you start sticking up for yourself. It’s so hard at a first but really worth it. As for any “fall out” - not your circus, not your monkeys. Leave the WhatsApp group and let them crack on.

LakieLady · 16/05/2022 12:17

YANBU at all and your MIL sounds controlling and manipulative. Shouting and screaming at you is abusive, and if she does it in the presence of your children it's beyond appalling.

If you and your DH are on the same page (and it sounds as though you are), I'd be asking her to stop the minute she starts and either you leave or you ask her to leave your house if she persists.

There are some great suggestions in this thread for how to deal with her, but you may end up having to very low, or no, contact if she keeps this up.

I'd be seriously considering moving a very long way if I was in your shoes!

Quitelikeit · 16/05/2022 12:17

I’m going to go against the grain. I don’t think these people are coming from a place of malice.

their nurturing approach will benefit your children and I think it’s great they want to be involved.

some things you have said it seems like it’s a clash of personalities and you’ve not said anything too dreadful.

the kids uncle was offering to take your child to see their cousins surely that’s not harmful or rude? I doubt he was trying to arrange it with your child without going through you at some point? I mean you were there when he said it?

Fadeout83 · 16/05/2022 12:11

You’re in control of all of this so be in control. I know it’s hard when you feel like you will offend and hell will break loose etc. but that’s only a reasonable concern if your actions were unreasonable. Your actions are NOT unreasonable. These people are controlling and the way they treat and undermine you is not ok.

you are also setting an example for your children. Don’t let them constantly watch their mother be a doormat.

Life is too short for this. Set. Some. Boundaries.

gwanwyn · 16/05/2022 12:09

All hell would break loose! Everyone would rush to defend MIL and how she's just giving advice and how I take everything the wrong way etc.

Could you not do the "and what does that mean" put her on the back foot? or "why do you think you know better than the GP" - or better yet - "well I've spoken to the professionals on the matter" depending on the advice - who told you that - advice changes that is hideously out of date - or simple that doesn't work for us. Or just a big sigh and completely refuse to engage or smile nod and ignore.

TBH with the what's app I'd just leave - why get wound up all the while - but the above in conversation with practise might help. You want statements that either put her on the spot not you or close down any conversation on the matter.

You need to stay clam and refuse to engage - it does take pratcise - if she perssist you do broken record repeat. You might need to think through how you prevent situations arising - like them just turning up - not answering the door being on the way out giving a more convienet alternative.

KettrickenSmiled · 16/05/2022 12:08

@Elliania - great post.

And now a derail ... is your username derived from Elliania Blackwater, by any chance? The Narcheska?

AskingforaBaskin · 16/05/2022 12:07

feelingwelljell · 16/05/2022 11:43

All hell would break loose! Everyone would rush to defend MIL and how she's just giving advice and how I take everything the wrong way etc.

FGS that's why you leave the group. They already don't like you why are you trying to keep them happy?

Pipsquiggle · 16/05/2022 12:06

You and your DH need to work as a team.

I have no idea why they are contacting you all the time. You and your DH need to tell them to contact him.

Your DH needs to tell them they can't come round unannounced and certainly cannot take your DC without prior approval

Essentially @feelingwelljell you need to take a massive step back from this and your DH needs to take a massive step forward.

Idontgiveashitanymore · 16/05/2022 12:05

They do sound a bit overbearing but your husband needs to step up and tell them, does he agree with you and feel the same?
if he does then step back and let him do some work. Stop sending them stuff too you are just fuelling the fire .
hope you get it sorted soon 💐

KettrickenSmiled · 16/05/2022 12:00

OP - you & DH need to get your heads round this - outofthefog.website/toolbox-1/2015/11/17/fog-fear-obligation-guilt

You need to work together as a team on dealing with his toxic family.
Have a look at the Toolbix & Forum pages - share them with him, discuss what you learn, & agree a mutual strategy for managing the interference & melodrama your MiL enjoys bringing to your lives.

runnerblade95 · 16/05/2022 12:00

worriedparent12 · 16/05/2022 07:33

Maybe I'm paranoid, but this would raise some safeguarding concerns for me as well. In my opinion, people not respecting your boundaries about your kids are a bit of a red flag.

Definitely not paranoid. Anyone this obsessed with my DD would get my back up instantly, relative or not. If they behaved this way with all of their grandchildren then fine, I would just put that down to being OTT in general but it sounds like it’s only OP’s children and that doesn’t sit right with me.

Also, DH is clearly not as involved as he should be. A pp suggested DH being the one to take the kids over to see your in-laws instead of you.

I don’t think you’re being OTT at all. As well as a potential safeguarding issue, they just sound downright annoying as hell in general. Looking at pictures (that you asked for btw) and overanalysing to the point where you’re questioning if my daughters hair is pulled too tight? Yeah okay, no. That’s where I draw the line. As if life isn’t stressful enough 🙄

So in short, hand this one over to your DH, this shouldn’t be stressing you out to this degree where they’re not even your biological parents.

NessieMcNessface · 16/05/2022 11:57

It’s really hard to be assertive if it’s not in your nature but I think you have to find a way of being more so whatever this takes. It’s interesting that when you first posted you kept saying that people would probably think you were in the wrong. You’ve been browbeaten to the point where you think it must be your inadequacy. Not the case of course because clearly, you are being bullied and intimidated by your ILs. I hate confrontation, it makes me feel ill but there is no way I’d let my child leave the house with another person if I wasn’t happy about it. These are your children NOT your MIL’s. You have to start telling her where to get off and let her shout away. At the moment you are empowering her; she knows her behaviour gets her what she wants and you have to break that cycle.

FictionalCharacter · 16/05/2022 11:57

This isn’t love, it’s being interfering and obsessive. MIL is trying to own your kids rather than love them. But your DH needs to step up and support you.
A MIL who shouts, screams and cries when you stand up to her is not a person I’d want looking after my kids.

KettrickenSmiled · 16/05/2022 11:57

All hell would break loose! Everyone would rush to defend MIL and how she's just giving advice and how I take everything the wrong way etc.

OP - all together now" - "SO WHAT?"

You don't have to witness "everyone"'s behaviour.
Let 'em get on with manufacturing drama.
You don't need to hear it, see it, or engage with it in any way.

If they bring it to your door "I'm not interested, come back when you've got something pleasant to say, BYE". AND SHUT THE DOOR/HANG UP THE PHONE.

Dotell · 16/05/2022 11:53

Let all hell break loose. What is the worst that can happen? is she going to spank you? I don't understand this. You carry on with this mouse like behaviour and your children would start talking to you like your MIL does, they will act like her and it will be too late.