Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Judged for *Only having one child

187 replies

Sameasitwas · 15/05/2022 21:03

Was at the playground yesterday with Dd, almost 4, she was playing with all the kids and I got chatting to a mum with a younger girl and two teenage boys. Chatting away quite happily until she asked if I had anymore children and I said only Dd…her face changed and she looked almost shocked, like a bad smell was under her nose 😬She drifted away after that and went to talk to someone else.
I've never encountered that before, do people really judge people with only one child?
Not that it would have been any of her business, but I had Dd late due to infertility and years of waiting, we would have loved more…but even if we hadn’t, so what?! What’s the issue?

OP posts:
LuckySantangelo35 · 16/05/2022 10:19

Latecomer131 · 16/05/2022 10:12

@LuckySantangelo35 , to branch off ever so slightly from the original thread topic. Did you ever have a wobble over this, and if so, how did you get over it and let your rational mind prevail? I feel exactly the same as you, in terms of one child being the best balance, as it preserves a "semblance" of pre-kids flexibility, and is likely to not do as much damage to my career.

However, I currently have a six month old, and I am occasionally having a wobble over the decision due to feeling guilty about not giving him a sibling. Rationally, I know that it's stupid to think about a second child due to pointless guilt over DS not having a sibling. (I have very little in common with my own brother and only see him a handful of times a year).

My guess is that these thoughts of a second are being driven hormones, and if I ride it out, then the occasional desire for a second will pass?

@Latecomer131

Absolutely! Ride it out and it will pass!

Latecomer131 · 16/05/2022 10:12

LuckySantangelo35 · 16/05/2022 09:53

”Children really aren't the be all and end all for so many people and whilst they might be willing to make some sacrifices to their lives in order to have one, that's the balance that is good for them and they don't want to tip that balance further by having another. What on earth is there to judge? I just don't get it?”

This is me in a nutshell! I DO want some semblance of pre-child life - I want to be able to get a baby sitter easily, go on holiday, minimal disruption to my career, still have a social life, etc so I’m deliberately one and done! And i make no apologies for my decision nor the reasons behind it! And I don’t judge people who have more than one kid either.

@LuckySantangelo35 , to branch off ever so slightly from the original thread topic. Did you ever have a wobble over this, and if so, how did you get over it and let your rational mind prevail? I feel exactly the same as you, in terms of one child being the best balance, as it preserves a "semblance" of pre-kids flexibility, and is likely to not do as much damage to my career.

However, I currently have a six month old, and I am occasionally having a wobble over the decision due to feeling guilty about not giving him a sibling. Rationally, I know that it's stupid to think about a second child due to pointless guilt over DS not having a sibling. (I have very little in common with my own brother and only see him a handful of times a year).

My guess is that these thoughts of a second are being driven hormones, and if I ride it out, then the occasional desire for a second will pass?

CheapFoodShits · 16/05/2022 10:04

I used to work with a woman and whenever the discussion of family life came up she would always mention that I only have the one. I had to bite my tongue every time to stop me from saying "Yes, but all four of yours were taken off you🤷". Her kids are now grown up and want nothing to do with her because she favoured being a heroin addict to being a mother. She's been clean now for 8 years and acts like she's the best thing the world ever produced. Let's just ignore the pain and suffering you caused your own children, and all the people you hurt and stole from to fund your habit 🙄

LuckySantangelo35 · 16/05/2022 10:00

@Hastingsontheup

Oh dear….

JesusInTheCabbageVan · 16/05/2022 09:56

Hastingsontheup · 16/05/2022 06:15

My sister is my best friend she is the person who taught me about what friendship is. She is my staunchest supporter and my most honest critic, my first port of call for support, advice and wisdom. I talk to her everyday, so I'd say sharing a room and the remote control was a tiny price to pay for a life long right hand woman.

That's great for you.

The thing about people, though, is that everyone is different.

LuckySantangelo35 · 16/05/2022 09:53

”Children really aren't the be all and end all for so many people and whilst they might be willing to make some sacrifices to their lives in order to have one, that's the balance that is good for them and they don't want to tip that balance further by having another. What on earth is there to judge? I just don't get it?”

This is me in a nutshell! I DO want some semblance of pre-child life - I want to be able to get a baby sitter easily, go on holiday, minimal disruption to my career, still have a social life, etc so I’m deliberately one and done! And i make no apologies for my decision nor the reasons behind it! And I don’t judge people who have more than one kid either.

LuckySantangelo35 · 16/05/2022 09:41

breatheintheamazing · 16/05/2022 09:23

I don't think jealousy has anything To do with it to be honest. If I wanted "more chance of having a life that has some semblance to what life was like pre kids" I wouldn't have had kids in the first place.

Most people who have more than one deliberately chose that life.

I fought secondary infertility to give my eldest siblings. So I understand totally those that can't for medical reasons but I admit I really don't understand (and yes probably judge) the deliberately"one and done"

@breatheintheamazing

Judge away, but lots of people miss the freedoms and things in life they had before they had kids. You see it here all the time. It’s no longer taboo for women to acknowledge it. Praise be!

Just out of interest - Why do you judge people who are deliberately one and done? Like what is your thought process in relation to those people? Do you think they are selfish for not giving their kid a sibling or something? That they don’t enjoy parenting enough and therefore are fundamentally lacking as a person? Or something else?

shiningstar2 · 16/05/2022 09:41

My Dd is an only child. She is the most well balanced person I know. She has two teenage kids and she has supported her husband who has serious mental health issues for 20 years. She does this in every sense of the word. Until this year until her husband got a part time job she was sole financial provider and she is his greatest advocator and supporter. She has a very busy and committed job and is a highly competent and popular teacher. Unlike the popular myth she is very unselfish and has great long term friends. I am one of three and I could not have done what she has done for her family for the past twenty years. I've found that for me, being one of a bigger family, I have a strong sense of self preservation and I am probably too selfish to have done all she has done. 😀 It was not the done thing, particularly in my husband's family to have an only in the 70s and dear mil(rip) was extremely and openly judgemental. I just got on doing my own thing and, although she openly judged me, I was too polite to point out that, seeing the outcomes of her own choices of a big family, some kids get a bit pushed out. Why would I comment? Her choices. If people are rude enough to judge yours, however many or few kids you have, politely ignore. 😀

SleeplessInEngland · 16/05/2022 09:40

Waxonwaxoff0 · 16/05/2022 06:06

Never seen it in real life, only on MN.

Quite - with a lot of these threads it's hard not to wonder how much projection's going on. Did the woman actually pull that face or did the OP expect her to and see it regardless. Seems to always happens with MILs too, never any concrete examples of judgmentalism, just a vague 'vibe'.

Tillymint10 · 16/05/2022 09:35

breatheintheamazing · 16/05/2022 09:23

I don't think jealousy has anything To do with it to be honest. If I wanted "more chance of having a life that has some semblance to what life was like pre kids" I wouldn't have had kids in the first place.

Most people who have more than one deliberately chose that life.

I fought secondary infertility to give my eldest siblings. So I understand totally those that can't for medical reasons but I admit I really don't understand (and yes probably judge) the deliberately"one and done"

But judge them for what exactly?

Rosesandbutterflys · 16/05/2022 09:34

breatheintheamazing · 16/05/2022 09:23

I don't think jealousy has anything To do with it to be honest. If I wanted "more chance of having a life that has some semblance to what life was like pre kids" I wouldn't have had kids in the first place.

Most people who have more than one deliberately chose that life.

I fought secondary infertility to give my eldest siblings. So I understand totally those that can't for medical reasons but I admit I really don't understand (and yes probably judge) the deliberately"one and done"

Why?

Children really aren't the be all and end all for so many people and whilst they might be willing to make some sacrifices to their lives in order to have one, that's the balance that is good for them and they don't want to tip that balance further by having another. What on earth is there to judge? I just don't get it? Why would parents who are stressed and miserable because they regret the financial and practical demands that a second has placed on their family be better than happy parents of an only child?

You do know that lots of only children have cousins that they're close to and friends that they have round most nights of the week etc, why are you assuming they're all lonely and crying/ rocking in a corner every night? As I can only assume that's why you'd judge?

TellerTuesday · 16/05/2022 09:29

@Hastingsontheup that's absolutely lovely. I'm an only child so I didn't have this. My DH is a twin so I asked him if he savours this staunch support & critique, then he reminded me that BIL is a total arsehole & they haven't spoken for a decade.

What a fucking melt you are coming on & commenting that 🙄

breatheintheamazing · 16/05/2022 09:23

I don't think jealousy has anything To do with it to be honest. If I wanted "more chance of having a life that has some semblance to what life was like pre kids" I wouldn't have had kids in the first place.

Most people who have more than one deliberately chose that life.

I fought secondary infertility to give my eldest siblings. So I understand totally those that can't for medical reasons but I admit I really don't understand (and yes probably judge) the deliberately"one and done"

Dixiechickonhols · 16/05/2022 09:21

I really don’t understand the judging? There’s so many reasons why an only is an only. I rarely share my reasons. Several onlies I know the dad left so there’s no chance of a full sibling. Do you judge those only with a half sibling? Or those whose sibling died - again not something you’d share with a randomer in park. I just have DD can mean anything.

LuckySantangelo35 · 16/05/2022 09:19

In all honesty, I think that quite a few of the people who are contemptuous of only children and their parents are jealous.

Jealous that the parents of only children have less work, less parenting stress, more chance of having a life that has some semblance to what life was like pre kids. Easier to get a baby sitter, more money and freedom to go on holiday, less faff around school pick ups, etc.

Lots of people with more than one kid will have had more in order to conform to social pressures or to give their child a sibling and then as they’ve got older seen that the kids don’t actually get on… they feel regret/resentment conscious or otherwise, and so project that onto only children and their parents.

Sad really!

Dixiechickonhols · 16/05/2022 09:10

I have one child and have never come across anything negative. She has a disability so maybe people think that’s why we didn’t have another, actual reason is pregnancy triggered serious health condition in me most people have never heard of and I was strongly advised by several drs not to get pregnant again so I didn’t.
Lots have onlies these days or different set ups effectively making them onlies eg half sibling years older. Especially as people start families later and financial issues it’s only going to be more common.
I seriously wouldn’t give any more thought.

HistoricMoment · 16/05/2022 09:06

RustyShackleford3 · 16/05/2022 07:36

The issue is that you are a woman.

You would face similar judgement for having multiple children, and also for not having any children at all. Also for being too old when you had children, and also for being too young.

Oh and also for working after having children, and also if you were a stay at home mum.

People like that are just dickheads who go around judging people for ridiculous reasons. I know it's easier said than done but honestly just try and ignore it. Focus on yourself and your child and do what is right for you and your own family.

I came on here to say exactly the same thing. When you're a woman, whatever you do is wrong.

Mumwantingtogetitright · 16/05/2022 09:01

OMG12 · 16/05/2022 08:41

People are really weird about only children. I sometimes wonder if the ones that are rude about it actually regret having more/struggle and when faced with the reality of actually only children are fine get defensive over their position and are trying to convince themselves why they needed more.

I suspect that there is a lot of truth in this!

Clevs · 16/05/2022 08:59

We only have one child and as much as I'd like another it won't be happening. It really annoys me when people joke about having the next one soon, needing a playmate etc. You have no idea what we went through just to get the one we have, so please stop telling me I'll be having another when the choice has been taken away from me.

Ganymedemoon · 16/05/2022 08:53

People are very openly judgemental about many parenting choices one of them been how many kids you have even though many people have no choice in this.

People will judge women who choose not to have kids, have one, have 6, have a small age gap, have a large age gap... quite honestly people should just shut up and let people have the families they have.

I was an only and frequently to this day get sympathy about that 🙄 I have 2 ( my eldest would far prefer to be the only one btw!!) I have a 5 year age gap, that gets a lot of judgey comments. At the end of the day only the parents with 2.5 kids with a perfect 2 year age gap and of course one of each might just escape any judgement.

Ignore people like this OP there are many more only children now than when I grew up and from what I experienced and what I see now they are very happy, confident thriving kids and that's the main thing.

OMG12 · 16/05/2022 08:50

Marvellousmadness · 16/05/2022 07:28

I would judge a parent with only 1 kid. But also parents with more then 3 kids . But id do it behind their backs. Like a normal person.

Why would you judge though? What’s the magic cut off for 3? Is it because you think your own choices should be taken up by the rest of the population? Can you really not imagine/appreciate/understand that your view is only right for you.

I despair sometimes, I really do

Disneyblueeyes · 16/05/2022 08:49

I'd much rather judge people who bring more children into the world who are financially unable to support them, or have 0 parenting skills.
With only children it's just a stigma, all of which is total rubbish. Even research has shown only children are no unhappier than those with siblings.

Ignore it, and enjoy your small family. Doesn't really matter what anyone thinks after all.

OMG12 · 16/05/2022 08:41

People are really weird about only children. I sometimes wonder if the ones that are rude about it actually regret having more/struggle and when faced with the reality of actually only children are fine get defensive over their position and are trying to convince themselves why they needed more.

TempsPerdu · 16/05/2022 08:37

The issue is that you are a woman.

You would face similar judgement for having multiple children, and also for not having any children at all. Also for being too old when you had children, and also for being too young.

Oh and also for working after having children, and also if you were a stay at home mum

This. Women are constantly judged on their family and lifestyle choices, and it’s often other women doing the judging.

Also, a surprising number of people are deeply conformist and unimaginative, and feel threatened by those who don’t follow the herd, whether it’s by having no children, one child or five. For some, two children, ideally one of each sex (let’s not forget the judgmental comments around families with mutiple boys/girls) is all that’s acceptable.

Personally the pandemic highlighted for me that plenty of people lack basic empathy skills and struggle to grasp that other people are autonomous individuals whose life experiences differ from theirs.

Clovacloud · 16/05/2022 08:35

When DD was about 4, I actually had a school Mum tell me that if DD wasn’t an only child, and I’d had an older sibling for her, then I could have had some ‘hand me down’ school uniform for DD. WTAF?

To this day I have no idea what mental gymnastics she did to get to that conclusion, and it’s not like we couldn’t afford bloody school uniform. I did go into some nice detail about the miscarriages I’d had and why DD was an only child and then she never spoke to me again.

And don’t get me started on SIL’s comments on only children 🤬

People are really weird!